The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
25. The amounts awarded by this Court, as mentioned supra, are reworked and tabulated hereunder:Sl.No. Description Amount Amount Awarded by awarded by this the Tribunal Court (Rs.) (Rs.) Award confirmed or enhanced or granted or reduced Towards partial Rs.3,28,000/permanent disability Rs.3,69,000/- enhanced Towards pain and Rs. 40,000/sufferings Rs. 40,000/- confirmed Towards loss of earning during the treatment period( Rs.19,000/x 4 months) Rs. 76,000/- granted Rs. 30,000/-- enhanced confirmed - Towards transportation, extra nourishment and Rs. 6,000/attender charges Towards damages to clothing and articles Rs. 1,000/- Rs.. 1,000/- Total Rs..3,75,000/ - Rs.5,16,000/-
26. In the result, i) C.M.A.No.3692 of 2025 stands dismissed. ii) CMA.No.443 of 2026 stands partly allowed. Page12 of 15 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026 iii) The Compensation awarded by the Tribunal is enhanced from Rs.3,75,000/- to Rs.5,16,000/-. (iv)The Insurance Company / second respondent is directed to deposit the enhanced compensation amount now determined by this Court i.e., Rs.5,16,000/- (less the amount already deposited if any) together with interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum from the date of claim petition till the date of deposit, (excluding the period of default, if any) and costs to the credit of M.C.O.P.No.2228 of 2022 on the file of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal/IV Court of Small Causes, Chennai, within a period of eight weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this Judgment. (v)On such deposit being made, the appellant/claimant is permitted to withdraw the same along with interest and costs, by making necessary application before the Tribunal. vi)The appellant/claimant is directed to pay the Court fee for the compensation amount, if required. vii)The Tribunal below shall disburse the enhanced amount upon production of the certified copy showing proof of Page13 of 15 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026 payment of Court fee by the claimant. There is no order as to costs. Consequently, connect…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED:
11-03-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MRS.JUSTICE R. KALAIMATHI
CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026
and CMP.No.30777 of 2025
CMA.No.3692 of 2025
M/s.United India Insurance Company Ltd.,
Silingi Building, 4th Floor,
No. 134, Greams Road,
Chennai-600 006.
..Appellant(s)
Vs.
1. I.William Dominic
2. A.Anthony Charles
.. Respondent(s)
Prayer : This Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is filed under Section 173 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, to set aside the Award dated 22.04.2025 passed in
M.C.O.P.No.2228 of 2022 on the file of the Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal/ IV Court of Small Causes, Chennai.
For Appellant(s) : Mr.Arunkumar. S
For R1
: Mr.R.Dinesh Kumar
CMA.No.443 of 2026
I.William Dominic
..Appellant(s)
vs.
1. A.Anthony Charles
2. United India Insurance Co.Ltd.,
Silingi Building,
4th Floor,No.134 Greams Road,
Chennai 600 006.
(1st Respondent was set exparte by the Tribunal)
.. Respondent(s)
__________
Page1 of 15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026
Prayer : This Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is filed under Section 173 of Motor
Vehicles Act, to enhance the compensation awarded in the Judgment and
Decree dated 22.04.2025 passed in M.C.O.P.No.2228 of 2022 on the file of
the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal / IV Court of Small Causes, Chennai.
For Appellant(s)
: Mr.R.Dinesh Kumar
For R2
: Mr.S.Arunkumar
COMMON JUDGMENT
CMA.No.3692 of 2025 is preferred by the Insurance Company
against the Award dated 22.04.2025 passed in M.C.O.P.No.2228 of 2022
on the file of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal/IV Court of Small Causes
( Chennai) on the liability issue.
2. CMA.No.443 of 2026 is preferred by the Claimant herein against
the Award dated 22.04.2025 passed in M.C.O.P.No.2228 of 2022 on the
file of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal/IVth Court of Small Causes, Chennai
for enhancement of compensation.
3. The parties are indicated herein as per their litigative status and
ranking before the Tribunal.
__________
Page2 of 15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026
4. Claim Petition was filed under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988, claiming compensation of Rs.15,00,000/-
for the injuries
sustained by the claimant in a road traffic accident that took place on
03.05.2022.
5. The Tribunal upon considering the oral and documentary
evidence and after hearing the arguments advanced by either side, holding
that the second respondent shall pay compensation for a sum of
Rs.3,75,000/- with interest at the rate of 7.5% p.a. from the date of filing of
the claim petition, payable by the second respondent at the first instance
with liberty to recover the same from the first respondent later.
6. The amounts awarded by the Tribunal under various heads are
tabulated under :S.No.
Heads
Amount awarded
by the
Tribunal(Rs.)
Towards partial permanent
disability
Rs. 3,28,000/-
Towards pain and sufferings
Rs.
40,000/-
Towards transportation & extra
nourishment (Rs.2,000/each)
Rs.
4,000/-
Towards damages to clothing
and articles
Rs.
1,000/-
For attender charges
Rs.
2,000/-
Total
Rs.3,75,000/-
__________
Page3 of 15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026
CMA.No.3692 of 2025
7. The learned counsel for the appellant/Insurance Company would
vehemently contend that as the second respondent
has permitted the
vehicle to be ridden without a valid driving license and therefore, the
appellant is not liable to indemnify the claimant as per law. As per Section
149(5) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1998, though the provision has been
recalled, the Claims Tribunal has erroneously issued pay and recover
direction, which is also incorrect.
8. Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondent/claimant would
strenuously argue that though the accident occurred on 03.05.2022, as the
policy was issued on 04.09.2019, old provisions would apply and sought to
sustain pay and recover directions.
9. The core issue is that whether the insurance policies issued
before the commencement of the Motor Vehicles (Amendment) Act, 2019
are to be governed by the provisions of the unamended act, or not?
10. On behalf of the Insurance Company, counter has been filed to
the effect that the first respondent drove his motor cycle without valid
driving license at the relevant point of time. In this regard, the Officer of
Insurance Company has been examined as RW1( Mr.Jawahar).
RW1
would state that the first respondent admitted the charge and paid a fine of
__________
Page4 of 15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026
Rs.5,000/- to the Motor Vehicles Inspector for riding the Motorcycle without
valid driving license.
11. It is relevant to refer to the observations made by the Apex
Court in National Insurance Company vs. Swaran Singh and Others
reported in 2004(3) SCC 297, wherein it has been held as follows:-
(i) Chapter XI of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
providing compulsory insurance of vehicles
against third party risks is a social welfare
legislation to extend relief by compensation to
victims of accidents caused by use of motor
vehicles. The provisions of compulsory insurance
coverage of all vehicles are with this paramount
object and the provisions of the Act have to be so
interpreted as to effectuate the said object.
(ii) Insurer is entitled to raise a defence in a claim
petition filed under Section 163A or Section 166 of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 inter alia in terms of
Section 149(2)(a)(ii) of the said Act.
(iii) The breach of policy condition, e.g.
disqualification of driver or invalid driving licence of
the driver, as contained in Sub-section (2)(a)(ii) of
Section 149, have to be proved to have been
committed by the insured for avoiding liability by
the insurer. Mere absence, fake or invalid driving
licence or disqualification of the driver for driving at
the relevant time, are not in themselves defences
available to the insurer against either the insured
or the third parties. To avoid its liability towards
insured, the insurer has to prove that the insured
was guilty of negligence and failed to exercise
reasonable care in the matter of fulfilling the
condition of the policy regarding use of vehicles by
duly licensed driver or one who was not
disqualified to drive at the relevant time.
__________
Page5 of 15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026
(iv) The insurance companies are, however, with
a view to avoid their liability must not only
establish the available defence(s) raised in the
said proceedings but must also establish 'breach'
on the part of the owner of the vehicle; the burden
of proof where for would be on them.
(v) The court cannot lay down any criteria as to
how said burden would be discharged, inasmuch
as the same would depend upon the facts and
circumstance of each case.
(vi) Even where the insurer is able to prove
breach on the part of the insured concerning the
policy condition regarding holding of a valid
licence by the driver or his qualification to drive
during the relevant period, the insurer would not
be allowed to avoid its liability towards insured
unless the said breach or breaches on the
condition of driving licence is/ are so fundamental
as are found to have contributed to the cause of
the accident. The Tribunals in interpreting the
policy conditions would apply "the rule of main
purpose" and the concept of "fundamental breach"
to allow defences available to the insured under
Section 149(2) of the Act.
(vii) The question as to whether the owner has
taken reasonable care to find out as to whether
the driving licence produced by the driver, (a fake
one or otherwise), does not fulfill the requirements
of law or not will have to be determined in each
case.
(viii) If a vehicle at the time of accident was
driven by a person having a learner's licence, the
insurance companies would be liable to satisfy the
decree.
(ix) The claims tribunal constituted under Section
165 read with Section 168 is empowered to
adjudicate all claims in respect of the accidents
involving death or of bodily injury or damage to
property of third party arising in use of motor
vehicle. The said power of the tribunal is not
restricted to decide the claims inter se between
__________
Page6 of 15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026
claimant or claimants on one side and insured,
insurer and driver on the other. In the course of
adjudicating the claim for compensation and to
decide the availability of defence or defences to
the insurer, the Tribunal has necessarily the power
and jurisdiction to decide disputes inter se
between insurer and the insured. The decision
rendered on the claims and disputes inter se
between the insurer and insured in the course of
adjudication of claim for compensation by the
claimants and Se award made thereon is
enforceable and executable in the same manner
as provided in Section 174 of the Act for
enforcement and execution of the award in favour
of the claimants.
(x) Where on adjudication of the claim under the
Act the tribunal arrives at a conclusion that the
insurer has satisfactorily proved its defence in
accordance with the provisions of Section 149(2)
read with Sub-section (7), as interpreted by this
Court above, the Tribunal can direct that the
insurer is liable to be reimbursed by the insured for
the compensation and other amounts which it has
been compelled to pay to the third party under the
award of the tribunal Such determination of claim
by the Tribunal will be enforceable and the money
found due to the insurer from the insured will be
recoverable on a certificate issued by the tribunal
to the Collector in the same manner under Section
174 of the Act as arrears of land revenue. The
certificate will be issued for the recovery as
arrears of land revenue only if, as required by
Sub-section (3) of Section 168 of the Act the
insured fails to deposit the amount awarded in
favour of the insurer within thirty days from the
date of announcement of the award by the
tribunal.
(xi) The provisions contained in Sub-section (4)
with proviso thereunder and Sub-section (5) which
are intended to cover specified contingencies
mentioned therein to enable the insurer to recover
amount paid under the contract of insurance on
behalf of the insured can be taken recourse of by
the Tribunal and be extended to claims and
__________
Page7 of 15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026
defences of insurer against insured by, relegating
them to the remedy before, regular court in cases
where on given facts and circumstances
adjudication of their claims inter se might delay the
adjudication of the claims of the victims.
12. As the first respondent has admitted his guilt and paid the fine as
mentioned supra, under Section 149(2)(ii), the Tribunal gave a direction to
the second respondent to pay the compensation at the first instance and to
recover the same from the first respondent thereafter.
13. The accident took place on 03.05.2022.
The Amendment of
Motor Vehicles Act, 2019 came into effect from 01.04.2022.
It is not in
dispute that the insurance policy was issued on 04.09.2019, which is prior
to the Amendment Act, being brought into force on 01.04.2022.
The
answer to the query is given in Section 147(4) of the Act, 2019.
14. Section 147(4) of the said Act, is extracted hereunder :-
Notwithstanding anything contained in this act, a policy of
Insurance issued before the Commencement of the Motor
Vehicles (Amendment) Act, 2019 shall be continued on
the existing terms under the contract and the provisions of
this Act shall apply as if this Act had not been amended
by the said Act.
__________
Page8 of 15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026
15. As per Section 147(4) of the Act of 2019, if the Insurance Policy
is issued before 01.04.2022, the policy shall be continued on the existing
terms under the contract and the old provisions would govern the field.
Therefore, the Insurance policy was issued well before the cut off date i.e.,
01.04.2022 and as per Section 147(4) of the Act of 2019, it should not lie in
the mouth of the second respondent to contend that the new provisions
would govern the field. The said argument to that effect is not tenable in
law. Therefore, the pay and recover direction issued by the Tribunal is
found to be in order and it does not call for any interference by this Court.
The issue is answered accordingly.
CMA.No.443 of 2026
16. The learned counsel for the appellant/claimant would put forth
that the claimant was aged about 59 years and was working as a mason at
the relevant point of time and suffered Type II distal humerus fracture on
the right side, and having suffered 41% disability on account of the
accident, he finds it difficult to work as a mason as he did before, and the
Tribunal has failed to invoke the multiplier method, which is incorrect. It is
further argued that no amount towards loss of earning during the treatment
period was granted by the Tribunal.
17.
Per
contra,
the
learned
counsel
for
the
second
respondent/Insurance Company would strenuously contend that for the
__________
Page9 of 15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026
disability assessed by the Medical Board, the Tribunal, taking the same
into consideration, has granted a sum of Rs.3,28,000/- based on the
percentage method which is quite reasonable and acceptable and
according to him, it does not call for any interference by this Court.
18. It has come on record through the evidence of P.W.1 that on
account of the accident, he suffered type II distal femur fracture on the left
side.
The Regional District Medical Board, Rajiv Gandhi Government
Hospital, Chennai has assessed the disability of the claimant at 41%
(Ex.C1/Disability Certificate). As per Ex.B5 - Discharge summary issued
by the Rajiv Gandhi Government College Hospital, Chennai, he was
admitted as an inpatient on 03.05.2022 and discharged on 24.05.2022 and
underwent surgery on 19.05.2022 wherein open reduction and internal
fixation with medial plating was done.
19. A distal femur fracture is a serious break in the lower part of the
thigh-bone- just above the knee joint. It often causes severe pain, swelling
and inability to bear weight.
Type-B denotes a partial articular fracture
involving the articular surface. Open reduction and internal fixation were
performed using clamps and screws of 4.5mm and a plate and screws
were fixed.
__________
Page10 of 15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026
20. Of course, as rightly pointed out by the learned counsel for the
claimant, due to the fractures suffered the injured would definitely find it
difficult while walking, standing and climbing stairs etc.
21. On the other hand, the claimant was 59 years old at the relevant
point of time. Even before the accident, he was not in good health, as per
Ex.B5/Discharge Certificate.
22. In such a view of the matter, taking the functional disability at
41% and a sum of Rs.9,000/- per percentage is granted ( 41% x Rs.9,000/= Rs.3,69,000/-).
23. As regards the income of the injured /PW1 would state that as a
mason, he used to earn Rs.1,000/- per day. The date of the accident is
03.05.2022. In consideration of the above said details, this Court deems it
fit to fix the notional income of the injured at Rs.19,000/- per month, and a
sum of Rs.76,000/- is granted for the loss of earning during the treatment
period (Rs.19,000/- x 4 months). For transportation, extra nourishment
and for attender charges, a sum of Rs.10,000/- is granted under each
head, in addition to the amount already awarded to the Tribunal.
__________
Page11 of 15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026
24. As regards, the other amounts awarded by the Tribunal, they
appear to be reasonable and acceptable and hence, it does not call for any
interference by this Court.
25. The amounts awarded by this Court, as mentioned supra, are
reworked and tabulated hereunder:Sl.No.
Description
Amount
Amount
Awarded by awarded by this
the Tribunal
Court
(Rs.)
(Rs.)
Award
confirmed
or
enhanced
or granted
or reduced
Towards partial
Rs.3,28,000/permanent disability
Rs.3,69,000/-
enhanced
Towards pain and Rs. 40,000/sufferings
Rs.
40,000/-
confirmed
Towards loss of
earning during the
treatment
period( Rs.19,000/x 4 months)
Rs.
76,000/-
granted
Rs.
30,000/--
enhanced
confirmed
-
Towards
transportation, extra
nourishment and Rs. 6,000/attender charges
Towards damages
to clothing and
articles
Rs. 1,000/-
Rs.. 1,000/-
Total
Rs..3,75,000/
-
Rs.5,16,000/-
26. In the result,
i) C.M.A.No.3692 of 2025 stands dismissed.
ii) CMA.No.443 of 2026 stands partly allowed.
__________
Page12 of 15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026
iii) The Compensation awarded by the Tribunal is enhanced
from Rs.3,75,000/- to Rs.5,16,000/-.
(iv)The Insurance Company / second respondent is directed
to deposit the enhanced compensation amount now
determined by this Court i.e., Rs.5,16,000/- (less the
amount already deposited if any) together with interest at
the rate of 7.5% per annum from the date of claim petition
till the date of deposit, (excluding the period of default, if
any) and costs to the credit of M.C.O.P.No.2228 of 2022 on
the file of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal/IV Court of Small
Causes, Chennai, within a period of eight weeks from the
date of receipt of a copy of this Judgment.
(v)On such deposit being made, the appellant/claimant is
permitted to withdraw the same along with interest and
costs, by making necessary application before the Tribunal.
vi)The appellant/claimant is directed to pay the Court fee for
the compensation amount, if required.
vii)The Tribunal below shall disburse the enhanced amount
upon production of the certified copy showing proof of
__________
Page13 of 15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026
payment of Court fee by the claimant. There is no order as
to costs.
Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition
is closed.
11.03-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
KKD
To
The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
IV Court of Small Causes, Chennai.
__________
Page14 of 15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026
R.KALAIMATHI, J.
KKD
CMA Nos. 3692 of 2025 & 443 of 2026
11-03-2026
__________
Page15 of 15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review