Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010882032017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
WEDNESDAY,THE FOURTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 1171/2017
Between:
1. UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED, REP BY ITS
DIVISIONAL MANAGER DIVISIONAL OFFICE OPPOSITE TO
DHOBIGHAT ROAD KADAPA CITY AND DISTRICT.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. NETAPALLI PRAVALIKA 4 OTHERS, W/O LATE MASTHAN BABU
AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS, HINDU HOUSE -WIFE CHAKTAYAPETA
VILLAGE & MANDAL, KADAPA DISTRICT
2. NETAPALLI HARSITHA, D/O LATE MASTHAN BABU AGED ABOUT 7
YEARS HINDUMINOR REP BY THEIR NEXT FRIEND RESPONDENT
NO 1 BEING THEIR NATURAL GUARDIAN CHAKTAYAPETA
VILLAGE & MANDAL, KADAPA DISTRICT.
3. NETAPALLI HARSHA VARDHAN, S/O MASTHAN BABU AGED
ABOUT 1 1/2 YEARS, HINDU, MINOR REP BY THEIR NEXT FRIEND
RESPONDENT NO.1 BEING THEIR NATURAL GUARDIAN
CHAKTAYAPETA VILLAGE & MANDAL, KADAPA DISTRICT.
4. NETAPALLI UTTAMMA, W/O NAGULAIAH, AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
HINDU, HOUSE-WIFE CHAKTAYAPETA VILLAGE & MANDAL,
KADAPA DISTRICT.
5. RAYANI SUBBIMMA, W/O KONDAIAH, AGED ABIUR 40 YEARS
HINDU, OWNER OF THE LORRY BEARING NO AP 04 U 3366,
RESIFING AT D.NO.4-1187-A1, NEW COLONY, YERRAGUNTLA
VS,J
CMA.No.1171 of 2017
VILLAGE AND MANDAL, KADAPA DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal against orders aggrieved by the orders passed in W.C.No.2 of
2015 dated 15.03.2017 by the Commissioner for Workmen Compensation and
Assistant Commissioner of Labour, Kadapa.
IA NO: 1 OF 2017(CMAMP 2045 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
pass such other orders.
IA NO: 2 OF 2017(CMAMP 2046 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
pass such other orders.
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. MEDAPATI SANTOSH REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. D KODANDARAMI REDDY
The Court made the following:
VS,J
CMA.No.1171 of 2017
JUDGMENT:
The Insurance Company filed the present appeal challenging the order
dated 15.03.2017 in W.C.No.2 of 2015 on the file of the Commissioner for
Workmens Compensation and Assistant Commissioner of Labour, Kadapa,
whereby and whereunder the Tribunal granted compensation of Rs.7,62,633/(Rupees Seven lakhs Sixty Two thousand Six hundred and Thirty Three only)
to the claimants/respondent Nos.1 to 4 herein, as against the claim of
Rs.9,27,000/-, on account of the death of the deceased Natapalli Masthan
Babu in a motor accident that occurred on 07.08.2014.
02.
For the purpose of convenience, the parties will be referred to as they
are arrayed before the Tribunal.
03.
The claimant filed the claim petition before the Tribunal under
Workmen’s Compensation Act 1923 and the A.P. Rules 1923, the case of the
claimants, in brief, is as follows:
The deceased/Netapalli Masthan Babu was aged 31 years, working as
driver of the lorry bearing No.AP04-U-3366, under 1st opposite party and he
was earning Rs.9,000/- per month as wages. The 1st opposite party is the
registered owner of the lorry bearing No.AP04-U-3366 and the 2nd opposite
party is the insurer and the policy was in force as on the date of accident,
covering the risk of the driver of the lorry. On the instructions of the 1st
opposite party on 06.08.2014 the deceased was driving the lorry to
Sydapuram of Nellore District, loaded with timber/sticks and on 07.08.2014,
VS,J
CMA.No.1171 of 2017
he left Sydapuram and was proceeding to Ananthapuram to unload the same,
unfortunately on the way to Rapur to Chitvel ghat road, the lorry fell into 70
feet deep valley and the lorry was badly damaged, sticks scattered and the
deceased who was on steering sustained fatal injuries and met instantaneous
death. Thus, it is clear that the deceased died in the course of his employment
under 1st opposite party and there is employee and employer relationship in
between the deceased and 1st opposite party. Thereafter, the applicants tried
to contact the deceased on phone, there was no response, suspecting any
accident, the applicants made a search and noticed the dead body of the
deceased on 09.08.2014 due to fall of the lorry in the valley. All the belongings
of the deceased were lost in the said accident, inspite of the best efforts made
by the applicants. Basing on the report, Chitvel police registered a case in
Crime No.66 of 2014 under Section 304-A IPC. The deceased had valid
driving license to drive heavy transport vehicles. Due to sudden demise of the
deceased, the applicants lost their breadwinner.
04.
Before the Tribunal, opposite party No.1 remained ex parte.
05.
The opposite party No.2 filed written statement contending that the
applicants have to prove that the deceased died in a motor vehicle accident as
driver of the lorry bearing No.AP04-U-3366 by way of documentary evidence
such as FIR, charge sheet and the result of criminal case etc. The claimants
have also prove that the said lorry was duly insured with 2nd opposite party
and that valid coverage of policy and the policy was in force at the time of
VS,J
CMA.No.1171 of 2017
accident. The claimants have also to prove the deceased was having
subsisting driving license at the time of accident, subject to terms and
conditions of the policy, otherwise, 2nd respondent is not liable to indemnify the
applicants. The driver of respondent No.1 has no valid and effective driving
license at the time of accident and there is violation of terms and conditions of
the policy by opposite party No.1. A reading of FIR goes to show that the
accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the deceased. The
opposite party No.2 also denies the age, avocation and income of the
deceased and the manner of the accident. The amount of compensation
claimed by the applicants is high and excessive and finally sought for
dismissal of the claim against the 2nd opposite party.
06.
Basing on the pleadings, the Tribunal framed the following issues for
trial:
“1. Whether the deceased was a workman as per the provisions of the
Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923 and he met with the accident arising
out of and in the course of his employment?
2. What is the age of the deceased at the time of accident?
3. Whether the deceased really died during the course of his employment
under 1st opposite party or not?
4. What were the wages paid to the deceased at the time of accident?
5. What is the quantum of compensation payable to the applicants?
5. Who are liable to pay the compensation to the Applicants?”
VS,J
CMA.No.1171 of 2017
07.
On behalf of the petitioners/claimants, A.W.1 was examined and Exs.A1
to A7 were marked. On behalf of the opposite party No.II, Rws.1 and 2 were
examined and Exs.B1 and B2 were marked.
08.
After hearing both parties and after considering the oral and
documentary evidence on record, the Tribunal direct the opposite parties No.I
and II are liable to deposit an amount of Rs.7,62,633/- as compensation
besides stamp duty Rs.1,525/- with interest at 12% p.a. from the date of
accident till realization by means of demand draft in favour of the
Commissioner for Workmen’s Compensation and Joint Commissioner for
Labour, Kurnool drawn on State Bank of India, Kurnool within 30 days from
the date of receipt of this order. If failed to deposit the awarded amount within
the stipulated time, it has to pay the interest at 12% p.a. from the date of
accident till realization and also penalty under Section 4(A) 3(b) of the
Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923. Therefore, the applicants are directed to
make representation to the Commissioner for Workmen’s Compensation and
Joint Commissioner of Labour, Kurnool, for release of compensation amount
deposited by the Opposite Parties I and II.
09.
Aggrieved by the said award, the appellant/opposite party No.2
preferred this appeal contending that the learned Commissioner failed to
observe that the deceased was not under the employment of the respondent
No.5/opposite party No.1 and failed to follow the fairly established norms in
passing the award. The Authority ought to have seen that the applicants had
VS,J
CMA.No.1171 of 2017
not produced the driving license of the deceased to prove that the deceased
was a driver. The learned Commissioner ought to have seen that there is no
employer and employee relationship between the deceased and the insured of
the said vehicle. It is, therefore, prayed to allow the appeal.
10.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the claimants/respondent Nos.1
to 4 herein has supported the impugned award and prayed to dismiss the
appeal.
11.
Now the point for consideration is:
Whether the order of the Tribunal needs any interference?
POINT:
12.
To prove that the deceased met with an accident on 07.08.2014 while
the deceased was driving the lorry bearing No.AP 04 U 3366 of 1st opposite
party as a driver, unfortunately on the way the lorry fell into 70 feet deep valley
and the lorry was badly damaged and the deceased who was on steering
sustained fatal injuries, and succumbed to death instantaneously, the
applicants relied upon the evidence of AW1 and documentary evidence
Exs.A1 to A7.
13.
A perusal of the record reveals that the evidence of AW1, RW1 & RW2
coupled with Exs.A1 to A7, B1 & B2 clearly proves that on the date of accident
i.e., on 07.08.2014 as per the instructions of the 1st opposite party the
deceased attended as driver to the lorry and in that process as narrated supra
VS,J
CMA.No.1171 of 2017
the deceased succumbed to death. This in turn proves that the deceased was
a workmen (Driver) under the employment of 1st opposite party to his lorry and
there was employee and employer relationship in between the deceased and
the 1st opposite party. Thus, the Tribunal has rightly held that the accident
occurred while the deceased was discharging his duty as a driver and the
deceased succumbed to death because of the said accident and also rightly
held that there exists employer-employee relationship between the 1st
opposite party and the deceased.
14.
Since the Insured/1st opposite party is the employer of the deceased as
on the date of accident, and that the vehicle was insured with the 2nd opposite
party/Insurer, covering the risk of driver of the crime vehicle, for which
premium is paid, and that the Insurance Policy was in force as on the date of
accident and as there exists employer-employee relationship between the 1st
opposite party and the deceased. But the deceased has no valid and effective
driving license to drive the heavy vehicles at ghat section.
15.
Under similar circumstances, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in “National
Insurance Co. Ltd. V. Swaran Singh & Ors.1” Has categorically held that the
insurance company may not be liable to satisfy the decree and, therefore, its
liability may be zero but it does mean that it did not have initial liability at all.
Thus, if the insurance company is made liable to pay any amount it can
recover the entire amount paid to the third party on behalf of the assured.
(2004) 3 SCC 297
VS,J
CMA.No.1171 of 2017
Therefore, the Tribunal has power to direct them to satisfy the decree at the
first instance and then direct recovery of the same from the owner.
16.
In “National Insurance Co. Ltd. V. Swaran Singh & Ors.,” (referred
above) the Hon’ble Supreme Court while dealing with the case of
unauthorized passengers held as follows:
“Sub-section (5) of Section 149 which imposes a liability on
the insurer must also be given its full effect. The insurance
company may not be liable to satisfy the decree and, therefore, its
liability may be zero but it does mean that it did not have initial
liability at all. Thus, if the insurance company is made liable to pay
any amount it can recover the entire amount paid to the third party
on behalf of the assured. If this interpretation is not given to the
beneficent provisions of the Act having regard to its purport and
object, we fail to see a situation where beneficent provisions can
be given effect to Sub-section (7) of Section 149 of the Act, to
which pointed attention of the Court has been drawn by the
learned counsel for the petitioner, which is in negative language
may now be noticed. The said provision must be read with Subsection (1) thereof. The right to avoid liability in terms of Subsection (2) of Section 149 is restricted as has been discussed
herein before. It is one thing to say that the insurance companies
are entitled to raise a defence but it is another thing to say that
despite the fact that its defence has been accepted having regard
to the facts and circumstances of the case, the Tribunal has
power to direct them to satisfy the decree at the first instance and
then direct recovery of the same from the owner. These two
matters stand apart and require contextual reading.”
17.
As per the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
Judgment (referred supra) even if the insurer successfully proves a breach of
VS,J
CMA.No.1171 of 2017
policy condition, the insurance company may still be directed to pay
compensation to the claimant and then recover the amount from the insured
(owner of the vehicle). This ensures that the rights of the third-party victim are
protected and it was emphasized that insurance policies are statutorily
required to protect third parties, and even in cases of breach by the insured,
the insurer’s liability towards third-party victims does not vanish immediately.
18.
In view of the same and in the light of the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court referred to supra, the contention of 2nd opposite party –
insurance company that it cannot be directed to pay the compensation cannot
be accepted. In view of the same, this Court is of the considered opinion that
the 2nd opposite party is also jointly and severally liable to pay compensation
to the claimants.
19.
So far as the quantum of compensation is concerned, since no
documentary proof filed to substantiate his income, the Tribunal fixed the
wages of the deceased as per minimum wages fixed to heavy vehicle driver
vide G.O.Ms.No.83 LET&F (Lab-II) Department, dated 22.11.2006 at
Rs.7,406/- per month on the date of accident occurrence. As the age of the
deceased was 31 years as on the date of accident, the Tribunal below rightly
calculated the compensation amount of Rs.7,62,633/- by taking age, limited
wages and the relevant age factor (Rs.7,406/- x 50/100 x Rs.205.95). In
addition to the above, the Tribunal has rightly imposed interest @ 12% per
annum and also stamp duty of Rs.1,525/-. Thus, the tribunal has rightly
VS,J
CMA.No.1171 of 2017
applied the relevant age factor and calculated the amounts entitled by the
applicants and awarded compensation.
20.
In view of the above discussion, while confirming the quantum of
compensation awarded by the Tribunal, this Court deems it appropriate to
modify the award passed by the Tribunal only to the extent of directing 2nd
opposite party – insurance company to initially pay the compensation to the
appellants – claimants and then recover the amount from the owner of the
vehicle.
21.
Accordingly, the appeal is partly allowed directing 2nd opposite party –
Insurance company to initially pay the compensation amount of Rs.7,62,633/along with interest at the rate of 12% p.a. from the date of petition till
realization to the claimants, within a period of three months from the date of
receipt of copy of the order and then recover the same from the insured-owner
of the offending vehicle (1st opposite party) by filing Execution proceedings
before the Tribunal. No costs.
Interim orders granted earlier if any, stand vacated.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
___________________
JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
Date: 04.02.2026
PBS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review