Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010975502018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA
PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3505]
THURSDAY,THE NINTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE T.C.D.SEKHAR
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO:
3439/2018
Between:
1. UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO.LTD, REP. BY IT'S
DIVISIONAL MANAGER,
FIRST FLOOR, SRI DEVI
COMPLEX, THIRUPATHI
...APPELLANT
AND
1. Y SAI TEJA AND 2 OTHERS, S/O. Y.SURESH, 16 YEARS,
MINOR, BEING MINOR REP.BY NATURAL GUARDIAN
AND HIS FATHER, Y.SURESH, JANDAMANU STREET,
BUCHINAIDU KANDRIGA VILLAGE AND MANDAL,
CHITHOOR DISTRICT, ANDHRA PRADESH
2. VIKAS E M SCHOOL, REP.BY IT'S CORRESPONDENT,
P.RENUKA,
MAJOR,D.NO.1-186C,
BUCHINAIDU
KANDRIGA VILLAGE AND MANDAL,
CHITHOOR
DISTRICT, ANDHRA PRADESH
3. C CHENCHU RAMAIAH, S/O. SURAIAH, MAJOR, DRIVER,
D.NO.3-100, KANAMANAMBEDU VILLAGE, BUCHINAIDU
KANDRIGA
VILLAGE
AND
MANDAL,CHITHOOR
DISTRICT, ANDHRA PRADESH
TCDS, J
MACMA_3439_ 2018
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC praying that the High
court may be pleased to set aside the Judgment and Decree,
dated 2-7-2018, in MVOP NO- 328 of 2012 Passed by the
Chairman, MACT-X Additional District Judge at Tirupathi and
allow the appeal in the interest of justice.
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the
petition, the High Court may be pleased to condone the delay of
64 days in preferring the above appeal before this Hon'ble court
in the interest of justice
IA NO: 2 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the
petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay of all further
proceedings including the execution of the judgment and decree
in MVOP.No.328 of 201 dt.2-7-2018 passed by the MACT-X ADJ
at Tirupathi, pending the above appeal before this Hon'ble court
in the interest of justice
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. SRINIVASA RAO VUTLA
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GANDHAVALLI MAHESH DEVAN
2. D KODANDARAMI REDDY
The Court made the following:
TCDS, J
MACMA_3439_ 2018
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE T.C.D. SEKHAR
M.A.C.M.A.No.3439 of 2018
JUDGMENT:-
1.
Aggrieved by order dated 02.07.2018 in M.V.O.P
No.328 of 2012 on the file of Chairman Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal-cum-X Additional District Judge, Tirupati, the
present appeal is preferred by United India Insurance
company limited.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties are
referred as they were referred before the Tribunal.
3.
The petitioner filed claim petition under section
166(1) (c) of Motor Vehicles Act and the Rules made there
under claiming compensation of Rs.10,00,000/- on account
of the injuries sustained by him in the accident that occurred
on 08.03.2012 near Arigela Kandriga Yanadi Centre,
B.N.Kandriga Mandal in which the offending school bus
bearing registration No.AP-03-W-9878 was involved. It was
the case of the petitioner that he was prosecuting 10th
TCDS, J
MACMA_3439_ 2018
standard in 1st respondent school. On 08.03.2012 he
boarded the bus, when it reached Arigela Kandriga Yanadi
center, the driver of the offending bus drove the same at high
speed, in rash and negligent manner, thereby he lost control
over the vehicle and it turned turtle. As a result of which the
petitioner and other inmates of the bus sustained multiple
grievous injuries. The petitioner was taken to Area hospital,
Srikalahasti and later he was shifted to Miot hospital,
Chennai. Where he undertook treatment as inpatient from
08.03.2012 to 26.03.2012. He has also taken follow up
treatment in the said hospital. It was further case of the
petitioner that, he was distributing milk packets and earning
Rs.5,000/- per month and the same was contributed to his
family. In view of the injuries received by him, he approached
the Tribunal by filing the above claim petition.
4.
The respondent Nos.1 and 3 remained ex parte.
5.
The 2nd respondent resisted the claim by filing
counter affidavit.
TCDS, J
MACMA_3439_ 2018
6.
The 2nd respondent denied the averments made
in the claim petition and stated that the claim of the petitioner
was excessive. It was further contended that the insurance
company will indemnify the insured subject to confirmation of
the policy, provided the vehicle had RC and other relevant
documents. It was inter alia contended that the petitioner
was not earning member of the family and the injuries
sustained by him were simple in nature and there was no
permanent disability.
7.
In order to prove the case of the petitioner PWs 1
to 4 were examined and got marked Exs.A1 to A11. Copy of
Ex.X1 was marked through PW4.
8.
On the other hand, the respondent examined
RWs 1 and 2 and got marked Exs.B1 & B2 and Exs.X2 to
X4.
9.
the
claim
The Tribunal after hearing the parties, allowed
petition
by
awarding
compensation
of
Rs.10,00,000/- together with interest at the rate of 9% per
annum, fastening the liability on the respondents.
TCDS, J
MACMA_3439_ 2018
10.
Questioning the same, the present appeal is
11.
Heard the learned counsel for the appellant and
filed.
Sri Lakshmi Harish representing, Sri D.Kodandarami Reddy
appearing for 1st respondent and Sri Gandhavara Mahesh
appearing for 2nd respondent. Despite service of notice there
is no appearance for 3rd respondent.
12.
Though several grounds were raised in the
present appeal, during the course of hearing the counsel for
appellant confined his arguments as against the quantum of
compensation awarded by the Tribunal. He would submit
that the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is excessive
in as much as the petitioner was student and he was not
earning member of the family. He would further submit that
nothing is placed on record to show that he was earning
Rs.5,000/- per month by distributing the milk packets.
13.
In order to substantiate the said contention, the
insurance company examined RWs 1 and 2. A perusal of the
evidence of RWs 1 and 2 would show that they have
TCDS, J
MACMA_3439_ 2018
deposed in relation to the manner in which accident occurred
and with regard to the insurance policy issued as against the
offending vehicle. Therefore, the evidence of RWs 1 and 2
will not help the insurance company in as much as already
noted supra, the counsel for appellant has given up all other
grounds except questioning the quantum of compensation
awarded in favour of the petitioner.
14.
On the other hand, the petitioner examined PWs
1 to 4. A perusal of the evidence of PW1, would show that
the petitioner was contributing Rs.5,000/- per month by
distributing milk packets in the village.
15.
Though a suggestion was put to him in this
regard that the petitioner was not earning member, the same
was denied by PW1. The petitioner also reiterated the same
in the claim petition. It is not uncommon in rural areas where,
the school going children often engage in income generating
activities to support their household, especially to strengthen
financial situation. Further, it was specifically pleaded in the
claim petition that, the petitioner was contributing some
TCDS, J
MACMA_3439_ 2018
amount and PWs 1 & 3 also deposed in similar lines and
their evidence remained un-shattered.
16.
Except denying the evidence placed by the
petitioner, the respondent has miserably failed to disprove
the same. Though, it is the case of the petitioner that he was
getting Rs.5,000/- per month by distributing milk packets, it is
difficult to accept the same, nevertheless there cannot be
any dispute with regard to the contribution made by the
petitioner to his family. Therefore, the contention of the
learned counsel for appellant in this regard cannot be
countenanced, and accordingly the same is rejected.
17.
The Tribunal by following the Judgment rendered
by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of “Mallikarjun v.
Divisional
Manager,
National
Insurance
Company
Limited and another” 1 had awarded compensation of
Rs.10,00,000/-. The said amount was awarded under two
heads
(i)
Rs.6,00,000/-
towards
medical
expenses,
medicines and extra nourishment (ii) Rs.4,00,000/- towards
2013 ACJ 2445 (SC)
TCDS, J
MACMA_3439_ 2018
pain and suffering already undergone and to be suffered in
future, mental and physical shock, hardship, inconvenience
and discomfort etc., and loss of amenities of life on account
of permanent disability.
18.
The counsel for the respondent/claimant would
submit that while awarding compensation the Tribunal had
not followed the ratio laid down by the Honourable Apex
Court in the case of “Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport
Corporation=2. He would further submit that the Tribunal did
not appreciate the case of the petitioner in its proper
prospective and the disability suffered by him was also not
taken into account. He would further submit that the
petitioner had filed disability certificate dated 16.06.2014
issued by PW4.
19.
It is contended that the petitioner suffered
disability of 35% and in view of the same the petitioner is
unable to move his left hand freely and it is difficult for him to
attend day to day activities. By virtue of the said injury, the
2009 ACJ 1298
TCDS, J
MACMA_3439_ 2018
petitioner also lost future prospects and the prospects of
marriage etc. He would further submit that though the
compensation was restricted to Rs.10,00,000/- by the
claimant, if all these factors are considered the petitioner
would be entitled to much more than the claim and
requested
this
Court
to
enhance
the
compensation
accordingly.
20.
It is not in dispute that the petitioner suffered
disability of 35% to upper limb i.e., left hand. A perusal of the
photographs shown across the bar, it is clear that the left
hand of the petitioner suffered crush injury and he cannot
move the same freely as he was before. In such
circumstances the amount of compensation payable for the
injuries suffered by the petitioner has to compensate such
injury inasmuch as the petitioner has become handicapped
person and he has to suffer the same throughout the life.
21.
By taking into consideration of the fact that the
petitioner was studying 10th standard as on the date of
accident and keeping in mind that had he not met with the
TCDS, J
MACMA_3439_ 2018
accident, he could have secured a better employment, he
shall be compensated accordingly. Further, a perusal of the
order of the Tribunal, it is apparent that the compensation
was not awarded under the head of future prospects. The
Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of <Mekala Vs. M.Malathi
and others= 3 had held that the Courts are duty bound to
award just and reasonable compensation under the head of
loss of future prospects.
22.
A perusal of the evidence of PWs 1 and 3 would
go to show that he was also contributing his earnings to the
family. Though the Tribunal had allowed the claim petition by
awarding compensation as claimed by the petitioner, as can
be seen from the evidence of PW4, Dr.P.V.A. Mohandas
who deposed that the petitioner sustained major crush injury
to left upper limb. He had bronchial artery injury and soft
tissue lost triple nerve injury with compound fracture and
dislocation of the elbow. He was admitted in hospital on
26.09.2012 and discharged on 01.10.2012. Further he
(2014) 11 SCC 178
TCDS, J
MACMA_3439_ 2018
deposed that the petitioner was clinically examined and
observed clawing of fingers of the left hand and he has no
hand function. He also had scarsing of the entire left upper
limb and it was assessed as permanent partial disability of
35% and a certificate was issued to that effect which was
marked as Ex.A4. During the cross-examination he deposed
that the disability was assessed by following WHO norms.
Though he was cross-examined at length nothing was
elicited to disprove his evidence or the disability certificate
issued.
23.
Having considered the submissions made by the
counsel for the claimant and upon appreciating the oral and
documentary evidence placed, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the claimant is entitled to receive over and
above compensation claimed by him. The Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of “Ramla v. National Insurance
Company Ltd.,= 4had held that the Courts are duty bound to
award just compensation to the victim/claimant if he is
(2019) 2 SCC 192
TCDS, J
MACMA_3439_ 2018
entitled to receive more compensation than what has been
claimed. For the reasons recorded supra, the income of the
petitioner is fixed as Rs.10,000/- per month and accordingly
the compensation is computed as under:
S.No.
Head
Compensation Awarded
Net monthly Income
Rs.10,000/-
Future Prospects (50%)
Rs.5,000/-
Total Income (Net monthly)
Rs.15,000/-
Multiplier
Disability
35%
Loss of future income
Medical Expenses (Treatment)
Rs.6,00,000/-
Total
Rs.17,34,000/-
24.
Rs.15,000 x 12 x 18 x 35%
= Rs.11,34,000/-
In view of the above, there are no merits in the
present appeal and accordingly the same is dismissed.
Further the insurance company directed to pay the enhanced
compensation together with interest at the rate of 9% per
annum from the date of the petition till the date of realization.
It is needless to mention that the appellant is directed to pay
TCDS, J
MACMA_3439_ 2018
the said amount within a period of two (2) months from the
date of receipt of the copy of the order.
_____________________
JUSTICE T.C.D.SEKHAR
09.04.2026
PBS/DR
TCDS, J
MACMA_3439_ 2018
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE T.C.D.SEKHAR
M.A.C.M.A.No: 3439 of 2018
Date: 09.04.2026
U
PBS/DR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review