The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
04. 08.2022 passed by the Ld. Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No.2, West Tripura, Agartala, in TS(MAC) 152 of 2020 whereby the Ld. Tribunal below has awarded compensation of Rs.58,39,200/- only (Rupees Fifty eight lakhs thirty nine thousand two hundred) only to the claimant respondents to be paid by the opposite party No.3 appellant within a period of one month from the date of award along with a simple interest of 9% per annum from the date of registration of claim i.e. w.e.f. 12.10.2020 till the date of realization. [2] Brief facts leading to this case is that on 27.06.2019 at about 10-30 p.m. when the deceased was returning home after completion of his work from Teliamura market by riding a bicycle through Assam-Agartala road, at that time a Truck bearing registration No. AS-01-CC-1958 (here-in-after called the offending vehicle) came there with excessive speed and in negligent manner dashed Litan Miah face to face and a serious accident occurred as a result Litan Miah had fallen on the road and the offending vehicle ran over the head and body of the deceased and he died on the spot. In this connection Teliamura PS Case No. 38 of 2019, dated 28.06.2019 u/s 279/304-A of IPC was also registered. Claimant petitioners further stated in their claim petition that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving on the part of the driver of the offending vehicle. [3] Claimant pet…
7. 5% interest per annum, as awarded by the learned tribunal with effect from the date of presentation of the claim petition till the date of actual payment. Thus, the insurance company i.e. United India Insurance Co. Ltd, is liable to pay the total amount as awarded by the Tribunal below in favour of the claimant-respondents within a period of 30 days from today. However, it is made clear that if the amount is already deposited, the claimant-respondents are at liberty to withdraw the same unconditionally. [17] In view of the above, the award is modified and the appeal is allowed to the extent as indicated above. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand closed. Draw the decree accordingly and thereafter, send down the LCRs forthwith. Dipak 16:17:09 +05'30'
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC.App 01 of 2023
United India Insurance Co. Ltd.
Represented by the Divisional Manager,
RMS Chowmuhani, GRS Tower Agartala, District- West Tripura
(Insurer of AS-01-CC-1958, Truck)
---Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Smt. Manoara Begam
W/o Late Litan Miah alias Siraj,
Resident of Vill- Baishgharia, PO: Golabari,
PS: Teliamura, Dist: Khowai presently residing at C/O Abdul Rahim
Chowdhury, G/P+ PO- West Noabadi, PS: Bodhjungnagar, Dist: West
Tripura
2. Smt. Niharika Akter
D/o Late Litan Miah alias Siraj,
R/o village- Baishgharia, PO: Golabari, PS: Teliamura, District: Khowai,
presently residing C/o Abdul Rahim Chowdhury, G/P+PO- West
Noabadi, PS: Bodhjungnagar, Dist: West Tripura
3. Smt Rosana Begam,
W/o- Abdul Rahaman alias Rahaman Miah, R/o- Vill-Baishgharia, PO:
Golabari, PS: Teliamura, Dist: Khowai
4. Abdul Rahaman alias Rahaman Miah
S/o Late Surjat Ali, R/o Village- Baishgharia, PO: Golabari, PS:
Teliamura, Dist: Khowai, (Driver of AS-01CC-1958, Truck)
---Claimant Respondent(s)
5. Sri Pujan Bhowmik,
S/o Late Manimoy Bhowmik Resident of Jagannathbari Road, PS- West
Agartala, PO: Agartala, Dist: West Tripura (Owner of AS-01CC-1958,
Truck)
6. Sri Nikhil Dey
S/o Late Kanai Lal Dey Resident of Kashipur (Water supply), PS: East
Agartala, PO: Agartala, Dist: West Tripura.
---Opposite party Respondents.
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing and
date of delivery of
judgment and order
Whether fit for reporting
: Ms. R. Purkayastha, Advocate.
: Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
Mr. S. Rahaman, Advocate.
: 05.10.2023
: No.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & Order (Oral)
This is an appeal against the impugned award dated
04.08.2022 passed by the Ld. Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No.2,
West Tripura, Agartala, in TS(MAC) 152 of 2020 whereby the Ld.
Tribunal below has awarded compensation of Rs.58,39,200/- only
(Rupees Fifty eight lakhs thirty nine thousand two hundred) only to the
claimant respondents to be paid by the opposite party No.3 appellant
within a period of one month from the date of award along with a
simple interest of 9% per annum from the date of registration of claim
i.e. w.e.f. 12.10.2020 till the date of realization.
[2]
Brief facts leading to this case is that on 27.06.2019 at
about 10-30 p.m. when the deceased was returning home after
completion of his work from Teliamura market by riding a bicycle
through Assam-Agartala road, at that time a Truck bearing registration
No. AS-01-CC-1958 (here-in-after called the offending vehicle) came
there with excessive speed and in negligent manner dashed Litan Miah
face to face and a serious accident occurred as a result Litan Miah had
fallen on the road and the offending vehicle ran over the head and
body of the deceased and he died on the spot. In this connection
Teliamura PS Case No. 38 of 2019, dated 28.06.2019 u/s 279/304-A
of IPC was also registered. Claimant petitioners further stated in their
claim petition that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent
driving on the part of the driver of the offending vehicle.
[3]
Claimant petitioners also stated that at the time of
accident deceased was aged about 30 years and he was a Plumber by
profession and he used to earn Rs. 26,000/- per month before the
accident.
[4]
The claimant petitioners, therefore, approached the court
below seeking compensation due to death of the deceased and
quantified their claim to the tune of Rs.61,99,200/-.
[5]
OP Nos.1 and 2 through their written statement apart from
denying all the allegations in the claim petition contended, inter alia,
that OP No.1 is the registered owner of the said offending vehicle and
it was duly insured with the OP No.2(United India Insurance Co. Ltd.).
OP No.1,therefore, urged for fixing the liability of his insurer to pay the
compensation, if any.
[6]
The case of OP No.2 is also of total denial and thereby put
the claimant petitioners as well as OP No.1 in strict proof thereof.
[7]
With a view to decide the claim of the claimant petitioners
following issues were framed :ISSUES
(i) Is the claim maintainable in its present form and nature ?
(ii) If the death of the deceased was caused due on the alleged
date, time and place due to road traffic accident on the rash
and negligent driving of the driver of alleged vehicle ? If so, are
the claimant petitioners entitled to get compensation ?
(iii) What should be the quantum of compensation and who
shall be liable to pay the compensation?
[8]
After considering all these aspects and materials available
in the record, this Tribunal finally observed in the following manner:
“Claimant petitioners are entitled to get the award of
Rs.58,39,200/- only (Rupees Fifty eight lakhs thirty nine
thousand two hundred) only along with 9% simple interest per
annum from the date of registration of claim i.e, w.e.f. 12-102020 till the date of realization thereof.
The petitioner No.1 exclusively shall be entitled to get
the amount of Rs. 40,000/- as consortium. The claimantpetitioner No. 2 shall also be entitled to get the amount of Rs.
2,00,000/- towards love and affection. All the claimant
petitioners shall have equal share on the rest amount.
(ii) 50% of the share of the claimant petitioner No.1 in
the award be invested by purchasing separate Fixed Deposit
certificate from any Nationalized Bank at least for the next 5
years and no loan or advance or premature withdrawal shall be
allowed without prior sanction of this Tribunal.
75% of the share of the claimant-petitioner No. 2 shall
also be invested by purchasing separate Fixed Deposit
certificate from any Nationalized Bank at least for the next 5
years and no loan or advance or premature withdrawal shall be
allowed till she attains the age of majority i.e. 21 years without
prior sanction of this Tribunal.
Remaining amount of shares of the claimant petitioners
shall be credited directly to their individual bank account.
However, the claimant petitioner No. 1 shall have the
liberty to withdraw the monthly interest from the fixed deposit
certificates to be purchased.
The OP No.3, i.e., the United India Insurance Company
Limited shall deposit the awarded amount along with interest
thereon within one month to this Tribunal.”
Aggrieved by the award delivered on 04.08.2022, the
[9]
appellant herein has approached this court seeking the following
reliefs:
[10]
(1)
Admit the appeal;
(2)
Call for the records from the Ld. Tribunal below;
(3)
Issue notice upon the respondents; and
(4)
After hearing the parties would further be pleased enough to
quash/set aside the impugned award dated 04.08.2022 passed by
the Ld. Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No.2, West Tripura,
Agartala in TS(MAC) 152/2020 whereby the Ld. Tribunal below has
most
illegally
and
arbitrarily
awarded
compensation
of
Rs.58,39,200/- only (Rupees Fifty eight lakhs thirty nine thousand
two hundred) only to the claimant respondents to be paid by the
opposite party No.3 appellant within a period of one month from
the date of award along with a simple interest of 9% per annum
from the date of registration of claim i.e. W.e.f. 12.10.2020 till the
date of realization and further be pleased enough to stay the
operation of the impugned award till final disposal of the appeal,
otherwise the appellant would be highly prejudiced.
Mrs. R. Purkayastha, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant has submitted before this court that claimants have
miserably failed to prove the age and income of the deceased. The Ld.
Tribunal most arbitrarily relied upon the income certificate issued by
the PW3, who has himself admitted in cross examination that he has
no
authority
to
issue
income
certificate,
and
has
considered
Rs.26,000/- as monthly income which appears to be extremely
exorbitant. According to the counsel for the appellant, the Ld. Tribunal
has considered one fourth to be deducted towards personal and living
expenses taking into account the father as one of the dependent. But
the Ld Tribunal had failed to consider that father is not treated as
dependent. It is further submitted that the Ld. Tribunal has awarded
compensation beyond the guidelines laid down by the Hon’ble Apex
Court. The Ld. Tribunal has most arbitrarily awarded Rs. Two lakhs
towards loss and love and affection. Moreover, the rate of interest
awarded is also unreasonable and unjustified.
[11]
On the other hand, Mr. S. Rahaman, learned counsel
appearing for the claimant-respondents has submitted before this
court that the impugned order dated 04.08.2022 is just and proper
and needs interference from this court. He further prays to dismiss the
instant appeal.
[12]
Heard learned counsel appearing for the parties.
[13]
Having perused the entire record, this Court is of the view
that the learned Court below erroneously determined the monthly
income of the deceased to the tune of 26,000/-, wherein from the
claimants side, there is no such evidence to prove the monthly income
of the deceased as such, this aspect of the matter must be interfered
by this Court. This Court is of the view that the monthly income of the
deceased shall be reduced to Rs.21,000/- in terms of the income
certificate issued by PW-3, (Sri Sarbat Ali). The counsel for the
claimant-respondents has failed to provide any document to support
his contention with regard to additional monthly income of the
deceased @Rs.5000/- by performing bamboo
and
cane
works.
Therefore, the additional Rs.5000/- to his monthly income stands
rejected.
[14]
This Court is also of this view that the father of the
deceased cannot be treated as dependent since he has already married
for the second time and staying separately with the second wife and
with major children. Accordingly, one fourth deduction is converted
into one third deduction applying the principle as laid down in National
Insurance Co. Ltd vs Pranay Sethi reported in AIR 2017 SC 5157.
[15]
In so far as parental consortium with regard to love and
affection is concerned, in terms of Hon'ble Apex Court Judgment
reported in (2018) 18 SCC 130 titled as Magma General Insurance
Company Ltd. Vs. Nanu Ram Alias Chuhru Ram and ors, the
dependents of the deceased are only entitled to a sum of Rs.40,000/each.
Thus, the amount would come to
(i) Income per month = Rs.21,000/(ii) 40% of above to added as future prospect= Rs.8,400/(iii) Total of Sl. Nos (i) and (ii) above comes to Rs.21,000/- +
R.8400/- = Rs.29,400/(iv) one third (1/3) of above to be deducted as personal and living
expenses of deceased :– Rs.29,400/- minus Rs.9,800/- =
Rs.19,600/(v) compensation after applying multiplier of 17= Rs.19,600 x12 x
17 = Rs.39,98,400/(vi) Loss of Estate= Rs.15,000/- only
(vii) Funeral expenses = Rs.15,000/- only
(viii) Loss of consortium = Rs.40,000/- only
(ix) loss of love and affection = 1,20,000/- (i.e. Rs.40,000/- each)
(x) Thus the total compensation stands at Rs.39,98,400/- +
Rs.15,000/-+ Rs.15,000/- + Rs.40,000/- + Rs.1,20,000/- =
Rs.41,88,400/-
[16]
This Court in all matters is fixing 7.5% interest and to
maintain uniformity while comparing the bank rate of interest which is
also much less. Consequently, the total compensation as would be
entitled by the claimant-respondents is Rs.41,88,400/- (Rupees Forty
one lakhs eighty eight thousand and four hundred) only along with
7.5% interest per annum, as awarded by the learned tribunal with
effect from the date of presentation of the claim petition till the date of
actual payment. Thus, the insurance company i.e. United India
Insurance Co. Ltd, is liable to pay the total amount as awarded by the
Tribunal below in favour of the claimant-respondents within a period of
30 days from today. However, it is made clear that if the amount is
already deposited, the claimant-respondents are at liberty to withdraw
the same unconditionally.
[17]
In view of the above, the award is modified and the appeal
is allowed to the extent as indicated above. As a sequel, miscellaneous
applications pending, if any, shall stand closed. Draw the decree
accordingly and thereafter, send down the LCRs forthwith.
JUDGE
Dipak
DIPAK DAS
DIPAK DAS
Date: 2023.10.10
16:17:09 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review