Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
NADIM MOHLE
2026:CGHC:4070
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MAC No. 2019 of 2023
1 - United India Insurance Co. Ltd. Through Branch Manager, T.P. NagarKorba, District- Korba, Cg Through In- Charge, T.P. Hub, United India
Insurance Co. Ltd, 1st Floor, Lic Building, Magarpara Road, District : Bilaspur,
Chhattisgarh.
... Appellant
versus
1 - Shivshankar Kharsena S/o Shri Asharam Kharsena Aged About 46 Years
R/o
Mungadih,
TehsilPali,
DistrictKorba,
Cg
(Claimant)
2 - Abdul Zaheer Khan S/o Abdul Hafiz Aged About 30 Years R/o Piprapara,
Kohadia,
PsKotwali,
Korba,
District
:
Korba,
Chhattisgarh
3 - Smt. Abha Singh W/o Late Shiv Kumar Singh R/o Mannu Chowk, Ramdas
Nagar, Tikrapara, Bilaspur, District- Bilaspur, Cg (Vehicle Owner)
... Respondent(s)
For Appellant
:
For Respondent(s) :
Mr. Akash Shrivastava, Advocate, holding the
brief Mr. R. N. Pusty, Advocate
Mr. Praveen K. Dhurandhar, Advocate
Hon’ble Shri Justice Rakesh Mohan Pandey
Judgment on Board
23/01/2026
1. The appellant/Insurance Company has filed this appeal challenging the
quantum part of the award passed by the learned First Additional
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Katghora, District Korba, in Claim Case
No.85/2021, whereby the learned Tribunal has granted compensation
to the tune of Rs.18,36,028/- with interest @7 % per annum on account
of injury sustained by the claimant.
2. Facts in brief are that on 25.02.2021, at about 02.30 hrs, near main
road- Baksahi, the motorcycle of the claimant was dashed by the driver
of the offending Bus bearing registration No. CG-10-G-1676 by driving
it rashly & negligently. In the said accident, the claimant sustained
injuries including fracture of thigh bone and wrist bone.
3. The claimant filed claim case under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicle
Act, wherein he pleaded that he suffered permanent disability to the
extent of 98.4 % and he is no longer able to work as labour.
He
claimed compensation to the tune of Rs.25,70,000/-. The owner and
the driver of the offending vehicle were proceeded ex-parte.
4. The insurance company filed reply and took a plea that the claimant
has exaggerated the claim amount. The plea of contributory negligence
was also taken. The Insurance Company further took a plea of breach
of terms and conditions of the insurance policy.
5. The learned Tribunal framed issues, parties led evidence and thereafter
award was passed.
6. Mr. Shrivastava, learned counsel appearing for the appellant would
submit that there was fracture of right thigh bone and the medical
board assessed the permanent disability to the extent of 70 % and 27 %
of left wrist. He would contend that the learned Tribunal assessed
functional disability to the extent of 100%, whereas, functional disability
refers to the incapacity or loss of use of some part of the body. He
would contend that there was no permanent disability and no loss of
earning capacity. He has placed reliance on the judgment passed by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Rajkumar v. Ajay Kumar
reported in 2011 (1) SCC 343; thus, he would pray to allow this appeal.
7. On the other hand, Mr. Dhurandhar, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent No.1 would oppose the submissions made by Mr.
Shrivastava, and submit that the learned Tribunal has granted just and
proper compensation. It is contended that the claimant was a labourer
and he suffered two fractures, first over thigh, second over right wrist.
8. Mr. Dhurandhar would submit that fractures sustained by the claimant
turned into permanent disability and in this regard disability certificate
to the extent of
98.40 % was issued by Medical Board. He would
contend that Dr. Ghanshyam Diwan (AW/2) proved contents of the
disability certificate. He would submit that learned Tribunal considered
the loss of earning of the claimant to the extent of 100%,
as the
claimant was no longer able to work as labourer. He would submit that
the learned Tribunal has granted reasonable amount on conventional
heads; thus, he would submit that the appeal deserves to be dismissed.
9. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
10.The claimant met with an accident on 25.02.2025 and suffered fracture
of right thigh and right wrist. He remained hospitalized and thereafter,
he appeared before the Medical Board. Medical Board issued
permanent disability certificate vide Ex.P/91. Permanent disability on
account of injury sustained over knee was assessed to the extent of
70.92 % and permanent disability on account of injury sustained over
wrist was assessed to the extent of 27.48 %.
11.The evidence of Dr. Ghanshyam Diwan would show that no question
was put forth by the insurance company as to whether the nature of
the disability is temporary or permanent.
12.Admittedly, the claimant was labourer; the Insurance Company could
not lead evidence to prove the contrary; the claimant pleaded and
proved the fact that due to injuries sustained over right leg and right
wrist, he is unable to work as labourer, which certainly affected his
earning capacity.
13. In the matter of Raj Kumar (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
held that “disability” refers to any restriction or lack of ability to
perform an activity in the manner considered normal for a human
being. “Permanent disability” denotes the residual incapacity or
permanent loss of use of any part of the body.
14. In case of injury, the learned Tribunal is required to determine whether
the claimant has suffered disablement or permanent injuries. If the
disablement is permanent, whether it constitutes permanent total
disablement or permanent partial disablement; and where the
percentage of disablement is assessed with reference to a specific limb,
the impact of such disablement on the functioning of the entire body,
that is, the extent of permanent disability suffered by the person. The
relevant paragraphs No. 8, 9, 11 and 12, are reproduced hereinbelow:-
“8.Disability refers to any restriction or lack of ability to
perform an activity in the manner considered normal for a
human-being. Permanent disability refers to the residuary
incapacity or loss of use of some part of the body, found
existing at the end of the period of treatment and
recuperation, after achieving the maximum bodily
improvement or recovery which is likely to remain for the
remainder life of the injured. Temporary disability refers to
the incapacity or loss of use of some part of the body on
account of the injury, which will cease to exist at the end of
the period of treatment and recuperation. Permanent
disability can be either partial or total. Partial permanent
disability refers to a person's inability to perform all the
duties and bodily functions that he could perform before
the accident, though he is able to perform some of them
and is still able to engage in some gainful activity. Total
permanent disability refers to a person's inability to
perform any avocation or employment related activities as a
result of the accident. The permanent disabilities that may
arise from motor accidents injuries, are of a much wider
range when compared to the physical disabilities which are
enumerated in the Persons with Disabilities (Equal
Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation)
Act, 1995 (`Disabilities Act' for short). But if any of the
disabilities enumerated in section 2(i) of the Disabilities Act
are the result of injuries sustained in a motor accident, they
can be permanent disabilities for the purpose of claiming
compensation.
10. Where the claimant suffers a permanent disability as a
result of injuries, the assessment of compensation under
the head of loss of future earnings, would depend upon the
effect and impact of such permanent disability on his
earning capacity. The Tribunal should not mechanically
apply the percentage of permanent disability as the
percentage of economic loss or loss of earning capacity. In
most of the cases, the percentage of economic loss, that is,
percentage of loss of earning capacity, arising from a
permanent disability will be different from the percentage
of permanent disability. Some Tribunals wrongly assume
that in all cases, a particular extent (percentage) of
permanent disability would result in a corresponding loss of
earning capacity, and consequently, if the evidence
produced show 45% as the permanent disability, will hold
that there is 45% loss of future earning capacity. In most of
the cases, equating the extent (percentage) of loss of
earning capacity to the extent (percentage) of permanent
disability will result in award of either too low or too high a
compensation. What requires to be assessed by the
Tribunal is the effect of the permanently disability on the
earning capacity of the injured; and after assessing the loss
of earning capacity in terms of a percentage of the income,
it has to be quantified in terns of money, to arrive at the
future loss of earnings (by applying the standard multiplier
method used to determine loss of dependency). We may
however note that in some cases, on appreciation of
evidence and assessment, the Tribunal may find that
percentage of loss of earning capacity as a result of the
permanent disability, is approximately the same as the
percentage of permanent disability in which case, of course,
the Tribunal will adopt the said percentage for
determination of compensation (see for example, the
decisions of this court in Arvind Kumar Mishra v. New India
Assurance Co.Ltd. - 2010(10) SCALE 298 and Yadava Kumar
v. D.M., National Insurance Co. Ltd. - 2010 (8) SCALE 567).
11. What requires to be assessed by the Tribunal is the
effect of the permanently disability on the earning capacity
of the injured; and after assessing the loss of earning
capacity in terms of a percentage of the income, it has to
be quantified in terns of money, to arrive at the future loss
of earnings (by applying the standard multiplier method
used to determine loss of dependency). We may however
note that in some cases, on appreciation of evidence and
assessment, the Tribunal may find that percentage of loss
of earning capacity as a result of the permanent disability, is
approximately the same as the percentage of permanent
disability in which case, of course, the Tribunal will adopt
the said percentage for determination of compensation
(see for example, the decisions of this court in Arvind
Kumar Mishra v. New India Assurance Co.Ltd. - 2010(10)
SCALE 298 and Yadava Kumar v. D.M., National Insurance
Co. Ltd. - 2010 (8) SCALE 567).
12. Therefore, the Tribunal has to first decide whether there
is any permanent disability and if so the extent of such
permanent disability. This means that the Tribunal should
consider and decide with reference to the evidence: (i)
whether the disablement is permanent or temporary; (ii) if
the disablement is permanent, whether it is permanent total
disablement or permanent partial disablement, (iii) if the
disablement percentage is expressed with reference to any
specific limb, then the effect of such disablement of the
limb on the functioning of the entire body, that is the
permanent disability suffered by the person. If the Tribunal
concludes that there is no permanent disability then there is
no question of proceeding further and determining the loss
of future earning capacity. But if the Tribunal concludes that
there is permanent disability then it will proceed to
ascertain its extent. After the Tribunal ascertains the actual
extent of permanent disability of the claimant based on the
medical evidence, it has to determine whether such
permanent disability has affected or will affect his earning
capacity.“
15.In the present case, the claimant was labourer. He suffered permanent
disability. The learned Tribunal considered it total permanent
disablement.
16.The learned Tribunal assessed overall permanent disability to the extent of
98.40 % on the basis of disability certificate and evidence led by Dr.
Ghanshyam Diwan (AW/2). It is also not in dispute that the claimant is
labourer and disablement of right leg and right wrist caused 100% loss of
earning
capacity,
therefore,
learned
Tribunal
rightly
assessed
permanent disability to the extent of 100 %.
17.Taking into consideration the above discussed facts and the law laid
down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Raj Kumar
(supra), I do not find any good ground to interfere with award passed
by the learned Tribunal.
18.Accordingly, this appeal is hereby dismissed.
Sd/Rakesh Mohan Pandey
JUDGE
Nadim
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review