Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010416952023
2026:CGHC:42699
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MAC No. 139 of 2024
1 - United India Insurance Co. Ltd. Through Divisional Manager,
Divisional Office, Lic Building 1st Floor Magarpara Road, Bilaspur
Chhattisgarh. Insurer Of Truck No. CG 15 AC 3443.
--- Appellant
versus
1 - Sawan Barla W/o Late Anup Kumar Barla Aged About 29 Years
R/o Village Bhanesar Mission House No. 145, Behind Mission
School, Post Jairamnagar, Police Station Masturi, District Bilaspur,
Chhattisgarh.
2 - Aarav Kumar Berla S/o Late Anup Kumar Barla Aged About 6
Years Minor, Represented Through Mother And Natural Guardian
Smt. Sawan Barla, W/o Late Anup Kumar Bar, Aged 29 Years, R/o
Village Bhanesar Mission House No. 145, Behind Mission School,
Post
Jairamnagar,
Police
Station
Masturi,
District
Bilaspur
Chhattisgarh.
3 - Mahesh Yadav S/o Bahoran Yadav Aged About 43 Years R/o
Village Salkha, P.O. Beltara, Police Station Ratanpur, District
Bilaspur Chhatttisgarh (Driver Of Truck No. CG 15 AC 3443)
4 - Mohammad Iqbal Haq S/o Shamsul Haq Aged About 65 Years
R/o Ward No. 40, Near Torwa Primary School, P.S. Torwa, District
Bilaspur Chhattisgarh. (Registered Owner Of Truck No. CG 15 AC
3443)
--- Respondents
For Appellant
:
Mr. R.N. Pusty, Advocate with
Mr. Akash Shrivastava, Advocate.
Digitally signed
by HEERA LAL
SAHU
Date:
2026.10.01
16:55:28 +0530
For Respondents No. 1 & 2 :
Mr. Anand Kesharwani, Advocate.
For Respondents No. 3 & 4 :
None.
MAC No. 373 of 2024
1 - Sawan Barla Wd/o Late Anup Kumar Barla, Aged About 29 Years
R/o Bhanesar Mission, House No. Bhanesar Mission, House No. 145
Behind Of Mission School, Post Jairmnagar, Police Station Masturi,
District Bilaspur Chhattisgarh.
2 - Araw Kumar Barla S/o Late Anup Kumar Barla, Aged About 2
Years Minor Through The Mother (Natural Guardian) Appellant No.
01 Sawan Barla, R/o Bhanesar Mission, House No. Bhanesar
Mission, House No. 145 Behind Of Mission School, Post Jairmnagar,
Police Station Masturi, District Bilaspur Chhattisgarh.
---Appellants
Versus
1 - Mahesh Yadav S/o Bahoran Yadaw Aged About 43 Years R/o
Village Salkha, Post Office Beltara, Police Station Ratanpur District
Bilaspur Chhattisgarh (Driver Of The Vehicle Truck No. C.G. 15/AC3443)
2 - Mohammad Iqbal Haq S/o Shamshul Haq Aged About 65 Years
R/o Ward No. 40, Near Of Primary School, Torwa, Police Station
Torwa, District Bilaspur Chhattisgarh (Owner Of The Vehicle No.
Truck No. C.G. 15/AC-3443)
3 - United India Insurance Company Limited, Through Divisional
Division Office Lic Building, 1st Floor, Magarpara Road, Bilaspur
Chhattisgarh. (Insurer Of The Vehicle No. Truck No. C.G. 15/AC3443)
--- Respondents
For Appellants/Claimants :
Mr. Anand Kesharwani, Advocate.
For Respondents No. 1 & 2 :
None.
For Respondent No. 3
Mr. R.N. Pusty, Advocate along with
Mr. Akash Shrivastava, Advocate.
:
Hon'ble Shri Justice Sanjay Kumar Jaiswal
Judgment on Board
(01.10.2026)
1. Since both the appeals arise out of the same judgment/order of
award, they are being heard and disposed of by this common
order.
2. MAC No. 139/2024 under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 (for short the "Act of 1988") has been preferred by the
Insurance Company/appellant and MAC No. 373/2024 under
Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short the "Act of
1988")
has
been
preferred
by
the
Claimants/appellants,
challenging the impugned award dated 26.09.2023, passed in
Claim Case No.1098/2022, whereby the learned Claims Tribunal
has awarded a total sum of Rs.84,62,520/- as compensation for
the death of Late Anup Kumar Barla (45 years, 18 days old), who
died in a road accident which took place on 19.07.2022.
3. In
MAC
No.
139/2024,
learned
counsel
for
the
appellant/insurance company submits that since the deceased
was a salaried person, there will be a statutory deduction towards
income tax from the annual income of the deceased. However, the
learned Claims Tribunal has not deducted income tax from the
deceased's annual income. As such, by allowing the present
appeal, the impugned award may be modified accordingly.
4. In MAC No. 373/2024, learned counsel for the Appellants
submitted that the learned Tribunal erred in law by applying a
multiplier of 13. The Tribunal itself found that the date of Birth of
the Deceased is 01.07.1977 (as per pen card) and the date of death
of the deceased was 19.07.2022. Accordingly, at the time of the
fatal accident, the deceased was aged 45 years and 18 days. As per
the binding guidelines established by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in the landmark judgment of Sarla Verma & Others v. Delhi
Transport Corporation & Another ((2009) 6 SCC 121), for
victims falling within the age bracket of 41 to 45 years, the
applicable multiplier is 14, not 13. Because the deceased had not
yet completed his 46th year, he squarely falls within the 41 to 45
age category. It is therefore contended that the Tribunal committed
a patent error in applying a multiplier of 13. The appeal deserves
to be allowed on this count, and the compensation ought to be
suitably enhanced by adopting the correct multiplier of 14 in
accordance with the law.
5. I have heard learned counsel for the parties, considered their rival
submissions made herein-above and went through the records
with utmost circumspection.
6. So far as the age of the deceased is concerned, as per pen card
produced by insurance company, his date of birth is 01.07.1977,
whereas the date of death was 19.07.2022. Thus, on the date of
the accident, the deceased was aged about 45 years and 18 days
and had not completed 46 years of age.
7. In
Shashikala
&
Others
vs.
Gangalakshmamma
&
Another, (2015) 9 SCC 150, the Hon’ble Supreme Court, while
considering the age of the deceased for the purpose of
determining the appropriate multiplier, has held that the
completed years of age are to be taken into consideration. The
relevant observation made by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
paragraph 16 reads as under:
“16. Insofar as appropriate multiplier, the date of birth
of the deceased as per driving licence was 16-6-1961.
On the date of accident i.e. 14-12-2006, the deceased
was aged 45 years 5 months and 28 days and the
Tribunal has taken the age as 46 years. Since the
deceased has completed only 45 years, the High Court
has rightly taken the age of the deceased as 45 years
and adopted multiplier of 14 which is the appropriate
multiplier and the same is maintained. Total loss of
dependency is calculated at Rs. 16,82,310 (Rs.
1,20,165x14).”
8. In the case at hand, the learned Tribunal placed reliance on
Exhibit P-11 and assessed the deceased's monthly income at
₹61,779/-,
which
remains
undisputed.
Furthermore,
accounting for the age of the deceased, an addition of 30%
toward future prospects was appropriately made, a point
likewise undisputed. Given that the deceased left behind 2 (two)
dependent family members, a deduction of 1/3rd toward
personal and living expenses was correctly applied. However,
the Tribunal fell into patent error in three critical aspects:
(1) Application of Incorrect Multiplier: The Tribunal applied a
multiplier of 13. However, since the deceased was aged 45 years
and 18 days at the time of the fatal accident, meaning he had
not completed his 46th year, the correct and applicable
multiplier under the framework of Sarla Verma (supra) is 14,
not 13.
(2) Since the deceased was a salaried person, there will be a
statutory income tax deduction as per the tax slab for the
relevant period.
(3) Inadequate Sum Under Conventional Heads: The Tribunal
awarded a meager amount of ₹1,10,000/- under conventional
heads. In accordance with settled jurisprudence (including
National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi ((2017)
16 SCC 680) and subsequent judicial enhancements for
inflation and spousal/parental/filial consortium), this figure
deserves enhancement to ₹1,21,000/- to comprehensively cover
Loss of Estate, Funeral Expenses, and Loss of Consortium for
each dependent. Consequently, the impugned award warrants
suitable modification to rectify the multiplier, tax deduction and
enhance the conventional heads in the interest of justice.
9. Thus, taking monthly income of the deceased as Rs. 61,779/(as per Ex.P-11), i.e. Rs. 7,41,348/- per annum. The deceased
was salaried person so considering the age of the deceased i.e.
45 years as per National Insurance Company Ltd., Vs.
Pranay Sethi and Others, (2017) 16 SCC 680, the future
prospects would be 30%. After adding 30% future prospects i.e.
Rs. 2,22,404/- the annual income of the deceased comes to Rs.
9,63,752/- (7,41,348+2,22,404).
10.From the annual income of the deceased, there will be statutory
deduction towards income tax.
The income tax slab for the
financial year 2022-2023 was as follows:
Income Tax Slabs
Income Tax
in the FY
Rates
Taxable Income
Total Tax
2022-2023
Upto 2.5 lakh
nill
Rs. 2,50,000/-
nill
5%
Rs. 2,50,000/-
Rs. 12,500/-
5,00,001 to 10
20%
Rs. 4,63,752/-
Rs. 92,750/-
Total
Rs. 9,63,752/-
Rs. 1,05,250/-
4% of total
Rs. 1,05,250/-
Rs. 4,210/-
Total Tax
Rs. 1,09,460/-
2,50,001
to
lakh
lakh
Education Cess
tax
11.In view of the above, after deduction of income tax, the annual
income comes to Rs.8,54,292/- (9,63,752-1,09,460).
12.Accordingly, in light of the aforesaid discussion and in light of
the judgments of the Supreme Court rendered in the matters of
Pranay Sethi (supra), Sarla Verma (supra) and Magma
General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram @ Chuhru Ram &
Ors1, this Court is computing the compensation as below:1
(2018) 18 SCC 130
Sr.
No.
Heads
Compensation awarded by this
Court
Income
Rs. 61,779 x 12 = 7,41,348/-
2.
Future prospect
(+)30% (i.e. Rs. 2,22,404) =
9,63,752/-
Tax deduction
Rs. 9,63,752-1,09,460 =
8,54,292/-
3.
Deduction
towards (-) 1/3 (i.e. 2,84,764) = 5,69,528/personal expenses
4.
Multiplier
Other
heads
(x) 14 = 79,73,392/conventional
Total
Rs. 1,21,000/[16,500+16,500+(44000x2)]
Rs. 80,94,392/-
13. Thus, the claimants are entitled to total compensation of
Rs.80,94,392/- instead of Rs.84,62,520/- as awarded by the
Claims Tribunal. Accordingly, the impugned award stands
modified to the above extent and rest of the conditions shall
remain intact.
14. In the result, both the appeals of appellant/s are partly
allowed to the above extent.
Sd/(Sanjay Kumar Jaiswal)
Judge
H.L. Sahu
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review