The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. 07.2026 Whether the operative part or full judgment is pronounced: Full UT OF J&K ...PETITIONER(S) Through: - Mr. Mohsin Qadiri, Sr. AAG, with Mr. Haaris Khan, Assisting Counsel. Vs. NAZIR AHMAD WANI & ORS. …RESPONDENT(S) Through: - Ms. Saniya Qadir, Advocate. CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE 1) The petitioner has challenged order dated 14.12.2019 passed by the learned Special Judge, Anti-Corruption, Baramulla, whereby respondent No.2 has been discharged in a case arising out of FIR No.24/2012 for offences under Section 5(1)(d) read with 5(2) of J&K Prevention of Corruption Act and Section 201, 109 and 120-B RPC registered with Police Station, VOK. 2) It appears that a verification was conducted into the allegation of demand and acceptance of illegal gratification by accused Nazir Ahmad Wani, the then Office Qanungo, and accused Syed Shabir Ahmad Andrabi, the then Tehsildar Sumbal Sonawari, from complainant Haji Abdul Aziz Dar for implementation of order passed by the Joint Financial Commissioner (AR), in respect of mutation No.400 dated
12. 01.1989 and mutation No.401 dated 13.01.1989 relating to land measuring 23.4 kanals situated at Village Sarie Dangerpora, Tehsil Sonawari. After conducting verification, it was revealed that accused Nazir Ahmad Wani, the then Office Qanungo, had demanded illegal gratification of Rs.40,000 from the complainant on the plea that the same is to be paid to the accused Shabir Ahmad Andrabi, the then Tehsildar Sumbal Sonawari, for implementation of the order passed by the Joint Financial Commissioner. It was found that out of Rs.40,000, an amount of Rs.35,000 was paid by the complainant to accused Nazir Ahmed Wani through cheque No.1774193 dated 08.08.2011, and he had handed over the said cheque to accused Manzoor Ahmad Dar, the then Orderly, who got the same encashed. 3) After investigation of the case, offences under Section 5(1)(d) read with 5(2) of the J&K PC Act and Sections 201, 109 and 120-B RPC were found established against the accused, including respondent No.2 herein and the charge sheet was laid before the learned Special Judge Anti-Corruption, Baramulla. 4) The learned Special Judge, after considering the material annexed to the charge sheet and after hearing the parties proceeded to pass the impugned order whereby charges for offences under Section (5)(1)(d) read with 5(2) of J&K PC Act and Sections 201, 109, 120-B RPC were framed against accused Nazir Ahmed Wani and Sye…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU &KASHMIR AND LADAKH AT
JAMMU
Reserved on:
06.07.2026
Pronounced on: 10.07.2026
Uploaded on:
10.07.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
Crl R No.18/2020
UT OF J&K
...PETITIONER(S)
Through: - Mr. Mohsin Qadiri, Sr. AAG, with
Mr. Haaris Khan, Assisting Counsel.
Vs.
NAZIR AHMAD WANI & ORS.
…RESPONDENT(S)
Through: - Ms. Saniya Qadir, Advocate.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1)
The petitioner has challenged order dated 14.12.2019
passed by the learned Special Judge, Anti-Corruption,
Baramulla, whereby respondent No.2 has been discharged in
a case arising out of FIR No.24/2012 for offences under
Section 5(1)(d) read with 5(2) of J&K Prevention of Corruption
Act and Section 201, 109 and 120-B RPC registered with
Police Station, VOK.
2)
It appears that a verification was conducted into the
allegation of demand and acceptance of illegal gratification by
accused Nazir Ahmad Wani, the then Office Qanungo, and
accused Syed Shabir Ahmad Andrabi, the then Tehsildar
Crl R No.18/2020
Sumbal Sonawari, from complainant Haji Abdul Aziz Dar for
implementation of order passed by the Joint Financial
Commissioner (AR), in respect of mutation No.400 dated
12.01.1989 and mutation No.401 dated 13.01.1989 relating
to land measuring 23.4 kanals situated at Village Sarie
Dangerpora, Tehsil Sonawari. After conducting verification, it
was revealed that accused Nazir Ahmad Wani, the then Office
Qanungo, had demanded illegal gratification of Rs.40,000
from the complainant on the plea that the same is to be paid
to the accused Shabir Ahmad Andrabi, the then Tehsildar
Sumbal Sonawari, for implementation of the order passed by
the Joint Financial Commissioner. It was found that out of
Rs.40,000, an amount of Rs.35,000 was paid by the
complainant to accused Nazir Ahmed Wani through cheque
No.1774193 dated 08.08.2011, and he had handed over the
said cheque to accused Manzoor Ahmad Dar, the then
Orderly, who got the same encashed.
3)
After investigation of the case, offences under Section
5(1)(d) read with 5(2) of the J&K PC Act and Sections 201, 109
and 120-B RPC were found established against the accused,
including respondent No.2 herein and the charge sheet was
laid before the learned Special Judge Anti-Corruption,
Baramulla.
Crl R No.18/2020
4)
The learned Special Judge, after considering the
material annexed to the charge sheet and after hearing the
parties proceeded to pass the impugned order whereby
charges for offences under Section (5)(1)(d) read with 5(2) of
J&K PC Act and Sections 201, 109, 120-B RPC were framed
against accused Nazir Ahmed Wani and Syed Shabir Ahmad
Andrabi whereas accused Manzoor Ahmad Dar (respondent
No.2 herein) was discharged.
5)
The petitioner Investigating Agency has challenged the
impugned order to the extent of discharge of accused Manzoor
Ahmad Dar (respondent No.2 herein), on the grounds that the
same is perverse, both on facts as well as on law. It has been
contended that there is enough material on record of the
charge sheet to prima facie connect accused Manzoor Ahmed
Dar with the crime, as it stands established that he had
received the cheque for an amount of Rs.35,000 from accused
Nazir Ahmed Wani and after putting his signatures on the
said cheque, he withdrew the cash from J&K Bank, Sumbal.
It has been submitted that, as per opinion of the FSL, it has
been established that accused Manzoor Ahmed Dar had
appended his signatures on the cheque at the time of its
presentation and encashment before the bank and, therefore,
there is sufficient material on record to show his complicity
in the crime. It has been contended that accused Manzoor
Crl R No.18/2020
Ahmad Dar, while encashing the cheque, was not performing
any official duty and he was expected to encash the cheque
which had been handed over by the complainant to the
accused Nazir Ahmad Wani.
6)
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused
record of the case including record of the trial court.
7)
Before proceedings to analyze the factual aspects of the
case, it would be necessary to notice the legal position as
regards the scope and power of the Court to analyze the
material annexed with the charge sheet for the purpose of
determining whether or not an offence is made out against
the accused against whom the charge sheet has been filed.
Section 251-A of J&K Cr. P. C, which is applicable to the
present case, provides the procedure for framing of charges
in a warrant trial case instituted on a police report. As per the
said provision, if the Court, upon consideration of all
documents referred to in Section 173 of the Cr. P. C and after
giving prosecution and the accused an opportunity of being
heard, considers the charge against the accused to be
groundless, it has to discharge the accused
but if, upon
consideration of such documents and after giving an
opportunity of hearing to accused and the prosecution, the
Court is of the opinion that there is ground for presuming that
Crl R No.18/2020
the accused has committed the offence, it has to frame charge
in writing against the accused.
8)
It is to be noted that at the time of considering the case
for the purpose of charge/discharge of an accused, the Court
is not expected to meticulously analyze the material on record
but it has to sift the evidence in order to find out whether or
not the allegations made in the charge sheet are groundless
so as to pass an order of discharge. The Court has to proceed
on the assumption that the material brought on record by the
prosecution is true and the same has to be accepted at its
face value at the time of framing of the charge. Probative value
of the material cannot be gone into by the Court and it is not
expected to deeply analyze the material with a view to frame
an opinion whether, on the basis of the said material, accused
can be convicted. Even a grave suspicion against the accused
on the basis of the material annexed to the charge sheet
would warrant framing of charge. However, the Court cannot
act as a mouthpiece of the prosecution but it has to
independently apply its mind to the material on record and
frame an opinion whether or not the charge against the
accused is groundless.
9)
With the aforesaid position of law in mind, let us now
analyze the facts and the material in the present case. The
allegations in the charge sheet against respondent No.2, who
Crl R No.18/2020
has been discharged by virtue of the impugned order, are that
he has collected the cheque in the amount of Rs.35,000 from
co-accused Nazir Ahmad Wani which had been tendered by
the complainant to said Nazir Ahmad Wani as illegal
gratification. It is allegation of the prosecution that accused
Manzoor Ahmad Dar, after collecting the cheque from Nazir
Ahmad Wani, put his signatures on the reverse of the cheque
leaf and encashed the same from the bank. According to the
prosecution, the cheque in question was bearer and it was not
drawn in the name of any person.
10)
In order to find an answer to the question as to whether
on the basis of these allegations, it can be stated that accused
Manzoor Ahmed Dar had connived with other two accused in
demanding and accepting the bribe money from the
complainant, the statements of witnesses recorded during
investigation of the case are required to be noticed.
11)
If we go to the statement of the complainant recorded
under Section 161 Cr. P. C during investigation of the case,
he has stated that accused Nazir Ahmad Wani, Office
Qanungo, went to Tehsil office on 09.08.2011 at about 8.30
hours but found the Tehsil office closed, whereafter he called
accused Nazir Ahmad Wani on telephone, who advised him to
hand over the cheque to one photostat shopkeeper,
Muhammad Sultan and, accordingly, the complainant
Crl R No.18/2020
handed over the cheque to Muhammad Sultan and asked him
to hand over the same to accused Nazir Ahmed Wani. He has
further stated that Muhammad Sultan also contacted
accused Nazir Ahmad Wani and confirmed that he has
received a cheque for an amount of Rs.35,000 from the
complainant. It has been further stated by the complainant
that in the evening on the same day, he contacted accused
Nazir Ahmad Wani on phone and confirmed from him whether
he has received the cheque for an amount of Rs.35,000 from
Muhammad Sultan. He was informed by accused Nazir
Ahmad Wani that he has received the cheque and he further
told him that he had deputed accused Manzoor Ahmad Dar,
Orderly of Tehsil office, to J&K Bank Branch Sumbal. After a
few days, Nazir Ahmad Wani confirmed to the complainant
that the cheque was encashed and the money was paid to
Tehsildar
accused
Syed
Shabir
Ahmad
Andrabi.
The
complainant was also informed that an amount of Rs.30,000
was paid to the Tehsildar whereas accused Nazir Ahmad Wani
had retained a sum of Rs.5,000 for himself.
12)
PW Muhammad Sultan Khan, photostat shopkeeper,
has, in his statement under Section 161 Cr. P. C, submitted
that under the instructions of accused Nazir Ahmad Wani, he
received a cheque worth Rs.35,000 from the complainant.
According to him, the cheque did not bear name of the payee.
Crl R No.18/2020
He further stated that he handed over the said cheque to Nazir
Ahmad Wani.
13)
In addition to the aforesaid statements, the Investigating
Agency has seized the cheque in question, which is shown to
have been signed by accused Manzoor Ahmed Dar at the time
of its encashment.
14)
Thus, from the material collected by the Investigating
Agency during the course of investigation, it has been
established that accused Manzoor Ahmed Dar, who was
working as an Orderly, after collecting the cheque in respect
of illegal gratification of Rs.35,000 from accused Nazir Ahmad
Wani, encashed the same under the directions of the said
accused. There is also material on record to show that
accused Manzoor Ahmad Dar has not retained any amount
out of the cheque amount and instead he has handed over
whole cash to accused Nazir Ahmad Wani. The complainant
has nowhere alleged that he had any contact with accused
Manzoor Ahmad Dar or that he was in picture at any stage of
the transaction relating to demand and acceptance of the
bribe money. Merely because accused Manzoor Ahmed Dar
has, under the instructions of his superior officer, encashed
the cheque relating to the bribe money, does not show even
prima facie that he has either connived with other two
accused or he was part of the conspiracy. There is no material
Crl R No.18/2020
on record to show that accused Manzoor Ahmad Dar was
having any knowledge about the transaction of bribe between
the complainant and the other two accused nor is there any
material on record to show that he was having knowledge that
the amount of cheque constituted illegal gratification. In the
absence of any such material on record, it cannot be stated
that accused Manzoor Ahmad Dar was in any manner
involved in the alleged crime. Thus, the charge against the
said accused is groundless.
15)
Thus, the learned trial court while discharging accused
Manzoor Ahmad Dar has exercised its jurisdiction perfectly in
accordance with law. The conclusion drawn by the trial court
is based upon proper analysis of the material collected by the
Investigating Agency during investigation of the case. The
impugned order, therefore, does not call for any interference
from this Court.
16)
For the foregoing reasons, the petition lacks merit and
is dismissed accordingly.
(Sanjay Dhar)
Judge
SRINAGAR
10.07.2026
“Bhat Altaf-Secretary”
Whether the judgment is reportable: YES/NO
Crl R No.18/2020
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review