Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 118
Supplementary Cause List
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
CM No. 5661/2026 in
RP No. 43/2026
CM No. 5662/2026
Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir & Ors.
… Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr T. A. Lone, Dy. AG.
V/s
Mohd. Iqbal Ganie & Ors.
… Respondent(s)
Through: None.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE M. A. CHOWDHARY, JUDGE.
(ORDER)
02.09.2026
CM No. 5661/2026:
01.
This is an application moved by the Applicants/ Review
Petitioners under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, seeking condonation of
delay in filing review against the Judgment dated 30th of January, 2020
passed by the Writ Court in SWP No. 1951/2017. It is apt to mention here
that the said SWP No. 1951/2017 was filed by the Writ Petitioners, who are
Non-Applicants/ Respondents herein, and the Applicants/ Review
Petitioners were Respondents in the aforesaid Writ Petition.
02.
In the instant application, it has been stated that the
accompanying Review Petition could not be filed within the prescribed
period of limitation of thirty (30) days from the date of Judgment and that
there is a delay of 2365 days in filing the same which needs to be
condoned; that the delay in filing the Review Petition is neither deliberate
nor intentional, but has occasioned only because of administrative/
procedural reasons; that after passing of the Judgment under Review on 30 th
of January, 2020, the matter remained under active consideration at various
levels of the Department due to policy decisions of the Government relating
to recruitment process and the matter required fresh examination by the
CM No. 5661/2026 in
RP No. 43/2026
CM No. 5662/2026
Administrative Department, for which purpose, relevant records had to be
requisitioned from different offices, examined in detail and processed at
various administrative levels.
03.
It is further stated by the Applicants/ Review Petitioners that
the implementation of the Judgement under review was being discussed in
view of the fact that the General Administration Department (GAD), vide
Circular No.02-GAD of 2019 dated 2nd of January, 2019, had conveyed to
all the Departments the State Administrative Council (SAC) decision
No.31/05/2018 dated 17th of July, 2018 and SRO-404 of 2018 dated 15th of
September, 2018, whereby the Departments were required to refer the
Class-IV vacancies to the General Administration Department (GAD) for
consolidation and further reference to SSB; that in terms of the said SRO,
the amendments had been carried out in the Jammu & Kashmir Civil
Service Decentralization and Recruitment Act, 2010 as well as in the
Jammu & Kashmir Civil Service Decentralization and Recruitment Rules,
2010 and the Jammu & Kashmir Service Selection Board (SSB) was
notified as the recruitment agency for Class-IV posts borne on the
establishment of any Department or service of Government, therefore, in
law, the Class-IV posts were not available with the Department even before
passing of the Judgement/Order dated 30th of January, 2020 which is under
review; that, in the meanwhile, the Non-Applicants/ Writ Petitioners filed
Review Petition bearing RP No.55/2021, which came to be dismissed as
withdrawn vide Order dated 30th of March, 2022; that, the General
Administration Department, vide No. GAD-MTGORBIV/200/2021-09GAD dated 3rd of February, 2022, forwarded the Administrative Council
Decision No.01/01/2022 dated 29th of January, 2022, in terms whereof, all
the posts referred to the JKPSC/ SSB prior to 31st of October, 2018, in
which selection has not been finalized as also the posts in which cases were
pending in the Courts, were deemed to have been withdrawn, therefore, a
stumbling block had already come in the way of implementation of
Judgement under review.
04.
The Applicants/ Review Petitioners further proceed to state
that, thereafter in respect of the aforementioned Administrative Council
CM No. 5661/2026 in
RP No. 43/2026
CM No. 5662/2026
Decision dated 29th of January, 2022 and communication dated 3rd of
February, 2022, the General Administration Department (GAD), vide OM
No. GAD-MTGORBIV/35/2022-09-GAD-Part(3) dated 3rd of August, 2023
further clarified regarding withdrawal of posts and advised all the
Departments that the posts are to be treated available with Department and
not with the respective recruiting agencies from 3rd of February, 2022; that
the Applicant-Department, still in order to bring more clarity relating to the
instant case, took up the matter with General Administration Department
(GAD) for advice, which returned the case vide U.O. No. GADMYGORBIV/129/2023-09 with the advice that no recruitment can take
place on the basis of a reference made in the year 2013 and that all such
references stand withdrawn; that, subsequently, in view of filing of the
Contempt Petition bearing CCP (S) No.196/2022 by the Non-Applicants/
Writ Petitioners, the matter was again considered by the Department and
Government Order No. 107-JK(FCS&CA) of 2023 dated 21st of September,
2023 was issued, whereby it was ordered that in view of the policy decision
of the Government conveyed by the General Administration Department
(GAD), the recruitment process initiated, in pursuance to Advertisement
Notice dated 3rd of July, 2013 read with notice dated 16th of September,
2017, relevant to the instant case, could not sustain and, as such, was
abandoned and no further action was taken to take the process forward.
05.
In the application, it is further averred that, thereafter, the
record of the case was referred to the Department of Law, Justice and
Parliamentary Affairs, Government of J&K, for legal opinion, which
accorded sanction to file the present Review Petition vide communication
No.LAW-LIT7/865/2025-10 dated 22nd of July, 2026, whereafter, complete
records and instructions were furnished to the Counsel for drafting and
filing the accompanying Review Petition. In the light of these facts, the
Applicants/ Review Petitioners plead that the delay has occurred on account
of official procedural requirements and administrative decision-making and
not due to any deliberate, wilful or mala fide conduct on the part of the
Applicants/ Review Petitioners.
CM No. 5661/2026 in
RP No. 43/2026
CM No. 5662/2026
06.
The Applicants/ Review Petitioners, in support of their case,
have placed reliance on the following Judgments passed by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court:
07.
i.
Collector Land Acquisition, Anantnag v. Mst. Khatiji, (1987) 2 SCC 107;
ii.
G. Ramegowada V. Land Acquisition Officer, (1988) 2 SCC 142; and
iii.
Thirunagalingam V. Lingeswaran & Anr., 2025 Online SC 1093.
I have heard the learned Counsel appearing for the Applicants/
Review Petitioners and have also perused the pleadings available on record.
08.
From the perusal of the pleadings available on record, it
appears that the Writ Petitioners/ Non-Applicants herein had filed SWP No.
1951/2017 against the Review Petitioners herein, which came to be
disposed of vide Judgment dated 30th of January, 2020. Against the said
Judgment passed in the year 2020, the Writ Petitioners/ Non-Applicants
herein filed a Review Petition bearing RP No. 55/2021 which came to be
dismissed on 30th of March, 2022. That apart, the Writ Petitioners/ NonApplicants herein, on not implementation of the Judgment under Review,
preferred a Contempt Petition bearing CCP (S) No. 196/2022, wherein
notice was issued on 21st of May, 2022 and pursuant to notice, the
Applicants/ Review Petitioners filed Statement of Facts, stating therein that
the implementation of the Judgment passed by the Writ Court was
impracticable as the posts had been withdrawn in view of the State
Administrative Council Decision taken on 2nd of January, 2019. The said
Contempt Petition is still pending before this Court. It is clearly discernible
from the perusal of the pleadings available on record that the Applicants/
Review Petitioners contested all the aforesaid three proceedings filed by the
Writ Petitioners/ Non-Applicants herein viz. the main Writ Petition (SWP
No.1951/2017, Review Petition (RP No. 55/2021) as also the Contempt
Petition [CCP (S) No. 196/2022].
09.
There is an inordinate and almost unexplained delay of 2365
days in filing the Review Petition and the present application has been
moved to condone this period without explaining as to how the Applicants/
Review Petitioners could not file the Review Petition within the period of
CM No. 5661/2026 in
RP No. 43/2026
CM No. 5662/2026
limitation or even thereafter before filing of the Contempt Petition. This
Court takes judicial notice of the fact that the Judgment, sought to be
reviewed by the Applicants/ Review Petitioners, was passed in favour of the
Writ Petitioners/ Non-Applicants herein after hearing the Applicants/
Review Petitioners and in presence of their Counsel. The Applicants/
Review Petitioners had also contested the Review Petition earlier filed by
the Writ Petitioners/ Non-Applicants herein, which came to be dismissed on
30th of March, 2022, on the same subject matter. Besides, the Review
Petitioners are also facing contempt proceedings since 21 st of May, 2022
before this Court with regard to the Judgment sought to be reviewed, as
such, there is no reason, much less a sufficient one, projected by the
Applicants/ Review Petitioners which would warrant condonation of delay
of such a huge nature, 2365 days to be precise.
10.
The precise reasons urged by the Applicants/ Review
Petitioners in this application are mostly related to delay in examination of
the files/ record by the Department in consultation with the General
Administration Department (GAD) and the Law Department of the
Government of Jammu & Kashmir on the subject.
11.
Although, there can be no quarrel with the proposition that a
liberal approach has to be adopted in the matter of condonation of delay
when there is no gross negligence or deliberate inaction or lack of bona
fides on the part of the State/ Government functionaries, but, in the instant
case, the Applicants/ Review Petitioners took their own time to formulate
an opinion that the Review Petition has to be filed. It has, nowhere, been
stated that they were, at all, prevented earlier to take such a decision. It was
incumbent upon the Applicants/ Review Petitioners to do so for bringing
home the argument that they did not adopt dilatory tactics and that every
action taken had the semblance of fairness attached to it.
12.
In this behalf, the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in “Union of India & Ors. V. Nripen Sarma, AIR 2011 SC 1237”
enunciates the aforesaid principle and it lays down as follows:
“…….. 3/ This appeal emanates from the judgement of the
Division Bench of the Guahati High Court (High Court of Assam,
Nagaland, Meghalaya, Manipur, Tripura, Mizoram and Arunachal
Pradesh) in Misc. Case No. 1569 of 2007 in W.A.No. 72020 of 2006. The
CM No. 5661/2026 in
RP No. 43/2026
CM No. 5662/2026
appeal filed by the Union of India was dismissed by the High Court
because of inordinate delay of 239 days. The Division Bench of the High
Court, while dismissing the appeal, has observed as under:
“We have gone through the contents of the petition. The
delay occurred because of the respondents took their own sweet
time to reach the conclusion whether the judgement should be
appealed or not. It is not that they were prevented by any reason
which is beyond their control to take such a decision in time.
Even otherwise, on merits of the case also it does not appear to
have any tenable ground of appeal. In the circumstances, we do
not see any merits in this petition.”
4/ We have also gone through the condonation of delay
application which was filed in the High Court. In our considered view,
the High Court was fully justified in dismissing the appeal on the ground
of delay because no sufficient cause was shown for condoning the delay.
………………..
6/ The Union of India ought to have been careful particularly in
filing this Civil Appeal because the Division Bench, by the impugned
order, has dismissed the appeal before it on the ground of delay. It is a
matter of deep anguish and distress that majority of the matters filed by
the Union of India are hopelessly barred by limitation and no satisfactory
explanations exist for condoning inordinate delay in filing those cases.”
13.
Again, in “Esha Bhattacharjee V. Mg. Commit of
Raghunathpur Nafar, (2013) 12 SCC 649”, the Hon’ble Supreme Court,
observed as under:
“……….. 21.2. (ii) The terms “sufficient cause” should be
understood in their proper spirit, philosophy and purpose regard being
had to the fact that these terms are basically elastic and are to be applied
in proper perspective to the obtaining fact-situation.
21.9. (ix) The conduct, behavior and attitude of a party relating to
its inaction or negligence are relevant factors to be taken into
consideration. It is so as the fundamental principle is that the courts are
required to weigh the scale of balance of justice in respect of both parties
and the said principle cannot be given a total go by in the name of liberal
approach.
21.10. (x) If the explanation offered is concocted or the grounds
urged in the application are fanciful, the courts should be vigilant not to
expose the other side unnecessarily to face such a litigation.
………………
21.12. (xii) The entire gamut of facts are to be carefully
scrutinized and the approach should be based on the paradigm of judicial
discretion which is founded on objective reasoning and not on individual
perception.
………………..
31. Neither leisure nor pleasure has any room while one moves an
application seeking condonation of delay of almost seven years on the
ground of lack of knowledge or failure of justice.”
CM No. 5661/2026 in
RP No. 43/2026
CM No. 5662/2026
14.
Applying the ratio of law laid down above by the Hon’ble
Apex Court to the facts and circumstances of the present case, it is clearly
evident that the Applicants/ Review Petitioners have been negligent in
prosecuting their claim within time and the explanation offered for the
delay in filing the Review Petition is neither plausible nor reasonable. The
application appears to have been drafted casually without giving a proper
account of the dates and details of the grounds agitated in it and recourse
has been had to the leisure and pleasure in moving the application.
15.
Counsel
The Judgments referred to and relied upon by the learned
for
the
Applicants/
Review
Petitioners,
being
clearly
distinguishable on facts, are of no help to the case of the Applicants/
Review Petitioners.
16.
For the foregoing reasons, it is found that the Applicants/
Review Petitioners have miserably failed to explain the huge delay of 2365
days. That being so, the application for condonation of delay, in filing the
Review Petition, is hereby rejected and, as a corollary thereto, the Review
Petition shall also stand dismissed as barred by time.
(M. A. CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR
September 2nd, 2026
“TAHIR”
Tahir Manzoor Bhat
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review