Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
LPA No. 256/2022
Reserved on: 23.07.2026
Pronounced on: 04.08.2026
Uploaded on: 05 .08.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced:Full
UT of Jammu and Kashmir and others
Appellants
Through: Mr. Hakim Aman Ali Dy.AG.
vs
Abdul Rashid Durrani
…Respondent(s)
Through: - Mr. A. Haqani Sr. Advocate with
Ms. Muneeba Advocate.
CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE(ACTING)
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHD. YOUSUF WANI
JUDGMENT
Chief Justice (A)
This intra-Court appeal, filed by the Union Territory of Jammu and
Kashmir, is directed against an order and judgment dated 11.10.2022 passed by
the learned Single Judge of this Court (hereinafter referred to as the "writ Court")
in SWP No. 190/2017 titled Abdul Rashid Durrani vs. State of Jammu and
Kashmir and others, whereby the writ petition filed by the respondent under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India came to be allowed and Government Order
No. 152/ADM/JKTDC of 2012 dated 22.08.2012, terminating the services of the
respondent, was quashed.
The impugned judgment is assailed by the appellants on multiple
grounds. Before we advert to the grounds of challenge urged by the appellants, it
would be appropriate to notice the facts which are necessary for the disposal of this
appeal.
The respondent came to be appointed as a Waiter on ad hoc basis in
the appellant-Corporation in the year 1983 and was regularized against the said
post in the year 1985. He was subsequently promoted as Floor Supervisor in the
year 2008. Thereafter, he was sent on deputation to the Tourism Department and
remained attached with the Personnel Section of the then Tourism Minister till
September, 2008. Thereafter, he was posted at different establishments of the
Corporation, including T.E. Gulmarg and Cheshmashahi Hutments. The
respondent, however, remained absent w.e.f. 01.05.2010, though he claims that he
remained attached with a Member of the Legislative Council w.e.f. 01.05.2010 till
31.10.2011. It is further claimed by the respondent that, despite the appellants
being aware of his attachment with the MLC, they, without any reason or
justification, withheld his salary with effect from 01.05.2010 . And later vide
Government Order No. 152/ADM/JKTDC of 2012 dated 22.08.2012, terminated
his services retrospectively with effect from 31.05.2010 on the allegation of
unauthorized absence from duty. The respondent claims to have submitted
representations before the appellants seeking redressal of his grievance with regard
to the impugned order of termination as well as for release of his withheld salary,
but no action was taken thereon.
Aggrieved of his dismissal from service, the respondent invoked the
writ jurisdiction of this Court by filing the writ petition, inter alia, contending that
the impugned order of termination, passed retrospectively on the allegation of
unauthorized absence from duty, was arbitrary, illegal and violative of Articles 14
and 16 of the Constitution of India. It was pleaded that the impugned order had
been passed without informing him of the allegations levelled against him and
without affording him any reasonable opportunity of being heard. It was further
contended that his attachment with the Personnel Section of the then Tourism
Minister was under valid orders issued by the competent authority and, therefore,
the said period could not have been treated as unauthorized absence from duty. It
was also urged that before imposing the penalty of dismissal, the appellants were
under a legal obligation to frame charges, communicate the same to the
respondent, call for his explanation and, in the event the explanation was found
unsatisfactory, hold a regular departmental enquiry in accordance with the
applicable service rules and the principles of natural justice so as to enable the
respondent to effectively defend himself. According to the respondent, no such
procedure prescribed by law was followed by the appellants.
The writ petition was contested by the appellants by filing their reply.
It was pleaded that an Inquiry Officer had conducted a preliminary enquiry and
found that the respondent had remained unauthorizedly absent from his legitimate
duties, thereby rendering himself liable to disciplinary action under the relevant
rules. It was further pleaded that on the basis of the enquiry report, a detailed
charge-sheet was framed and served upon the respondent, requiring him to explain
the reasons for his unauthorized absence and directing him to resume duties within
a period of fifteen days. However, according to the appellants, the respondent
neither submitted any reply to the charge-sheet nor resumed his duties. It was
further stated that a final show-cause notice dated 10.07.2012 was thereafter issued
to the respondent calling upon him to show cause as to why his services be not
terminated. As the respondent failed to respond even to the said notice, the
appellants, after following the prescribed procedure, terminated his services on the
ground of unauthorized absence from duty.
The writ Court, after considering the rival submissions and examining
the record, came to the conclusion that although an enquiry appeared to have been
initiated into the alleged misconduct of the respondent, the mandatory procedure
prescribed under Rule 145 of the Employees Service Rules of the Jammu and
Kashmir Tourism Development Corporation Limited had not been complied with.
The writ Court found that the record produced by the appellants did not disclose
the manner in which the enquiry had been conducted. There was nothing on record
to indicate that the statement containing the allegations of misconduct had been
read over or explained to the respondent. Equally, there was no material to
demonstrate that any evidence had been recorded during the enquiry. The writ
Court, thus, held that the procedure prescribed under Rule 145 had not been
followed at any stage of the disciplinary proceedings and, consequently, the order
of dismissal was unconstitutional, illegal and unsustainable in law.
The judgment impugned is assailed by the appellants, inter alia, on
the grounds that the respondent had been afforded adequate opportunity to defend
himself and to submit his reply to the charge-sheet, thereby satisfying the
requirements of the principles of natural justice. It is submitted that despite such
opportunity having been afforded, the respondent failed to submit any reply to the
charge-sheet or the final show-cause notice. It is further contended that the
respondent had participated in the enquiry proceedings before the Inquiry Officer
but thereafter deliberately chose not to respond to the disciplinary proceedings and,
therefore, cannot be permitted to contend that the order of termination was passed
in violation of the principles of natural justice. It is also urged that the appellants
had complied with the mandate of Rule 145 of the Employees Service Rules by
providing the respondent repeated opportunities of hearing and that the respondent,
having consciously abstained from participating in the proceedings, is estopped
from questioning the order of dismissal. According to the appellants, the record
demonstrates that a full-fledged departmental enquiry had been conducted into the
unauthorized absence of the respondent and, therefore, the writ Court erred in
interfering with the order of dismissal. It is further submitted that the appellants
had strictly adhered to the procedure prescribed under Rule 145 and, therefore, the
impugned judgment deserves to be set aside. It is also argued that the respondent
never reported back for duty after the order of suspension and, therefore, was not
entitled to any service benefits as directed by the writ Court. Lastly, it is contended
that since the respondent was an employee of the Corporation governed by its own
Service Rules, the writ Court committed an error in extending him the benefit of
judgments which, according to the appellants, were not applicable to the facts of
the present case.
Before we proceed further, we deem it appropriate to reproduce Rule
145 of the Employees Service Rules of J&K Tourism Development Corporation
Limited [‘Services Rules’], which reads as under:
"145. Procedure for imposing major penalties:
(i) When an employee is charged with misconduct which may lead to
the imposition of a major penalty, the Disciplinary Authority shall
frame definite charges on the basis of the allegations against him. The
charges, together with a statement of allegations on which they are
based, shall be communicated in writing to the employee, who shall be
required to submit within such time as may be specified by the
Disciplinary Authority (not exceeding 15 days), a written statement of
his defence.
(ii) On receipt of the written statement of the employee or if no; such
statement is received within the time specified, an enquiry may be
held by the Disciplinary Authority itself, or by an officer or committee
appointed for the purpose (hereinafter called the Inquiring Authority)
by the Disciplinary Authority.
(iii) At the enquiry a reasonable opportunity shall be afforded to the
employee for explaining defending his case but he will not be allowed
to engage a legal practitioner for this purpose.
(iv) At the conclusion of the enquiry, the Inquiring Authority shall
prepare a report of the enquiry and record its findings on each of the
charges, together with the reason therefor."
From a plain reading of Rule 145, it clearly transpires that Rule 145 is
intended to provide an adequate opportunity of being heard to the delinquent
employee before he is visited with one of the major penalties. The first requirement
of the said Rule is to frame a definite charge/charges on the basis of allegations
against a delinquent employee. These charges, together with the statement of
allegations, are required to be communicated in writing to the delinquent employee
with a view to enabling him to submit his reply/defence within such time as may
be specified by the Disciplinary Authority, but such period should not exceed 15
days. It is only upon receipt of the written statement from the delinquent employee,
the Disciplinary Authority shall proceed to hold the enquiry either itself or through
an officer or committee appointed for the purpose. There is a further requirement
that, at the enquiry, the delinquent employee shall be afforded a reasonable
opportunity to explain and defend his case. The Enquiry Officer shall, upon
following the aforesaid procedure, make his report and record his findings on each
of the charges together with the reasons thereof.
From the above, it is vividly evident that the entire procedure
prescribed under Rule 145 aims at providing a fair and adequate opportunity to the
delinquent employee to defend himself against the charge/charges framed against
him.
In the instant case, before framing the regular charges against the
respondent, the appellants instituted a preliminary fact-finding enquiry. During the
course of the preliminary enquiry, the respondent was given repeated opportunities
to come forward and resume his duties and explain his unauthorised absence. The
first notice was issued on 29.03.2011, calling upon him to report for duty and
explain his absence. He was also warned that in case he fails to join and explain his
absence, disciplinary action would follow. The notice was duly dispatched to his
residential address, which he himself had furnished and which was available in the
official record. Having received no response to the notice dated 29.03.2011, the
competent authority placed the respondent under suspension vide order dated
18.11.2011, pending regular enquiry into his unauthorised absence w.e.f.
01.06.2010.
From a reading of the preliminary enquiry report, it further emerges
that the respondent did appear before the Enquiry Officer and was also heard. He
sought to explain his absence by pleading that during the period of absence, he had
been working in the office of the former Tourism Minister, who, at the relevant
time, was a Member of the Legislative Council. The Enquiry Officer considered
the explanation tendered by the respondent in the light of the documents available
on the official record and came to the conclusion that the respondent was absent
from duty unauthorisedly and that there was no order of any authority, much less
the competent authority, placing his services at the disposal of the MLC, who
happened to be a former Tourism Minister. It was found that the respondent was
absconding from duty after 31.05.2010.
On the basis of the preliminary enquiry, formal charges were framed
and communicated to the respondent, granting him 15 days’ time to submit his
written defence. The charge-sheet was sent to his residential address and was also
published in a local newspaper. Despite all these opportunities, the respondent
neither submitted any written statement nor resumed his duties. Since the charges
against the respondent were prima facie established during the fact-finding enquiry
and the respondent had failed to avail the opportunity of defending himself in the
regular enquiry by explaining his absence from duty, a formal show-cause notice
dated 10.07.2012, proposing the penalty of dismissal, was issued. This notice too
was sent to his residential address and was also published in the daily newspaper.
The respondent failed to respond.
From the sequence of events, it is clearly demonstrated that the
respondent was afforded adequate and reasonable opportunity, both at the
preliminary enquiry stage as well as during the disciplinary proceedings. In these
circumstances, it is very difficult for us to accept the contention of Mr. Haqani
learned Senior Counsel that the order of dismissal passed against the respondent is
in violation of the principles of natural justice. The principles of natural justice
require that the delinquent employee is provided a reasonable and adequate
opportunity to defend the charge. The Disciplinary Authority/Enquiry Officer is
not under an obligation to postpone the proceedings indefinitely until the
delinquent employee chooses to appear and participate. A person who, despite
having an opportunity, abstains from the enquiry cannot subsequently complain of
denial of a reasonable opportunity to defend himself.
It is true that even in a case where the delinquent employee chooses
not to appear in the domestic enquiry, the Enquiry Officer is under an obligation to
establish the charge. In the case on hand, the charge stood firmly established. The
initial onus of the employer stood discharged when, on the basis of the record, it
was found that the respondent was unauthorisedly absent from duty and the
respondent was called upon to explain his absence. It is also true that before the
Enquiry Officer conducting the preliminary enquiry, the respondent took a plea
that during the period of absence, he was working with the MLC, but could not
disclose or produce any order or communication of any officer of the appellant
Corporation, much less of the competent authority. He seems to have managed a
certificate later from the MLC under whom he had served when he was the
Minister for Tourism, so as to cover up his absence.
We are in agreement with the submission of Mr. Haqani, learned
Senior Counsel, that a fact-finding enquiry/preliminary enquiry cannot be made the
basis for terminating the services of a delinquent employee. However, the facts in
the instant case are entirely different. The charges framed against the respondent
were definite and pertained to unauthorised absence. It was never the case of the
respondent that during the said period, he had attended any office of the
Corporation at any place under the orders of the competent authority. As a matter
of fact, in one of his representations, the respondent himself submitted that he
could not attend his duties due to certain family circumstances.This is evident from
the representation of the respondent dated 16.11.2016 addressed to the General
Manager (Administration), JKTDC, Srinagar, requesting the latter to re-engage
him in service. This communication is part of the writ petition filed by the
respondent. Interestingly, in this representation, he does not refer to having
performed his duties with the MLC, but has submitted that after his attachment
with the then Tourism Minister, Mr. Ajatshatru Singh, was over, he was directed to
attend his duties back in the Corporation. He would submit that he could not join
his duties back in the Corporation due to some personal circumstances. In the said
representation, he has only pleaded that the Corporation, in the case of many
similarly situated employees, had taken a lenient view and later reinstated or reengaged them. He also pleaded his family difficulties to the extent that he had three
unmarried daughters, etc.
From the representation dated 16.11.2016, it is crystal clear that the
certificate managed from the MLC was an additional ground carved out by the
respondent to save himself from the charge. In view of the clear evidence available
with the appellants, the initial burden of proving that the respondent had remained
unauthorisedly absent was discharged, and it was now for the respondent to come
forward with his written statement and explain his absence.
As noted above, the respondent miserably failed to do so. He denied
having been served with any notice or any charge-sheet ever. As we have noticed
above, and would like to reiterate here, the respondent was an employee who had
remained absent from duty without leaving any whereabouts. In these
circumstances, the only address available with the appellants was his residential
address available in the official record. Not only did the appellants serve the
respondent with different communications, including the articles of charge, by
posting them to his residential address, but they also published the information in
the daily newspapers.
Viewed thus, the argument of Mr. Haqani learned Senior Counsel that
Rule 145 of the Service Rules was breached with impunity is not acceptable. The
findings recorded by the Enquiry Officer are based on the service record and the
failure of the respondent to rebut such findings by submitting his written statement
and leading evidence in support thereof. The learned Single Judge, in reassessing
the adequacy of compliance with the principles of natural justice and the
requirements of Rule 145, exceeded the permissible limits of judicial review under
Article 226 of the Constitution.We are, therefore, satisfied that the order of
dismissal does not suffer from any procedural illegality or violation of the
principles of natural justice warranting interference. The impugned judgment of the
learned Single Judge cannot be sustained and is, accordingly, liable to be set aside.
Consequently, the present Letters Patent Appeal is allowed. The impugned
judgment passed by the learned Single Judge is set aside, and the order of dismissal
passed by the competent authority against the respondent is upheld. The writ
petition filed by the respondent stands dismissed.
(MOHD. YOUSUF WANI)
JUDGE
(SANJEEV KUMAR)
CHIEF JUSTICE(A)
Jammu
04 .08.2026
Sanjeev
Whether judgment is reportable:Yes
Sanjeev Kumar
2026.08.05 11:49
I am the author of this
document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review