Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
…..
LPA no.264/2024
CM no.6276/2024
Reserved on: 09.07.2026
Pronounced on: 23.07.2026
Uploaded on: 23.07.2026
Whether the operative part or
full judgment is pronounced: Full
1. Union Territory of J&K through Commissioner/Secretary to
Government, Revenue Department, Civil Secretariat, Jammu/Srinagar
2. Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir, Srinagar
3. Deputy Commissioner, Ganderbal
4. Tehsildar, Ganderbal
5. Patwari Halqa Bakoora, Ganderbal
…….Appellant(s)
Through: Mr. Mohsin Qadri. Sr.AAG with
Ms. Maha Majid, assisting counsel
Versus
Saleema Begum Aged 75 years W/o Mushtaq Ahmad Beigh R/o
Towheed Abad, Nowshera, Srinagar
……Respondent(s)
Through: Mr.Aatir Javed Kawoosa, Advocate
with Mr. Areeb Javed Kawoosa, Advocate
CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE MOHD YOUSUF WANI, JUDGE
JUDGEMENT
1. This intra court appeal by Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir
arises from an order and judgement dated 8th November 2023, passed
by learned Single Judge [“Writ Court”] in WP(C) no.290/2023, titled
as Saleema Begum v. UT of J&K and others, whereby the Writ Court
has allowed the petition of respondent and directed appellants herein
Page 1
LPA no.264/2024
not to interfere with the possession of respondent over the land
measuring 40 Kanals bearing Khasra no.1315/1274/287/2-min situate
at Village Bakura Tehsil & District Ganderbal (hereinafter to be
referred as “subject land”).
2. Before we come to grounds of challenge urged by appellants to assail
the judgment impugned, we deem it appropriate to notice few facts
relevant to this appeal.
3. Indisputably, subject land came to be mutated in the name of
respondent in terms of Government Order no.LB-6/C of 1958 dated 5th
June 1958 read with Government Order no.S-432 of 1966 dated 3rd June
1966. The two mutations bearing nos.1154/1 and 1156, attested in
terms of the aforesaid orders, are intact as on date and have not been
set-aside or quashed by any component authority after following due
process of law.
4. Apprehending that appellants may, without adopting the due process of
law, evict her from subject land, respondent filed WP(C) no.290/2023,
seeking, inter alia, a direction to appellants herein not to evict or
dispossess her from the subject land. The writ petition was filed by
respondent pleading, inter alia, that she was owner in possession of
subject land on the basis of proprietary rights conferred upon her in
terms of Government Order no.S-342 of 1966. She submitted that she,
having been found in cultivating possession of subject land since 1957
and meeting the requirement of Government Order no.LB-6/C of 1958,
was declared as tenant-at-will and later in terms of Government Order
no.S-342 of 1966, was conferred the proprietary rights. She claimed
Page 2
LPA no.264/2024
that she was declared as tenant-at-will and later conferred proprietary
rights pursuant to the valid mutations attested by competent revenue
officers.
5. Writ petition was contested by appellants herein, contending that
mutations, were attested in terms of Government Order no.LB-6/C of
1958 and Government Order no.S-342 of 1966, in favour of respondent,
when there was a ban on attestation of such mutations in terms of
Government Order no.158/LB of 1989 dated 22nd June 1989. It was,
thus, contended that mutations attested during ban are nullity in the eye
of law and, therefore, do not confer any right upon respondent to own
and possess the subject land. It was claimed by appellants that since
respondent was in illegal occupation of the State land, therefore, they
were entitled to proceed against her under the provisions of J&K State
Lands (Vesting of Ownership to the Occupants) Act, 2001.
The
appellants, however, deny having made any attempt to evict or
dispossess the respondent from the subject land without adopting the
due process of law.
6. The Writ Court considered the rival contentions of the parties and
perused the material on record. The Writ Court came to the conclusion
that the plea of ban taken by appellants was not tenable in view of the
judgement rendered by a Division Bench of this Court in the case of
Kewal Krishan v. State of J&K and others, 2004 (II) SLJ 617 , in which
this Court had declared the ban imposed on attestation of mutations
under Government Order no.LB-6/C of 1958 and Government Order
no.S-342 of 1966, arbitrary and unconstitutional. Placing reliance upon
Page 3
LPA no.264/2024
the aforesaid judgement, the contentions raised on behalf of appellants
were rejected and writ petition was allowed in favour of respondent.
7. Feeling aggrieved, the appellants are before us in this appeal, reiterating
the grounds of contest which they had urged before the Writ Court. It
was vehemently contended that the Writ Court did not appreciate in
correct perspective that the appellants, vide Government order
no.158/LB of 1989 dated 22nd June 1989, had banned the attestation of
mutations under Government Order no.LB-6/C and Government Order
no.S-342 of 1966. Since the mutations in favour of respondent were
attested on 27th April 1996, as such, the same were clearly in violation
of Government Order no.158/LB of 1989 (supra).
8. Mr. Mohsin Qadri, learned Sr. AAG, appearing for appellants, drew our
attention to Government Order no.(LB) 201 of 2007 dated 12 th June
2007, whereby the Government Order no.158/LB of 1989 dated 22 nd
June 1989 was rescinded. It was submitted by learned counsel, Mr.
Qadri, that Government Order no.(LB) 201 of 2007 clearly stipulated
that where any mutation is attested in violation of Government Order
no.LB-6/C and Government Order no.S-342 of 1966, the same would
be void ab initio and land would be dealt with under J&K State Lands
(Vesting of Ownership to the Occupants) Act, 2001. And for that
purpose the persons, in whose favour mutations stood attested in
violation thereof, would be declared as ‘unauthorized occupants’.
9. We have heard learned counsel for parties and perused the material on
record. We are of the considered opinion that the judgement passed by
Page 4
LPA no.264/2024
the Writ Court suffers from no legal or factual infirmity calling for
interference by us in this appeal.
10.There is no dispute with regard to the fact that the subject land is in
cultivating possession of respondent since the year 1957. The
respondent was declared as tenant-at-will in terms of Government
Order no.LB-6/C of 1958 and conferred proprietary rights in terms of
Government Oder no.S-352 of 1966.
11.True it is that both the mutations in favour of respondent were attested
on 27th April 1996 when the ban on attestation of such mutations by the
Government in terms of Government Order no.158/LB of 1989 dated
22nd June 1989 was in operation. Therefore, we do not dispute that the
mutations were attested during the ban period. However, this Court
cannot lose sight of the fact that this ban imposed by the Government
on attestation of mutation under Government Order no.LB-6/C and
Government Order no.S-342 of 1966, in terms of Government Order
no.158/LB of 1989, was held arbitrary and unconstitutional in the case
of Kewal Krishan (supra). The relevant excerpts of the judgement in
Kewal Krishan (supra) have been reproduced by the Writ Court in
paragraph 08 of impugned judgement and the same is again set out
below for reference:
“8) The only contention that has been raised by the respondents is that
in 1996 when the mutation was attested in favour of the petitioner, there
was a ban on attestation of such mutations in terms of Government
No.158/LB of 1989 dated 22.06.1989. The issue as to whether the
respondents could have imposed such a ban has been determined by a
Division Bench of this Court in the case of Kewal Krishan vs. State of
J&K and others, 2004 (II) S.L.J. 617. In the said case, the Court has
observed that the right to be recorded as a tenant at will is a substantive
and independent right which emanates from Government Order No.LB6 and is dependent only upon the satisfaction of the conditions set out
in the order itself. It was further observed that order No.LB-6 does not
extinguish the ownership of the State over the land in occupation of
Page 5
LPA no.264/2024
person who becomes 'tenant-at-will' after satisfying the requisite
conditions. It was also observed that attestation of mutation is of no
consequence so far this right accrued under LB-6 is concerned. While
determining the question whether the ban could have been imposed on
attestation of mutation under the aforesaid two Government Orders, the
Court observed as under:
“Could such a ban as envisaged by the Government order be
legally imposed by the Government? In our considered opinion
the ban order is bad in law being an arbitrary exercise of the
power. The mutations to be attested pursuant to Government
orders LB/6 and Section 432 are in the nature of recognition of
vested rights in favour of the person entitled to be recorded as
tenant-at-will and owner under the said Government orders.
Though the rights emanating from the said Government orders
are not dependent upon the attestation of mutations yet the ban
order arbitrarily without any lawful reason causes unreasonable
and irrational restriction upon the recognition of already vested
rights. So long as these Government orders which confer
substantive rights upon the occupants of State lands are in force,
no restriction can be imposed upon the recognition of such rights
by imposing a ban upon the attestation of mutations. No reason
for necessitating such ban on the attestation of mutation has been
brought to our notice by the learned Deputy Advocate General
nor any is discernable from the language of the Government
order. We, therefore, quash the same for the reason of its being
arbitrary. Consequently, we set aside the order dated 21.8.1993
passed by learned Director Land Records (Settlement Officer)
in appeal No. 46/DLR/AP/92-93 with a direction to him for
passing fresh order in accordance with law after hearing the
parties. The judgment passed by the learned Single Judge is also
set aside and writ petition is allowed.”
12. In view of aforesaid legal position enunciated by this Court in Kewal
Krishan (supra), it does not lie in the mouth of appellants to contend
that the mutations are bad in the eye of law on the ground that the same
were attested during the ban imposed by the Government Order of
1989.
13.So far as contention by Mr. Qadri, learned counsel for appellants, with
regard to impact of Government Order no.158/LB of 1989 (supra) is
concerned, needless to say that if any mutation, whether it is attested
under Government Order no.LB-6/C or under Government Order no.S342 of 1966, is found to have been attested in violation of the terms and
conditions laid down in the aforesaid Government Orders, the same
would be void ab initio. However, the competent revenue authority
Page 6
LPA no.264/2024
cannot come to such conclusion unless it exercises power conferred
upon it under J&K Land Revenue Act, and after it follows the principles
of natural justice.
14. In the instant case, competent revenue officer has not initiated any
proceeding suo moto or otherwise to revise or set-aside the two
mutations attested in favour of respondent. In absence of any such
exercise having been undertaken, the recorded position is that the
respondent is owner in possession of the subject land pursuant to the
two valid mutations attested by competent revenue officer and,
therefore, she cannot be evicted otherwise than by following due
process of law.
15.For the foregoing reasons, we concur with the view taken by the Writ
Court and find no merit in this appeal.
16.Dismissed.
(Mohd Yousuf Wani)
Judge
(Sanjeev Kumar)
Chief Justice (Acting)
Srinagar
23.07.2026
Ajaz Ahmad, Secy
Whether approved for reporting? Yes/No.
Page 7
LPA no.264/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review