Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No.25
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
FAO No. 35/2024
Date of pronouncement: 25.09.2026
Date of uploading:26.09.2026
…..Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s)
01. Union Territory of J&K
through Chief Secretary Civil
Secretariat Jammu/Srinagar.
02. Director Estates,
Civil Secretariat Jammu/Srinagar.
03.Deputy Director Estates
Kashmir Division Srinagar.
Through: Mr. Illyas Nazir Laway, GA.
q
vs
Mehmooda Shaheen Medical Trust
Hospital, TulsiBagh Srinagar through
Rashid Ahmad Dar S/o Late Abdul
Rehman Dar R/o TulsiBagh Srinagar.
.…. Respondent(s)
Through: None.
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SEKHRI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
25.09.2026
(ORAL)
01.
Present appeal has been directed by the appellant Union Territory and
its instrumentalities, against order dated 19.08.2024, passed by
learned Additional District Judge, Srinagar [“the trial Court”] in case
titled “State of J&K and Ors. vs. Mehmooda Shaheen Medical Trust
Hospital”, whereby application preferred by the appellant for
condonation of 110 days delay in filing an application for setting
aside ex-parte judgment and decree dated 18.12.2012 came to be
dismissed.
02.
Before a closer look at the grounds urged in the memo of present
appeal, it shall be expedient to have an overview of the background
facts of the case.
03.
The respondent filed a civil suit for perpetual injunction restraining
the appellant from demolishing his house situate at Tulsi Bagh,
Srinagar, where some trust was stated to be running by him in the
capacity of chairman of the said trust. The suit came to be decided by
learned Municipal Magistrate, 1st Sub-ordinate Civil Judge, Srinagar,
whereby appellants were restrained by way of perpetual injunction
from demolishing the structure or causing interference with the
subject matter of the suit except in due course of law. Simultaneously,
the petitioners also approached this Court by way of OWP No.
686/2006 and this Court vide order dated 21.09.2006 allowed
respondent No. 3, an instrumentality of the appellant to take steps for
the removal of unauthorized occupation/obstruction on the public
road, shown at mark ‘D’ in the site plan Annexure-L to the said
petition.
04.
Pursuant to the aforesaid order of this Court dated 21.09.2006,
respondent came to be served upon a demolition order dated
29.05.2007, under Section 07 of J&K Public Premises (Eviction of
Unauthorized Occupants) Act, 1959, whereby he was directed to
demolish the encroachment within 10 days. This demolition order
dated 29.05.2007 came to be challenged by the respondent in the
FAO No. 35/2024
Court of learned 2nd Additional District Judge, Srinagar by way of an
appeal, which came to be dismissed on 23.02.2012. After dismissal of
the aforesaid appeal against the demolition notice, the unauthorized
occupation/obstruction came to be demolished by the appellants with
the assistance of police.
05.
According to the appellants, since respondent obstructed the
demolition process, an FIR bearing No. 133/2011, for offences under
Sections 447-A, 353, 506, 336 RPC, came to be lodged against him
with Police Station Shergarhi, Srinagar. After the demolition,
however, respondent preferred a suit for recovery of damages against
the appellants for an amount of Rs. 80.00 lakhs on 24.11.2010, which
came to be allowed in ex-parte by learned Additional District Judge,
Srinagar [“the trial Court”] on 18.12.2012, whereby 1/4th of the
amount of the estimated cost, to the tune of Rs. 20.00 lakhs was
ordered to be recovered from the appellant as compensation along
with simple interest @ 6% per annum from the date of decree.
06.
According to the appellants, on coming to know about the aforesaid
ex-parte judgment passed by the trial Court, an application in the trial
Court for setting aside the ex-parte judgment and decree along with
an application for condonation of 110 days delay was preferred by
them. Respondent also preferred an execution petition in the trial
Court, whereby in terms of order dated 12.10.2019, attachment
warrant came to be issued by the executing Court, and account head
of the Chief Secretary, State of J&K, Civil Secretariat to the extent of
Rs. 20 lakhs with interest @ 6% per annum w.e.f. 18.12.2012 came
FAO No. 35/2024
to be attached till the decretal amount along with interest was
deposited in the Court. This order came to be assailed by the
appellants by way of RFA No. 41/2019 and this Court vide order
dated 09.06.2020 set aside the said attachment order dated
12.10.2019 and allowed the appellants to lead evidence in support of
their application for condonation of delay.
07.
Pursuant to the aforesaid order of this Court, appellants adduced
evidence in support of their application for condonation of delay and
learned trial Court vide impugned order dated 19.08.2024 dismissed
the application on the ground that there was no plausible reason
constituting sufficient cause warranting condonation of delay.
According to the executing Court, from the statements of witnesses
of the appellants, it was found that plea taken by the appellants was
unfounded because after the issuance of institution of the suit, the
trial Court issued registered cover summons to the appellants way
back in the year 2013, which was evident from the postal receipts on
record.
08.
Appellant is aggrieved of the impugned order, primarily on the
ground that learned executing Court has failed to appreciate the
controversy in its correct perspective.
09.
Having heard Mr. Illyas Laway, learned counsel appearing for the
appellants, I have gone through the record.
10.
The appellants approached the trial Court for condonation of 110
days delay, primarily on the ground that they were unaware about the
proceedings held by the Court because they were never served with
FAO No. 35/2024
any summons. They came to know about the ex-parte judgment and
decree, as also the filing of the suit only on 25.04.2013, when they
received summon in the execution proceedings. Immediately
thereafter they contacted the standing counsel who applied for
issuance of the certified copies which were made available to them
on 07.05.2013 and the application for setting aside ex-parte decree
was presented on 09.05.2013.
11.
According to the appellants, though their application, for setting
aside ex-parte judgment and decree, was within the prescribed period
of limitation, however, as a matter of abundant precaution
application for condonation of delay was filed by them, which was
required to be condoned, because the controversy involves public
interests as respondent has encroached upon the state land and it
should not have been overlooked by the trial Court.
12.
A perusal of the impugned order reveals that learned trial Court has
dismissed the application preferred by the appellants, for
condonation of delay, primarily on the ground that after the
institution of the suit, summon under registered covers were issued to
the appellants, defendants in the suit, and there are postal receipts as
evidence on the record.
13.
A postal receipt proves only dispatch or posting, not actual or due
delivery of the item, though it triggers a rebuttable presumption of
service under law. Under Section 27 of the General Clauses Act,
1897 and Section 114 Indian Evidence Act, 1872, if a document is
properly addressed, prepaid and sent by registered or speed post to
FAO No. 35/2024
the correct address, court raises a presumption that it would have
been delivered in the ordinary course of business. However, in such
circumstances, the Court before raising the statutory presumption, is
obliged to record a finding that document or the summons, as the
case may be, was not only properly addressed but also sent by
registered or speed post to the correct address of the addressee,
otherwise a postal receipt would only confirm that item was handed
over to the post office with correct address and prepaid charges but it
would not verify that the envelope actually arrived at its destination.
14.
To firmly establish due delivery when service is disputed, Courts
may also look for corroborating evidence beyond the basic postal
receipt including the tracking report of the India Post website
showing “item delivered”, a signed physical acknowledgement card
returned by the recipient or the official written remarks of the postal
authorities on the returned cover such as “refused”, “house locked”
or “addressee not found”, which may also invite legal presumption of
valid tender.
15.
The appellants in order to establish their contention produced three
witnesses. All the 3 witnesses on affidavit deposed in clear terms that
respondent has encroached on its state land and an FIR in this respect
was also lodged against them. They also stated in clear terms that
they never received any notice/summon from the Court and the
department came to be know about the proceedings when they
received a notice in the execution petition. However, it appears that
learned trial Court by reading in between the lines has observed that
FAO No. 35/2024
since the witnesses never perused the dispatch register, they could
not say, if any summon was received by the department and was
entered in the dispatch register or not.
16.
Learned trial Court has dismissed application preferred by the
appellants, for condonation of delay, solely on the ground that there
was postal receipts on the record. Nothing more nothing less. A
perusal of the record reveals that neither the trial Court before
proceeding ex-parte against the appellants, recorded the required
satisfaction that the registered envelope containing the summons was
properly addressed and sent by registered post to the addresses, the
appellants herein, nor dealt with this important aspect of the matter
while deciding application of the appellants for condonation of delay.
17.
Be that as it may, since the contention raised by the petitioner is that
respondent has encroached upon the state land, learned trial Court
having regard to the public interest involved in the matter ought to
have condoned the delay and allowed the parties to contest fair &
square.
18.
For what has been analysed, observed and discussed above, present
appeal is allowed and impugned order dated 19.08.2024, passed by
the trial Court, whereby application filed by the appellants for
condonation of delay came to be dismissed is set aside. As a result,
the said application is allowed and delay of 110 days in filing the
application for setting aside ex-parte proceedings is condoned.
FAO No. 35/2024
19.
Trial Court is directed to consider the application preferred by the
appellants for setting aside ex-parte judgment and decree, after
affording a reasonable opportunity of being heard to both the sides.
20.
Disposed of.
(Rajesh Sekhri)
Judge
Srinagar
25.09.2026
Sushant
Whether the order is speaking?
Whether the order is reportable?
FAO No. 35/2024
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review