Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3488 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY, THE TENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
WRIT APPEAL NO: 963 OF 2025
Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent Writ Appeal preferred
against the order dated.18l03l2o25 passed in Review l.A.No.1 of 2018 in W P No.
6403 of 2013 and pass on the file of the High Court.
Between:
1. Union of lndia, Rep. by its lnspector General, South Sector, Central lndustrial
Security Force, Ministry of Home Affairs, CISF South Sector Headquarters,
Chennai Port Trust, Chennai.
2. The Deputy lnspector General, Central lndustrial Security Force, Ministry of
Home.Affairs, Department of Space Head Quarters, Antariksha Bhavan, New
BEL Road, Bangalore.
3. The Commandant, Central lndustrial Security Force, tMinistry of Home Affairs,
QISF Unit, VSSC, Thumba, Kerala State.
4. The Assistant Commandant, Central lndustrial Security Force, Ministry of
Home Affairs, CISF Unit, NRSC, Balanagar, Hyderabad - 625.
...APPELLANTS
AND
Kishan Kumar Azmeera, S/o Raju Naik, Aged about 43 Years, Occ. ExConstable/Sweeper, N o 5-47, Chanthripapal ly Village, G urrampet ( Post)
Bhupalpally Mandal, Warangal District.
.RESPONDENT
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the order 18-03-2025 in Rev.l.A.No. 1 of 2018 in W.P.No. 6403 of 2013.
Counsel for thr: Appellants: SRI ARAVIND KUMAR KATA,
SC FOR CENTRAL GOVERNMENT COUNSEL
counsel for the Respondents: sRl KISHAN KUMAR AZMEERA
(PARTY-!N-PERSON)
The Court made the following: JUDGMENT
t
I
l
:
l
i
i
:
i
i1
i1
{,1
,iq
IN THE HIGH COT'RT FOR THE STATE OF TEIIINGAITA
AT TTYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARFSH KT'IVIAR SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
WRIT APPEAL No.963 OF 2025
DATE: l0 . 02. .2026
Between
Union of India and 3 others
....Appellants
AND
Kishan Kumar Azrneera
...Respondert
JUDGMENT
This Writ Appeal is directed against the order dated
L8.03.2O25 passed by the learned Single Judge in Review I.A.No.1 of
201.8 in W.P.No.6403 of 2O13. The operative portion of impugned
order of the learned Single Judge is extracted hereunder:
B. In that uiew of the matter, the irnpugrted punishrnent of remoual from
seruice sfands modiJied to that of Compulsory Retire-ntent from Seruice,
with effect from O 5. 0 6. 2 O 1 2.
9. Accordingly, the reuieut petitionis disposed of 'No costs'. The respondent
department shall take necessary steps for tlrc payntent of pension and
retirement benefits as applicable to tLrc petitioner within a period of three
month.s from the date of receipt of a copg of this order, 'lhe petitioner shall
not claim ang interest on tLe pension and retirement benefits due, on
arcount of this order. Miscellaneous petitions pending, if ang, shall stand
closed.
2.
Heard Sri Aravind Kumar Kata, learned Standing Counsel for
central Government appearing for appellants and Sri Kishan Kumar
Azmeera, respondent (party-in-person) and perused the record.
Factual background (in brieff
3.
The respondent was appointed as a Constable/Su/eeper in the
Cerrtral Industrial Security Force (CISF) on 14.09. L997 aud served in
various u:rits in Andhra Pradesh. During thc respondent's service
tenure, he, was imposed with two major punishrnents and six minor
punishments for misconduct, mostly relating to unauthorized
absence a.rd overstay of leave.
4.
In the incident relating to the removal of the respondent, the
responden[ \,i1s sanctioned earned leave for a pcriod o[ 13 day-s from
19.10.2011 to 31.10.2011 and was required to report for dutl'on
02.ll.2Oll. The respondent, however, failed to report for dut)' and
remained absent without authorisation. Despite call up notices in
connectiorL with the departmental enquiry, the respondent neither
responded nor participated in the proceedings.
5.
Conr;equently, a
Memorandum of
Charge No'V-
1s014/clsiF/vssc/DISC/AKKl2Or2l49 dated 03.01.2o12 \{',as
issued to the respondent, framing two articles of charge under Rule
36 of CISF Rules 2OOl, namely: (i) unauthorrzed absence from duty
with effect from O2.ll.2}ll; and (ii) incorrigible attitude in view of
his past s:rvice record. A departmental enquiry was conducted in
accordanct: with the Rules. As the respondent failed to participate,
the enquiry was conducted ex parte, and by final order dated
\
tI
i
,i
,.n
O5.06.2OL2, the disciplinary authority imposed the penalty of
'removal from service.'
6.
The statutory appeal and revision filed by the respondent were
dismissed by the appellate and revisional authorities by orders dated
2l.oB.2Ol2 and 30.11.2012 respectively. Aggrieved thereby, the
respondent filed W.P. No.6403 of 2013. The learned Single Judge, by
order dated I5.06.2018, dismissed the writ petition, upholding the
penalty of removal from service.
7.
Thereafter, the respondent liled Review I.A. No.1 of 2018
seeking review of the order dated 15.06.2018. By the impugned order
dated 18.03.2025, the learned Single Judge allowed the review
petition, holding that the punishment of removal from service was
disproportionate to the charge of unauthorized absence, having
regard to the respondent's length of service, and accordingly modified
the punishment to that of compulsory retirement from service rvith
effect from 05.06.2012, with consequential pensionary benelits.
8.
Assailing the said order passed in revierv, the appellants have
preferred the present writ appeal.
Contentions on behalf of the appellants
g.
The learned Senior Standing Counsel for Central Government
appearing for the appellants has contended:
I
Thzrt the learned Single Judge exceeded the permissible limits
anc, tht: limited scope of review jurisdiction under order XLVII
Rule I of the code of civil procedure, 190g (for short 'cpc).
1I
That Lhe power of revierv is circumscribed and can be exercised
onll' on the grounds expressly enumerated under Order XLVII
Rult: 1 cPC, namely, discovery of new and important matter or
evidence , error apparent on the face of the record, and none oI
these statutory grounds were made out in the review petition.
The respondent under the guise of a revieu, sought a reconsideration ol the quantum of punishment, which amounts
to a rehearing on merits and is impermissible in review.
That the learned Single Judge, while passing the order dated
15.Oti.2018 dismissing the writ petition, had exhaustively
exarr inecl the disciplinary procecdings, the nature of chargcs,
the :-espondent's past conduct, and the proportionalitv of
punis;hment. Re-visiting the same issues in review jurisdiction
amounts to sitting in appeal over one's own judgment, a course
expressly disapproved by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in perry
Kansagra a. Smriti Madan Kansagral, and Murali
Sundq.ram u. Jothibai Kannan2.
iv
That the finding recorded in the impugned order that rhe
punis.rment of removal from service was disproportionate
' lzorsy 20 scc 7i;3
'z(2023l| 13 scc sls
,,7
amounts to a re-appreciation of evidence and re-evaluation of
facts, which is whotly beyond the scope of review. Placing
reliance on (Jnion oJ India a. P. Gunoseko,rons, it was
submitted that even in judicial revicu, of disciplinary
proceedings, the High Court cannot re-assess evidence or
interfere with the conclusions of the disciplinary authority,
much less in review proceedings.
v
That the respondent was a member of a disciplined force and
that unauthorized absence, even for a short duration,
constitutes a serious act of indiscipline. 'lhe respondent's
service record disclosed two major and six minor punishments,
establishing an incorrigible pattern ol misconduct. The
observation in the impugned order that the respondent was
absent for "only about 107 days" tn 14 years was contended to
be legally untenable, as cumulative misconduct, and not
isolated duration of absence, governs the proportionaliry of
punishment in a uniformed force.
vl
That leniency in matters of prolonged and repeated
unauthorized absence would undermine discipline and
operational efficiency. Reliance was placed on The
Cotnm.c;ndant, 22 Bqttalion, CRPf Srinogar and Ors. Vs.
Surinder Kumart to contend that Courts must exercise
'(2015) 2 scc 6ro
' MANU/sc/ t266l2otr
r
restraint whilc interfering with penalties imposed in disciplined
for,--es.
vii. Thzrt the respondent had wilfully abandoned service, as evident
frorn his submission of resignation vi,hile on unauthorized
lea*e ,
failure to respond to four call..-up notices dated
03. t I .2ott, 12.1 1.20r 1, 22.rr.2orr and or.r2.2orr, and
deliberate non-participation in the departmental enquiry.
viii. That thc conccpt of "error apparent on the face of the record,,
in the domain of revien, jurisdiction, contemplates a patent and
self-evident error, not one which requires elaborate reasoping
or pcrnrits tu,o possiblc vielvs. Reliance was placed on
Ka,nr'Iesh verma u. Magautqti and otherss to contend that
the Inere possibility of an alternative view does not furnish a
grourd for revierv
ix. That the punishment imposccl by the disciplinary authority
was neither arbitrary rlor shocking to the conscience of the
cour -, having regard to the respondent,s incorrigible servicc
recorrl and the nature of duties performed. The impugned
order passed in review was therefore liable to be set aside.
Contentions by the respondent (party-in-person)
10. The rt:spondent appeared as party-in-person. Be it noted here
that having regard to the complexity of the legal issue involved in the
present matter, this court offered to provide the respondents (20r3)s scc
32tx\
a
employee with the services of a Legal-aid counsel through the High
Court Legal Services Authority. Although the petitioner initially
accepted the said offer, he has subsequently expressed his desire to
proceed in-person and has declined the assistance of the empanellecl
counsel
11. As the respondent appeared in-person and advanced
arguments in Hindi, this Court has, with a view to effectively
adjudicate the matter and contextualise the submissions within
established legal frameworks, distilled the contentions into a
legalistic lormat and referred to relevant authorities supporting the
substance of the arguments.
L2. The respondent in-person contended:
(i) That the learned Single Judge was justilied in exercising review
jurisdiction to prevent grave injustice.
(ii) That the service difliculties arose primarily due to the
respondent's efforts to pursue higher education with a view to
self-improvement, which repeatedly conflicted with his
postings outside Hyderabad. The respondent's requests for
transfer on educational grounds were rejected, leaving him
with no viable alternative.
(iii) That during the relevant period, the respondent's family
suffered a severe personal tragedy owing to the sudden demise
of his elder brother, who was also serving in the CISF. The
rE,
,,,;,'.*l+Ee-*lih.lr:,t.4,:.rdr**$+:.1;
r i.ri':. 1' :l;.,.
: ::
t
ernotional trauma caused by this event, coupled with the
res;pondent's responsibility towards aged parents, rendered
hirn incapable of reporting back to duty or effectively
particiltating irr tl-re dcpartrnental proceedings.
(it') ThzrL hc belor-rgs to the scheduled Tribe community and hails
frorn an impo'erishecl family, and his employment was the sole
meilns of livelihood fclr his dependents. The punishment of
removal from service, rvhich disentitles him to pensionary
ben:fits, had car-astrophic consequences for his family.
(v) Thar the punishment of removal from service was grossly
disproportionate to the misconduct alleged, as the
respondent's total abscnce of approximately 107 days over a
service span of 14 years, which viewed in the backdrop of
personal hardship and his low-ranking position, did not
warrir.nt the severest penalty under service jurisprudence.
("i) That similarl-1, situated employees, including one of his
batcLLmates, charged n'ith
a similar misconduct of
unauthorised absence had been awarded the lesser penalty of
compuisory retirement with pensionary benefits, and that
denia of similar treatment amounted to discrimination.
(vii) That the respondent's mental and emotional condition
follow:ng his brother's death constituted a significant
mitigating circumstance, which was not given due
consideration by the disciplinary authority or the original writ
court.
(viii) That the expression "any other sufficient reason" under Order
XLVII Rr-rle 1 CPC is wide enough to encompass cases where
failure to review would result in manifest injustice. Reliance is
placed on s. Nagarai and others u. state of Karnatq.ka and
others' to contend that Courts possess inherent power to
correct orders that result in miscarriage of justice.
(ix) That the modification of punishment from removal to
compulsory retirement strikes a just balance between the
requirement of discipline and the need for compassion, and
that the impugned order does not warrant interference.
13. We have taken note o[ the respective contentions urged and
material on record.
Consideration by this Court
L4. It is to be noted that the power of review under Order XLVII
Rule 1 of CPC is a limited and exceptional jurisdiction. Review is
permissible only on the grounds of discovery of new and important
matter or evidence, which after exercise of due diligence was not
within the knowledge of the applicant, or on account of an error
apparent on the face of the record, or for any other sufficient reason
analogous thereto.
n
MANU/sc/o797 / 1993
t0
15. It .s u'ell settled through a catena of decisions of the Hon,ble
Supreme court that review proceedings cannot be treated as an
appeal in disguise. A review court does not sit in appeal over its own
judgment, nor can it re-hear thc matter on merits nrerely because
another
'ielv is possible. The object of review is only to correct a
patent er.or and not to substitute a different opinion.
16. The Apex court in yashwant sinha and others u. central
Bureau of Inuestigation through its Director and. anotherz has
categorically held that review lies only lor correction of a manifest
error and that re-appreciation of evidence or re-consideration of
conclusior,s already arrived at is impermissible . Similarly, in
Kamlesh Verma (supra S), the principles governing review
jurisdiction have been succinctly summarized, holding that repetition
of old argtrments and rc-examination of issues already decided do
not constitute grounds for review, u,hich is extracted hereunder for
ready refert:nce:
2O.2. When the reuiew will not. be maintainable:
(i) tl repetition of old and ouerntlecl argument is not enough to
reo p e n co nclu de d adj u dicatio ns.
(ii) Irlinor mistakes of inconsequential import.
(iii) .Reuieut proceedings cannot be equated. u.tith the original hearing
of tlrc. case.
(iu) Reuiew rs not maintainabre unress the mateiar error, manifest
on lhe face of the order, undermines its sound.ness or results in
miscarriag e of lustice.
(u) tl reuieut is by
.no means an appeal in disguise wherebg an
erro,Leous decision is reheard qnd corrected. but lies
onrg for pitent
erTot'.
(ui) ',he nere possibilitg of two uiews on the subject
cannot be a
grou,td for reuietu.
'12ozo1z scc
st'\
ll
,.>
,')
(uii) The error apparent on the face of the record should not be an
error whtch has to be fished out and searched.
(uiii) The appreciatton of euirletlce on record is fully ttithin the
domain of the appellate court, it cannot be permitted to be aduanced
in the reuiew petitioru
(ix) Reuiew ts not nmintainable when the same relief sought at the
time of arguirtg the rnairu matter ltad been negatiued.
L7. A perusal of the review petition filed by the respondent
discloses that the grounds urged therein, pertain essentially to the
alleged disproportionality of punishment, length of service, personal
hardship, and socio-economic background of the respondent. These
issues were already urged and considered in the original writ
proceedings and formed the subject matter of adjudication in the
order dated 15.06.2018. While this Court is not insensitive to the
respondent's personal circumstances the factors Such as, his tribal
background, family tragedy etc., however compelling, cannot override
the paramount need [or discipline and accountability in an
uniformed force. The respondent's failure to respond to multiple
notices and participate in the departmental proceedings
demonstrates a lvilful disregard.
18. The learned Single Judge, while allowing the review petition,
undertook a fresh assessment of the proportionality of punishment,
the period of absence, and the respondent's service tenure, and on
such re-evaluation concluded that the punishment of removal from
service was disproportionate. This exercise amounts to reappreciation of flacts and substitution of a different view on the same
material, which is impermissible in review jurisdiction. This Court
.
',-. .:l:'.i;:,:,'..
,
t2
acknowledges the respondent's long service of 14 years and the
severe irnpact of removal without pension on his family. These are
undenial:ly sympathetic factors. Honever, the role of a court in
judicial ;-evicrn, is not to acL as a super-discipiinary authority.
The
penalty <>f rcmoval, imposed after duc process and upheld by the
appellate and revisional authorities as r.t ell as the lcarned Single
Judge in original jurisdiction cannot be termed per se perverse or
shockingly disproportionate in the context of a habitual offender in a
disciplinec force. To allow personal hardships to routincly mitigate
penalties for absentecism u,ould erode discipline and set an
un'*,orkable prccedent for forces where presence and reliability are
non-negotiable.
19. whi..e this court is not unmoved by the respondent,s plea for
compassion, the imperatives o[ institutional discipline, the limited
scope of r:view jurisdiction, and the need to maintain integrity of
hierarchal adjudication compel the restoration of the original order.
20. It is to be noted rhat the original order dated 1s.06.201g had
expressly considered the respondent's past service record, repeated
acts of unauthorized absence, and the nature of duties in a
disciplined force. The impugned order does not point out any patent
or self-evidr:nt error in the said findings. The mere formation of a
different opinion on proportionality does not constitute an .,error
apparent on the face of the record,,.
r3
21. It is to be noted that an error apparent must be manifest and
obvious, not one which requires a long-drawn process of reasoning or
permits two plausible views. In the present case the question of
proportionality of punishment necessarily involves an evaluative
exercise, and a more sympathetic assessment cannot retrospectively
render thc earlier view erroneous in law.
22. Further, it is also not in dispute that no new or additional
material was placed before the Court in review. The impugned order
is founded entirely on [he same factual matrix which had already
been examined in the original rvrit petition. Thus, the impugned
order passed in review travels beyond the permissible contours of
Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC.
23. On perusal of the record, it indicates that the respondent's
sefvice record reveals two major ancl six minor punishments, largely
on account of overstay of leave and unauthorized absence. The
charge in question was not an isolated instance but part of a
continuing pattern of indiscipline of the respondent. Further, the
respondent failure to report back to duty despite repeated call-up
notices and faiture to participate in the departmental enquiry, and
the submission of a resignation letter while on leave reflects a lack of
commitment to service
24.
The CISF being a central armed police force entrusted with the
protection of vital installations. Discipline and availability are
t
T
l4
t
fbundatic,nal to its functioning. In such forces, unauthorized
absence, e\ren for limited periods, has serious operational
implicaticrns. The Hon'ble Suprcme court in Deputg Inspector
General of Police u. s. samuthirams by reiterating thc vierv taken
in state Bank of Hgderabad v. p. Kata Raos has consistently
caut.ioned thzrt Courts must exercise great restrair-rt u,hile interfering
with purrishment imposed in discipiinary matters concerning
uniformec. serwices.
25. In the present case, the disciplinary authorit-r,, appelrate
i::
aruthority, revisional authority, and the writ Court in its original
I
I
I
,:
jurisdictio:r concurrently found the pcnalty justificd. This coq11 ig
unable to hoid that the punishment imposed shocks the judicial
conscience . Therefore, the punishment imposed cannoL be said to be
shockingly disproportionate so as to warrant interference.
Conclusio:n
26. F'or the foregoing reasons, this court is of the considered
opinion thtrt the learned Single Judge exceeded the limits of review
jurisdiction in allowing Revier,r, I.A. No.1 of 2018 on grounds not
contemplated under order XLVII Rule 1 of cpc. conscquently, the
order dateri 18.03.2025 passed by the learned Singte Judge in
Review [.A. No.l of 20i8 in w.P. No.6403 of 2013 is held to be
unsustainacle in law.
*
MANU/sc/ ro29 /2ot)"
ltt/2003
e MANU/SC//75
l5
27.
Accordingly, the Writ Appeal is allowed and the order dated
18.03.2025 passed by the learned Single Judge in Review I.A. No.1 of
2018 in W.P. No.64O3 ot2013 is set aside. In view of the above, the
order dated 15.06.2018 passed in W.P. No.6403 of 2013 dismissing
the writ petition and affirming the penalty of removal from service
i
li
imposed upon the respondent stands restored.
t,
t:
I
2A. In consequence thereof, the clirections issued in the impugned
I
I
review order relating to grant ol pensionary and retirement benefits
!
are vacated, and the respondent shall not be entitled to any
pensionary benefits consequent upon removal from service. However,
terminal benefits, if any, surch as ()encral Provident Fund (GPF),
which are otheru,ise admissible and not liable to forfeiture under the
applicable Rules, shall be released in accordance with law, subject to
compliance with the prescribed lormalities. No order as to costs.
As a sequel, the miscellancous peLitions, if any, shall stand
-clased.
I
SD/.M.RAMANA KRISHNA
JOINT
//TRUE COPY/
II
ER
I
I
I
,
i
i
To,
1. Union of lndia, Rep. by its lnspector General, South Sector, Central lndustrial
:
!
I
Security Force, Ministry of Horne Affairs, CISF South Sector Headquarters,
Chennai Port Trust, Chennai.
2. The Deputy lnspector General, Central lndustrial Security Forcg, Ministry of
Home Affairs, Department of Space Head Quarters, Antariksha Bhavan, New
BEL Road, Bangalore.
3. The Commandant, Central lndustrial Security Force, Ministry of Home Affairs,
CISF Unit, VSSC, Thumba, Kerala State.
4. The Assistant Commandant, Central lndustrial Security Force, Ministry of
Home Affairs, CISF Unit, NRSC, Balanagar, Hyderabad - 625.
5. One CC to SriAravind Kumar Kata, SC for Central Government COUNSEL
loPUCl
6. One CC to Sri Kishan Kumar, Azmeera, Party in person[OPUCJ
I
TJ
7. Two C[) Copies
I
CWL
t
\
HIGH COURT
DATED:'10/0212026
t
f
i
(
(
J
JUDGMENT
WA.No.963 ot 2O25
ALLOWING THE WRIT APPEAL
WITHOUT COSTS
UP
#'ru
1 HES
2 7 rEB 2026
*
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review