The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
31. 08.2021 in Civil Suit No. 66/2020, we find that the Learned Senior Civil Judge, Khallikote, after due discussion and deliberation, accepted the fact that the proposal for adoption was accepted on 04.07.2003 after observing the giving and taking ceremony as well as "Dutta Home" and since at the time of adoption, the applicant No.2 was about 5 years which fulfilled the criteria required u/s.10 of the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act, 1956. It was further observed that net down loaded residence certificate digitally signed by the Revenue Officer, Caste Certificate, HSC Certificate and HSC mark sheet, which were exhibited, undisputedly establishes that the husband of applicant No.1 executed some written documents regarding adoption of Applicant No. 2 as he was issueless. The findings so recorded by the competent court of law, stated above, in Civil Suit No. 66/2020, are all unimpeachable evidence in law and, thus, is acceptable by the Tribunal&&= (4) Is Adoption Deed compulsorily registrable ? (i) There is another aspect to the matter: the claim of OP No.2 for compassionate appointment is negatived by the petitioners inter alia on the ground that the registered adoption deed is dated 08.02.2010 and therefore said adoption being post-demise of the employee, the conditions of Policy Circular render candidature of OP No.2 ineligible. Neither in Section 17(1) of the Registration Act,…
12. Effects of adoption.5An adopted child shall be deemed to be the child of his or her adoptive father or mother for all purposes with effect from the date of the adoption and from such date all the ties of the child in the family of his or her birth shall be deemed to be severed and replaced by those created by the adoption in the adoptive family: Provided that5 (a) the child cannot marry any person whom he or she could not have married if he or she had continued in the family of his or her birth; (b) any property which vested in the adopted child before the adoption shall continue to vest in such person subject to the obligations, if any, attaching to the ownership of such property, including the obligation to maintain relatives in the family of his or her birth; (c) the adopted child shall not divest any person of any estate which vested in him or her before the adoption.= (iii) The above provision deals with the effect of valid adoption. Mayne9s Hindu Law & Usage, 16th Edition Bharat Law House, New Delhi at Page 602 has succinctly stated the effect of adoption in terms of Section 12 of the 1956 Act as under: <&This section deals with the effects of a valid adoption. The main effect of an adoption is to transplant the child adopted from the family of his birth to the adoptive family. As from the date of adoption the child will be considered to be the natural child of the adopti…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) NO.36932 OF 2025
In the matter of an application under Articles 226 & 227 of the
Constitution of India, 1950.
-------------&.
Union of India and others
Petitioners
-versus&.
K. Manoj Patra and others
Opposite Parties
Advocates Appeared in this case
For Petitioners
-
For Opp. Parties -
Mr. R.K. Kanungo, Sr. Panel Counsel
M/s. D.K. Mohanty, S. Nayak, B.N.
Behera & S. Das, Advocates
-----------
CORAM
HON9BLE MR. JUSTICE DIXIT KRISHNA SHRIPAD
HON9BLE MR. JUSTICE SIBO SANKAR MISHRA
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Hearing & Judgment : 06.01.2026
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------PER KRISHNA S. DIXIT,J.
Central Government and South Eastern Railway are knocking at
the doors of Writ Court for assailing the order dated 29.01.2025 made
by the Central Administrative Tribunal at Cuttack (Annexure-1),
whereby OA No. 260/00256 of 2022 filed by OPs has been favoured.
The Tribunal has quashed the order dated 14.12.2021, by which the
claim for compassionate appointment was negative, and further it has
directed to consider the claim afresh, within an outer limit of sixty days.
II.
The brief facts of the case are as under:
(a)
One Mr. Late K. Sadhu Patra was working as Ex-Technician
(C&W) in the Railway Department. He died in harness on 02.04.2008.
OP No.2 being an adopted son had staked his claim for appointment on
compassionate ground. The same having been turned down, vide order
14.12.2021, he along with his mother, who is OP No.1 herein, had
approached the Tribunal through the subject OA, that was resisted by
the Petitioners by filing the Statement of Objections.
(b)
The OA was resisted essentially on the ground that there was no
adoption; even otherwise, the alleged adoption deed was executed on
08.02.2010 after the death of employee; in support of this Petitioners
had pressed into service Railway Board9s Policy vide RBE
No.106/1988, Railway Board9s Letter No.E(NG)II/86/RC-1/1 dated
20.05.1988; the alleged adoption was not made with the consent of
Railways, as required by the Policy Circulars; lastly, the decree obtained
in adoption case in Civil Suit No.1 of 2012 does not bind the Railways.
This contention having been rejected, the Tribunal handed the impugned
order, which is put in challenge at our hands.
Learned counsel
appearing for the OPs resists the petition making submission in
justification of the impugned order and the reasons on which it has been
constructed.
III.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and having perused
the petition papers, this Court declines indulgence in the matter for the
following reasons:
(1)
As to what is not in dispute:
There is no dispute about the employee dying in harness on
02.04.2008. There is no dispute that OP No.1-Smt. K. Subhadra Patra is
the widow of said employee. The essential dispute is whether OP No.2
is the adoptive son of the couple. This question of fact need not detain
the Court for long, there being a judgment & decree obtained by OPs in
C.S. No.1 of 2012, decreed on 27.02.2013 to the effect that OP No.2 is
the adoptive son. It is apparent from the said judgment & decree that
the rival claimants were parties to the suit, and that the judgment has
attained finality, there being no further challenge thereto.
(2)
As to judgment in rem vis a vis judgment in personum.
(i)
The contention of learned Senior Panel Counsel appearing for the
Petitioners that the said judgment & decree, being in personum as
against in rem, do not bind his clients, is attractively true. Section 41 of
the erstwhile Indian Evidence Act, 1872 speaks of binding nature of
judgments in rem. Such judgments are rendered only in four
jurisdictions, namely, Matrimonial, Insolvency, Probate & Admiralty.
These judgments bind every one whether party eo nomine or not. To put
in differently a kind of res judicata applies de hors Section 11 of CPC
1908, which broadly incorporates the said doctrine. Apparently, the
judgment secured by OPs in the subject suit has not been rendered in
one of these jurisdictions and therefore, the same being not a judgment
in rem, would not bind the Petitioners, who were not parties to the same.
(ii)
The above being said, we hasten to clarify that the binding nature
of a judgment is one thing and its evidentiary value, is another. Section
43 of the 1872 Act broadly deals with this aspect of the matter. In the
Law of Evidence by Sir John Woodroffe & Syed Amir Ali 15 th Edn1991, Vol.-2 at pages 352 & 353 it is observed as under:
<Though judgments, other than those mentioned in Secs. 40-42, are
relevant qua judgments, this section does not make them absolutely
inadmissible when they are the best evidence of something that may be
proved aliunde. The existence of such judgments maybe a fact in issue,
or it may be a relevant fact, otherwise than in its character of a
judgment.
Where a judgment is admissible, it is <conclusive evidence for or
against all persons, whether parties, privies or strangers, of its own
existence, date and legal effect as distinguished from the accuracy of
the decision rendered.= With regard to the existence of the judgment, its
date or its legal consequences, the production of record or of a certified
copy is conclusive evidence of the facts against all the world, the reason
being that a judgment, as a public transaction of a solemn nature, must
be presumed to be faithfully recorded.=
The law is well settled that a judgment in personum although does not
bind non-parties, can be a piece of evidence that would throw light on
the matter in debate. What evidentiary weight needs to be attached to
such a judgment, is a matter of judicial prudence.
(3)
As to adoption of OP No.2.
(i)
A perusal of the judgment & decree, copies whereof were part of
the record before the Tribunal, would show that OP No.2 was adopted
by the deceased employee and his wife-OP No.1 on 04.07.2003. The
question of Petitioners being made parties to the case in C.S. No.1 of
2012 would not arise, inasmuch as they were was neither necessary
parties nor proper parties in the light of Apex Court decision in Razia
Begum v. Sahebzadi Anwar Begum1. Had they been parties to the said
suit, they would have been bound by the decree, hardly needs to be
stated. As already mentioned, the judgment is only evidentiary of the
factum of adoption. In any event, it excludes claim of the defendants for
appointment on compassionate ground.
(ii)
As to essentials of adoption:
. AIR 1958 SC 886.
Adoption is a matter of personal law applicable to Hindus.
Mulla9s Hindu Law, 21st Edition, paragraph 445, page 660 discusses
about the requirement of valid adoption. The same is as under:
<445. Requirements of a valid adoption.- No adoption is valid unless:
(1) the person adopting is lawfully capable of taking in adoption;
(2) the person giving in adoption is lawfully capable of giving in
adoption;
(3) the person adopted is lawfully capable of being taken in adoption;
(4) the adoption is completed by an actual giving and taking;
(5) the ceremony called datta homam (oblation to fire) has been
performed. It is however, doubtful, whether the datta homam ceremony
is essential is all cases for the validity of adoption.=
The contents of judgment in the subject suit demonstrate that these
requisites have been complied with and the event of adoption was
accomplished way back on 04.07.2003.
(iii)
As to significance of Adoption Deed of Feb. 2010
Learned Senior Panel Counsel appearing for the petitioners
vehemently contends that, the adoption deed having been registered on
08.02.2010 i.e. after the demise of employee on 02.04.2008, the claim of
OP No.2 for compassionate appointment does not fit into the parameters
of Railway Board policy which requires the accomplishment of adoption
before the death of employee. This is difficult to agree with and reasons
for the same are not far to seek: firstly, a valid adoption comes into
existence once the rites & rituals obtaining the community are
performed. The requisites of adoption as stated by Mulla9s Hindu Law
supra are complied with, the Adoptee becomes the son/daughter of
Adopters. The Adoption Deed is registered long after the demise of
employee concerned, is not much relevant to validity of adoption. It
needs no mentioning that performance of prescribed rites is constitutive
of adoption and subsequent execution & registration of Deed of
Adoption is only evidentiary. In other words, the subject Deed only
records the event of adoption.
This subtle difference between
accomplishment of adoption and the subsequent execution of document
of adoption cannot be ignored, be it under the shaastrik process or under
the provisions of the Hindu Adoption & Maintenance Act, 1956, more
particularly when there is a civil court judgment.
(iv)
It is relevant to see the observation of Tribunal made in Para-5 of
the impugned order which treat the subsequent suit proceeding in which
the issue of adoption has been decided:
<5. We have gone through the provision made in RBE No.
106/1988 circulated as SER Estt. Srl.No.141/1988 providing
that adopted sons/adopted daughters can only be eligible for
appointment on compassionate ground if the adoption process
has been completed and has become valid before the date of
death of the employee. On examination of the order dated
31.08.2021 in Civil Suit No. 66/2020, we find that the Learned
Senior Civil Judge, Khallikote, after due discussion and
deliberation, accepted the fact that the proposal for adoption
was accepted on 04.07.2003 after observing the giving and
taking ceremony as well as "Dutta Home" and since at the time
of adoption, the applicant No.2 was about 5 years which
fulfilled the criteria required u/s.10 of the Hindu Adoption and
Maintenance Act, 1956. It was further observed that net down
loaded residence certificate digitally signed by the Revenue
Officer, Caste Certificate, HSC Certificate and HSC mark sheet,
which were exhibited, undisputedly establishes that the husband
of applicant No.1 executed some written documents regarding
adoption of Applicant No. 2 as he was issueless. The findings so
recorded by the competent court of law, stated above, in Civil
Suit No. 66/2020, are all unimpeachable evidence in law and,
thus, is acceptable by the Tribunal&&=
(4)
Is Adoption Deed compulsorily registrable ?
(i)
There is another aspect to the matter: the claim of OP No.2 for
compassionate appointment is negatived by the petitioners inter alia on
the ground that the registered adoption deed is dated 08.02.2010 and
therefore said adoption being post-demise of the employee, the
conditions of Policy Circular render candidature of OP No.2 ineligible.
Neither in Section 17(1) of the Registration Act, 1908 nor under the
provisions of 1956 Act, we are shown that the registration of the
Adoption Deed is a sine qua non for validity of adoption. In other
words, once the requisites of valid adoption, as discussed by Mulla9s
Hindu Law supra, are met, adoption takes effect, regardless of
registration. Similar view is taken by Punjab & Haryana High Court in
Union of India v. Sukhpreet Kaur2 and by the Karnataka High Court in
N.L. Manjunatha v. B.L. Ananda3. To put it succinctly, registration is
2025:PHHC:020462-DB
2023:KHC:23875
optional. However, Section 16 of 1956 Act raises a presumption of
validity a registered Adoption Deed, if conditions stipulated therein are
satisfied. In the case at hand, those conditions are not satisfied,
inasmuch as adoptive father, namely, the employee was dead & gone
when the document was presented for registration.
(ii)
The Allahabad High Court in Shanu Kumar v. The Nagar Ayukt
Municipal (Commissioner) Nagar Nigam Lko4, has held that
Administrative Officer cannot question validity of registered adoption
deed for rejecting compassionate appointment. The Apex Court vide
Chandrasekhara Mudaliar v. Kulnadaivelu Mudaliar5, in line with the
decisions of Privy Council has expressed the view that the validity of
adoption is to be determined by spiritual rather than temporal
considerations, devolution of property being only of secondary
importance. Mulla9s Hindu Law supra at paragraph 444 states:
<The objects of adoption are twofold: the first is religious,
to secure spiritual benefit to the adopter and his ancestors
by having a son for the purpose of offering funeral cakes
and libations of waters to the soul of the adopter and his
ancestors. The second is secular, to secure an heir and
perpetuate the adopter9s name.
(iii)
As to the burden of proof of adoption:
. 2025 : AHC-LKO: 77122.
. AIR 1963 SC 185.
The above being said, it needs to be clarified that subject to the
presumption of validity of registered Adoption Deed enacted in Section
16 of the 1956 Act, the burden of proof of adoption lies on the person
who asserts it, and that obviously it is a heavy burden, inasmuch as
adoption has serious implications & consequences qua the adoptive
parents, natural parents & the adoptive child in terms of family status
and proprietorial interest, which aspect is discussed herein below. In the
case at hand, the burden is duly discharged by the OPs by producing the
judgments & decrees in two suits, which discussed & decided the factum
& legality of adoption.
The authorities treating the claim for
compassionate appointment of adoptive children, have to exercise due
diligence & seriousness, lest fake claims should be favoured, to the
prejudice of public employment and to the interest of deserving
candidates.
(5)
As to the consequences of valid adoption:
(i)
Ordinarily, a strong belief obtains amongst Hindus,
O(,Nk Q
(
.S
N(a .Sd N3Y(a ,4e literally meaning that for a sonless
person there is no heaven/salvation/destination; therefore, man should
have a son. This is how the institution of adoption is developed by the
ancient smrutikaraas. The Privy Council in Bal Gangadhar Tilak v.
Sriniwas Pandit6, observed under the Hindu law, adoption has the effect of
transferring the boy from the family of his birth to that of his adoption, and he
becomes, for all legal purposes, the son of his adoptive father. *
.T:n >
],
O( m > : *
.S
O.]e
O.(S e .S] 1:O( +2k(e m literally means
that in the case of a son who is given in adoption, the former
relationship with his natural parents is extinguished, and he becomes, in
law, the son of the adoptive father. In Kishori Lal v. Chaltibai,7 the
Apex Court observed that the effect of adoption is to sever the child
adopted from the natural family and to graft him into the adoptive
family for all purposes, including succession & inheritance. Of course,
right to public employment does not have proprietary character, is also
true.
(ii)
Substantial alterations and modifications in the shaastrik law
relating to adoption have been brought about by the legislative process.
The Parliament has enacted the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act,
1956, which has the overriding application. Adoptions made after the
commencement of this Act must be in accordance with the provisions
thereof. Any adoption done in violation of the provisions of this Act is a
. (1915) 42 IA 135 PC.
. AIR 1959 SC 504.
nullity and therefore would not bring into existence the sonship/
daughtership. Section 12 of the Act has the following text:
12.Effects of adoption.5An adopted child shall be deemed to be
the child of his or her adoptive father or mother for all purposes
with effect from the date of the adoption and from such date all
the ties of the child in the family of his or her birth shall be
deemed to be severed and replaced by those created by the
adoption in the adoptive family:
Provided that5
(a) the child cannot marry any person whom he or she could not
have married if he or she had continued in the family of his or
her birth;
(b) any property which vested in the adopted child before the
adoption shall continue to vest in such person subject to the
obligations, if any, attaching to the ownership of such property,
including the obligation to maintain relatives in the family of his
or her birth;
(c) the adopted child shall not divest any person of any estate
which vested in him or her before the adoption.=
(iii)
The above provision deals with the effect of valid adoption.
Mayne9s Hindu Law & Usage, 16th Edition Bharat Law House, New
Delhi at Page 602 has succinctly stated the effect of adoption in terms of
Section 12 of the 1956 Act as under:
<&This section deals with the effects of a valid adoption. The
main effect of an adoption is to transplant the child adopted
from the family of his birth to the adoptive family. As from the
date of adoption the child will be considered to be the natural
child of the adoptive family and all the ties with the original
family are severed. However, this section is subject to three
exceptions: (1) that the adopted child cannot marry any person
whom he could not have married had he continued in the
original family; (2) that the adopted child is not deprived of the
estate vested in him or her prior to his adoption when he lived
in his natural family subject to any obligations arising from
such vesting of the estate, (3) that the adopted child shall not
divest any persons in the adoptive family of any estate vested in
that person prior to the date of adoption. The main object of the
present section is to modify the old Hindu law which considered
doctrine of 'relation back'. The Act does away with the theory of
relation back and confers on the child adopted a status
equivalent to that of a natural born child in the adoptive family
only from the date of adoption. The expression "effects of
adoption" refers to all the legal consequences flowing from an
adoption.=
The aforementioned view broadly gains support from Daniraiji v.
Chandraprabha8. It is also relevant to mention Clause 57 of Section 3
of the General Clauses Act, 1897, that reads as under:
<&son, in the case of any one whose personal law permits
adoption, shall include an adopted son;=
We hasten to add that in the domain of public employment, it is open to
the employer to regulate the terms & conditions of appointment on
compassionate grounds. The subject Policy Circular promulgated by the
Railway Department does this, cannot be disputed. If the stipulation in
the Circular is complied with, there is no justification whatsoever for
denying rehabilitatory appointment, when breadwinner of the family dies
in harness, as has happened in the case at hand. The Tribunal has
structured the impugned order with this inarticulate premise, some of it
being articulate to.
. AIR 1975 SC 784.
In the above circumstances, this petition being devoid of merits is
liable to be rejected and accordingly it is, costs having been made easy.
The impugned order of the Tribunal shall be given effect to within two
months reckoned from this day. Non-compliance shall be viewed very
seriously in the next level of legal battle.
Web copy of the judgment to be acted upon by all concerned.
(Dixit Krishna Shripad)
Judge
(S.S. Mishra)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack
The 6th day of January 2026/Anisha
Digitally Signed
Signed by: ANISHA NANDA
Designation: Jr. Stenographer
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC, Cuttack
Date: 08-Jan-2026 17:29:17
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review