Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.37617 of 2026
CNR No. ODHC010886202026
….
Srimanta Kumar Dash
Petitioner
Mr. Arun Kumar Patra, Advocate
-Versus….
State of Odisha and others
Opposite Parties
Ms. Biswabara Dash, ASC
CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MURAHARI SRI RAMAN
ORDER
12.11.2026
Order No.
01.
1.
Letter
No.OEC-POL-PM-0318-2025/9902/Ex.(Policy)
dated
12.12.2025 issued by the Excise Commissioner, Odisha and
Letter
No.2464/Ex.
Dated
16.12.2025
issued
by
the
Superintendent of Excise, Puri vide Annexure-3 series insisting
for installation of fire safety equipment and obtain Fire Safety
Certificate/Fire NOC from the competent authority under the
provisions of the Odisha Fire Prevention and Fire Safety Rules,
2017, being questioned as arbitrary and unconscionable, brought
the petitioner before this Court to assail the actions of the said
authorities by way of filing the present writ petition.
2.
The facts as adumbrated by the petitioner reveals that he was
granted license to run restaurant with lodging and IMFL ON
shop, which was renewed for the year 2026-27 till the year 202526. None of the authorities insisted for obtaining the Fire Safety
Certificate/Fire NOC from the competent authority but the same
is directed to be obtained by letters dated 16.12.2025 and
12.12.2025 as referred to supra.
3.
It is submitted by Mr. Arun Kumar Patra, learned Advocate that
provisions of Rules 9(1)(h)(i) and (ii) and Rule 11 of the Odisha
Fire Prevention and Fire Safety Rules, 2017, as amended by the
Odisha Fire Prevention and Fire Safety (Amendment) Rules,
2019, provide that business or office buildings having height of
12 meters and above; or having built up area of 500 square
metres or above are required to obtain Fire Safety Certificate/Fire
NOC.
4.
Drawing attention to “Existing Plan of Santana Bar & Restaurant
& IMFL & IMFL On Shop of Sri Shrimant Kumar Dash over
Revenue Plot Nos.13 & 14, Khata No.75, in the Revenue MouzaBalukhanda, Puri, Odisha”, it is contended that the business
premises of the petitioner does not fall within the specifications
contained in the above Rules. Therefore, it is argued by Sri Arun
Kumar Patra, learned Advocate that the amendment of Rule
51(2) by virtue of the Odisha Excise (Amendment) Rules, 2026
inserting “fire safety certificate from the competent authority” is
required to be read juxtaposed with Rules 9(1)(h)(i) and (ii) and
Rule 11 of the Odisha Fire Prevention and Fire Safety Rules,
2017, as amended by the Odisha Fire Prevention and Fire Safety
(Amendment) Rules, 2019.
4.1.
It is further arduously submitted that the requirement of Fire
Safety Certificate/NOC from the competent authority as amended
in Rule 51(2) of the Odisha Excise Rules, 2017, having came to
be inserted by Notification dated 17.07.2026 vide the Odisha
Excise (Amendment) Rules, 2026, with effect from 18.07.2026,
being published in the Extraordinary Issue No.3273, dated
18.07.2026, cannot have retrospective operation inasmuch as the
license under Rule 52 has been issued by the Department of
Excise for the period from 01.04.2026 to 31.03.2027 on
06.04.2026, i.e. prior to coming into force the said Amendment
Rules of 2026.
4.2.
In order to claim parity of consideration, the learned Advocate
relied on a decision of this Court rendered in the case of S.
Sanamakh Rao Vrs. State of Odisha and others, W.P.(C)
No.17811 of 2026 disposed of by order dated 27.07.2026 with the
following observation:
“1.
We are not unmindful of the reality, that in public places,
where there is conglomeration of large number of the
people happens, the fire safety measures and equipments
should be to avoid the loss of human life as well as the
property. There is not even an inkling of doubt in our mind
that the fire safety gadgets should be there in every such
places to combat the situation, when the fire broke out; but
equally, we cannot issue a writ of mandamus commanding
the authorities to do a thing not provided in the statute or
forbidden therein. In order to maintain the social order,
the safety and security of the citizenry, every responsible
persons of the society should bear in mind and take
adequate steps to install the safety gadgets at the time the
fire broke out, but the authorities have to proceed within
the precinct of law and cannot travel beyond it. The subject
matter of challenge in the instant Writ Petition is the
communication of an Excise Commissioner, Odisha to all
Excise Deputy Commissioner and the Superintendent of
Excise, to issue a necessary direction to all licensees of
IMFL ON shop units within their jurisdiction to obtain and
maintain a valid fire safety certificate/ NOC and submit a
consolidated district wide report to the Directorate on
priority basis. The Petitioner apprehends that, in the event
the certificate or NOC is not submitted, action would be
taken to close down the IMFL ON shop for which the
license has been granted, and approaches this Court with
the categorical assertion that neither the Excise
Department is competent to impose such conditions upon
the public and/or the license granted to the holder thereof,
nor do the Orissa Fire Prevention and Fire Safety Rules,
2017, contain any such provision. It is categorically stated
that the structure in which the IMFL ON shop is currently
operating is constructed in less than 500 square meter area
and is less than 12 meter in height. It is thus, contended
that Rule 9 as amended vide Odisha Fire Prevention and
Fire Safety (Amendment) Rules, 2019. Rule (9)(1) as
amended in 2019, keeps such premises outside the purview
of obtaining the license under Section 10 of the Orissa Fire
Service Act and Rule 11 of the said Rules.
2.
In order to complete the sequence of the events, it would be
pertinent to recapitulate the provisions contained under
Rule 11 of the said Rules, where all buildings, premises or
occupancies as specified in Rule 9, shall at all times have a
valid fire safety certificate as provided under Rule 13. It
also forbids all the owners, developers, promoters and
builders of a building or a premises, specified in Rule 9, to
sell lease, occupy or allow in occupation without first
obtaining the fire safety certificate, issued by the director
or any officer authorized by him in this regard. It also
contains a prohibitory clause in continuing with the
construction or occupation in the said building. Rule 9(1)
of the said Rule has undergone a significant change in the
year 2019 when the Odisha Fire Prevention and Fire
Safety (Amendment) Rules, 2019 was notified, which
engulfed within its folds the following categories or class
of the premises such as the following:
„(1)
for the purpose of sub-section (1) of Section 10 of
the Act, the following classes of premises or
occupancies are likely to have risk of fire, namely:
(a)
Aerodromes, airports and airstrips;
(b)
Cinema Halls and Multiplexes;
(c)
Explosives or fireworks or hazardous substances
(manufacturing, storage, transportation, display and
sale etc.);
(d)
Factories and Industries;
(e)
Depot of Petroleum and other inflammable
substances and refineries (Storing, handling,
refining, blending and retail outlets etc.);
(f)
All underground or partially underground structures
of five hundred square meters or above used for any
purpose or occupancy;
(g)
Places of Assembly like Auditoria, convention halls,
Assembly halls, recreation halls etc. having a built
up area of five hundred square meters and above on
any one or more floors where people congregate or
gather for amusement, recreation, social, religious
or any other similar purposes.
(h)
Business or office buildings—
(i)
having a height of twelve meters and above;
Or
(ii)
(i)
having a built up area of five hundred square
meters or above;
Clinical Establishments—
(i)
clinical establishments having height of
twelve meters and above or
(j)
(k)
(l)
(m)
(ii)
functioning in buildings having more than
three floors including all underground,
basement, stilt and mezzanine floors or,
(iii)
having more than thirty beds or,
(iv)
having any Critical Care Unit.
Educational Buildings—
(i)
having a height of twelve meters and above
or,
(ii)
having a built up area of one thousand square
meters or above; or
(iii)
having three storied building;
Hotels, Lodgings and Guest Houses—
(i)
having a height of twelve meters and above
or,
(ii)
having a built up area of five hundred square
meters or above,
(iii)
of three Star and above categories,
(iv)
having places of Assembly like Auditoria,
Convention Halls, Assembly Halls, Recreation
Halls etc. of built up area of five hundred
square meters and above on any one or more
floors where people congregate or gather for
amusement, recreation, social, religious and
similar other purposes;
Malls, shopping
buildings—
complexes
and
mercantile
(i)
having a height of nine meters and above or,
(ii)
having a built up area of five hundred square
meters or above,
Residential Buildings (other than hotels, lodgings
and guest houses), having a height of fifteen meters
and above;
(n)
Temporary structures of one thousand square
meters and above where the congregation is two
thousand or more;
(o)
Warehouses or Storage area of five hundred square
meters built up area or above;
(p)
Any other classes of buildings or premises notified
by the State Government from time to time.‟
(b) For sub-rule (12) the following shall be
substituted:
„(12)
3.
In case of existing buildings constructed
or occupied prior to commencement of the
Odisha Development Authority Act, 1982
on receipt of an application from the
owner of the building, without sacrificing
reasonable safety, the Director may grant
exemption from the conditions prescribed
under these rules.‟
Though the Petitioner has taken shelter under clause-h
thereof, which relates to business or office building, having
a height of 12 meters and over, but we also took notice of
clause (g) and (k), which has a remote connection with the
operation of the restaurant and thus, find that the
mandatory requirement of a certificate is either to the
premises having an height of 12 meters and above or
constructed beyond 500 square meters and above area.
Rule 11 as indicated herein above, thus, is applicable in
relation to the premises or a class of premises identified in
Rule 9(1) thereof and in the event, the same is contrived in
the area and/or a height, it puts such premises or a
building beyond the purview thereof. The authority cannot
compel a person to do a thing, not provided in law nor can
compel a person to meet the requisition if the situation
keeps the same outside the purview of the statutory
provision. We, thus, find that insisting upon a certificate to
be issued from the fire department or an NOC is
unwarranted and beyond the scope of the Excise Act and
the Rules framed thereunder. Even if we hold that it is
beyond the purview of the Act, yet the importance of
providing safety measures and keeping safety gadgets
within such building or the premises is a need of an hour
and should not be dispensed with.
4.
5.
A responsible citizen would always make endeavour to
keep those safety gadgets to avoid any incident of fire to
surge and we are informed by the learned Advocate for the
Petitioner that the fire extinguisher have already been
installed at different places and a regular monitoring
and/or refilling and/or replacement are being made from
the authorized agencies.”
Ms. Biswabara Dash, learned Additional Standing Counsel
opposing grant of relief as claimed by the petitioner submitted
that the competent authority is required to determine factually
whether the petitioner’s business premises falls within the
specifications contemplated with respect to height and/or built up
area under the provisions of the Odisha Fire Service Act, 1993
read with Odisha Fire Prevention and Fire Safety Rules, 2017, as
amended in the year 2019. Such factual dispute is not required to
be considered at this stage by the Writ Court.
6.
Heard Mr. Arun Kumar Patra, learned Advocate for the petitioner
and Ms. Biswabara Dash, learned Additional Standing Counsel
for the State.
7.
Having perused the order dated 27.07.2026 passed by this Court
in the case of S. Sanamakh Rao (supra) and the impugned letter
dated 12.12.2025 of Excise Commissioner, Odisha and dated
16.12.2025 of Superintendent of Excise, Puri, this Court feels it
appropriate to leave the factual finding for determination by the
authority concerned taking into consideration the plan of bar and
restaurant/shop being built up over Plot Nos.13 and 14 in Khata
No.75 in the Revenue Mouza: Balukhanda, which is furnished by
the petitioner enclosed with the writ petition. This Court,
therefore, directs the authority to make spot verification in the
presence of the petitioner and consider the documents as enclosed
with the writ petition at Annexure-2, which is furnished to
support the contention of the petitioner that the business or office
building having height of 12 meters and above is only required to
obtain Fire Safety Certificate from the competent authority. It is,
therefore, directed that the authority shall take appropriate
decision after taking into consideration the reply/explanation, if
any, furnished by the petitioner and on the basis of spot
verification report.
8.
With such observation, the wit petition stands disposed of.
(Harish Tandon)
Chief Justice
(Murahari Sri Raman)
Judge
Rabi
Digitally Signed
Signed by: RABINDRA KUMAR MISHRA
Designation: Personal Assistant
Reason: Authentication
Location: HIGH COURT OF ORISSA, CUTTACK
Date: 13-Nov-2026 12:20:54
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review