Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No.154/2026
Pronounced on: 31.01.2026
Uploaded on:03.02.2026
1.
2.
3.
4.
Union of India through its Secretary to Government of India,
Ministry of Defence, South Block, New Delhi-110011.
Additional Director General Personnel Services,
Adjutant General‟s Branch, Integrated HQ of Ministry of
Defence (Army), DHQ PO, New Delhi-110001
The Principal Controller of Defence Accounts (Pension).
Draupadi Ghat, Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh-211014
OIC Records, DOGRA Records, PIN-191202 C/o 56 APO
...Petitioners(s)
Through:- Mr. Vishal Sharma, DSGI with
Mr. Sumant Sudan, Advocate
Versus
No.3996090A Ex Hav Vinay Kumar S/o Shri Inder Ram
R/o village & Post Office: Saikalan, Tehsil: R.S.Pura, District: Jammu
(J&K)-181131.
...Respondent(s)
Through:- Mr. B.S.Sarmal, Advocate with
Mr. Ami Singh, Advocate
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
Sanjeev Kumar “J”
1.
JUDGMENT
By this writ petition, filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, Union of India and others throw challenge to an
order and judgment dated 22nd May, 2023 passed by the Armed Forces
Tribunal, Regional Bench Srinagar at Jammu [“AFT”] in OA No.161
of 2022 titled Ex Hav Vinay Kumar v. Union of India and others,
WP(C) No.154/2026
whereby the AFT has allowed the OA filed by the respondent and set
aside the impugned order in the OA, whereby the respondent‟s claim of
disability pension was rejected. The respondent has been held entitled
to disability pension @ 50% for life as against 40%. Strong reliance
has been placed by the AFT on Dhahramvir Singh v. Union of India,
(2013) 7 SCC 316 and Union of India v. Ram Avtar, 2014 SCC
OnLine SC 1761.
2.
The impugned judgment of the AFT is assailed by the petitioners
on the ground that the AFT has failed to consider that the disability of
the respondent had been assessed by the Release Medical Board as
neither attributable to nor aggravated by military service. The AFT also
did not appreciate that the opinion of the Medical Board consisting of
experts was not amenable to judicial review by the Court unless there
was strong medical evidence on record to dispute such opinion.
3.
Having heard learned counsel for the petitioners and perused the
material on record, we are of the considered opinion that the judgment
passed by the AFT is perfectly legal and does not call for any
interference by us in the exercise of our extraordinary writ jurisdiction.
4.
The facts, which are not in dispute are that the respondent was
enrolled in Indian Army on 01.03.1996 in a fit state of health and
discharged on 31.03.2021 in low medical category. Before discharge,
the respondent was brought before a duly constituted Release Medical
Board, which assessed the disability incurred by the respondent
WP(C) No.154/2026
“Primary Hypertension (I-10 (TOD PRESENT)” @ 40% for life and
regarded the same as neither attributable to nor aggravated by military
service. Respondent‟s claim for grant of disability pension was,
accordingly, rejected by the petitioners. The first appeal preferred by
the respondent, too, came to be rejected vide letter dated 24.07.2021.
The second appeal preferred by the respondent on 01.12.2021 was also
of no avail.
5.
Feeling aggrieved, the respondent filed OA No. 161 of 2022
before the AFT seeking inter alia a direction to the petitioners herein to
grant the disability element of disability pension w.e.f. 01.04.2021 @
50%. The OA was contested by the petitioners herein and in the reply
affidavit filed, the stand taken was that the invaliding disease in the
case of the respondent was neither attributable to nor aggravated by
military service, hence he was not entitled to disability pension. It was
submitted that the opinion of the Medical Board, being an expert body,
was accepted and must be respected by the courts as well.
6.
The AFT having considered the OA in the light of rival
contentions of the parties and having regard to the legal and factual
position obtaining in the matter, held the respondent entitled to
disability pension @ 40% with the benefit of rounding off to 50% for
life. It is in these circumstances, the OA filed by the respondent came
to be allowed.
WP(C) No.154/2026
7.
This Court in a batch of writ petitions [WP(C) No. 3173/2023
a/w connected matters decided on 03.11.2025], has considered the
issue with respect to the grant of disability pension to persons
discharged/invalided out of service from armed forces and after
considering the relevant rules, regulations and legal positions obtaining
on the issue, culled out following principles:i) The grant of disability pension to the army personnel is not a
charity or an act of generosity but a true act of acknowledge of
the sacrifices made by them during their service, which manifest
in the form of diseases and disabilities. The Pension Regulations
and the Entitlement Rules framed by the Government of India for
providing financial benefits to the soldiers and military
personnel, who encounter diseases and disabilities which are
attributable to or aggravated by military service are meant to
provide absolute undiluted protection and recompense for the
injury that leads to loss of service and leaves such soldiers
without any effective means of sustenance. The Pension
Regulations and the Entitlement Rules being in the realm of
welfare measures must receive liberal interpretation and in case
of any doubt or ambiguity, the interpretation must tilt in favour of
the claimant/pensioner.
ii) The nature and extent of disability or cause of death falls within
the domain of medical experts and, therefore, the opinion of the
medical board with regard to nature and extent of disease or
disability should ordinarily be accepted as final, unless there is
strong medical evidence on record to dispute such opinion. And
even in such cases, the judicial review would be limited to the
extent of directing the army authorities to consider review
medical board for examination of the claimant.
iii) That since the entitlement of a member of the force to disability
pension depends largely on the opinion of the medical board, as
such, it is obligatory on the medical boards to record clear and
cogent reasons in support of their medical opinion. Absent such
WP(C) No.154/2026
clear and cogent reasons in support of the medical opinion, it
shall be presumed that the disease that afflicted the soldier
during service was due to army service.
iv) Under the 1982 Entitlement Rules, there was a presumption in
favour of the claimant that he was in sound physical and mental
condition when he joined the service except to a specific
disability noted or recorded at the time of entrance into service.
In the event of his subsequently being discharged from service on
medical grounds, any deterioration of his health which has taken
place, is due to service (Rule-5).
v)
A disease which has led to an individual’s discharge or death
shall ordinarily be deemed to have been arisen in service, if no
note of it has been made at the time of individual’s acceptance in
military service. This is, however, subject to medical opinion
holding, for reasons to be stated, that the disease was such as
could not have been detected on medical examination prior to
acceptance
for
service.
Even
if,
in
the
circumstances
aforementioned, disease is accepted as having arisen in service,
the army authorities must establish that conditions of military
service determined or contributed to the onset of the disease and
that the conditions were due to circumstances of duty in military
service. The onus of proof is not on the claimant and it is for the
employer to demonstrate the conditions for non-entitlement of the
claimant, for, there is a presumption in favour of the army
personnel, who entered in service while being in fit physical and
mental conditions and suffered from disease or disablement
during service. This was the position precisely in the 1982
Entitlement Rules. However, in 2008 Entitlement Rules, there is
no such presumption, yet the onus of proof is still on the employer
to establish the disentitlement of the soldier to the benefit of
disability pension on the prescribed grounds. It is only where
claim for disability pension is lodged after 15 years, the initial
onus will shift to the claimant.
vi) That notwithstanding the removal of presumption of entitlement
envisaged in the 1982 Entitlement Rules, the legal position has
not undergone any substantial change. An army personnel, who
is accepted in army service after proper physical and mental
examination shall be deemed to possess sound physical and
WP(C) No.154/2026
mental condition. The Army would not accept an individual, who
is not mentally and physically fit for army service. Though, as is
now provided under the 2008 Entitlement Rules, the examination
at the time of entering into service shall be of general nature and
would not be exhaustive to find out latent and hidden hereditary,
constitutional or congenital diseases, yet any onset of such
disease during service has to be certified to be so by the medical
authorities supported by clear and cogent medical reasons.
vii) In terms of Rule 15 of 1982 Entitlement Rules, if onset and
progress of a disease is affected by environmental factors
relating to service conditions, dietic compulsion, exposure to
noise, physical and mental stress and strain or is due to infection
arisen in service, such disease would merit entitlement of
attributability. The possibility of pre-service history of such
condition as may be certified by the medical authorities may rule
out entitlement of attributability but would require consideration
regarding aggravation. Annexure-III to the 1982 Entitlement
Rules classifies the diseases which are affected by environmental
factors in service and would serve as guide to find as to whether
a particular disease or disability is attributed to or aggravated by
army service.
viii) However, the cases post 2008 Regulations and governed by 2008
Entitlement Rules would leave the attributability or aggravation
to be determined by the medical authorities. The disease would
be accepted as attributable to military service, if it has arisen
during the period of military service and has been caused by the
conditions of employment in military service. The diseases due to
infection arisen during service, other than sexually transmitted
diseases, shall be deemed to be attributable to military service. In
the case of diseases where their cause is not known, there shall
be presumption of entitlement in favour of the claimant that it is
also attributable to military service unless such presumption is
rebutted on the basis of clinical picture and current scientific
medical application.
ix) A disability shall be considered aggravated by service conditions,
if its onset is hastened or the subsequent course is worsened by
specific conditions of military service, such as posted in places of
extreme climatic conditions, environmental factors related to
WP(C) No.154/2026
service conditions e.g. Fields, Operations, High Altitudes etc.
This again would be subject to clear and cogent medical opinion
by the competent medical authority.
x) A disease or disability shall not be held attributable to or
aggravated by military service unless a causal connection
between the disability or death and military service has been
established by appropriate authority.
xi) That the Guide to Medical Officers (Military Pension), 1980 as
amended from time to time shall be kept in mind by the medical
boards and the authorities concerned to determine as to whether
disability or death is due to military service i.e. either
attributable to or aggravated by military service.
xii) The amendments to Chapter-VI to Guide to Medical Officer
(Military Pensions), 2008 analyze different type of diseases and
lay down guidelines to determine whether a particular disease is
attributable to or could be aggravated by military service.
Diseases like, hypertension, diabetic mellitus, Ischaemic Heart
Disease (IHD) etc etc. find mention in paragraph 43, 26 and 47
of the GMO, 2008 and serve as broad guide to determine
attributability or aggravation aspects.
xiii)Burden to disprove the acceptance of causal connection between
disability and the military service is on the authorities and the
same cannot be said to have been discharged by any inchoate,
casual, perfunctory or vague approach of the authorities.
This underlines the profound significance of the requirement
of recording reasons by the medical board(s).
xiv) That so long as it is established that the disability or death bears
causal connection with the service condition, it is immaterial
whether the cause giving rise to the disability or death occurred
in an area declared to be a field service/active service area or
under normal peace condition (Regulation 423 of the Regulations
for Medical Services to Armed Forces, 2010).
8.
In view of the aforesaid legal position, the only question that
needs determination in this case is whether opinion of the medical
board, which assessed the disability incurred by the respondent as
WP(C) No.154/2026
neither attributable to nor aggravated by military service can be relied
upon to justify the disentitlement of the army personnel to the disability
element of pension in respect of his military service.
9.
Before we proceed further, it needs to be taken note of that
respondent-Vinay Kumar having been discharged for disablement in
the year 2021 is covered by 2008 Regulations read with 2008,
Entitlement Rules. As provided in Rule 1(b) of 2008, Entitlement
Rules, the Guide to Medical Officers (Military Pension), 2008, as
amended from time to time, is required to be read with the said Rules.
10.
Para 43 of GMO 2008 is relevant for determination in this case,
which for facility of reference is reproduced hereunder:
“43. Hypertension - The first consideration should be to determine
whether the· hypertension is primary or secondary. If secondary,
entitlement considerations should be directed to the underlying disease
process (e.g. Nephritis), and it is unnecessary to notify hypertension
separately.
As in the case of atherosclerosis, entitlement of attributability is
never appropriate, but where disablement for essential hypertension
appears to have arisen or become worse in service, the question
whether service compulsions have caused aggravation must be
considered. However, in certain cases the disease has been reported
after long and frequent spells of service in field/HAA/active operational
area. Such cases can be explained by variable response exhibited by
different individuals to stressful situations. Primary hypertension will
be considered aggravated if it occurs while serving in Field areas,
HAA, CIOPS areas or prolonged afloat service.”
11.
It is not in dispute that when the respondent was accepted in
army service, he was found physically and mentally fit by the
authorities and, therefore, the disease hypertension, which he was
found suffering from at the time of his discharge from army service,
occurred during service. To disentitle the respondent from claiming the
disability pension, the petitioners are required to plead and demonstrate
WP(C) No.154/2026
that the disability „hypertension‟, which led to discharge of the
respondent, though arisen during army service, was neither attributable
to nor aggravated by army service. The burden to prove absence of
causal connection between the disability and the army service was also
on the petitioners.
12.
With a view to determining as to whether the petitioners have
successfully discharged the burden and have by clear, unambiguous
and
cogent
medical
evidence established
that the disability
„hypertension‟, which led to the invalidation of the respondent from
military service is neither attributable to nor aggravated by army
service, we have gone through the medical record, which is part of the
paper-book. The relevant portion whereof is set out below:“As per posting profile Indl was posted in Hasimara (WB) wef 20 Sep
2018 to 20 August 2020 and as per spl opinion dated 24 May 2019
onset of dis was in HAA during 1st stage of HAA induction. When Indl
was on temp duty to Dokla Sikkim wef 24 Feb 19 to 28 Mar 2019.
Hypertension has long incubation period and short stay in HAA has no
causal factor related to service condition. Hence, the disability is
conceded NANA by mil service vide Para 43 of Chapter VI of GMO
2008.”
13.
From the reading of the above, it transpires beyond any shadow
of doubt that given the medical opinion on record, it cannot be said that
the petitioners have succeeded in discharging the burden to prove
disentitlement on the ground of absence of causal connection between
the disability and the army service. According to the Medical Board,
the onset of the disease was in HAA during 1 st stage of HAA.
Induction. Therefore, one line opinion of the medical board that the
disability was neither attributable to nor aggravated by army service is
WP(C) No.154/2026
not a substitute for clear, unambiguous and cogent medical reason to
disentitle the respondent from disability pension.
14.
GMO, 2008 and in particular para 43 mandates that the medical
authority must opine that the „hypertension‟ that has arisen during
service career became worse in service or not. The medical authority
must answer the question whether the service compulsions have caused
aggravation or not. Furthermore, the medical authority must consider
the entire service career of the individual to find out as to whether any
long or frequent spells of service in field/HAA/active operational area
have
created
stressful
situations,
thus,
aggravating
primary
hypertension. The medical opinion sans such reasons and, therefore,
the benefit of ambiguity in medical opinion has to be given to the
respondent. Even, as per the personal statement recorded in the medical
board proceedings, the onset of the disability occurred while the
respondent was serving in HAA, which denotes High Altitude Area,
which, as per Para 43 of GMO 2008, is to be considered as aggravated
by military service.
15.
For all these reasons, we find no illegality or infirmity in the
judgment passed by the AFT. The writ petition is, therefore, found
devoid of any merit, the same is, accordingly, dismissed.
(Sanjay Parihar)
Judge
(Sanjeev Kumar)
Judge
JAMMU
31.01.2026
Vinod
Vinod Kumar
2026.02.03 12:28
I am the author of this
document
Whether the order is speaking : Yes/No
Whether the order is reportable: Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review