Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP (C) No. 1325/2025
CM No. 3136/2025
Reserved on: 09.02.2026
Pronounced on:
02.2026
Uploaded on:
02.2026
1. Union of India through its
Secretary to Government of
India, Ministry of Defence,
South Block, New Delhi-110011
2. Additional Director General
Personnel Services, Adjutant
General’s Branch, Integrated
HQ of Ministry of Defence
(army), DHQ PO, New Delhi110001
3. Principal Controller of Defence
Accounts (Pensions), Draupadi
Ghat,
Allahabad,
Uttar
Pradesh-211014
4. OIC Records, JAK LI Records,
PIN-911097, C/o 56 APO
Through:-
…. Petitioner/Appellant(s)
Mr. Sachin Sharma, Advocate
V/s
1. No. 9103808YEx. Lance Naik
Sohan Lal, S/o Chhla Ram, R/o
Village and Post Office: Baran,
District: Jammu-181122
…..Respondent(s)
Through:-
Mrs. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
JUDGEMENT
Sanjeev Kumar J
1.
This petition, by the Union of India and three others filed under Article
226 of the Constitution of India, seeks to challenge an order and
WP(C) No. 1325/2025_______
judgment dated 23.02.2023 passed by the Armed Forces Tribunal,
Regional Bench, Srinagar at Jammu, [“AFT”] in OA No. 266/2022
titled “Sohan Lal Vs. Union of India and others,” whereby the Tribunal
has allowed the OA filed by the respondent and has held him entitled to
get disability element for the third disability i.e., “IMPAIRED
GLUCOSE TOLERANCE” @ 20% for life and, thus, the composite
assessment of all three disabilities @ 50% for life to be rounded off to
75% for life. The Tribunal has restricted the arrears to a period of three
years preceding the date of filing of the OA.
2.
The impugned judgment of the Tribunal is challenged by the petitioners
primarily on the ground that the AFT has failed to consider that the
disability of the respondent, Impaired Glucose Tolerance, though was
assessed as aggravated by military service by the duly constituted
Release Medical Board, yet the said disability stood assessed at 15-19%
which was less than the admissible 20% required for qualifying for
disability pension.
3.
The reliance placed by the AFT on the judgment of Hon‟ble Supreme
Court in case titled “Sukhwinder Singh Vs. Union of India” (2014)
STPL (WEB) 468 SC has been seriously disputed on the ground that
aforesaid judgment was rendered by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court as per
the Entitlement Rules of 1982.
4.
Per Contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent would support
the judgment of the Tribunal and submit that the AFT has taken note of
the relevant rules and has rightly concluded that the composite disability
suffered by the respondent was 50% and, therefore, required to be
rounded off to 75%.
WP(C) No. 1325/2025_______
5.
He would argue that the AFT has rightly placed reliance upon the
judgment of Sukhwinder Singh (supra), for, the regular tenure of the
respondent was cut-short because of the disability and, therefore, he shall
be deemed to have suffered the disability to the extent of minimum of
20%.
6.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material on
record, we are of the considered opinion that the judgment passed by the
Tribunal falls within four corners of law and, therefore, does not call for
interference by us in these proceeding. The undisputed facts leading to
the filing of this petition are that the respondent was enrolled in Indian
Army on 07.04.1999 and discharged from service on 31.10.2014 after
rendering 15 years, 06 months and 25 days of qualifying service. During
the course of his service the respondent suffered from (i) Retinal
Vasculitis Left Eye (OPD), (ii) Primary Hypertension, and (iii) Impaired
Glucose Tolerance, in the months of January 2023, March 2013 and
March 2014 respectively. He was thus downgraded to low medical
category. Because of the disabilities suffered, the respondent was
brought before the Invaliding Medical Board, which examined him on
28.06.2014. The Invaliding Medical Board assessed the disabilities of the
respondent in the following manner:
(i)
Retinal Vasculitis left
Eye (OPD)
20% for life and considered attributable
to military service
(ii)
Primary Hypertension
(iii)
Impaired Glucose
Tolerance
30% for life and considered aggravated
by military service.
15-19% for life and considered
aggravated by military service.
WP(C) No. 1325/2025_______
7.
The composite disability was assessed by the Invaliding Medical Board
@ 40% for life. Regard being had to the assessment of the Invaliding
Medical Board, the petitioners herein was held entitled to disability
pension by taking his disability @ 40% for life, rounded off to 50%. The
respondent was, thus, granted disability element for the disabilities: (i)
Retinal Vaculitis Left Eye (OPD) and (ii) Primary Hypertension, @ 40%
rounded off to 50% for life. The third disability i.e., Impaired Glucose
Tolerance was not taken into consideration.
8.
Feeling aggrieved, the respondent approached the appellate authority, but
the appeal preferred by the respondent was rejected by the appellate
authority vide letter dated 02.09.2022. This is how the respondent
approached the Tribunal by way of OA No. 266/2022 which OA has
been decided in favour of the respondent in terms of the judgment
impugned in this petition.
9.
From the factual narration given above, the only question that begs
determination in these proceedings is “whether the composite disability
of the respondent as assessed by the Invaliding Medical Board @ 40%
by ignoring the third disability i.e., Impaired Glucose Tolerance which
has been assessed by the medical authority @ 15-19% is correct”.
10. The answer to this question is not far to seek. The third disability i.e.,
Impaired Glucose Tolerance is indisputably a disability to the extent of
15-19% considered aggravated by Army service by none other than the
medical authority. The pension authority cannot take a view different
from the one taken by the medical authority, that too, without indicating
any reasons or without being backed by statute. The third disability is a
disability in any case, and it has to be considered along with other two
WP(C) No. 1325/2025_______
disabilities. We could understand a case where a person suffers only
from a single disability and such disability is less than 20%. In such
situation, the respondent may be justified in holding such an individual
disentitled to seek disability pension.
11. As a matter of fact, even this argument would not be available to the
petitioners in view of the law laid down by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
in case tilted Sukhwinder Singh (supra). Indisputably, in the instant case,
the tenure of services of the respondent was cut-short because of his
discharge on medical grounds and, therefore, as per the law laid down in
Sukhwinder Singh, his disability shall be deemed to be a minimum of
20% so as to enable him to seek the benefit of disability pension.
12. Viewed thus, we are of the considered opinion that the petitioners were
bound to take into account all the three disabilities and assess the
composite percentage of disability. The medical authority has assessed
all the three disabilities @ 20%, 30% and 15-19%.
13. Although, prior to issuance on Entitlement Rules, 2023 and the Guide to
Medical Officers 2023, there was no set formula for composite
assessment of disability where the disabilities suffered by an individual
were more than one, however, the medical authority had been giving the
composite assessment of the disabilities suffered by the individual,
relying primarily on their expertise in the field. The Entitlement Rules, of
2023 and the Guide to Medical Officers, 2023 have now put in place a
proper formula for working out the composite disability of a person
suffering from more than one disability. Rule 13(b) of the Entitlement
Rules, 2023 lays down such formula ,which for facility of reference is
reproduced as under:
WP(C) No. 1325/2025_______
(b) Assessment
(i) The assessment with regard to percentage of
impairment in both injury and disease cases as
recommended by the Invaliding Medical Board,
retention cum Impairment Assessment Board or
Release Medical Board, read in conjunction with the
Guide to Medical Officers and duly accepted by the
Competent/Appellate Authority, as the case may be,
shall be treated as final and „For Life‟, except in the
cases of impairments that are not of a permanent
nature, unless the individual himself requests for a one
time review.
(ii) Where the impairment is due to more than one
medical condition, a composite assessment of the
degree of impairment shall be made by reference to
the combined effect of all medical conditions in
addition to separate assessment for each medical
condition. In case of overlapping medical conditions,
the composite assessment of impairment will not be
the sum of individual medical conditions. After
accounting for the percentage of the first medical
condition, the percentage of every subsequent medical
condition shall be calculated against the total after
discounting its assessment from 100 percent, or the
remainder thereof. The composite assessment of
impairment shall be the sum of the percentages of
individual accepted medical conditions calculated in
this discounted manner. This is based on the principle
that no person can be more than 100 percent disabled.
Illustration:
If an individual has three „accepted disabilities‟
assessed as follows.
Disability A = 30%
Disability B = 20%
Disability C = 10%
The net impairment is calculated as follows:30% + (100 - 30%) 20%+ (70 – 14) 10%
30% + 14% + 5.6% = 49.6%
14. From reading of Clause (ii) of Rule 13 (b), it clearly transpires that
where a person, like the respondent herein suffers from more than one
WP(C) No. 1325/2025_______
disability, the formula as indicated in the illustration would be used to
make the composite assessment. Applying the aforesaid formula to the
case on hand, the first disability i.e., Retinal Vasculitis Left Eye (OPD)
is 20% and, therefore, is to be taken as 20%. The second disability i.e.,
Primarly Hypertension which is assessed @ 30% is to be taken as 30%
of 80, i.e., 24%. The third disability i.e., Impaired Glucose Tolerance,
which is 15-19%, shall be taken as 19% of 56, i.e., 10.64. The total
composite disability would, therefore, be 20 + 24 + 10.64 i.e., 54.64%.
In any case, in the instant matter, the composite assessment of all the
three disabilities by applying a very rational formula indicated in Rule
13 reproduced above, would be more than 50%. The said disability is
required to be rounded off to 75%. This exactly is what the Tribunal has
held in terms of the judgment impugned.
15. For all these reasons we find no merit in this petition, and the same is
accordingly dismissed.
(SANJAY PARIHAR)
JUDGE
(SANJEEV KUMAR)
JUDGE
Jammu:
.02.2026
Shafqat
Whether this order is speaking: Yes/No
Whether this order is reportable: Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review