Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:1160-DB
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Serial No. 03
Daily List
WP(C) No. 101 of 2024
Date of CAV
: 25.11.2024
Date of pronouncement : 16.12.2024
1.
Union of India through the Secretary,
Ministry of Environment, Forest & Climate Change,
Government of India, Indira Paryavaran Bhawan, New Delhi-3
2.
The Secretary,
Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions,
Department of Personnel & Training, Government of India,
New Delhi.
......Petitioners
- Versus -
Shri. Nripemo Odyuo
S/o E. Ramongo Odyuo
Botanical Survey of India, Eastern Regional Centre,
Shillong, Meghalaya
......Respondent
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice I.P. Mukerji, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioners
: Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. N.A.U. Sogra, Adv.
For the Respondent
: Mr. N. Zubemo Lotha, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
2024:MLHC:1160-DB
JUDGMENT
(Delivered by the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice)
This is a writ petition by the Central Government. It is aggrieved
by a judgment and order dated 10th January, 2024 of the Central
Administrative Tribunal, Guwahati Bench in an Original Application
made by the respondent Nripemo Odyuo.
Nripemo, is a Scientist working with the said government and
posted at the Botanical Survey of India, Eastern Regional Centre,
Shillong, Meghalaya. The impugned order of the tribunal quashed a
government Order dated 20th June 2022. It directed the petitioners to
grant promotion to the respondent from Scientist Grade-C to Scientist
Grade-D from his “due dates of eligibility and further consequential
promotions with other benefits.”
The facts of the case are these.
On 16th December 2002 the respondent was appointed Scientist in
Grade- B. During his time of appointment, the Flexible Complementing
Scheme (FCS) as modified on the recommendation of the Fifth Central
Pay Commission had been introduced by the petitioners.
Under it,
promotion was to be granted to the next higher Grade upon completion of
the prescribed residency period. A Table showing the designation and
residency period is inserted below:-
2024:MLHC:1160-DB
“
Sl. No.
a
b
c
d
e
f
Designation
Scientist B
Scientist C
Scientist D
Scientist E
Scientist F
Scientist G
Residency period
3 years
4 years
4 years
5 years
5 years
------”
The
respondent’s Annual
Confidential
Grading
had
been
outstanding and very good in three years. His case was that his next
promotion to the higher Grade-C ought to have been with effect from 1 st
January 2006. He was not so promoted. He was promoted only on 7 th
March 2008, with effect from 1st January 2006.
The respondent is aggrieved by this. According to the above
Scheme and Table, his next promotion to Grade - D was due w.e.f. 1st
January,2010.
However, the promotion was effected on 4th February
2015.
If the petitioner authorities gave his promotion from the alleged
date i.e. 1st January, 2010, then the respondent would have attained GradeE w.e.f 1st January 2014. The respondent was promoted to Grade-E only
on 2nd March 2020.
The main contention of the petitioners as made by Dr. N. Mozika,
learned DSGI was that the respondent’s entitlement to promotion arose
2024:MLHC:1160-DB
out of Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change, “Scientific
Group A posts recruitment Rules, 2015” notified on 23 rd January, 2015,
wherein inter alia, it was stated that in-situ promotions under the Flexible
Complementing Scheme would be applicable for promotion upon
completion of the prescribed residency period in grades B, C, D, E, F and
G. He contended that the respondent could not claim retrospective
operation of this notification to get promotion.
We think he is completely wrong.
The Office Memorandum of the Department of Personnel and
Training, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions,
Government of India dated 9th November, 1998, is absolutely plain that
the government was implementing the recommendation of the Fifth
Central Pay Commission in relation to the Flexible Complementing
Scheme for scientists. In fact the government was immediately
implementing those recommendations as would appear from paragraphs
3, 4 and 5 of the said office memorandum which are inserted below:
“3. The recommendations of the Pay Commission that the
existing disparities in the operation of Flexible Complementing
Scheme in various scientific and technical departments in the
matter of designation of posts, the number of pay scales and the
residency period should be removed and there should be uniformity
in this regard has been accepted. Accordingly, all the posts covered
under the Flexible Complementing Scheme shall carry the
following uniform scales of pay, designations and the minimum
residency period linked to performances:-
2024:MLHC:1160-DB
Scales of pay
Designation
(a) Rs. 8000-13500
(b) Rs. 10000-15200
(c) Rs. 12000-16500
(d) Rs. 14300-18300
(e) Rs. 16400-20000
(f) Rs. 18400-22400
Scientist B
Scientist C
Scientist D
Scientist E
Scientist F
Scientist G
Minimum
Residency
Period
linked
to
performance
3 Years
4 Years
4 Years
5 Years
5 Years
In order to give immediate effect to the decision contained in this
para, an umbrella Notification has been issued vide G.S.R. No.
660(E) dated 9.11.1998.
4.
The recommendation of the Fifth Central Pay Commission
for introducing a ‘cooling off’ period of 3 years before an officer is
considered for the Flexible Complementing Scheme on the second
occasion at the same level has not been accepted. The
recommendation for disqualification of the candidate permanently
from the FCS in case of failure to qualify thrice at the same level,
etc., has also not been accepted. Therefore, the existing system of
assessing the officer every year would continue.
5.
It has further been decided that in order to extend the benefit
of in-situ promotions under the Flexible Complementing Scheme to
other Scientific Organisations that are demanding the extension of
FCS in their case, the administrative Ministry of such institutions
shall satisfy itself that such institutions are scientific and technical
institutions and the officers are scientists holding scientific posts
and are involved in scientific and technical activities as defined in
the Annexure I to this Office Memorandum and make its
recommendations to the Department of Science & Technology. On
receipt of such a request the Department of Science & Technology
shall set up a Committee, including the representatives of the
Department of Personnel and Training and of the Department or
experience as well as eminent scientists relevant to the discipline,
for examining the proposal referred by the administrative Ministry
concerned. A final decision on the proposal of an administrative
Ministry for extension of FCS to other scientific organisations shall
be taken based on the recommendations of this Committee. Since it
2024:MLHC:1160-DB
is not necessary that all the pay scales under the Flexible
Complementing Scheme should be applicable in all the scientific
organisations, as the size of the organisations may not justify
introduction of the entire group of scales, the Committee, while
making its recommendations, would take a specific view as to the
number of scales that should be operated in the organization as well
as the appropriate residency period for ensuring an even pace of
promotion. However,
the
progression
under
Flexible
Complementing Scheme will only be as per scales indicated in para
3 of this Office Memorandum.”
The fact that the Government was implementing the Flexible
Complementing Scheme (FCS) modified according to the Fifth Central
Pay Commission, 1998, recommendation and incorporated in the Office
Memorandum dated 9th November 1998 of the Department of Personnel
and Training, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pension
would be evident from the fact that on 14 th February, 2014, the petitioners
gave retrospective effect from 1st January, 2006 to the promotion of the
respondent from Scientist Grade - B to Scientist Grade - C made on 7 th
March, 2008. This was on the representation by the respondent, that
having been appointed Scientist Grade-B on 16th December 2002, his next
promotion to Scientist Grade-C under the above Scheme was due from 1 st
January, 2006.
In fact, the Office Memorandum by the Personnel Department
dated 17th July, 2002, very plainly indicated that the Scheme was being
carried out. This Office Memorandum is inserted below:-
2024:MLHC:1160-DB
“New Delhi- 110001
July 17, 2002
OFICE MEMORANDUM
Subject: Flexible Complementing Scheme for scientists in Scientific
and Technological Departments – Date of effect of promotions.
The recommendations made by the fifth Central Pay Commission
for modifying the Flexible Complementing Scheme (FCS) in
operation in scientific and technological departments for in situ
promotion of scientific/technical personnel with a view to removing
the shortcomings/inadequacies in the scheme had been examined
some time back and this Department in O.M.No. 2/41/97-PIC dated
9.11.1998 had issued detailed guidelines modifying the then
existing FCS. From a number of references received in this
Department, it appears that an element of confusion exists in some
scientific departments on the date from which in situ promotions
under FCS are to be given effect. Promotions are made effective
from a prospective date after the competent authority has approved
the same. This is the general principle followed in promotions and
this principle is applicable in the case of in situ promotions under
FCS as well.
2.
As a matter of fact, no occasion requiring application of
promotion with retrospective effect should arise in FCS cases, as it
is provided in the rules for scientific posts that the Assessment
Boards shall meet at least once a year to consider cases of in situ
promotions. Rules notified for scientific posts also contain a
provision for review of promotion by the Selection
Committee/Assessment Board twice a year - before 1st January and
1st July of every year – and the Selection Committee/Assessment
Board is required to make its recommendation on promotions
keeping in view these crucial dates of 1st January and 1st July. The
competent authority, which has to take a final view based on these
recommendations, shall ensure that no promotion is granted with
retrospective effect.
3.
Hindi version will follow.
Sd/(ALOK SAXENA)
DEPUTY SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF INDIA”
2024:MLHC:1160-DB
Hence, the respondent was absolutely right in contending that his
next promotion under the said Scheme was due by 1 st January 2010 which
was effected only on 4th February, 2015. Likewise, the promotion to
Grade-E was due by 1st January, 2014. He was promoted to Grade-E only
on 2nd March, 2020.
There is no dispute that the respondent’s Gradings in the Annual
Confidential Reports were always “outstanding and very good”.
Therefore, there was no reason to deny him promotion.
In the case of a Scientist of the Botanical Survey of India where the
facts were quite similar Union of India and another vs SK Mutti, the
Supreme Court vide Judgment and Order decided on 2nd May 2011,
affirmed the order of the High Court directing the Ministry to promote the
Scientist “from the date of acquiring the eligibility under the Flexible
Complementing Scheme (FCS)”.
For the above reasons, we find no infirmity in the impugned
judgment and order of the Tribunal. We affirm the same and dismiss this
writ petition. No Order as to costs.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
LIZ KHARBHIH
Date: 2024.12.16 19:30:15 IST
(I.P. Mukerji)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review