Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 8746/2017
UNION OF INDIA AND ANR
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. P.S. Singh, CGSC, with
Mr. Rajneesh K Sharma and Ms. Annu
Singh, Ms. Shivangi Sharma, Advs.
versus
DR. SAHADEVA SINGH
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Suhail Dutt, Sr. Advocate
with Mr. Sankalp Goswami and Mr. Azhar
Alam, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE OM PRAKASH SHUKLA
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
16.04.2026
%
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
1.
This writ petition assails judgment dated 3 April 2017, passed
by Principal Bench of the Central Administrative Tribunal1 whereby
OA 2907/2013 filed by the respondent has been allowed.
2.
The only issue for consideration before us, and before the
Tribunal, was whether the mandate of the judgment of the Supreme
Court in Union of India v. B.V. Gopinath2 was followed.
1 “the Tribunal” hereinafter
2 (2014) 1 SCC 351
W.P.(C) 8746/2017
KUMAR
16:08:28
3.
We may note that Mr. P S Singh, learned CGSC for the Union
of India, has also cited a more recent decision of the Supreme Court in
State of Jharkhand v. Rukma Kesh Mishra3.
4.
The burden of the song, whether in B.V. Gopinath or whether
Rukma Kesh Mishra, is that the disciplinary proceedings have to be
preceded by approval, by the competent disciplinary authority, of the
charge-sheet which is proposed to be issued to a charged officer.
5.
The relevant paragraphs from B.V. Gopinath and Rukma Kesh
Mishra may be reproduced thus:
From B V Gopinath
“30. According to the learned senior counsel, the most important
issue to be decided by this Court is that whether the stage of
initiating Disciplinary Proceedings is the same as issuing a charge
sheet/charge memo? A plain reading of Rule 14(2) and Rule 14(3)
of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control & appeal)
Rules, 1965 makes it amply clear and the only interpretation
possible is that the stage of initiating the disciplinary proceedings
U/Rule 14(2) is distinct and separate from issuing a charge memo
U/Rule 14(3) and it is not a continuing act because it is not
necessary that every disciplinary proceeding initiated would
definitely result in issuing a charge memo because after initiating
disciplinary proceedings it may be found from the material on
record that, the memo of charge need not be served because the
charges may not be made out or a lesser charge could be made out.
Mind has to be applied to the evidence and material on record
pursuant to initiation of disciplinary proceedings to again come to a
fresh decision as to whether now, a charge memo deserves to be
issued. Thus, the material before the Disciplinary authority is
different at both the stages of Rule 14(2) and Rule 14(3) of the
Central Civil Services (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules,
1965.
*****
3 AIR 2025 SC 1656
W.P.(C) 8746/2017
KUMAR
16:08:28
49.
We are unable to accept the submission of the learned Addl.
Solicitor General. Initially, when the file comes to the Finance
Minister, it is only to take a decision in principle as to whether
departmental proceedings ought to be initiated against the officer.
Clause (11) deals with reference to CVC for second stage advice.
In case of proposal for major penalties, the decision is to be taken
by the Finance Minister. Similarly, under Clause (12)
reconsideration of CVC’s second stage advice is to be taken by the
Finance Minister. All further proceedings including approval for
referring the case to DOP & T, issuance of show cause notice in
case of disagreement with the enquiry officer report; tentative
decision after CVC’s second stage advice on imposition of penalty;
final decision of penalty; and revision/review/memorial have to be
taken by the Finance Minister.
50.
In our opinion, the Central Administrative Tribunal as well
as the High Court has correctly interpreted the provisions of the
Office Order No. 205 of 2005. Factually also, a perusal of the
record would show that the file was put up to the Finance Minister
by the Director General of Income Tax (Vigilance) seeking the
approval of the Finance Minister for sanctioning prosecution
against one officer and for initiation of major penalty proceeding
under Rule 3(1)(i) and (3) (1) (iii) of the Central Civil Services
(Conduct) Rules against the officers mentioned in the note which
included the appellant herein. Ultimately, it appears that the
charge memo was not put up for approval by the Finance Minister.
Therefore, it would not be possible to accept the submission of Ms.
Indira Jaising that the approval granted by the Finance Minister
for initiation of departmental proceedings would also amount to
approval of the charge memo.”
*****
52.
In our opinion, the submission of the learned Addl.
Solicitor General is not factually correct. The primary submission
of the respondent was that the charge sheet not having been issued
by the disciplinary authority is without authority of law and,
therefore, non est in the eye of law. This plea of the respondent has
been accepted by the CAT as also by the High Court. The action
has been taken against the respondent in Rule 14(3) of the
CCS(CCA) Rules which enjoins the disciplinary authority to draw
up or cause to be drawn up the substance of imputation of
misconduct or misbehaviour into definite and distinct articles of
charges. The term “cause to be drawn up” does not mean that the
definite and distinct articles of charges once drawn up do not have
to be approved by the disciplinary authority. The term “cause to be
drawn up” merely refers to a delegation by the disciplinary
W.P.(C) 8746/2017
KUMAR
16:08:28
authority to a subordinate authority to perform the task of drawing
up substance of proposed “definite and distinct articles of charge
sheet”. These proposed articles of charge would only be finalized
upon approval by the disciplinary authority. Undoubtedly, this
Court in the case of P.V.Srinivasa Sastry v. CAG4, has held
that Article 311(1) does not say that even the departmental
proceeding must be initiated only by the appointing authority.
However, at the same time it is pointed out that (SCC p. 422, para
4)
“4. ... However, it is open to the Union of India or a State
Government to make any rule prescribing that even the
proceeding against any delinquent officer shall be initiated
by an officer not subordinate to the appointing authority."
It is further held that:
“4. ... Any such rule shall not be inconsistent with
Article 311 of the Constitution because it will
amount to providing an additional safeguard or
protection to the holders of a civil post”
From Rukma Kesh Mishra
“30. Reverting to Rule 55 of the 1930 Rules, it is observed that
the same did not specify any particular authority to be under an
obligation to issue the charge-sheet against a civil servant. In such
view of the matter and having regard to the law settled by this
Court, it is axiomatic that any officer holding a rank subordinate to
the respondent’s appointing authority but superior in rank than the
respondent could have issued the charge-sheet. Admittedly, the
facts do reveal initiation of disciplinary proceedings against the
respondent having the approval of the Chief Minister dated 21st
March, 2014. The draft charge-sheet was part of the proposal
dated 13th January, 2014. Once the draft charge-sheet was on
record before the Chief Minister, approval of the proposal to
initiate disciplinary proceedings should have been read as
including the Chief Minister’s assent not only to the draft chargesheet, as drawn up, but also to the other proposals to suspend the
respondent as well as appointment of an inquiry officer and
presenting officer. In such circumstances, reference by the Division
Bench to Rule 17(3) of the 2016 Rules appears to be wholly
misplaced since the charge-sheet was not issued under such subRule.”
(Emphasis supplied)
4 (1993) 1 SCC 419
W.P.(C) 8746/2017
KUMAR
16:08:28
6.
The only issue to be considered is whether the proposal for
initiation of disciplinary proceedings as well as the draft chargesheet
proposed to be issued to the charged officer were approved by the
competent disciplinary authority before they were issued.
7.
It is settled that mere approval for initiation of disciplinary
proceedings is insufficient and that the draft chargesheet has also to be
put up before the disciplinary authority and approved by the
disciplinary authority before it is issued, failing which the disciplinary
proceedings would be without jurisdiction ab initio.
8.
Mr. Singh’s contention is that the draft charge-sheet, or at least
the draft charges, were approved by the Agriculture Minister, who was
the competent disciplinary authority, and that the Tribunal erred in
holding otherwise.
9.
The file noting preceding the issuance of chargesheet to the
respondent, reads thus:
“11. In view of the above, kind approval of Hon'ble AM is
solicited for initiating disciplinary proceedings against Dr.
Sahdeva Singh, Deputy Commissioner in this Department, under
Rule 14 of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. The Article of charges, a
statement of imputation of misconduct or misbehaviour and a list
of documents by which and a list of witnesses by whom the article
of charge is proposed to be sustained, are placed below for
perusal.
Sd/5/1/09
US(P-I) sd/-5/1/09
Dir(P) sd/-5/1/09
JS(A) sd/- 06.1.09
W.P.(C) 8746/2017
KUMAR
16:08:28
AS (PKB) sd/-7/1/09
Secretary (A&C) sd/-10.1.09
AM sd/-12/1/09"
(Emphasis supplied)
10.
Though the afore-extracted para 11 from the file noting states
that the article of charges, statement of imputations and misconduct
and list of documents and list of witnesses were “placed below for
perusal” – which is what Gopinath and Rukma Kesh Mishra require
– the Tribunal has, in para 7 of the impugned judgment, noted and
observed as under:
“7.
In para 11 of office notings extracted hereinabove, approval
of the Agriculture Minister (delegated disciplinary authority) was
sought with regard to initiating disciplinary proceedings under rule
14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. However, from the original
record produced before us we find that the aforesaid note was not
accompanied with the proposed/draft memorandum of charge,
imputations of misconduct or misbehaviour, list of witnesses and
list of documents, though the note mentions that the articles of
charge, statement of imputation of misconduct, list of documents
and list of witnesses by whom the articles of charge are proposed
to be sustained are placed for perusal. The preceding note, i.e.,
para 10 at p.l2-13/N also does not refer to the charge-sheet or
charge memorandum. The said para 10 reads as under:
“10. It would be appreciated that Dr. Singh has
committed the following acts which amount to misconduct
and 'unbecoming of a Government servant' and thereby
violated the provisions of Rule 3 of CCS(Conduct) Rules:i.
remaining on unauthorized leave and not
complying with the orders of the competent
authority transferring him to NRAA;
ii.
suppressing of facts and misleading the
Hon'ble CAT;
iii.
writing directly to the Hon'ble PM and
Hon'ble AM bypassing the prescribed channel of
submission, contrary to official propriety and
subversive of good discipline;
W.P.(C) 8746/2017
KUMAR
16:08:28
iv.
misuse of the National Emblem in violation
of Section 3 of the State Emblem of India
(Prohibition of Improper Use) Act, 2005;
v.
criticizing the policy of Government and
seeking restructuring of the Department of
Agriculture
&
Cooperation,
through
his
representations to the Hon'ble PM.”
(Emphasis supplied)
11.
Following this, the Tribunal has concluded, in para 8 of the
impugned order, thus:
“8.
From the record we find that the charge memorandum is
dated 16.01.2009 which was prepared on 13.01.2009, i.e., after the
approval was granted by the Hon'ble Agriculture Minister on
10.01.2009. In B. V. Gopinath's case (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme
Court categorically held that where the disciplinary authority
himself is not the inquiring authority, the charge-sheet must be
approved by him. In the present case, from para 11 of the official
noting reproduced hereinabove we find that only initiation of the
disciplinary proceedings was approved by the Hon'ble Agriculture
Minister. Though there is reference to the articles of charge,
imputation of misconduct or misbehaviour, list of documents and
list of witnesses, however, the same were not placed before the
disciplinary authority on 10.01.2009.”
(Emphasis supplied)
12.
Apropos the observations in para 7 of the impugned judgment,
the writ petition of the UOI merely avers, in Ground (I), thus:
“For that the Learned Tribunal also fell in error by coming to
wrong conclusion that since the proposed/draft memorandum of
charge mentioned in the note dated 05.01.2009, imputations of
misconduct or misbehaviour, list of witnesses and list of
documents were not accompanied, it proved that "draft chargesheet" was prepared after obtaining approval for initiating
disciplinary proceedings at Para (11) of the noting dated
05.01.2009 (P.13/N)”.
13.
We have already noted that, in para 11 at page 13 of the file
W.P.(C) 8746/2017
KUMAR
16:08:28
noting, it was stated that the draft memorandum of charge, statement
of imputations of misconduct, list of witnesses and list of documents
were placed below the note for the perusal of the Agriculture Minister,
being the disciplinary authority.
14.
Despite this, the Tribunal has noted in para 7 that the official
file showed that there was in fact no such draft charge-sheet placed
below the note.
15.
At the request of Mr. Singh, as also to satisfy ourselves, we
have also perused the original file. The position is exactly as the
Tribunal has noted in para 7 of the impugned judgment.
16.
The note reproduced by us in para 8 supra, which ends with the
statement that “(i) article of charges, (ii) statement of imputation of
misconduct or misbehaviour, (iii) list of documents and (iv) list of
witnesses by whom the article of charge is proposed to be sustained,
are placed below for perusal” is followed only by a sequence of
signatures.
17.
Thereafter, we have seen the next page, i.e. page 14 of the file
as well and there is no reference to any draft charge-sheet. There is no
page between page 13 and page 14 which contains any draft chargesheet which was put up before the Agriculture Minister.
18.
As such, it is apparent that, perhaps by inadvertence, the draft
charge-sheet was never in fact put up for approval by the Agriculture
Minister as was noted in the note dated 5 January 2009.
W.P.(C) 8746/2017
KUMAR
16:08:28
19.
The omission is fatal.
20.
Whether one proceeds as per the exposition of law in B.V.
Gopinath or in para 30 of Rukma Kesh Mishra, it is essential that the
draft charge-sheet was put up before the disciplinary authority and
received his approval before the final charge-sheet was issued to the
charged officer.
21.
This mandatory requirement not having been satisfied, there is
no error in the view adopted by the Tribunal.
22.
Mr. Singh sought to contend that, in para 10, above para 11 at
page 13 of the file noting (reproduced in para 7 of the impugned
judgment), enumerated the acts of misconduct committed by the
respondent.
23.
Mere enumeration of the acts of the misconduct does not
constitute a draft charge-sheet. A charge-sheet consists of the
statement of articles of charge, statement of imputations of
misconduct, a list of witnesses and a list of documents on which the
charges are proposed to be proved. Application of mind to the manner
in which the Articles of Charge, and the Statement of Imputations of
Misconduct, are required to be drawn up, is essential, before a chargesheet is finalized for service on a charged officer.
24.
It is this draft charge-sheet which has to be put up before the
disciplinary authority before it is issued, as per B.V. Gopinath and
W.P.(C) 8746/2017
KUMAR
16:08:28
Rukma Kesh Mishra. That never took place in the present case.
25.
Mr. Singh has also sought to place reliance on the “Central
Secretariat Manual of Office Procedure” issued by the Department of
Administrative Reforms and Public Grievances, Ministry of
Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, from which certain select
pages have been provided to us.
26.
He has placed reliance on paras 23(v) and 25((ii) of the said
manual which read thus:
“23(v) When the ‘notes’ plus the ‘correspondence’ portion of the
file become bulky (say exceeds 150-200 pages), it will be marked
‘Volume I’. Further papers on the subject will be added to the new
volume of the same file, which will be marked ‘Volume II’, and so
on. In Volume II and subsequent volumes of the same file, page
numbering in notes portion and correspondence portion will be
made in continuity of the last page number in note/correspondence
portion of the earlier volume”.
“25(ii) The drafts of letters issued having crucial policy, financial
and vigilance implications, where the drafts have been changed by
Senior Officers in the process of movement of files upwards,
barring grammatical corrections should also form a part of
correspondence portion, which shall be numbered ad seriatim”.
27.
We are at a completely loss as to how these clauses are at all
relevant, or dilute the law laid down by the Supreme Court in B.V.
Gopinath and Rukma Kesh Mishra.
28.
We, therefore, find no cause to interfere with the impugned
judgment of the Tribunal, which is upheld in its entirety.
W.P.(C) 8746/2017
KUMAR
16:08:28
29.
The writ petition is accordingly dismissed, with no orders as to
costs.
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
OM PRAKASH SHUKLA, J.
APRIL 16, 2026
dsn
W.P.(C) 8746/2017
KUMAR
16:08:28
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review