The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. Accordingly, the petition is allowed. The impugned order dated
12. 08.2025 is set aside. The plaintiffs are granted two opportunities to conclude their evidence, including the examination of plaintiff No. 2 as his own witness, subject to payment of costs of ₹5,000/- to be deposited before the trial court on or before 02.02.2026. On that date, the plaintiff shall file an affidavit of his testimony and furnish an advance copy to the defendants to enable effective crossexamination. The evidence shall be concluded within two hearings.
19. The petition stands disposed of accordingly.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 35
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case No:- CM(M) No. 3/2026
Date of Pronouncement:15.01.2026
Uploaded on:
Union of India and another
19.01.2026
…. Petitioner(s)
Through:-
Mr. Sandeep Gupta, Advocate
V/s
…..Respondent(s)
Vipan Sawhney and others
Through:CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
ORDER
1.
The plaintiffs-petitioners have invoked the supervisory jurisdiction
of this Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India to assail
the order dated 12.08.2025 of the trial court, whereby the
application filed by the plaintiffs under Order XVIII Rule 3A CPC,
seeking permission to examine the plaintiff as his own witness, was
dismissed and the evidence of the plaintiffs was closed.
2.
It is contended that the civil suit has been instituted by plaintiff No.
2, DIG, BSF, Sector Headquarters, BSF, Rajouri, in his official
capacity, for the purpose of preservation and protection of the
property of the Union of India. The suit seeks a declaration that the
“No Objection” granted by the official defendants in favour of the
private defendants for construction of a commercial hotel building
over land measuring 1 Kanal and 16 Marla’s, falling under Khasra
Case No.
CM(M) No. 03/2026Page 1 of 7
No. 2 min, situated at Salani, Rajouri, is invalid, inoperative, and
non-est in the eyes of law, as the said construction breaches vital
security concerns. It is pleaded that, considering the sensitive nature
of the area of Rajouri, the construction, if allowed, would
jeopardize the security of the BSF campus and expose its officials
to grave security risks.
3.
It is further submitted that the plaintiffs had already examined
several witnesses and, prior to closure of their evidence, moved an
application under Order XVIII Rule 3A CPC seeking permission to
examine plaintiff No. 2 as his own witness. The application was
filed on the ground that the evidence of plaintiff No. 2 could not be
recorded earlier due to compelling official exigencies, as he was
supervising four battalions of BSF deployed at the Sector
Headquarters, Rajouri, which lies close to the Line of Control and
functions under the operational control of the Indian Army in the
districts of Rajouri and Poonch, the entire area being highly
sensitive from a security perspective.
4.
It was in this backdrop that plaintiff No. 2 could not earlier appear
as his own witness and accordingly sought permission by way of a
formal application. The trial court, though observing that the
provisions of Order XVIII Rule 3A CPC are directory in nature,
dismissed the application without appreciating the peculiar facts
and circumstances of the case, thereby depriving the plaintiff of an
opportunity to lead material evidence. The dismissal of the
Case No.
CM(M) No. 03/2026
application resulted in the closure of the plaintiffs’ evidence, which,
it is contended, has caused serious prejudice to the plaintiffs’ case.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the petitioners
had no efficacious alternative remedy except to approach this Court
for correction of the errors committed by the trial court. It is argued
that the observation of the trial court that the plaintiffs were
lethargic in pursuing the case is misplaced, as the evidence could
not be produced earlier due to the pandemic. Subsequently, five
witnesses were examined, and only plaintiff No. 2 remained to be
examined. The trial court, however, failed to exercise its
jurisdiction in accordance with law, leaving the petitioners with no
option but to file the present petition.
6.
A perusal of the impugned order reveals that although the trial court
was of the view that Order XVIII Rule 3A CPC is directory, it
nevertheless declined to exercise discretion in favour of the
plaintiffs on the ground that plaintiff No. 2 remained lethargic and
was not diligent in pursuing the suit. The trial court further held that
no convincing reasons were furnished to justify the exercise of
discretion, particularly since a last and final opportunity had already
been granted to the plaintiffs to lead evidence. Instead of producing
the evidence, the plaintiffs filed the application under Order XVIII
Rule 3A CPC, which, according to the trial court, appeared to be an
attempt to protract the proceedings.
7.
Having regard to the nature of the issues involved, it is evident that
upon dismissal of the application under Order XVIII Rule 3A CPC,
Case No.
CM(M) No. 03/2026
the evidence of the plaintiffs stood closed and the matter was
thereafter listed for evidence of the defendants. This Court has
consistently held that the provisions of Order XVIII Rule 3A CPC
are directory in nature. Reference may be made to Romesh Kumar
v. Chaman Lal, 1990 SLJ J&K, wherein it was held that the said
provisions are directory and not mandatory, and that a party may be
permitted to appear as a witness at a later stage, provided sufficient
reasons are shown and it is ensured that such appearance is not
intended to fill up lacunae in the evidence.
8.
Similarly, in Dwarika Devi v. Dhani Ram Mangotra, 2002 (1) SLJ
J&K 159, it was held that the Court has the power to grant
permission to the plaintiff to appear as his own witness even after
examination of other witnesses, but such permission must be
supported by recorded reasons. The trial court is duty-bound to
record reasons even where no rebuttal is filed by the opposing
party.
9.
In Ali Mohd. Khandey v. State of J&K, 2010 SLJ (2) 734, it was
held that a plaintiff may be permitted to appear as his own witness
at a later stage, for reasons to be recorded, namely: (i) up to the
closure of the plaintiff’s evidence; (ii) where the plaintiff opts to
produce evidence on certain issues after the defendants’ evidence;
and (iii) when evidence is to be produced in rebuttal. However,
permission cannot be sought after the rebuttal evidence has finally
been closed.
Case No.
CM(M) No. 03/2026
10.
In Mohan Lal v. Vinod Kumari, 1988 SLJ 144, it was held that
where the Court is satisfied that the prayer for examining a party at
a later stage is genuine, made in good faith, and would not result in
filling lacunae in the evidence already recorded, such permission
ought to be granted to further the cause of justice.
11.
From the aforesaid legal position, it is clear that the provisions of
Order XVIII Rule 3A CPC are directory and confer discretion upon
the trial court to permit examination of a party at a later stage,
subject to satisfaction of the Court and recording of reasons.
12.
It is equally well-settled that procedural technicalities should not be
allowed to impede the administration of justice and that adequate
opportunity must be afforded to a party to prove its case.
13.
In the present case, it is undisputed that the suit has been filed by
the Union of India through plaintiff No. 2 in his official capacity.
While the trial court acknowledged the directory nature of Order
XVIII Rule 3A CPC, it declined to exercise discretion on the
ground that the plaintiff remained lethargic, despite having availed
a last opportunity.
14.
During the course of hearing, learned counsel for the plaintiffs
submitted that the petition could be disposed of by granting two
opportunities to enable plaintiff No. 2 to appear as his own witness
and that the plaintiffs were willing to compensate the respondents
by way of costs. In view of the directory nature of the provision, the
pivotal question is whether the plaintiff can truly be termed
lethargic, which must be inferred from the impugned order itself.
Case No.
CM(M) No. 03/2026
15.
Plaintiff No. 2, being the in-charge of Sector Rajouri covering the
districts of Rajouri and Poonch, a sensitive border area under the
operational command of the Indian Army, had specifically pleaded
that due to operational exigencies and frequent changes in officers,
he could not appear earlier. To avoid any procedural infirmity, he
moved a formal application under Order XVIII Rule 3A CPC.
These grounds cannot be faulted or characterized as lethargic. It is
not a case where the plaintiffs failed to lead evidence altogether;
rather, several witnesses had already been examined, and only the
statement of the plaintiff himself remained, which was considered
necessary for a just adjudication of the dispute.
16.
Considering that plaintiff No. 2 was acting in an official capacity
and could have been prevented from attending court due to
operational duties, the trial court, having held the provision to be
directory, ought to have exercised discretion in favour of permitting
his examination. The dismissal of the application resulted in the
termination of the plaintiffs’ right to lead evidence, thereby causing
serious prejudice. The defendants would not have been prejudiced,
as the testimony of plaintiff No. 2 would have been subject to crossexamination.
17.
In these circumstances, the trial court failed to exercise its
jurisdiction in accordance with law, resulting in a miscarriage of
justice by denying plaintiff No. 2 the opportunity to appear as his
own witness. Although the suit was instituted in the year 2012 and
Case No.
CM(M) No. 03/2026
the plaintiffs cannot be absolved of delay, such delay can be
adequately addressed by imposing compensatory costs upon them.
18.
Accordingly, the petition is allowed. The impugned order dated
12.08.2025 is set aside. The plaintiffs are granted two opportunities
to conclude their evidence, including the examination of plaintiff
No. 2 as his own witness, subject to payment of costs of ₹5,000/- to
be deposited before the trial court on or before 02.02.2026. On that
date, the plaintiff shall file an affidavit of his testimony and furnish
an advance copy to the defendants to enable effective crossexamination. The evidence shall be concluded within two hearings.
19.
The petition stands disposed of accordingly.
(SANJAY PARIHAR)
JUDGE
JAMMU
15.01.2026
Rahul Sharma
Whether the order is speaking? : Yes
Whether the order is reportable? : Yes
Case No.
CM(M) No. 03/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review