Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/14
GAHC010293322019
2026:GAU-AS:885
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/8878/2019
1.UNION OF INDIA AND 3 ORS.
REP. BY THE SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF INDIA,
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE, SOUTH BLOCK, NEW DELHI- 110011.
2: THE DIRECTOR GENERAL (PERS.)
MILITARY ENGINEER SERVICES,
ENGINEER-IN-CHIEFS BRANCH
IHQRS OF MOD (ARMY) KASHMIR HOUSE
NEW DELHI- 110011.
3: THE CHIEF ENGINEER
HEADQUARTERS EASTERN COMMAND
ENGINEER BRANCH PIN- 908542
C/O- 99 APO.
4: THE COMMANDER WORKS ENGINEER
HEADQUARTER 137 WORKS ENGINEER
PIN- 914137 C/O 99 APO
……Petitioners
-VERSUS1.BIJAY SINGH .
S/O LT. OMPRAKASH SINGH, R/O RANGAPAHAR RAILWAY GATE NO. 1,
THAHEKHU, BLOCK III, P.O. RANGAPAHAR, PIN- 797123, DIMAPUR
(NAGALAND).
2:ADITYA POWGAM
S/O- SHRI LATE DURGA POWGAM R/O RANGAPAHAR RAILWAY GATE NO.
1 THAHEKHU BLOCK III P.O. RANGAPAHAR PIN- 797123 DIMAPUR
(NAGALAND).
3:SUBHAM DORJEE
S/O- LT. KAMAL BAHADUR DORJEE R/O RANGAPAHAR RAILWAY GATE
Page No.# 2/14
NO. 1 THAHEKHU BLOCK III P.O. RANGAPAHAR PIN- 797123
DIMAPUR (NAGALAND).
4:SAYED AHMED MAZUMDER
S/O LT. TAZUMUL ALI MAZUMDER R/O RANGAPAHAR RAILWAY GATE
NO. 1 THAHEKHU BLOCK III P.O. RANGAPAHAR PIN- 797123 DIMAPUR
(NAGALAND).
5:MD. KHERUL KHAN
S/O MD. JAMAL KHAN R/O RANGAPAHAR RAILWAY GATE NO. 1
THAHEKHU BLOCK III P.O. RANGAPAHAR PIN- 797123 DIMAPUR
(NAGALAND).
6:MD. ABID KHAN
S/O MD. JAMAL KHAN R/O RANGAPAHAR RAILWAY GATE NO. 1
THAHEKHU BLOCK III P.O. RANGAPAHAR PIN- 797123 DIMAPUR
(NAGALAND).
7:GULAMALI KADIR
S/O SHRI QAIYOOM ANSARI R/O RANGAPAHAR RAILWAY GATE NO. 1
THAHEKHU BLOCK III P.O. RANGAPAHAR PIN- 797123 DIMAPUR
(NAGALAND).
8:PADAM KUMAR BAHADUR
S/O SHRI SURJA BAHADUR R/O RANGAPAHAR RAILWAY GATE NO. 1
THAHEKHU BLOCK III P.O. RANGAPAHAR PIN- 797123 DIMAPUR
(NAGALAND).
9:MANOJ BALMIKI
S/O SHRI RAMDIN BALMIKI R/O RANGAPAHAR RAILWAY GATE NO. 1
THAHEKHU BLOCK III P.O. RANGAPAHAR PIN- 797123 DIMAPUR
(NAGALAND).
10:SUKANTO DAS
S/O SATYA NARAYAN DAS R/O RANGAPAHAR RAILWAY GATE NO. 1
THAHEKHU BLOCK III P.O. RANGAPAHAR PIN- 797123 DIMAPUR
(NAGALAND).
11:SALSENG MARAK
S/O EDRICKSON MARAK R/O RANGAPAHAR RAILWAY GATE NO. 1
THAHEKHU BLOCK III P.O. RANGAPAHAR PIN- 797123 DIMAPUR
(NAGALAND).
12:PRASANTA BOSE
S/O SHRI PIJUSH KANTI BOSE R/O RANGAPAHAR RAILWAY GATE NO. 1
THAHEKHU BLOCK III P.O. RANGAPAHAR PIN- 797123 DIMAPUR
(NAGALAND).
Page No.# 3/14
13:KAUSHIK PAUL
S/O- LT. KUSHENDRA KUMAR PAUL R/O VILL. KUMARPARA P.O.ARUNACHAL PIN- 788025 NID DIST. KACHAR (ASSAM)
…… Respondents
Linked Case : WP(C)/8935/2019
1.UNION OF INDIA AND 3 ORS.
REP. BY THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF INDIA MINSITRY OF DEFENCE
SOUTH BLOCK NEW DELHI-110011
2: THE DIRECTORATE GENERAL (PERS.)
MILITARY ENGINEER SERVICES ENGINEER-IN-CHIEFS BRANCH
IHQRS OF MOD (ARMY). KASHMIR HOUSE NEW DELHI-110011
3: THE CHIEF ENGINEER
HEADQUARTERS EASTERN COMMAND ENGINEER BRANCH
PIN-908542 C/O 99 APO
4: THE COMMANDER WORKS ENGINEER
HEADQUARTER. 137 WORKS ENGINEER
PIN-914137 C/O PP APO
……Petitioners
-VERSUS1.HONCHAI KONYAK AND 7 ORS.
S/O SHRI PAIWANG KONYAK WALFORD HOUSE NO. 99 (H)
NEAR ARK HOUSE P.O. DIMAPUR PIN-797112 NAGALAND
2:MISS MARTINA
D/O SHRI SHIHOTO SEMA VILL. BANK COLONY DIMAPUR
HOUSE NO. 140 P.O. DIMAPUR PIN-797112 NAGALAND
3:AMARJIT SINGHA
S/O MANI MOHAN SINGHA VILL. HAZARIGRAM P.O. HAZARIGRAM
DIST. CACHAR ASSAM
4:N. IBOCHOUBA SINGHA
S/O N. NIGAMANANA SINGHA VILL. LAKHIPUR TOWN P.O. LAKHIPUR
DIST. CACHAR ASSAM
5:CHITTA RANJAN SINGH
S/O W. SHANTI SINGH VILL. NAYAGRAM DIST. CACHAR ASSAM
DIST. KACHAR ASSAM
…… Respondents
Page No.# 4/14
6:SRINIVASAN S
SELECTED MATE (SSK) C/O OFFICE OF THE COMMANDER WORKS
ENGINEER HEADQUARTER 137 WORKS ENGINEER PIN-914137 C/O 99 APO
7:BISHU KUMAR
SELECTED MATE (SSK) C/O OFFICE OF THE COMMANDER WORKS
ENGINEER HEADQUARTER 137 WORKS ENGINEER PIN-914137 C/O 99 APO
8:MADHUSMITA BORAH
SELECTED MATE (SSK) C/O OFFICE OF THE COMMANDER WORKS
ENGINEER HEADQUARTER 137 WORKS ENGINEER PIN-914137 C/O 99 APO
…… Pro-forma Respondents
– BEFORE –
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. ASHUTOSH KUMAR
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN DEV CHOUDHURY
Advocate for the petitioner(s)
:
Mr. R.K.D. Choudhury, Deputy Solicitor General
of India.
Advocate for the respondent(s) :
Mr. A. Ahmed, Advocate.
Date of Hearing & Judgment
27.01.2026
:
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(Ashutosh Kumar, CJ)
We have heard Mr. R.K.D. Choudhury, learned Deputy Solicitor
General of India for the petitioners and Mr. A. Ahmed, learned Advocate
for the respondents.
2.
The challenge in the present petitions is to the order dated
06.05.2019 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal (hereinafter to
be referred as ‘Tribunal’), Guwahati Bench, whereby the public
examination held for the post of Mate (SSK) in the office of the HQ 137
Works Engineers, Dimapur, Nagaland has been cancelled and the
Page No.# 5/14
authorities of the petitioners have been directed to hold examination
afresh for such posts. The Tribunal has further recorded that if some
candidates have been selected and posted pursuant to the afore-noted
examination, they shall be allowed to continue till completion of the
selection process, as directed, for filling up the advertised vacancies. It
was made clear that in the fresh exercise for selection, the candidates
would be served with due notice within a period of four months from the
date of receipt of the copy of the order of the Tribunal.
3.
The Directorate General (Pers.), Military Engineer Services,
Ministry
of
Defence
had
issued
an
employment
notice
[EN
No.34303/LRS/12-13/E1B (S)] inviting applications for various posts,
including 87 posts of Mate (SSK) in HQ 137 Works Engineer, Dimapur
(Nagaland). The last date of receipt of application was fixed on 3 rd
January, 2015 and the scheduled date for written examination was 14 th
February, 2015.
However, the date of the written examination was postponed
to 10.05.2015. Later on, it was decided to hold the written examination on
11.05.2015 for the reason of prevailing volatile security situation in
Nagaland. The examination was conducted without any objection from
any one of the candidates. After the written examination, the results
were declared and the successful candidates in order of merit were
appointed. The merit list of the selected candidates had been prepared
and finalized as per the standard operating procedure by a Board of
Officers.
Page No.# 6/14
Be it also noted that evaluation of the answer sheets was
carried out by a separate Board of Officers.
4.
After uploading of the results on May 4, 2016, the respondents
challenged the examination process on various grounds, including the
change of the venue of written examination even though the
advertisement clearly spelt out that the applicants had to indicate the
area for which he had applied for and the applicant would be
considered only for that particular area which he would apply for and
that no change of centre of examination would be allowed under any
circumstance; that the results were based only on written examination
and not on further interview; the authorities not adopting the system of
OMR answer sheets which is commonly used in competitive examination
for posts under the Central Government or the State Government; the
examination being held on two different dates and few questions of the
examination held on both the dates tallied as also for the reason of some
of the candidates having been issued admit cards for two Centres, which
was impermissible as per the terms of the advertisement.
5.
It would also be relevant in this context to state that the
challenge to
the
holding
of
examination and
the
consequent
preparation of merit list and posting of Mates (SSK), was made before the
Tribunal without impleading the successful/selected candidates.
6.
The Tribunal after taking note of all these objections raised by
the failed candidates, found that few instances of double admit cards
having been issued to some of the candidates, who had appeared in
Page No.# 7/14
the
examination
at
two
Centres
on
two
different
dates,
had
compromised the purity of the entire examination system and the
Tribunal thus set aside the result with a direction that a fresh selection
process be initiated for those 87 posts.
7.
Mr. R.K.D. Choudhury, learned Deputy Solicitor General of
India while challenging the afore-noted order of the Tribunal submitted
that the examination was held as per the standard operating procedure
which was in sync with the advertisement. The venue was changed only
because of the volatile situation at Dimapur in Nagaland which was
never objected to by the candidates at any point of time. Because of
the change of venue, the examination was held on two dates at two
different centres but apparently it has caused prejudice to none.
8.
Responding further to the grounds relied upon by the Tribunal
in setting aside the entire selection process, Mr. Choudhury submitted
that merely because the OMR system was not adopted, it could not be
said that the examination process was faulty. There was no declaration in
the advertisement that OMR sheets shall be used in the examination. The
posts to be filled up were of Mate (SSK), wherein the candidates had to
be evaluated on the basis of their knowledge of the matriculation
standard. There was manual evaluation of answer scripts. In fact, it was
submitted that the question paper was prepared by the College of
Military Engineering, Pune and evaluation also, as noted above, was
made by a separate Board. The allegation of the cyclostyled question
and answer sheets being worn out and faded was factually disputed.
With respect to two admit cards having been issued to few of the
Page No.# 8/14
candidates for two Centres, the stand of the petitioners is that at the time
of issuance of such admit cards, there was no way to cross-check as to
how many centre/centres the applicants had applied for. However, such
instances were very few. Only few questions in the two Centres on two
different dates were similar and that was also for the reason of the
question paper having been normalized for evaluating the applicants.
The methodology of holding the examination was such that the question
paper could have been shared to non-applicants. In fact, two
examinations were held, one on 10.05.2015 and the other on 11.05.2015
at two distant places, where it was not possible for any candidate to
appear at both the Centres.
9.
That apart, Mr. Choudhury contends that even for those
candidates who were issued two admit cards and who allegedly had
come out successful, they were required to be impleaded in the
proceeding before the Tribunal before any order could have been
passed cancelling the examination and the result.
10.
The respondents, however, have expostulated that the
sanctity of the examination was seriously compromised as two admit
cards had been issued to few of the candidates and there was no use of
OMR Sheets. They also submitted that manual evaluation was a very
crude way of conducting examination and it took very long for the results
to be published, throwing the entire system under doubts.
11.
After having heard the learned counsel for the parties and
having gone through the records, we are of the opinion that the Tribunal
Page No.# 9/14
was not justified in ordering the cancellation of the entire examination on
the grounds so raised by the respondents; more so, in view of the nonimpleadment of the successful candidates.
12.
That apart, more than 9(nine) years have passed since the
successful candidates have been discharging their duties as Mates.
Unsettling such employment at this stage would not be beneficial for the
system or for anybody else.
13.
The law with respect to cancellation of Public Examination is
well settled. Cancellation of Public Examination is an extreme step which
is resorted to only when the examination process is vitiated by mass
malpractices, systemic fraud or illegality going to the roots of the
selection process.
14.
In Sachin Kumar & Ors. -vs- Delhi Subordinate Service Selection
Board (DSSSB) & Ors. :: (2021) 4 SCC 631, the position in law with respect to
a judicial decision holding an examination to have been vitiated has
been laid down.
15.
The Supreme Court, after evaluating a number of judgments
postulated that essentially the answer to the issue turns upon whether the
irregularity in the process have taken place at a systemic level so as to
vitiate the sanctity of the process. In some cases, the authority
conducting the examination might itself come to the conclusion that as
a result of the subversion of the process for any supervening event or
circumstances rendering the process to lose its legitimacy, there would
be no option but to cancel the entire examination in its entirety. In this
Page No.# 10/14
situation, there is no fact finding exercise into individual acts involving use
of malpractices or unfair means. Such a situation would arise only when
there is a systemic failure of the process where it would be difficult to
segregate the tainted from the untainted participants in the process. The
other situation would be where some of the participants in the process
allege irregularities. In that case, it may well be possible to segregate
those persons or candidates at a particular centre to be subjected to reexamination and excluding the others from the process. This serves the
purpose of protecting the interest of the candidates who have done their
part and should not be slapped with any price for the wrong doings of
the others. Segregating the wrong doers and allowing the selection
process to be continued and taken to its logical conclusion is an
accepted principle of service jurisprudence, which stands on the
bedrock principles enshrined under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution
of India. Nonetheless, if there is evidence of systemic irregularities, the
entire process becomes vitiated.
16.
What the Supreme Court has emphasized is that whenever it is
possible to segregate persons who have indulged in malpractices and
the recruiting or examination taking body does not do so, then it would
be unfair to the diligent applicants who ought not to be subjected to the
consequences of cancellation of the entire process. This, in fact, would
be contrary to Article 14 of the Constitution of India because in that
event unequals would be found to have been treated equally. A
recruiting body, no doubt is subject to judicial control but only on settled
principles that the recruiting authority must have a measure of discretion
Page No.# 11/14
to take decisions in accordance with law which are best suited to
preserve the sanctity of the process.
[Also refer to Bihar School Examination Board –vs- Subhash
Chandra Sinha & Ors. :: (1970) 1 SCC 648; Anamica Mishra & Ors. -vs- U.P.
Public Service Commission, Allahabad & Ors. :: (1990) Supp SCC 692;
Madhyamic Shiksha Mandal, MP –vs- Abhilash Shiksha Prasar Samiti &
Ors. :: (1998) 9 SCC 236; Union of India & Ors. –vs- Rajesh P.U.,
Puthuvalnikathu & Anr. :: (2003) 7 SCC 285 & Inderpreet Singh Kahlon &
Ors. -vs- State of Punjab & Ors. :: (2006) 11 SCC 356].
17.
In Vanshika Yadav & Union of India & Ors. :: (2024) 9 SCC 743 ,
one of the latest pronouncements of the Supreme Court, the position of
law was clearly adumberated. A three Judges Bench of the Supreme
Court in this case has opined that it is a settled law that the cancellation
of an examination, either for the purposes of gaining admission to any
professional or other courses or for the purposes of recruitment to
Government posts, is justified only in cases where the sanctity of the
examination is found to be compromised at a systemic level. A Court can
direct cancellation of an examination or approve such cancellation by
the competent authority only if it is not possible to separate the tainted
candidates from untainted ones.
18.
Again, while taking reference of Amamica Mishra (supra),
Subhas Chandra Sinha (supra), Madhyamik Shiksha Mandal, M.P. (supra)
and Sachin Kumar (supra), the Supreme Court held that the purpose of
testing whether the integrity of the exam has been compromised at a
systemic level is to ensure that the cancellation of the examination which
has already taken place and the holding of a fresh examination is a
Page No.# 12/14
proportionate response. In that context, it was said that it is for this reason
that the Courts must assess the extent of the use of unfair means, and
separately, it must consider whether it is possible to separate tainted and
untainted candidates. The direction in the aforesaid decision is that a
holistic view is required to be taken by the Courts.
19.
How to arrive at such a conclusion viz. whether the
examination has suffered from widespread irregularities?
20.
The Courts have to ensure that the allegations of malpractice
are substantiated and that the materials on record point to that
conclusion. There must be at least some evidence to allow the Court to
reach that conclusion. However, it was also clarified that this standard of
test need not be unduly strict i.e. to say that it is not necessary that the
materials pointed out regarding irregularities ought to indicate that the
only conclusion which any prudent person would arrive at would be that
malpractice has taken place at a systemic level and not otherwise.
[Also refer to Anand Legal Aid Forum Trust –vs- Bihar Public
Service Commission & Ors. :: 2025 0 Supreme (Pat) 182 ].
21.
In the case at hand, segregation was not possible for the
reason that such candidates with double admit cards were never
impleaded. There is only a vague generalization that the examination
process was compromised.
This is not sufficient for a wholesale cancellation of the
examination result.
Page No.# 13/14
22.
That apart, we have already noted that there was no breach
of any directions in the advertisement, nor was it justified for the Tribunal
to lend credence to the submissions of the respondents/the failed
candidates, that OMR question answer system would have been better
and that manual evaluation gave rise to suspicion that the scrutiny would
not be appropriate.
23.
That the successful candidates have been discharging their
duties for more than 9(nine) years has also weighed with us in differing
with the opinion of the Tribunal.
24.
have
The credibility of the entire examination cannot be said to
been
destroyed.
The
change
of
examination
venue
for
administrative or security reasons do not per se vitiate the process,
particularly when no mala fide or breach is pleaded or proved. The
administrative exigencies are within the domain of the Examining
Authority and Courts ought not to interfere with such decisions sans
arbitrariness.
25.
The material on record does not disclose that the issuance of
double admit cards to a few candidates resulted in any undue
advantage or manipulation of results. If true, it can at best constitute an
isolated irregularity, not warranting wholesale cancellation. Mere
repetition of few questions across two different sittings does not establish
compromise of the purity of the examination.
26.
The Tribunal, in our estimation has failed to record any finding
of any systemic failure or fraud.
Page No.# 14/14
27.
Thus, we find the order passed by the Tribunal to be wholly
unsustainable in the eyes of law. Consequently, we have no other option
but to set aside the same.
28.
Both
the
writ
petitions
[WP(C)
No.8878/2019
&
WP(C)
No.8935/2019] are allowed accordingly.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
CHIEF
JUSTICE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review