Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally
signed by
ANURADHA
ANURADHA TIWARI
TIWARI
Date:
2026.01.16
17:08:58
+0530
2026:CGHC:2632-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRMP No. 240 of 2021
Sharad Agrawal S/o Shri Brij Bihari Agrawal Aged About 30 Years R/o
M-Ii, 48, Phase-2, Kabir Nagar, P. S. Kabir Nagar, Raipur District Raipur
Chhattisgarh
--- Petitioner
Versus
1 - State of Chhattisgarh Through The Thana Incharge, Purani Basti
Raipur District Raipur Chhattisgarh
2 - Umesh Agrawal S/o Late Shrikant Agrawal Aged About 40 Years R/o
Baniyapara, Near Agrawal Aata Chakki, Purani Basti, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
--- Respondents
CRMP No. 2082 of 2022
1 - Umesh Agrawal S/o Late Shri Shrikant Agrawal Aged About 44
Years R/o Agrawal Aata Chakki, Near Gopidas Goal Mandir,
Gopiyapara, Police Station Purani Basti, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
2 - Rajesh Agrawal S/o Late Shri Shrikant Agrawal Aged About 45
Years R/o Agrawal Aata Chakki, Near Gopidas Goal Mandir,
Gopiyapara, Police Station Purani Basti, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
---Petitioners
Versus
1 - State of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Ministry Of Home,
New
Mantralaya,
Chhattisgarh.
Indravati
Bhavan, Atal
Nagar,
New
Raipur,
2 - Superintendent of Police (S.P.) District Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
3 - The Station House Officer (S.H.O.) Police Station Kabir Nagar,
District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
4 - Smt. Sharda Agrawal S/o Late Shivendra Agrawal R/o M2/48,
Phase2, Kabir Nagar, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
5 - Rajesh Kumar. B. Singh Investigating Officer, Police Station Kabir
Nagar, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
... Respondents
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner in CRMP
No.240/2021
: Mr. J.K. Gupta, Advocate
For Petitioners in CRMP
: Mr. Devershi Thakur, Advocate
No.2082/2022 and
Respondent No.2 in CRMP
No.240/2021
For State
: Mr.
Priyank
Advocate
Rathi,
For Respondent No.4 in
CRMP No.2082/2022
: Ms. Aditi Singhvi, Advocate
Government
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Bibhu Datta Guru, Judge
Order on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
16.01.2026
1.
Heard Mr. J.K. Gupta, learned counsel for the petitioner in CRMP
No.240/2021 and Mr. Devershi Thakur, learned counsel for the
petitioners in CRMP No.2082/2022 and respondent No.2 in
CRMP No.240/2021. Also heard Mr. Priyank Rathi, learned
Government Advocate, appearing for the State and Ms. Aditi
Singhvi, learned counsel appearing for respondent No.4 in CRMP
No.2082/2022.
2.
In CRMP No.240/2021, the petitioner has prayed for following
relief(s) :“It is therefore prayed that this Hon'ble Court may
kindly be pleased to allow the instant review
application and order dated 31.10.2025 passed
in WPPIL No. 85/2025 particularly the directions
contained in Paragraph 16 thereof may kindly be
reviewed in larger interest of Justice.”
3.
In CRMP No.2082/2022, the petitioners have prayed for following
relief(s) :“It is therefore most respectfully prayed that this
Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to allow the
petition and quash the impugned FIR and entire
criminal
proceedings
initiated
against
the
petitioners pursuant to impugned FIR bearing
crime no.192/2021 for the offences punishable
U/s 67,67(a) of I.T Act & Sec. 506 of 1.P.C at
P.S.-Kabir Nagar, Dist: Raipur (CG), in the
interest of Justice.
It is further humbly & most respectfully prayed
that this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
direct to direct the respondent authorities to
proceed against the private respondents per law
along with Any other relief or reliefs that may be
deemed fit and proper
in the facts
and
circumstances of the case may kindly also be
granted in the interest of justice.”
4.
Brief facts of CRMP No.240/2021 are as follows :•
A complaint was lodged by the complainant, Shri Umesh
Agrawal, S/o Shrikant Agrawal, Resident of Baniya Para,
Purani Basti, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.), who is the elder
brother of the brother-in-law of the petitioner. The complaint
was filed on the apprehension that the petitioner was in
possession of a mobile number from which obscene
WhatsApp messages and erotic calls were allegedly received
by the complainant, his wife, and his younger brother
(brother-in-law of the petitioner). On the basis of the said
complaint, FIR No. 0279 was registered.
•
Pursuant to registration of the FIR, the respondent police
initiated
investigation
and
arrested
the
petitioner
on
26.08.2019. During the course of investigation, one laptop
and two mobile phones were seized from the possession of
the petitioner.
•
Thereafter, a final charge-sheet dated 23.10.2019 was filed,
which was primarily based on photocopies of screenshots
allegedly taken from the mobile phones of the complainant
and other persons. The seized laptop and mobile phones
were sent to the Forensic Science Laboratory for analysis.
•
The petitioner remained in judicial custody from 26.08.2019
and was subsequently enlarged on bail by order of this Court
passed in MCRC No. 6500/2019 dated 22.11.2019.
•
During the pendency of the trial, the petitioner filed an
application under Section 91 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure seeking a direction to the Trial Court to call for and
produce certain relevant documents, particularly the Call
Detail Records (CDRs) of the petitioner as well as of the
complainant for the period 01.06.2010 to 03.08.2019, as the
same were essential for proper adjudication of the case.
•
Despite the specific request for production of the said
documents, no reply was filed by the respondent, which fact is
duly reflected in the order sheets of the Trial Court.
•
Upon careful scrutiny of the materials placed on record along
with
the
charge-sheet,
including
the
photocopies
of
screenshots and the available CDRs, it is evident that no
prima facie case is made out against the petitioner and the
alleged offences are not substantiated by cogent or legally
admissible evidence.
•
In these circumstances, the petitioner has been constrained
to file the present CRMP No. 240/2021, seeking appropriate
relief from this Court, as continuation of the criminal
proceedings against the petitioner would amount to abuse of
the process of law.
5.
Brief facts of CRMP No.2082/2022 are as follows :•
An FIR dated 07.11.2021 was registered alleging that the
present petitioners had used electronic modes to upload
indecent
chats,
messages
and
photographs
of
the
complainant and her minor daughter on social media and
WhatsApp. On the basis of the said allegations, a complaint
was lodged before Police Station, Raipur, District Raipur
(C.G.), leading to registration of the impugned FIR.
•
It is relevant to note that despite the said complaint, initially no
action was taken against the present petitioners, and instead
Sharad Agrawal, brother of the complainant Smt. Sharda
Agrawal
(Respondent
No.4),
was
proceeded
against.
Subsequently, Respondent No.4 preferred Writ Petition
(Criminal) No. 539/2021, pursuant to which the present FIR
came to be registered, alleging involvement of the petitioners
in the alleged acts.
•
The petitioners were arrested in connection with the
impugned crime and were later enlarged on bail by this Court
in MCRC No. 4493/2022. After their release, the petitioners
came to know that while filing the charge-sheet, material facts
were deliberately suppressed by the investigating agency,
particularly the earlier complaints and enquiries wherein
allegations against Sharad Agrawal had been found to be
prima facie true. No permission under Section 173(6) Cr.P.C.
was sought for withholding such vital documents.
•
In a connected matter, upon a complaint made by
Respondent No.4, another FIR was registered at Police
Station Kabir Nagar, Raipur being Crime No. 192/2021, in
which the petitioners apprehended arrest and approached this
Court. Considering the facts and circumstances, this Court
was pleased to grant anticipatory bail by order dated
28.07.2022.
•
The petitioners submit that the impugned FIR is a direct
consequence of pressure exerted through WPCR No.
539/2021, and is nothing but an arm-twisting measure
adopted by the complainant to shield her brother Sharad
Agrawal, who is accused in multiple cases involving similar
allegations of misuse of electronic media for sexually abusive
content.
•
The
petitioners
themselves
are
victims
of
repeated
harassment through electronic means. In this regard, Crime
No. 279/2019 was registered at Police Station Purani Basti,
Raipur under Sections 507 IPC and 67-A of the IT Act,
wherein investigation revealed that the incriminating mobile
number belonged to Sharad Agrawal. He was granted bail in
MCRC No. 6500/2019 and subsequently challenged the
charge-sheet in CRMP No. 240/2021.
•
Several complaints lodged by the petitioners and their family
members, including Late Shri Shivendra Agrawal (husband of
the complainant), relating to identical modus operandi
adopted
by
Sharad Agrawal,
have
been
ignored
or
deliberately omitted from consideration in the present case.
Multiple FIRs, enquiries and CBCID reports have consistently
indicated Sharad Agrawal’s involvement in such offences.
•
The petitioners submit that continuation of the criminal
proceedings against them is a gross abuse of the process of
law, as no prima facie case is made out against them even if
the prosecution case is accepted in toto. The investigation
has been conducted in a biased and unfair manner,
suppressing material evidence favourable to the petitioners.
•
Hence, the petitioners have been constrained to file the
present CRMP No. 2082/2022, seeking appropriate relief(s),
including quashment of the impugned FIR/charge-sheet and
directions for a fair and proper investigation, as continuation
of the proceedings would amount to an abuse of the process
of law.
6.
Mr. J.K. Gupta, learned counsel for the petitioner in CRMP
No.240/2021 submits that the impugned charge-sheet is illegal
from its very inception and, therefore, liable to be quashed.
Learned counsel submits that the entire prosecution case rests
merely on photocopies of screenshots, purportedly taken from the
mobile phone of the complainant, without the complainant’s
mobile phone ever being seized, examined, or sent for forensic
analysis. No investigation whatsoever was carried out either by
the respondent police or by the Forensic Science Laboratory in
respect of the complainant’s device, rendering the foundation of
the charge-sheet wholly unsustainable.
7.
It is contended by Mr. Gupta that the alleged obscene
screenshots were, in fact, received on the mobile phone of the
real sister of the petitioner, bearing mobile number 9300608842,
and not on the mobile phones of the complainant or his family
members. Copies of such screenshots, obtained from the
petitioner’s sister, have been placed on record. Despite this, the
investigating agency, acting in collusion with the complainant, has
falsely implicated the petitioner without conducting a fair,
scientific, and legally permissible investigation. He further submits
that the investigation is vitiated by mala fide intent, as no effort
was made to obtain critical electronic evidence such as
WhatsApp server logs, call logs, IP addresses, cache data, or
temporary files either from the service providers or from
WhatsApp itself. In the absence of such primary electronic
evidence, no charge-sheet could legally have been filed merely
on the basis of unverified photocopies of screenshots.
8.
It is also pointed out by Mr. Gupta that the alleged WhatsApp
profile name “M1” is shown to have been created on 24.02.2009,
a
period
when
WhatsApp
did
not
even
exist,
clearly
demonstrating that the prosecution story is inherently absurd and
fabricated. This singular fact itself demolishes the credibility of the
charge-sheet and shows non-application of mind by the
investigating officer. He emphasizes that information obtained
under the Right to Information Act, 2005, categorically establishes
that the mobile numbers of the complainant and his family
members were never seized, nor were any panchnamas
prepared, nor were the devices forwarded for forensic or cyber
examination. Thus, the charge-sheet filed solely on photocopies
is per se illegal.
9.
It is argued by Mr. Gupta that although certain mobile numbers
allegedly belonging to the petitioner were seized and purportedly
sent to the FSL, no forensic report whatsoever has been received
till date. One of the seized devices was a basic keypad mobile
phone, incapable of supporting WhatsApp due to the absence of
a compatible operating system. In the absence of any forensic
confirmation, the continuation of prosecution is an abuse of the
process of law. He further submits that even the petitioner’s
sister, while deposing before the Women Cell, categorically
stated that although she had received certain calls, the voice was
not of the petitioner and that such acts could only be carried out
by a technically skilled third party. These crucial statements have
been ignored by the investigating agency.
10.
Lastly, it is contended by Mr. Gupta that despite claims of mental
harassment made by the complainant, no incriminating material
was recovered from the mobile phones of the complainant’s wife
or the wife of his younger brother. In the absence of legally
admissible electronic evidence linking the petitioner to the alleged
offence, the impugned charge-sheet does not disclose the
commission of any offence and is therefore liable to be quashed
to prevent miscarriage of justice and abuse of the criminal
process.
11.
Mr. Devershi Thakur, learned counsel for the petitioners in CRMP
No.2082/2022 and respondent No.2 in CRMP No.240/2021
submits that the impugned FIR is nothing but an arm-twisting
measure, engineered only to create a defence and protective
shield for the complainant’s brother Sharad Agrawal, who, as
borne out even from the CBCID reports, is the real perpetrator of
the alleged heinous acts. The entire prosecution case against the
petitioners is tainted by mala fides, as there exist multiple reports
and materials contradicting the very genesis and narration of the
alleged crime. He further submits that the complainant and other
family members had initially lodged complaints against unknown
persons, and upon discovering the involvement of Sharad
Agrawal, instead of allowing the investigation to reach its logical
conclusion, she invoked WPCR No. 539/2021 only to fabricate a
ground so as to divert the investigation and falsely implicate the
petitioners. It is urged that the petitioners are being prosecuted
for acts admittedly committed by Sharad Agrawal, thereby
subjecting them to gross abuse of the criminal process.
12.
It is submitted by Mr. Thakur that the investigation suffers from
serious procedural irregularities, inasmuch as vital documents,
statements and expert reports recorded during investigation,
including those favourable to the accused have been deliberately
withheld, without any application or justification under Section
173(6) Cr.P.C. He emphasizes that the prosecution has never
claimed any privilege before the Trial Court, nor furnished
reasons in writing for suppressing such material, as mandatorily
required by law. Placing reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Vinay Tyagi v. Irshad Ali, (2013) 5 SCC 762,
it is contended that a fair, impartial and honest investigation is an
integral part of criminal jurisprudence, and the endeavour of the
investigating agency must always be to bring the truth before the
Court, not to secure a conviction by suppressing the material
facts.
13.
Mr. Thakur lastly submits that the contradictions apparent on the
face of the complaint and the FIR, coupled with suppression of
material evidence, clearly demonstrate that the investigating
agency
has
acted
hand-in-glove
with
the
complainant.
Continuation of the criminal proceedings against the petitioners
would therefore result in grave miscarriage of justice and the
same may be quashed.
14.
On the other hand, Mr. Priyank Rathi, learned Government
Advocate appearing on behalf of the State submits that the
charge-sheet has been filed after due investigation in accordance
with law; the materials collected during investigation disclose a
prima facie case against the accused; the scope of interference
at this stage is limited; and the disputed questions of fact,
including appreciation of electronic evidence, can only be
adjudicated during trial. It is therefore contended that no ground
is made out for quashment of the FIR or charge-sheet and the
petitions deserve to be dismissed.
15.
Ms. Aditi Singhvi, learned counsel appearing for respondent No.4
in CRMP No.2082/2022 submits that the present petition is wholly
misconceived, vexatious and an abuse of the process of law, filed
with an oblique motive to derail the criminal proceedings arising
out of serious and heinous allegations involving transmission of
obscene and sexually explicit material through electronic modes,
including against a minor child. It is submitted that the impugned
FIR dated 07.11.2021 was registered strictly in accordance with
law on the basis of specific allegations made by the complainant,
which clearly disclose the commission of cognizable offences.
The contents of the FIR, read as a whole, prima facie make out
offences under the relevant provisions of the IPC and the
Information Technology Act, and therefore no interference is
warranted in the exercise of inherent jurisdiction.
16.
Ms. Singhvi submits that respondent No.4 emphatically denies
the allegation that the FIR is an arm-twisting measure or that it
has been lodged to save her brother, Sharad Agrawal. It is
submitted that such allegations are baseless, speculative and
malicious, aimed solely at shifting the focus away from the
culpability of the petitioners. The attempt to rely upon selective
portions of prior complaints, parallel proceedings, or third-party
reports is a matter of defence, which cannot be gone into at the
stage of considering a petition for quashment. She submits that
the investigation was carried out by the competent police
authorities and culminated in filing of the charge-sheet after due
application of mind. The petitioners’ contention that certain
devices were not seized or that forensic examination is allegedly
deficient raises disputed questions of fact, which require
appreciation of evidence and expert opinion and are therefore
matters exclusively within the domain of the trial Court.
17.
It is submitted by Ms. Singhvi that the reliance placed by the
petitioners on alleged contradictions, WhatsApp log data, IP
addresses, or forensic reports pertains to issues of evidentiary
value and admissibility, which cannot be assessed in proceedings
under Section 482 Cr.P.C. At this stage, the court is only required
to see whether the uncontroverted allegations and material
collected disclose the commission of an offence, which they
clearly do. The petitioners are attempting to give a colour of mala
fides to a lawful prosecution by making sweeping allegations
against the complainant, investigating officers and even superior
authorities, without any cogent or acceptable material on record.
Mere allegations of bias or unfair investigation do not, by
themselves, constitute a ground for quashing a charge-sheet.
18.
It is contended by Ms. Singhvi that the petitioners have been
afforded all procedural safeguards, including grant of bail, and
have adequate remedies before the Trial Court to seek
production
of
documents,
cross-examine
witnesses
and
challenge the prosecution evidence in accordance with law. The
extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court cannot be invoked to
conduct a mini-trial or to pre-empt a lawful prosecution. She
further submits that crimes involving cyber-offences, obscenity
and exploitation through electronic media, particularly where a
minor is involved, have serious societal ramifications, and such
matters ought to be tried on merits rather than being scuttled at
the threshold.
19.
We have heard learned counsel appearing for the petitioners, the
learned State counsel, as well as learned counsel appearing for
the private respondent, at length, and have carefully examined
and considered the pleadings, the rival submissions advanced on
behalf of the parties, the documents and annexures placed on
record along with the petitions, as also the material relied upon
during the course of arguments.
20.
In CRMP No. 240/2021, it is evident that the foundation of the
impugned charge-sheet is based entirely on photocopies of
screenshots allegedly received on mobile phones purportedly
belonging to the complainant and his family members. The
investigation record demonstrates that no attempt was made to
seize, examine, or analyze the devices of the complainant or his
family, nor were critical electronic evidences such as WhatsApp
server logs, IP addresses, call logs, cache data, or temporary
files sought from the service provider. The alleged WhatsApp
profile “M1” predates the inception of WhatsApp, clearly
indicating
fabrication.
Further,
the
petitioner’s
sister
has
categorically stated that the calls in question were not of the
petitioner and could have only been made by a technically skilled
third party. The absence of legally admissible electronic evidence
renders the charge-sheet wholly unsustainable and continuation
of proceedings would constitute an abuse of process.
21.
In CRMP No. 2082/2022, the Court notes that the petitioners
have been implicated in proceedings which, prima facie, appear
to be motivated by an intent to shield another individual, Sharad
Agrawal, who has been repeatedly found to be the actual
perpetrator in similar instances. Multiple complaints, FIRs, and
expert reports indicate the involvement of Sharad Agrawal, while
the petitioners have been falsely implicated. The investigation
suffers from procedural irregularities, including suppression of
material evidence favorable to the petitioners, in violation of the
mandate of Section 173(6) Cr.P.C., as highlighted in the judgment
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Vinay Tyagi (supra).
Continuation of the criminal proceedings against the petitioners
would therefore amount to gross abuse of the process of law.
22.
This Court recognizes that the extraordinary powers under
Section 482 Cr.P.C. are to be exercised sparingly and with due
caution, primarily to prevent miscarriage of justice or abuse of the
process of law. In the present cases, the Court finds that:
• The investigation in both matters is marred by material
irregularities and suppression of critical electronic evidence.
• The charge-sheets are founded on unverified, photocopied
material which does not constitute legally admissible
evidence.
• Prima facie, no offence is made out against the petitioners in
the absence of proper forensic corroboration or examination
of devices.
• There exists a clear possibility of mala fide motive and
manipulation of legal process in both cases, resulting in
harassment of the petitioners.
23.
In view of the above, the Court is satisfied that the continuation of
criminal
proceedings
in
CRMP
No.240/2021
and
CRMP
No.2082/2022 would result in manifest injustice to the petitioners
and would constitute abuse of the process of law. Accordingly, in
exercise of its inherent jurisdiction, the Court deems it just,
proper, and necessary to intervene at this stage to prevent such
injustice.
24.
Accordingly, in CRMP No. 240/2021:
a) The impugned charge-sheet dated 23.10.2019, filed in
connection with FIR No. 0279/2019 at Police Station
Purani Basti, Raipur, is hereby quashed.
b) All criminal proceedings arising therefrom, including
further investigation or trial, are stayed and shall not be
continued against the petitioner.
c) The respondent authorities are directed not to take any
coercive action against the petitioner in relation to the
said FIR.
25.
In CRMP No. 2082/2022:
a) The impugned FIR dated 07.11.2021 bearing Crime
No. 192/2021 at Police Station Kabir Nagar, Raipur, and
the entire criminal proceedings emanating therefrom, are
hereby quashed.
b) All coercive steps, including arrest, investigation, or
trial proceedings against the petitioners arising from the
said FIR, shall cease forthwith.
c) The respondent authorities are directed to ensure that
the petitioners are not subjected to harassment or
intimidation in any form in connection with the said FIR.
26.
In the result, both CRMP No.240/2021 and CRMP No.2082/2022
are allowed in their entirety, and the impugned FIRs, charge-
sheets, and all criminal proceedings arising therefrom stand
quashed to prevent further harassment of the petitioners and to
safeguard the principles of justice.
27.
A certified copy of this order shall be forwarded to the trial Court
concerned for its information and necessary compliance forthwith,
and the authorities concerned are directed to act strictly in
accordance with the directions contained in this order.
28.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Sd/(Bibhu Datta Guru)
Judge
Anu
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review