Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Decided on: 04.05.2026
+
CRL.M.C. 9293/2025
UJJAWAL BHARDWAJ & ANR.
Through: Ms.
Shinmila
Advocate.
versus
STATE (NCT OF DELHI)
Through:
.....Petitioners
Ngasainao,
.....Respondent
Ms. Manjeet Arya, APP for State.
SI Sanjay K., PS Hauz Khas.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE PRATEEK JALAN
PRATEEK JALAN, J. (ORAL)
CRL.M.A. 13766/2026 (Exemption)
Exemption allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
The application stands disposed of.
CRL.M.A. 13765/2026 (early hearing)
By way of this application, the petitioner seeks early hearing of the
captioned petition. For the reasons stated therein, the application is
allowed, and the petition is taken up for hearing.
The application stands disposed of.
CRL.M.C. 9293/2025
1.
By way of the present petition, the petitioner assails an order
passed by the learned Sessions Court in proceedings arising out of FIR
No. 404/2022 dated 18.10.2022, registered at Police Station Hauz Khas
under Sections 3(1)(r), 3(1)(s) and 3(1)(v) of the Scheduled Castes and
Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989. The prayer clause
Signed By:BHUPENDER
12:05
CRL.M.C. 9293/2025
in the present petition reads as under:
“1.
Set aside the impugned order dated 31.08.2024, passed by the
Ld. Sessions Court, whereby the Applicant’s application under
Section 348 BNSS (311 CrPC) for recalling PW- 1 Sh. Rajesh
Lodhiwal, for further cross-examination, was dismissed and
consequently direct the recall of PW-1 Sh. Rajesh Lodhiwal for
further and complete cross-examination;
2.
Pass such other or further orders as this Hon’ble Court may
deem fit and proper in the interest of justice.”
2.
Although the prayer clause refers to an impugned order dated
31.08.2024, whereby the petitioners’ application under Section 348 of the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 [“BNSS”] (corresponding to
Section 311 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 [“CrPC”]) is stated
to have been dismissed, it is clarified by Ms. Shinmila Ngasainao, learned
counsel for the petitioners, that the said application was, in fact,
dismissed by a subsequent order dated 12.02.2025, which has been
handed over in Court.
3.
I have heard Ms. Ngasainao, and Ms. Manjeet Arya, learned
Additional Public Prosecutor.
4.
The FIR was registered at the instance of the complainant, who was
examined as PW-1. The petitioners are the accused in the proceedings.
5.
The chronology of events which led to the impugned order is as
follows:
a. The complainant’s examination-in-chief was recorded before the
learned Sessions Court on 08.04.2024, and cross-examination was
deferred at the request of learned counsel for the petitioners.
b. On the next date of hearing, i.e., 18.04.2024, although PW-1 was
present, an adjournment was sought on the ground of non-
Signed By:BHUPENDER
12:05
CRL.M.C. 9293/2025
availability of learned counsel for the petitioners herein.
c. Thereafter, on 08.05.2024, PW-1 was partly cross-examined;
however, further cross-examination was deferred at the request of
learned counsel for the petitioners, for production of certain
documents.
d. On
subsequent
dates,
being
10.05.2024
and
28.05.2024,
adjournments were again sought on behalf of the petitioners despite
the presence of PW-1 for cross-examination.
e. On the next two dates of hearing, i.e., 06.06.2024 and 01.07.2024,
the cross-examination could not proceed for reasons not
attributable to the petitioners.
f. When PW-1 was once again present on 31.08.2024 for further
cross-examination, an adjournment was sought on behalf of the
petitioners. The learned Sessions Court, however, declined the
request, noting that several opportunities had already been granted
to the accused persons for completing the cross-examination.
Consequently, the right of the petitioners to further cross-examine
PW-1 was closed.
6.
The petitioners thereafter filed an application under Section 311 of
CrPC [corresponding to Section 348 of BNSS], seeking recall of the
witness for further cross-examination. The said application came to be
rejected by order dated 12.02.2025, having regard to the repeated
adjournments sought on behalf of the petitioners, with the following
observations:
“5.
In the above noted order, the repeated adjournments sought
on behalf of the accused persons and the accommodation granted by
the court have been manifested, which in my view, dis-entitle the
Signed By:BHUPENDER
12:05
CRL.M.C. 9293/2025
accused persons from invoking the power of the court by way of
application under section 311 CrPC. No doubt, the import and
purpose of the application under section 311 CrPC is to recall the
witness whose evidence may be essential for the just decision of the
case, but it is also a settled legal proposition that this provision
cannot be exercised as a tool in the hands of the accused persons
so as to take the trial for granted by squandering the repeated
opportunities granted for the cross-examination of witnesses and
thereafter seek to invoke the provision of section 311 CrPC for
recalling the witnesses. The power under section 311 CrPC is not to
be exercised in a routine manner to recall the witness as and when
the counsel for accused persons moves an application expressing his
unavailability on the earlier dates for some reasons. In the
application in hand, though it is submitted that the crossexamination of PW1 Rajesh Lodhiwal could not take place as the
main counsel was not available on the scheduled date for valid
reasons, what were the valid reasons which prevented the counsel
from appearing on the given dates have not been specified. It is
already noted in the order dated 31.08.2024 that it is not on one date
that the counsel for accused persons was not present for crossexamining of PW1, but on numerous occasions, this was the position.
Thus, I do not find any tenable ground to allow the present
application to recall PWI Rajesh Lodhiwal for his further crossexamination.”1
7.
The present petition came to be filed after a lapse of approximately
10 months thereafter, i.e., in December 2025, by which time, it is
submitted, the trial had progressed substantially and all prosecution
witnesses, except the Investigating Officer, had already been examined.
8.
In the aforesaid circumstances, I do not consider it appropriate to
exercise the inherent jurisdiction of this Court. It is evident from the
chronology of events recorded hereinabove, which remains undisputed,
that several opportunities were granted to the petitioners to complete the
cross-examination of the complainant [PW-1]; however, adjournments
were repeatedly sought on one ground or another.
Emphasis supplied.
Signed By:BHUPENDER
12:05
CRL.M.C. 9293/2025
9.
Even after the order dated 31.08.2024, whereby the right to further
cross-examine PW-1 was closed, the accused persons approached the
learned Sessions Court under Section 311 of CrPC [corresponding to
Section 348 of BNSS] only after a lapse of approximately five and a half
months, and thereafter approached this Court after a further delay of
nearly 10 months.
10.
While the jurisdiction under Section 311 of CrPC [corresponding
to Section 348 of BNSS] is undoubtedly available to secure the ends of
justice, the Court is equally required to examine the conduct of the party
in its entirety, and determine whether such conduct discloses a dilatory
approach or an attempt to obstruct the orderly progress of the trial.
11.
In this context, the judgment of the Supreme Court in State (NCT
of Delhi) v. Shiv Kumar Yadav2 underscores that the power to recall a
witness is not to be exercised as a matter of course, but only where it is
shown to be essential for a just decision, supported by tangible reasons.
The relevant observations are as follows:
“…….Certainly recall could be permitted if essential for the just
decision but not on such consideration as has been adopted in the
present case. Mere observation that recall was necessary “for
ensuring fair trial” is not enough unless there are tangible reasons
to show how the fair trial suffered without recall. Recall is not a
matter of course and the discretion given to the court has to be
exercised judiciously to prevent failure of justice and not
arbitrarily. While the party is even permitted to correct its bona
fide error and may be entitled to further opportunity even when
such opportunity may be sought without any fault on the part of
the opposite party, plea for recall for advancing justice has to be
bona fide and has to be balanced carefully with the other relevant
considerations including uncalled for hardship to the witnesses
and uncalled for delay in the trial. Having regard to these
considerations, we do not find any ground to justify the recall of
(2016) 2 SCC 402.
Signed By:BHUPENDER
12:05
CRL.M.C. 9293/2025
witnesses already examined.”3
12.
The scope and ambit of Section 311 of CrPC [corresponding to
Section 348 of BNSS] has been further elucidated by the Supreme Court
in Swapan Kumar Chatterjee v. CBI4, wherein the Court has clarified the
nature of the power conferred under the said provision as follows:
“11. It is well settled that the power conferred under Section 311
should be invoked by the court only to meet the ends of justice. The
power is to be exercised only for strong and valid reasons and it
should be exercised with great caution and circumspection. The
court has vide power under this section to even recall witnesses for
re-examination or further examination, necessary in the interest of
justice, but the same has to be exercised after taking into
consideration the facts and circumstances of each case. The power
under this provision shall not be exercised if the court is of the
view that the application has been filed as an abuse of the process
of law.
12. Where the prosecution evidence has been closed long back and
the reasons for non-examination of the witness earlier are not
satisfactory, the summoning of the witness at belated stage would
cause great prejudice to the accused and should not be allowed.
Similarly, the court should not encourage the filing of successive
applications for recall of a witness under this provision.”5
13.
In the present case, the petitioners failed to complete the cross-
examination of the complainant on several occasions, and thereafter
approached the learned Sessions Court, as well as this Court, seeking
relief only after substantial and unexplained delay. In the meanwhile,
other witnesses have now been examined, with the sole exception of the
Investigating Officer. If at all the petitioners genuinely wished to
complete the cross examination of PW-1, they ought to have taken their
Emphasis supplied.
(2019) 14 SCC 328.
Emphasis supplied.
Signed By:BHUPENDER
12:05
CRL.M.C. 9293/2025
remedies expeditiously, both after the orders dated 31.08.2024 and
12.02.2025. The conduct of the petitioners displays unexplained dilatory
tactics, which have the effect of undue delay in the progress of trial.
14.
In these circumstances, this Court is not inclined to exercise its
inherent jurisdiction to direct recall of the complainant. The petition,
alongwith the pending application, is therefore dismissed.
15.
It is clarified that this Court has not expressed any opinion on the
merits of the case, and the rights and contentions of the parties are left
open to be considered by the appropriate Court, in accordance with law.
PRATEEK JALAN, J
MAY 4, 2026
‘pv’/SD/
Signed By:BHUPENDER
12:05
CRL.M.C. 9293/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review