Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/14
GAHC010012262025
2026:GAU-AS:4684
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/300/2025
SMTI CHANDRAWATI SRIVASTAV
DAUGHTER OF LATE S. S. LAL SHRIVASTAVA AND WIFE OF UDAI PRATAP
SINGH, PERMANENT RESIDENT OF SARAYA MOTALIKAY, HEMAY, MAU,
UTTAR PRADESH- 275301 PRESENTLY RESIDING AT C/O 99 APO, EASTERN
BASE WORKSHOP (GREF), B.P. TINALI, TEZPUR, ASSAM, PIN 784151
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND ORS
THROUGH SECRETARY, GOVT. OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF DEFENCE,
BORDER ROAD WING, 4TH FLOOR B WING, SENA BHAWAN, NEW DELHI110011.
2:THE DIRECTOR GENERAL
BORDER ROADS ORGANISATION
MINISTRY OF DEFENSE
SEEMA SADAK BHAWAN
RING ROAD
DELHI CANTT.
NEW DELHI- 110010.
3:tTHE OFFICER IN CHARGE
RECORD OFFICE GENERAL RESERVE ENGINEER FORCE GREF
DIGHT CAMP
BUS STOP
MAHASKIBASTI
ST DNYANESWAR ROAD
KUSMADE COLONY
KALAS
PINE
Page No.# 2/14
MAHARASHTRA
4:MAJOR
RECORD OFFICE GENERAL RESERVE ENGINEER FORCE GREF
DIGHT CAMP
BUS STOP
MAHASKIBASTI
ST DNYANESWAR ROAD
KUSMADE COLONY
KALAS
PINE
MAHARASHTRA
5:SENIOR ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER STAFF OFFICER
RECORD OFFICE GENERAL RESERVE ENGINEER FORCE GREF
DIGHT CAMP
BUS STOP
MAHASKIBASTI
ST DNYANESWAR ROAD
KUSMADE COLONY
KALAS
PINE
MAHARASHTRA
6:LIEUTENANT COLONEL
RECORD OFFICE GENERAL RESERVE ENGINEER FORCE GREF
DIGHT CAMP
BUS STOP
MAHASKIBASTI
ST DNYANESWAR ROAD
KUSMADE COLONY
KALAS
PINE
MAHARASHTRA
7:ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR GENERAL
BORDER ROADS (EAST)
HQ
ADDL DGBR EAST (GREF)
JALUKBARI
NEAR LANKESHWAR TEMPLE
GUWAHATI
ASSAM
PIN-781013
8:THE COMMANDANT
EASTERN BASE WORKSHOP (EBW) GENERAL RESERVE ENGINEER
FORCE GREF
Page No.# 3/14
TEZPUR-784151
C/O-99 APO
9:ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER
FOR ADDL DGBR EAST (GREF)
JALUKBARI
NEAR LANKESHWAR TEMPLE
GUWAHATI
ASSAM
PIN-78101
Advocate for the Petitioner
: KHALID MOHAMMED, MD F FARIDI
Advocate for the Respondent : MR. U K GOSWAMI (C.G.C),
Linked Case : WP(C)/6914/2024
UDAI PRATAP SINGH AND ANR
S/O- AMAR NATH SINGH
PERMANENT R/O- TEHSIL KHAJANI
VILLAGE- HARIHAR PURWA
DIST- GORAKHPUR
UTTAR PRADESH-273212
PRESENTLY RESIDING AT C/O 99 APO
EASTERN BASE WORKSHOP (GREF)B. P TINIALI
TEZPUR
ASSAM
PIN-784151
2: CHANDRAWATI AHRIVASTAV
D/O- LATE SS LAL SHRIVASTAVA
W/O- UDAI PRATAP SINGH
PERMANENT R/O- SARAYA
MAU
UTTAR PRADESH-273212
PRESENTLY RESIDING AT C/O 99 APO
EASTERN BASE WORKSHOP (GREF)B. P TINIALI
Page No.# 4/14
TEZPUR
ASSAM
PIN-784151
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 8 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY (BR)
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
GOVT. OF INDIA
(BRDB))
ROOM NO. 418
B WING
4TH FLOOR
SENA BHAWAN
NEW DELHI- 110011.
2:THE DIRECTOR GENERAL
BORDER ROADS ORGANISATION
SEEMA SADAK BHAWAN
RING ROAD
DELHI CANTT.
NEW DELHI- 110010.
3:THE OFFICER IN CHARGE
(OIC)
RECORD OFFICE GENERAL RESERVE ENGINEER FORCE
(GREF) DIGHT CAMP
BUS STOP
MAHASKIBASTI
ST DNYANESHWAR RD
KUSMADE COLONY
KALAS
PUNE MAHARASHTRA-15
4:MAJOR
RECORD OFFICE
(OIC)
RECORD OFFICE GENERAL RESERVE ENGINEER FORCE
(GREF) DIGHT CAMP
BUS STOP
MAHASKIBASTI
ST DNYANESHWAR RD
KUSMADE COLONY
KALAS
PUNE MAHARASHTRA-15
5:SENIOR ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER
Page No.# 5/14
RECORD OFFICE GENERAL RESERVE ENGINEER FORCE
(GREF) DIGHT CAMP
BUS STOP
MAHASKIBASTI
ST DNYANESHWAR RD
KUSMADE COLONY
KALAS
PUNE MAHARASHTRA-15
6:LIEUTENANT COLONEL
RECORD OFFICE GENERAL RESERVE ENGINEER FORCE
(GREF) DIGHT CAMP
BUS STOP
MAHASKIBASTI
ST DNYANESHWAR RD
KUSMADE COLONY
KALAS
PUNE MAHARASHTRA-15
7:ADDL. DIRECTOR GENERAL BORDER ROADS (EAST)
HQ
ADDL
DGBR
EAST (GREF)
JALUKBARI
NEAR LANKESWAR TEMPLE
GUWAHATI
ASSAM
PIN-781013
8:THE COMMANDANT
EASTERN BASE WORKSHOP (EBW)
GENERAL RESERVE ENGINEER FORCE (GREF)
TEZPUR
PIN-784151
C/O-99 APO
9:ASSTT. ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER
FOR ADDL DGBR (EAST)
GENERAL RESERVE ENGINEER FORCE
JALUKBARI
NEAR LANKESWAR TEMPLE
GUWAHATI
ASSAM
PIN-781013
-----------Advocate for : MD F FARIDI
Page No.# 6/14
Advocate for : DY.S.G.I. appearing for THE UNION OF INDIA AND 8 ORS
BEFORE
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE SHAMIMA JAHAN
Advocate for the Petitioners
: Md. F. Faridi
Advocate for the Respondents
: Mr. S.P. Choudhury,Mr. U. K. Goswami (CGC)
Date on which judgment is reserved
: NIL
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 26.03.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of
the operative part of the judgment
:
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced
: Full judgment
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. F. Faridi, learned counsel for the petitioners. Also heard Mr. S. P.
Choudhury as well as Mr. U. K. Goswami, learned counsels for all the
respondents.
2.
By this application filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the
petitioners have prayed for spouse posting at one particular post. The
petitioners have also challenged the posting and transfer order dated
17.08.2024 by which petitioner no.1 transferred to Jammu Tawi and order dated
28.08.2024 by which petitioner no.2 was transferred to Silapathar.
3.
It is the case of the petitioner that both of them were working under the
Page No.# 7/14
General Reserve Engineer Force, petitioner no.1 as Operator Excavating Machine
(OEM) and petitioner no.2 was working as MSW PNR in the Eastern Base
Workshop (EBW), General Reserve Engineer Force (GREF), Tezpur.
4.
Both the petitioners were working in the organization since 2018 and 2003
respectively under the said graft. The petitioners states that while they were
working in their respective post at Tezpur, the respondent no.4 issued an order
dated 17.08.2024 for the posting and transfer of General Reserve Engineer
Force personnel, by which as stated above the petitioner no.1 was transferred
to Jammu Tawi and petitioner no.2 was transferred to Silapathar.
5.
The petitioners states that they have a minor child aged about 4 years and
being aggrieved by the posting the petitioner no.2 submitted a representation
on 03.08.2024 stating inter alia that both the petitioners are employed in the
same department and are parents to a 3 years old child and that posting at
different places would create hardships in raising their child. Accordingly,
petitioner no.2 requested the respondent authorities to consider granting
spouse posting in the same unit at a particular place. The petitioner no.2 had
also apprised the authorities of an ongoing legal dispute with her brother
regarding family property which according to her has caused immense hardship
and that posting at a different station from her husband would exaggerate her
problems which would have an effect upon her ability to discharge her duties.
6.
The said representation was forwarded by the Administrative Officer,
Estate and Finance Officer, on behalf of Officiating Commandant. However
respondent authorities thorough a letter dated 02.09.2024, replied that the post
of OEM which petitioner no.1 was holding was not present in some of the
selected choice stations. It be stated here that the petitioner no 2 while giving
her representation had enumerated 5 nos. of choice stations as per the ROI.
Page No.# 8/14
The authorities apprised her that she may file another representation.
7.
Thereafter, the petitioner no.2 submitted a fresh representation on
31.08.2025 to the respondent authorities by referring to her earlier
representation and she requested for spouse posting again. She has again
reiterated the reasons of her child to be raised and her family disputes. The said
representation was again forwarded by the authorities concerned. But the
respondent authorities informed that the posting orders were issued prior to the
receipt of the representation by petitioner no.2. It was intimated that the
petitioner has to submit representation 6months before the completion of the
tenure as per the alleged guidelines and as such the representation given by the
petitioner was not considered.
8.
Thereafter, petitioner no.2 had given yet another representation on
28.10.2024 stating inter alia that she was not aware of the 6 months advance
application and that she had given representation beforehand which was
rejected on one ground or the other. She therefore requested the respondent
authorities either to transfer her to a place near her husband’s posting or to
transfer her husband to a station near her posting.
9.
This representation was also rejected by the respondent authorities saying
that indication of choice of stations will not confer a right for posting and that
posting will be determined on the basis of the availability of the vacancies. The
petitioner no.2 was directed to proceed to the new place of posting.
10.
Mr. Faridi, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the rejection of
the representation on the grounds that giving choice posting is not a matter of
right or representation to be given 6 months before the tenure gets over or
none availability of vacancies are not tenable in the facts and eyes of law. He
Page No.# 9/14
submits that by posting order dated 17.08.2024, petitioner no.1 was transferred
from Tezpur to Jammu Tawi and by order dated 28.08.2024, petitioner no.2,
was transferred from Tezpur to Silapathar. He submitted that various
representations were given to the respondent authorities requesting spouse
posting and the same were rejected on the grounds as stated above.
11.
He placed reliance on the office memorandum dated 30.08.2009, wherein
it is stated that when spouses worked in the same department and if post are
available they may be mandatorily be posted at the same station. He has also
relied upon the office memorandum dated 24.11.2022, which states, inter alia,
that for enhancing the status of women in all walks of life and in order to enable
them to lead a normal family life, as well as to ensure the education and welfare
of children, the posting of husband and wife who are in Government service
should be at the same station. The said instructions were directed to be followed
by all departments in letter and spirit. It was further reiterated in the office
memorandum that spouses working in the same department should mandatorily
be posted at the same station, subject, of course, to the rider that the posts are
available.
12.
The said memorandum also provides that the spouse posting should be at
one place till the children attained 18 years of age. He also has relied on
chapter-24 of the Record Office Instructions (ROI) wherein, it is provided that
female employees would be asked 5 choice stations and efforts will be made to
post them to one of the choice stations.
13.
Furthermore, it is provided that efforts will also be made to the best
extent possible, to post husband and wife in the same station/unit/formation if
both the husband and wife are GREF employees. However subject to
requirement and constraints of the Organization. He as such submits that in
Page No.# 10/14
consonance with the said instructions the petitioner no.2 had given 5 stations of
her choice but the respondent authorities have not given any heed by saying
that the post of OEM is not available in few of the stations.
14.
Learned counsel has also relied on the instructions which provides that
after the posting order within 45 days representation can be made and he
submits that nowhere in the instructions or in the memorandum the
requirement of giving representation 6 months prior to the expiration of the
tenure is provided for to which the learned counsel for the respondent also
could not placed the said requirements.
15.
The learned counsel also submits that as per amendment to the office
memorandum dated 24.11.2022, it is provides that if the vacancy is not
available for both the husband and wife to be accommodated in the same
station the wife or the husband should be accommodated in the nearby station.
As such he submits that the petitioner no. 1 and 2 be accommodated at one
station and if it is not possible then at least the husband or the wife may be
accommodated in the nearby area and he also submits that the posting can be
done anywhere in the Country but they should be posted together or the nearby
areas as stated above.
16.
Mr. S. P. Choudhury, learned counsel for the respondents by relying on the
affidavit filed by him submits that the petitioner no.1 and 2 were posted in
Tezpur before they were transferred vide orders dated 17.08.2024 as well as
28.08.2024 and that he submits that back to back spouse posting is not
permissible under the rules. He submitted that the petitioner no.2 had served
more than 14.75 years in western sector and only 6.67 years in Eastern Sector
and that she served in most attractive area/soft area since her appointment in
July 2003 whereas, petitioner no.1 had only 6.5 years of total service in the soft
Page No.# 11/14
area since August 2021 and that the posting orders has been issued by
balancing their service tenure. He relies on the amendment to the office
memorandum dated 24.11.2022, in which it is stated that husband and wife
being GREF employees would be posted in the same station either in soft
area/most attractive area or Hard Area/ extremely Hostile Area/ High Hard Area/
High Altitude Area as per service provide and that choice of posting should be
considered only on grounds of higher education of children.
17.
It is further provided that if both the husband and wife are due for high
altitude area they may be considered for high altitude area units of course on
willingness of the couple. It also provides that when the husband is due for High
Altitude Area the wife may be considered to any station near the high altitude
area and that no back to back spouse posting should be applicable. He has also
pointed out that couples will be liable to serve separately in case of exigencies
of service and no one can claim spouse posting as a right.
18.
He has also submitted that specific period needs to be served by the
employees working in the GREF in respect of various areas that is
HAA/HHA/HA/EHA/SA. Accordingly, he submits that the posting orders to both
the petitioners are not illegal and the petitioners should go and join the
respective post at the respective places.
19.
To substantiate his arguments Mr. S. P. Choudhury, relies on two
judgments passed by the Hon’ble Apex Court in
(i) Union of India Vs. S.L. Abbas reported in (1993) 4 SCC 357 wherein
it has been held that “order of transfer is an incident of Govt. service and that
spouse posting is although provided for but the same does not confer upon the
employee any legal enforceable right”.
(ii) State of UP Vs. Siya Ram & Anr. reported in (2004) 7 SCC 405
wherein, the Apex Court had held that “the particular employee cannot claim to
Page No.# 12/14
stay at one particular place and the transfer is a condition of service necessary
in public interest and in the public Administration and unless the same is done
with some malafide exercise it cannot be interfered with”.
20.
I have heard the counsels and I have gone through the records. It is
noticed that the spouse posting is provided for under the various memorandum
and instructions provided for by the Govt. of India Ministry of Personnel Public
Grievances and Pension department of personal and training establishment and
it has been provided that the husband and wife should be posted as far as
possible at the same station so that there is enhancement of women status as
well as the children should get proper education and upbringing.
21.
The said policy has been followed in all the central services as well as
directed to be followed in all the departments. It is noticed that although a
spouse posting is not a matter of right but is has been provided for in various
memorandum and in the instructions that as far as possible the husband and
wife should be stationed at one particular place especially due to the fact that
the children should have a proper upbringing.
22.
Petitioner no.2 had made representation a number of times the first being
on 03.08.2024 that is before the transfer and posting of the petitioners
intimating the authorities that she has a 3 year old child and that she would
face problems in taking care of the child and that she has family problems too
and prayed by way of the said representation that her husband may be posted
at the same station as she was and she had given 5 places of posting that is
Tezpur, Chandigarh, Gangtok, Udhampur and Pathankot.
23.
The said representation however was rejected on the ground that the post
of OEM, which her husband is holding is not authorized in some of the selected
choice stations, which makes it clear that in few of the choice stations the OEM
Page No.# 13/14
post is available. It is not in respect of all the 5 stations but in few of them it is
available. As such, the rejection order is not proper. Thereafter, she made
another application with the same prayer but the said representation was again
rejected on the ground that the application for spouse posting has to be
submitted 6 months before the completion of tenure.
24.
The said reason for rejection is untenable inasmuch as it is nowhere
provided in the memorandum or in the instructions that the said requirement is
needed. What is provided in the instructions is that within 45 days from the date
of posting representations can be made. Thereafter, the petitioner has again
requested for spouse posting and the same was rejected on the ground that
giving of choice stations will not confer any right for posting. The said ground is
also not tenable since there is no dispute with that fact that it is not anybody’s
right but it is provided that as far as possible they should be posted together for
reasons mentioned above. Therefore, it is seen that the rejection of the
representations are not tenable in the eyes of law or in the facts of the case.
25.
It is also stated by the petitioners counsel that posts are available in
Jammu Tawi and employees are being transferred there. However, the same is
rejected in the case of the petitioners. In view of what has been stated above
this Court directs the respondent authorities to properly consider the
representation of the petitioner who would file the same before the authorities.
The authorities should consider the memorandum and the instructions that
when husband and wife, are GREF employees both of them should be posted in
the same station and if the husband is posted in hard areas or likewise the wife
that is petitioner no.2 should be posted near the same place specially because
of the underlined basic requirement given in the memorandum that is to
enhance the women’s participation in employment as well as for taking care of
Page No.# 14/14
the children.
26.
The petitioners are directed to submit the representation within a period
of 2 (two) weeks from the date of the order and the respondent authorities shall
dispose of the said representation within a period of 2 (two) weeks thereafter.
Furthermore, the transfer and posting orders dated 17.08.2024 qua the
petitioner no.1 and order dated 28.08.2024 qua the petitioner no.2 are hereby
interfered with.
27.
In view of the fact that the petitioners have a 4 year old child this Court
directs that the petitioners would make the representation while staying in
Tezpur and the same may be considered as an exceptional case and thereafter,
orders of posting and transfer be issued.
28.
This judgment and order is passed both in respect of WP(C) No. 300/2025
and WP(C) No. 6914/2024.
29.
Petition is disposed of and stay order stands vacated.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review