Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/u-srinivas-vs-sri-r-v-karnan-20260901/ · Printed 19 Nov 2026
Civil

U.Srinivas vs Sri.r.v.karnan

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Telangana High Court
Date
1 September 2026
Case No.
CC 2946/2025
Bench
Justice C.v. Bhaskar Reddy
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

Filed under

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 Section 12, Contempt of Courts Act, 1971

The law this judgment cites

Opens the section on Law Maker (lawmaker.in), our sister site for law students.

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

Y [32e6 ] IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD TUESDAY, THE FIRST DAY OF SEPTEMBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRIJUSTICE C.V. BHASKAR REDDY CONTEMPT CASE NO: 2946 OF 2025 Contempt Case filed Under Sections 10 to 12 of Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 to punish the respondents herein willful, disobedience, deliberate, unlawful, illegal action the Orders of the High Court dated 07.04.2025 passed in W.P.No.10349 ol 2025. Between: U.Srinivas, S/o Late. U.Narayana, Aged about 57 years Occ. Business, Fl/o H No 296 Gajularamaram Village, Qutubullapur Mandal Medchal Malkajgiri District. ...Petitioner AND 1. SRI.R.V.KARNAN, S/o.Not known to the petitioner, Occ. COMMISSIONER, Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation, (GHMC) Tank Bund,Hyderabad. 2. SRI.APURV CHAUHAN, Sio.Not known to the petitioner, OCC. ZONAL COMMISSIONER, GHMC, Circle-25, Kukatpally Zone, Medchal Malkajglri District. 3. SRI.MALLAIAH @MALLAREDDY, S/o.Not known to the petitioner OCC. DEPUTY COMMISSIONER, GHMC, Circle-26, Gajularamaram, Quthbullapur Mardal Medchal Malkajgiri District. 500055 ...CONTEMNORS/Respondents No. 10 to 12 in Main W.P. No. 1034912025 Counsel for the Petitioner : Sri. S. Srinivas Sridhar Rao Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 2 & 3 : Sri. K. Ravi Mahender Standing Counsel for GHMC The Court made the following: ORDER IN THE HIGH COI'RT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT IIYDERABAD THE HON'BLE SRI WSTICE C.V.BIIASKAR REDDY CONTEMPT CASE No.29 46 of 2o25 (CNR No. HBHco106 132720251 Date: O1. .2026 Between: Petitioner U. Srinrvas. AND Respondents Sri R. V. Karnan and two others ORDER This Contempt Case is hled by the petitioner under liections 1O to 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 , alleging willful and deliberate disobedience of the order dated 07.04.2O25 passed by this Court in W.P.No.10349 of 2O25. 2. The pelitioner Iiled W.P.No.10349 of 2025 questioning the legality and validity of the Joint Inspection Report dated 79 .O4.2t)24 in respect of land admeasuring Ac. 1.37 guntas in Sy.No.298 situated at Gajularamaram Village, Quthbullapur Mandal, Medr:ha1-Malkajgiri District. The grievance of the petitioner was that tl-re said Joint Inspection Report was contrary to the earlier surveys conducted by the Revenue authorities during the years 20Ol and 2019 and the subsequent proceedings and correspondence dated 14.O7.2027. The ,,f:etitioner claimed that he and his family members were r possess.ion of the subject land and that the authorities, without taling into consideration the earlier suwey proceedings and the boundaries fixed therein, were interfering with his possession and treating a portion of the land as part of the municipal park. 3. In.the affidavit hled in support of the writ petition, the petitioner stated that the subject tand in Sy.No.298 admeasuring Ac. 1.37 guntas was being claimed by him on the basis of the revenue records and the Occupancy Rights Certifrcate issued by the competent authority. He further stated that surveys were conducted by the competent Revenue authorities on 28.O4.2OO1 and 13.03.2019 and boundaries were fixed on the ground in the presence of panch witnesses. It was also stated that the Tahsildar, Quthbullapur Mandal, addressed letter No.B/810/2O21, dated 14.07.2027 to the Revenue Divisional Officer, enclosing the location sketch prepared by the Irrigation Department. According to the petitioner, the said proceedings disclosed that the land in Sy.No.298 admeasuring 9335 square yards was not affected by the Full Tank Level of Pariki Cheruur, though an extent of 940 square yards was stated to be partly affected by the buffer zone. 4- Having considered tl:e submissions made in the writ petition and the material placed on record, this Court, on 07 .O4.2O25' passed the following order: (' " Notice belore admission. Si L.Rauinder, leamed Assistant C,ouernment Plead.er for Reuenue takes notice for respondent Nos.1 lo g and seeks time to fil: counter dffidauit. Si K. Rauimahendra, learned. Standtng Counse[ takes notrce for respondent Nos.1O to 12. Si Laxmalla Sa.ndeep, learned Assistant Gouemment Pleader for lrngatton tqkes nottce for respondent ,Yo.13 and seeks time to get in-structtons. Leamed counsel for the. Petitioner ts permitted to take out persono'l notttce to respondent No.14 bA Regtstered Post with Acknouled'tment Drc and fite proof oJ seruice before tle Regtstry bg the next date of hec nng. This Wnt Petitton is filed praging thi.s Court to declan e the joint Inspection conducted on 19.O4.2024 Jor the lands in Sg No.29B, Gajula Ramaram Vtltage, qs i\egal, arbitrary and @ntrary to the provi: iotts oJ th.e Telangana Surueg and Boundaies Act, 1923 and ttte R.LIes made thereunder. The case oJ the petitioners is th.dt theA are tl9 owners and possessors of th.e land admeasuing Ac.1.37 guntas tn Sg.1[o:,. 145, 263 dnd 298, situated al Gajula Ramaram Vitlage, Qutubullap lr Mandal, Medchal-Malkajgii Dstrict, laung acquired ttLe same tLvough OccllpdncA Rights Centficate issued vide proceedings No.J/ 2003/ 2()O3, d.a.ted 27.11.2003. It is thg further case of the petitioners tlDt acttnll on their dppticdtrcn, suruey has been cond.ucted by respondent No.7 and boundaries hque been fxed on 13.0i.2O19 and panchanama uos drau n. It is ttle furtlLer c@se of th.e petitioners that respondent No.9, had ad.dre:;sed a letter n"o.B/810/2O21, dated 14.07.2021 to respondent No.8-ReuenL e Dnsional Off.cer, stating that the land in Sg.No.298 to @n ertent of Ac.1.37 guntqs situated ot Galularamaram, i,s rearded in tLLe ndme of Mangc.h NaraAana and location sketch prepared bg the Imgation Depdrtmenl is zn.closed. As per the report of the Assi-stant EnEneer, Norlh Tanits Duision, Secunderabad, the land in Sg.No.298 admeasuing 9335 square gards is not alJected in FTL of Paiki Cheruuu but an ertent oJ 940 sqL qre Aards is partlA affected in bulfer zone of Paikt Ch-eruru. The giet'ance of the petitioners is that Lxittaut tdking tnto con-sid.eration of the earlier two suruegs and the boundaies fxed thereon, the respondent aulhorities haue forcibtg occupied pqrt of the land of the petitioners and procee Ting uith the constructton oJ municipaL park. Since i, is staled. that the suruea has been conducted tuice and the bound.aies have been fixed Jor tlLe subject land in Sy.No.298 as per Letter No.B/810/2021, dated 14.07.2021, tl'Le respondent authoities are directed not to intArkre with the possession of tlrc petitioners ouer the land to an exte of Ac.1.37 guntas in Sy.No.298 or dishtrb the boundaies fxed in pursuonce oJ th.e inspection conducted bA tlv Asststant Engineer, North Tonks Diuision, dated 14,O7.2021, in ang manner. Flr1h-er, the resPondent autfu)rtties qre directed to maintoin slatus quo ouer the subject land in aLl respects. List on 16.06.2025.' 5. The grievance of the petiLioner in this contempt case is that immediately after passing of the aforesaid order, copies thereof were served upon the concerned authorities; in view of the earlier survey proceedings, he had erected stones and kaddies within the boundaries of the subject land; notwithstanding the subsistence of the order passed by this Court, the GHMC officials, namely Sri Ramesh, ACP, Sri Tulja Singh and subsequently Sri Somesh, entered the subject land on 1g.O4.2O25 and again on 07 .06.2025 and removed the stones and kaddies erected by him; complaints were lodged before the Commissioner, GHMC on 28.04.2O25 and 24.05.2025 and also before the police; and a legal noLice dated 27 .O9.2O25 was aiso issued to the respondents calling upon them to comply with the order of this Court. 6. This Court, on 07 .71 .2025, issued notice to the respondent Nos.2 and 3. Subsequently, as the notices were served and there was no representation on their behalf, this Court, by order dated 23.01 .2026, issued Form-I to respondent Nos.2 ard 3 and directed theil appearance before this Court. 7. In pursuance of the aforesaid order, the respondent Nos.2 and 3 entered appearance and filed their counter affidavit, inte.' alia stating that the GHMC had commenced construction of the colnpound wall around the park on 78.06.2024 after obtaining administr:.tive sanction and that tJle construction was completed on O4.01.2025, rnuch prior to the order dated O7.O4.2O25; after passing of the said order, the petitioner attempted to erect stone kaddies in the are r claimed by GHMC as park land; and upon recerpt of complaints dated 19.04'2O25 and o7.06.2025 alleging encroachment and erection of stc'ne kaddies in the park area, the GHMC officials removed tlte same in discharge of their statutory duties and for protection of municipal property. 8. Respondent No.2 thereafter hled an additional counter affidavit dated 23.O4.2O26, reiterating the aforesaid stand and speciltcally stating that the GHMC officials removed the stone kadclies erected by the petitioner after the order dated O7.O4.2O25. Thus, the factum of removal of the stone kaddies subsequent to the passing of tJ e order is not in dispute. 9. The petitioner filed a rejoinder denying the defen<e taken by the respondents. It is specifically contended that the respo rdents, instead of approaching this Court for clarificaLion or modiltcation of the order, \ took upon themselves the task of determining the alleged encroachment and removed the stone kaddies noturithstanding the express direction of ttris Court not to disturb the boundaries and to maintain status quo in all respects. The petitioner further contended that the respondents' own admission regarding removal of the kaddies establishes the violation of the order of this Court. 10. During the pendency of the Contempt Case, respondent Nos.2 and 3 were directed to appear before this Court by issuing Form-I. On 20.02.2026, they did not appear arld this Court directed the Commissioner of Police, Cyberabad Commissionerate, to secure their presence and produce them before this Court. On 23.02.2026, respondent Nos.2 and 3 appeared in person and tendered unconditional apolog, for their absence and sought time to file affidavits. 11. Thereafter, respondent Nos.2 and 3 filed affrdavits tendering unconditional apolory and explaining the circumstances for their absence. By order dated 25.02.2026, this Court accepted the explanation only for the purpose of dispensing with their personal appearance until further orders, while making it clear that they shali appear before this Court without fail upon receipt of aly further notice. The said affidavits and the order dated 25.02.2026 relate to their absence before this Court and do not constitute an explanation absolving them of the alleged disobedience of the ,rrder dated 07.04.2025. 12. The petitioner also filed I.A.No.3 of 2026 seeking permission to receive additional material papers i.e, survey proceedings, 'dllage maps, photographs depicting erection and removal of flte kaddies, representations submitted to the authorilies, corresponderce and other documents in support of his allegation that the boundaries protected by the order were disturbed after 07.04.2025. The said application was allowed by this Court on 06.05.2026. 13. The question that falls for consideration is whether the action of the responden[s in causing removal of the stone kaddies after the order dated 07.04.2025 amounts to willful disobedience of the serid order. 14. The learned Senior Counsel appearing for L'-rc petitioner submitted that the order dated 07.O4.2025 passed by this Courl is clear and unequivocal ald specif-rca1ly prohibits the respondent authorities from interfering with the possession of the petitroner over Ac.1.37 guntas in Sy.No.298 and from disturbing the boundaries 1-xed pursuant to the inspection dated 14.07 .2027 . It is further subm itted that the direction to maintain status quo in all respects was binding upon the respondents and that the respondents admittedly remc,ved the stone kaddies after passing of the said order. karned counsel v.,ould therefore contend that the subsequent justification offered by tie respondents e that the kaddies were erected in the park area cannot be accepted, as the respondents were required to approach t1lis Court if they were of the opinion that the order passed by this Court was being misused. 15. On the other hand, the learned Standing Counsel for GHMC submitted that there was no intention to disobey the order of this Court and that the GHMC offrcials acted only upon complaints received from the residents' Welfare Associatjon and in the interest of protecting municipal property. It is submitted that the compound wa.ll around the park had been completed even before passing of the order and that the removal of the kaddies was only intended to prevent alleged encroachment into the park area. It is therefore contended that the essential ingredient of willful disobedience is absent. 16. This Court has carefully considered the rival submissions and perused the material on record. 1,7. There is no dispute with regard to the nature and scope of tlre order dated 07.O4.2025. This Court specihcally directed the respondent authorities not to interfere with the possession of the petitioner over land admeasuring Ac.1.37 gUntas in Sy.No.298 or disturb the boundaries fixed pursuant to the inspection conducted by the Assistant Engineer, North Tanks Division, dated 14.O7.2O21, in any manner. The respondent autiorilies were further directed to maintain status quo over the subject iand in all respects. ent to the 18. Admittedly, the stone kaddies were removed subsequ No 2' in his passing of the aforesaid order' In fact' respondent that rhe GHMC additional counter affrdavit, specifically admitted officials removed the kaddies erected by the Petitioner dated 07.04.2025. Thus, the factum of removal after the order is esta:lished not merely from the allegation of the petitioner but also fronr the stand taken by the respondents themselves' were 19. The justifrcation offered by the respondents that the l:addies tie Welfart Association removed pursuant to complaints received from resPondent cannot be accePted. Once this Court directed the and to maintaln authorities not to disturb the existing boundaries status quo in all respects, the respondents were bound the said direction in letter and spirit lf they were to comply with of the view that the petitioner had erected the kaddies in an area forming part of the GHMC park or had otherwise acted contlary to the order, the appropriate seek was Lo bring the matter to the notice of this Court and course clarification or appropriate directions' They could not have unilaterallv determined the alleged violation and taken steps whit:h resulted in disturbance of the very boundaries protected by 07 .o4.2025 th': order dated 20. ln Reena Rumarl and others u, Pra oeer Kumar and otherst, the Hon'lcle Supreme Court observed as follows: '17........The poluer to punish for ciul contempt is a Potent mechonism explicitlg designed to seare public confidence in the administration of justice. As this Couri lrcId tn Anll Rd,t4,n sd:tk4r a' Htrak Ghosh ((2002) 4 SCC 21), once on order passed by a competent court is clear and unambiguous, its implementation cannot . witw S un rsta u be anditionol upon a disobedience signifies an act done uoluntaily tttith the intent to disregard the lau." In the present case, the order dated O7.O4-2O25 is clear and unambiguous. This Court specifically directed the respondent authorities not to interfere with the possession of the petitioner over the land admeasuring Ac.1.37 guntas in Sy.No 298 or disturb the boundaries fixed pursuant to the inspection conducted by the Assistant Engineer, North Tanks Division, dated 14.O7.2021, tn any manner and further directed them to maintain statu s quo over the subject land in all respects. Therefore, the respondents were bound to comply with the said directions and could not have acted contrary thereto on the basis of their own understanding of the order. The plea that the compound wall had been completed on O4.O1.2025 does not advance the case of the respondents. The issue in the present Contempt Case is not whether the construction of the compound wall was undertaken before or after the order dated 07.04.2025, but whether the respondents, ' 2026 tNsc 642 subsequent thereto, disturbed the boundaries and status quo protected bythesaidordcr'Therespondents'ownpleadingsestablishthatthe stone kaddies were removed after the passing of tlte order' tt is equally significant that the respondents have not placed before this Court any order of this Court permitting them to remove the stone kaddies after 07 .O4 .2025. The complaints received from third parties, eve n if taken at their face value, could not override the binding directron issued by this Court. Administrative convenience or the perception o[ an officer regarding the ownership or location of the land cannot be a ground to drsregard an order passed by this Court. 21. The material placed on recorcl, therefore, establishes that the respondents, despite having knowledge of the order dated 07 '04'2025, permitted their officials to remove the stone kaddies erected by t1le petitioner on 79.04.2025 and again on 07.06.2025 Th(r subsequent explanation offered by tl.e respondents does not satisfacl.orily account for the admitted act of removal. Such conduct resulted in rlisturbance of the boundaries and status quo which this Court had specifically directed the respondents to maintain. 22. The unconditional apologies tendered by responderit Nos'2 and 3 are confined to their absence before this Court pursuant to the Form-l notices. The said apologies do not contain any unconditio 1al acceptance of the violation complained of by the petrtioner, nor do they explain or \ undo the admitted removal of the stone kaddies. Hence, the said apologies cannot absolve the respondent Nos.2 and 3 of the consequences arising from the disobedience of the order. 23. Having regard to the clear and unambiguous nature of the order dated 07.O4.2025, the admitted removal of stone kaddies subsequent thereto and the failure of tJ:e respondents to establish any lawful authority for disturbing the boundaries protected by the said order, this Court is of the considered view that the petitioner has established willful and deliberate disobedience of the order dated 07.O4.2025 by the respondent Nos.2 and 3. 24. Accordingly, respondent Nos.2 and 3 are found guilty of willful disobedience of the order dated O7.O4.2O25 passed by this Court in W.P.No.10349 of 2025 and are liable to be punished under Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971. Insofar as respondent No.l is concerned, no separate finding is recorded, as the proceedings in Form-l were issued against t1.e respondent Nos.2 and 3 and the materia.l on record before this Court specifically concerns tleir conduct. 25. In the result, the Contempt Case is allowed, sentencing the respondent Nos.2 and 3/contemnors to suffer simple imprisonment for a period of one (01) week and to pay a fine of Rs.2,0O0/- (Rupees Two Thousand only) each, within three (03) days from today. In default of payment of line, the respondent Nos.2 and 3 shall undergo simple imprisonment for a further period of three (03) days. The per'itioner shall pay subsistence allowance as per Rules. The sentence of irnprisonment is suspended for a period of one (01) week from today. Alter expiry of the said period, the respondent Nos.2 and 3 shall surrender before the Registrar (Judicial-l), High Court for the State of Telangana, to undergo the sentence of imprisonment as stated supra. The resllondents are directed to ensure strict compliance with the order d'ated 07 .O4 2025 passed in W.P.No. iO349 of 2025 and shall not interfere with the possession of the petitioner over the subject land or disturb the boundaries fixed pursuant to the inspection dated l4-O7 2O21, except in accordance with any orders that may be passed in W.D'No' 10349 of 2025. Miscellaneous petitrons, pending if any, shall stand closed. //TRUECOPY// i sd/. v. KAVITHA /,--... Seuw REGIsTRAR ,/ .\ 'i\ '-- \i \ To, \ isecrtoN oFFlcER .,t' 1. The Registrar (Judicial-l), High Court for the State of Telangana, at Hyderabad. 2. The Section Officer, O.S. Section High Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad. 3. The Section Officer, Accounts Section, High Court for tre State of Telangana at Hyderabad. 4. U.Srinivas, S/o Late. U.Narayana, Occ. Business, R/o F No 2-96 Gajularamaram Village, QutubullapurMandal Medchal Malkajgiri District 5. SRI.R.V.KARNAN, Occ. COMMISSIONER, Greate" Hyderabad Municipal Corporation, (GHMC) Tank Bund,Hyderabad. 6. SRI.APURV CHAUHAN, OCC. ZONAL COMMISSICNER, GHMC, Circle-25, Kukatpally Zone, Medchal Malkajgiri District. 7. SRI.MALLAIAH @MALLAREDDY, OCC DEPUTY COMMISSIONER, GHMC, Circle-26, Gajularamaram, Quthbullapur Mardal Medchal Malkajgiri District. 500055 B. One CC to Sri. S. Srinivas Sridhar Rao, Advocate [OPLC] 9. One CC to Sri. K. Ravi Mahender Standing Counsel for GHMC IOPUC] ,+y 10.Two CD Copies DI --- 4 HIGH COURT CVBR, J DATED: 0110912026 1\\r: - ',1 t ORDER CC.No.2946 of 2025 io \r) 01 SiP 202t * ALLOWING THE CONTEMPT CASE @( C\ 1b -.4 l *

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Telangana HC judgments →
LegalFirms.in Directory
Find an advocate for this matter
Dealing with a similar case? Find an advocate who handles this kind of matter on LegalFirms.in.
Find an advocate →