Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/14
GAHC040004982023
2026:GAU-AP:336
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/187/2023
Tukpen Village Council (TVC) and 4 Ors.
an Organization for and amongst the residents of Rupa represented by Shri
D.K.Thongdok, Chairman, TVC,, Rupa Market, PO/PS Rupa, District West Kameng,
Arunachal Pradesh.
2: D. K. Thongdok
Age:
Occupation :
Rupa Market
PO/PS Rupa
District West Kameng
Arunachal Pradesh.
3: R. D. Thongon
Age:
Occupation :
Rupa Market
PO/PS Rupa
District West Kameng
Arunachal Pradesh
4: R. D. Khrime
Age:
Occupation :
Rupa Market
PO/PS Rupa
District West Kameng
Arunachal Pradesh
5: Wangdi Dorjee Khrimey
Age:
Occupation :
Rupa Market
PO/PS Rupa
Page No.# 2/14
District West Kameng
Arunachal Pradesh
Mobile No. 943625874
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA and 5 Ors.
Represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Govt. of India, South Block,
Room No 104, New Delhi 1
2:The Chief of Army Staff
Age: 0
Occupation :
Army Headquarters
South Block
DHQ
New Delhi 1
3:The Directorate General
Age: 0
Occupation :
Defence Estate
Raksha Sampada Bhawan Ulaanbaatar Marg
Delhi Cantt. New Delhi 10
4:The Defence Estate Officer
Age: 0
Occupation :
Tezpur Circle
Cole Park Road Tezpur 784001
Assam.
5:THE STATE OF AP
Age: 0
Occupation :
Represented by the Commissioner/Secretary
Department of Land Management
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
6:The Deputy Commissioner
Age: 0
Occupation :
Bomdila
West Kameng District
Arunachal Pradesh
Advocate for the Petitioner
: Tony Pertin, Uttam Bori,H K Jamoh,Mingkong Pertin,T Mize
Page No.# 3/14
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP), Yadab Doloi,DSGI,Marto Kato,Elina Perme
Linked Case : WP(C)/186/2023
Singchung Village Council Land Management Committee (SVCLMC) and 4 Ors.
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:an Organization for and amongst the residents of Singchung Village.
Represented by Shri Naresh Glow
Chairman
SVCLMC
Tenga Market
PO Tenga
PS Rupa
District West Kameng
Arunachal Pradesh.
2: Naresh Glow
Age: 50
Occupation :
Address:Tenga Market
PO Tenga
PS Rupa
District West Kameng
Arunachal Pradesh.
3: Sange Norbu Phiang
Age: 50
Occupation :
Address:Tenga Market
PO Tenga
PS Rupa
District West Kameng
Arunachal Pradesh.
4: Phuntso Phinya
Age: 50
Occupation :
Address:Tenga Market
PO Tenga
PS Rupa
District West Kameng
Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 4/14
5: Sang Norbu Sarai
Age: 50
Occupation :
Address:Tenga Market
PO Tenga
PS Rupa
District West Kameng
Arunachal Pradesh.
Mobile No. 9436045213
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA and 5 Ors.
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Represented by the Secretary
Ministry of Defence
Govt. of India
South Block
Room No 104
New Delhi 1
2:The Chief of Army Staff
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Army Headquarters
South Block
DHQ
New Delhi 1
3:The Directorate General
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Defence Estate
Raksha Sampada Bhawan Ulaanbaatar Marg
Delhi Cantt. New Delhi 10
4:The Defence Estate Officer
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Tezpur Circle
Cole Park Road
Tezpur 784001
Assam.
5:THE STATE OF AP
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Represented by the Commissioner/Secretary
Department of Land Management
Page No.# 5/14
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
6:The Deputy Commissioner
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Bomdila
West Kameng District
Arunachal Pradesh.
-----------Advocate for : Tony Pertin
Advocate for : GA (AP) appearing for THE UNION OF INDIA and 5 Ors.: Advocate ,
,
,
,
, appearing for 2,
3,
4,
5,
6, respectively.
BEFORE
Hon’ble MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MEDHI
Advocates for the petitioner:
Shri T. Pertin
Advocates for the respondents:
Shri I. Choudhury, AG, AP
Shri S. Tapin, Sr.GA, AP
Shri Y. Doloi, CGC
Date of hearing and Judgment : 01.04.2026
Judgment & Order (oral)
Both these writ petitions being connected and filed on an analogous cause
Page No.# 6/14
of action, the same have been heard together and are disposed of by this
common judgment and order. The claim in these writ petitions is with regard to
compensation for acquisition of land, the process of which started in the year
1962 and the lands appear to have been finally acquired sometime in the year
1972-73.
2.
For the sake of clarity, the reliefs prayed for in one of the writ petitions,
being WP(C)/187/2023 are extracted hereinbelow:
“PRAYER
In the premises aforesaid, it is most respectfully prayed that Your
Lordships may be pleased to
I. Declare the Letter of Ministry of Defence No. A/83676/TENGA/Q3L
[East]/498-SD [Lands] dated 18.09.1971 [Annexure-6], the Declaration
No. REV-7/72 dated 13/10/1972 issued by the Government of India,
Arunachal Pradesh Administration [Annexure-7]
II. Quash and set aside the alleged Award No. CON/101/72 dated
29/03/1973. [ANNEXURE-9]
III. Issue a writ of Mandamus directing the authorities more particularly
respondentNo. 1 & 2 to pay the annual rent for the land measuring
432.47 acres [Defence Land A-1] from 01.01.1964 onwards till date and
continue to pay regular rent as per the rate fixed by the Government of
Arunachal Pradesh within a time frame.
AND
IV. Issue a writ of Mandamus directing the authorities to calculate the
adequate compensation for the land and other properties against the
Page No.# 7/14
occupied 432.47 acres of land [Defence Land A-1] by lawfully acquiring
the land as provided under the Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Re-Settlement Act
2013 and to pay the calculated compensation within a time frame.
V. Or otherwise, to hand over of the vacant possession of the land of
432.47 acres[Defence Land A-1] to the Tukpen Village Council.
VI. Issue a direction for continuance of traditional fishing rights over water
and rights over its resources.
VII. Direct the State of Arunachal Pradesh [respondent 5] to revise the
hiring charge as per the Commissioner, Land Management, Govt of
Arunachal Pradesh Letter No. LM-75/2014/1294 Dated 13.08.2014
[Annexure-10]
AND
In the interim direct the State of Arunachal Pradesh to highlight and
apprise pertaining to the revision of the hiring charge as per the
Commissioner, Land Management, Govt of Arunachal Pradesh Letter No.
LM-75/2014/1294 Dated 13.08.2014 [Annexure-10]
And for this act of kindness the petitioners as in duty und shall ever pray.”
3.
As per the facts projected in these two writ petitions, after the 1962
Chinese aggression, the Indian Army had established the defence base in Rupa
and Tenga Circles in the West Kameng district. In the said process, initially lands
of the petitioners were taken up for requisition. Though it appears that the land
was ultimately acquired in the year 1972-73, it is contended that the petitioners
were not aware of any such acquisition process. Bereft of details, the claim, as
indicated above, is with regard to a compensation for the lands from which the
Page No.# 8/14
petitioners have been deprived of.
4.
I have heard Shri T. Pertin, learned counsel for the petitioners. I have also
heard Shri Y. Doloi, learned Senior Penal Counsel for the Union of India and Shri
I. Choudhury, learned Advocate General, AP assisted by Shri Y. Riram, learned
State Counsel.
5.
Shri Pertin, learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that the
lands were initially requisitioned and the same process continued whereby the
petitioners have been dispossessed. He has submitted that no compensation
has been paid for acquisition of the land to the petitioners. He has also
confirmed that such lands were not donated by the petitioners and therefore,
they have a valid claim for compensation. It is to be clarified that so far as
WP(C)/186/2023 is concerned, the same pertains to Singchung Village Council
whereas the land in WP(C)/187/2023 is concerned, the same pertains to Tukpen
Village Council at Rupa.
6.
The learned counsel for the petitioners has also drawn the attention of this
Court to various provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 and has submitted
that though there are certain documents to show that a proceeding was
initiated vide publication of a notice under Section 4 of the Act dated
29.04.1972, the other procedures including the requirement to give scope to the
land affected persons as required under Section 5A of the Act was not fulfilled.
He has submitted that to the knowledge of the petitioners, there was no valid
acquisition process and in an illegal manner, the petitioners have been deprived
of their entitlements for compensation. He has also submitted that though in the
proceeding, an Award dated 29.03.1973 has come into surface, the land, as
such have not been identified and therefore, it cannot be said that the said
Award is in the context of the land which is the subject matter of these two writ
Page No.# 9/14
petitions.
7.
In short, the learned counsel for the petitioner is praying for a fair
compensation for the land which has ultimately been taken by the army
authorities. On the aspect of delay in approaching the Court, he has relied upon
the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Tukaram Kana Joshi
and Ors. Vs. Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation and
Ors. reported in (2013) 1 SCC 353 and the observations made in paragraphs
10 and 11 of the said judgment are pressed into service, which are as follows:
“10. In the case at hand, there has been no acquisition. The question that
emerges for consideration is whether, in a democratic body polity, which is
supposedly governed by the Rule of Law, the State should be allowed to
deprive a citizen of his property, without adhering to the law. The matter
would have been different had the State pleaded that it has right, title and
interest over the said land. It however, concedes to the right, title and
interest of the appellants over such land and pleads the doctrine of delay
and laches as grounds for the dismissal of the petition/appeal.
11. There are authorities which state that delay and laches extinguish the
right to put forth a claim. Most of these authorities pertain to service
jurisprudence, grant of compensation for a wrong done to them decades
ago, recovery of statutory dues, claim for educational facilities and other
categories of similar cases, etc. Though, it is true that there are a few
authorities that lay down that delay and laches debar a citizen from
seeking remedy, even if his fundamental right has been violated,
under Article 32 or 226 of the Constitution, the case at hand deals with a
different scenario altogether. Functionaries of the State took over
possession of the land belonging to the appellants without any sanction of
Page No.# 10/14
law. The appellants had asked repeatedly for grant of the benefit of
compensation. The State must either comply with the procedure laid
down for acquisition, or requisition, or any other permissible statutory
mode. There is a distinction, a true and concrete distinction, between the
principle of "eminent domain" and "police power" of the State. Under
certain circumstances, the police power of the State may be used
temporarily, to take possession of property but the present case clearly
shows that neither of the said powers have been exercised. A question
then arises with respect to the authority or power under which the State
entered upon the land. It is evident that the act of the State amounts to
encroachment, in exercise of "absolute power" which in common parlance
is also called abuse of power or use of muscle power. To further clarify
this position, it must be noted that the authorities have treated the land
owner as a 'subject' of medieval India, but not as a 'citizen' under our
constitution.”
8.
The learned counsel for the petitioners has also relied upon the case of
Vidya Devi Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh and Ors. , reported in (2020) 2
SCC 569 wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed that for continuing
cause of action, the aspect of delay would not arise. In this connection, he has
pressed into service the observations made in paragraph 12.12, which read as
follows:
“12.12. The contention advanced by the State of delay and laches of the
Appellant in moving the Court is also liable to be rejected. Delay and
laches cannot be raised in a case of a continuing cause of action, or if the
circumstances shock the judicial conscience of the Court. Condonation of
delay is a matter of judicial discretion, which must be exercised judiciously
Page No.# 11/14
and reasonably in the facts and circumstances of a case. It will depend
upon the breach of fundamental rights, and the remedy claimed, and
when and how the delay arose. There is no period of limitation prescribed
for the courts to exercise their constitutional jurisdiction to do substantial
justice.”
9.
Per contra, Shri Doloi, learned CGC for the Union of India has submitted
that the entire premises of approaching this Court is fallacious inasmuch as,
both the rental compensation and acquisition compensation have been duly paid
to the land affected persons. He has drawn the attention of this Court to the
acquisition notification and also to the statements made in the affidavit-inopposition that in total 1115.941 acres of land was initially hired, which was
subsequently acquired by following the due process of law and in terms of the
Award, the compensation has been paid. He has also referred to the money
receipt of the Treasury Officer, Bomdila to confirm that the acquisition
compensation has actually been paid. He has also referred to a list of
beneficiaries and has confirmed that the present claim is wholly without any
basis.
10.
Shri Choudhury, learned Advocate General, AP has submitted that an
affidavit-in-opposition has been filed wherein it has been contended that no
records could be traced out in connection with the present acquisition process
because of the fact that such acquisition was done about 50 years back.
11.
The rival submissions have been duly considered and the materials placed
before this Court have been carefully examined.
12.
The dispute which has arisen for determination is in the realm of a factual
dispute. While the petitioners contend that there was no validly conducted
Page No.# 12/14
acquisition proceeding and also the principal issue that no compensation has
been received by them, such averments have been categorically denied by the
Union of India in their affidavit-in-opposition filed on 23.07.2024. To dispel any
doubts on the aspect of disputed questions of fact, the averments made in the
affidavit filed by the Union of India, more particularly in paragraph nos. 34 and
35 are extracted hereinbelow:
“34. That with regard to the statements made in paragraph Nos.44 and
45 of the writ petition, your humble deponent denies the same and
submits that Ministry of Defence acquired the land measuring 1115.941
acres at Tenga Valley by paying acquisition compensation of Rs.7,15,153.3
(i.e Rs.6,96,403.30/-for 1090.941 acres and Rs.18,750/- for 25 acres of
land). Therefore, there is no question of re-measuring the acquired land
and again acquired the same under Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Re-settlement Act
2013.
35. That with regards to the statements made in paragraph Nos.46 and
47 of the writ petition, the humble deponent denies the same and states
that Ministry of Defence paid hiring charges from 1965 till the acquisition
of land and paid Rs.7,15,153.3/-(i.e Rs.6,96,403.30/- for 1090.941 acres
and Rs.18,750/- for 25 acres of land) for the acquisition compensation as
mentioned in above Paras. Therefore, there is no question of paying rental
charges again since 1962 or handover the acquired A1 defence land to the
Singchung village council land management Committee.”
13.
This Court has also looked into the rejoinder affidavit filed by the
petitioners on 30.07.2024 wherein there is no specific in the concerned
paragraph, which is extracted hereinbelow:
Page No.# 13/14
“27.
That in response to the averments made in paragraph 29-36, your
deponent begs to state that through letter dated 15.06.1978 to till date it
is the consistent stand of the office of the Deputy Commissioner, West
Kameng district, Bomdila that there are no records of acquisition of the
land in question [means 1090.941 acres) and the Defense Estate Office of
the Ministry of Defence could not substantiate their claim. As rightly
pointed out, the onus of producing evidence for payment of compensation
to the rightful owners lies on the Deputy Commissioner, Bomdila however,
since there are no records of such payment of compensation in the office
of Deputy Commissioner, Bomdila it is clear that no such payment of
compensation was paid to the landowners. In response to the letter No.
DEO/TZP/LAND/NCST/SINGCHUNG/50 dated 02.12.2020 was replied by
the Deputy Commissioner, Bomdila vide BR-2795/486/19-20/687 dated
10.07.2020 [Annexure-16 @108-113 to the writ petition].”
14.
The aforesaid averments and the submission advanced by the learned
counsel for the parties before this Court would clearly show that the dispute is
factual in nature which this Court will not be in a position to adjudicate such a
dispute. It is trite law that this Court exercising its jurisdiction under Article 226
of the Constitution of India is not a Court on facts, more so, when such facts are
disputed. This Court is also of the view that the stand of the State Government
cannot be held to be unreasonable inasmuch as, it is possible not to be able to
trace out records which are 50 years old.
15.
Be that as it may, for prima facie satisfaction, the affidavit filed on
23.07.2024 by the respondent nos. 1, 3 & 4contains a certificate of payment
issued by the Treasury Officer, Central Treasury, Bomdila certifying that a sum of
Rs.6,96,403.30 was paid to the Deputy Commissioner, Bomdila on account of
Page No.# 14/14
payment of compensation for the land acquired. The said affidavit also contains
a list of beneficiaries.
16.
The learned counsel for the petitioners has however raised an objection
that such list cannot be relied upon as the same does not contain any counter
signatures or signatures of the petitioners. It is also contended that the date
appearing in the list is of the year 1975 whereas the Award has been stated to
be of 1973.
17.
As observed above, disputed questions of fact cannot be gone into by this
Court. At the same time, if there is a genuine claim of the petitioners, the same
cannot be left unredressed. In view of the above, while this Court is not inclined
to enter into the process of adjudication as the issues involved disputed
questions of fact, the petitioners are given liberty to approach the appropriate
Civil Court for the redressal of the grievance, if any.
18.
It is however made clear that if such an approach is made, the same is
required to be adjudicated strictly on merits as this Court has not expressed any
opinion on the inter se merits of either of the parties. This Court also observes
that if such an approach is made, the aspect of the delay may be considered in
a justice orientated approach.
19.
Both the writ petitions are accordingly disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review