Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
RP No. 87/2024 in
WP(C) No. 2603/2022
Reserved on :
Pronounced on:
Uploaded on :
…. Petitioner/Appellant(s)
Tufail Ahmad Khan, Age 43 years
Proprietor of Cell Air Multi Ventures
S/o Bashir Ahmad Khan
R/o Batmaloo, Srinagar.
Through:-
07.10.2025
06.06.2026
09.06.2026
Mr. Saqib Amin Parray, Advocate
V/s
…..Respondent(s)
1. Union Territory of J&K through
Commissioner/Secretary to
Government,
Urban Development Department
Civil Secretariat, Srinagar/Jammu.
2. Director,
Urban Local Bodies, Srinagar,
Kashmir.
3. Executive Officer,
Municipality Committee, Pahalgam.
Through:-
Mr. Ilyas Naizir Laway, GA
CORAM: HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE SINDHU SHARMA, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
01.
The petitioner seeks review of judgment dated 27.05.2024, passed
in WP(C) No. 2603/2022, titled “Tufail Ahmad Khan v. UT of J&K and
others”, whereby the petition filed by the petitioner was dismissed.
02.
The Municipal Corporation Pahalgam allotted a contract for collection
of toll tax at Toll Plaza Sarbal, Pahalgam in terms of notification dated
26.03.2021. The parties entered into an agreement on 28.07.2021. The period
of contract was initially for a period of one year i.e. till 24.06.2022, further
extendable for two years.
RP No. 87/2024
03.
During the currency of contract, it is submitted that the petitioner
suffered losses due to cancellation of Amarnath Yatra, which affected the
free flow of traffic and led to financial loss to the petitioner. Thereafter, the
respondents restricted the petitioner from charging toll tax from Yatris and
pilgrimage vehicles, in violation of the terms of notification. The petitioner
suffered
significant
losses
and
approached
the
respondents
for
indemnifying the loss sustained by him. It is submitted that the respondents
had extended assurance for compensation for such losses and, relying upon
such assurances, the petitioner opted for continuation of the contract for the
second and third years after depositing the requisite escalated bid amount.
04.
Since the petitioner failed to deposit the second installment of
current year amount due, a final notice dated 05.11.2022 was issued by the
respondents directing the petitioner to clear the dues or vacate the Toll
Plaza and handover the vacant possession immediately on account of
failure to maintain financial discipline and non-observance of the agreed
terms of the contract.
05.
By way of the writ petition, the petitioner sought quashing of notice
No. MC-PGM/22/3006-09 dated 05.11.2022, vide which, the petitioner was
directed to clear the pending dues within three days positively or vacate the
Toll Plaza at Sarbal Pahalgam and handover the vacant possession.
06.
Further direction is sought to allow the petitioner to continue to
collect toll tax at Toll Post Sarbal, Pahalgam from all vehicles except those
exempted under the terms and conditions of the contract without
interference, and also to direct the respondents to appoint a committee for
assessing the loss suffered by the petitioner on account of non-
RP No. 87/2024
realization/collection of toll tax from the vehicles carrying yatries to the
Holy Amarnath Cave between June 2022 to ending August 2022, and till
the committee finalizes the report, the respondents be directed not to
interfere with the collection of toll tax from the vehicles entering Pahalgam
through toll post at Sarbal, Pahalgam.
07.
Notice in this petition was issued on 21.11.2022, on which date this
Court has directed that subject to furnishing of bank guarantees amounting
to Rs. 25 lakhs before the Registrar Judicial of this Court within ten days
by the petitioner, the respondents shall refrain from enforcing
communication No. MC-PGM/22/3006-09 dated 05.11.2022, and shall
allow the petitioner to operate Toll Plaza Sarbal, Pahalgam, unless there is
any other legal impediment thereto.
08.
In terms of the directions of this Court, the petitioner continued to
operate the Toll Plaza at Sarbal during the pendency of the writ petition.
The respondents objected to the writ petition on the ground that neither the
auction notice nor the agreement contained any clause providing for
relaxation or compensation in the event of natural calamity, hartal, disaster,
or any unforeseen circumstance. The petitioner failed to fulfill the
conditions of the agreement and, as such, was liable to pay the pending
installments of second consecutive year and, as such, this writ petition
deserves to be dismissed.
09.
The writ petition came to be dismissed vide order dated 27.05.2024
on the ground that the dispute raised by the petitioner pertains to
contractual rights and liabilities between the parties. This Court observed
that allegations regarding financial loss suffered by the petitioner on
RP No. 87/2024
account of inability to collect toll tax from Yatra vehicles could not be
adjudicated in writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India. It was held that the petitioner, if aggrieved, could seek damages for
breach of contract before the appropriate civil forum.
10.
In the present review petition, the petitioner contends that the writ
petition was dismissed on an erroneous assumption that the petitioner had
failed to deposit the installments and had not opted for continuation of the
contract for the subsequent years. The petitioner submits that he had
deposited the entire amount of Rs. 25 lakhs in the shape of bank guarantee
and had continued with the contract for the second and third years, which
fact has been brought to the notice of this Court. It is argued that the
respondents being the party to the contract are bound by the terms and
conditions of the contract and cannot take recourse to any sort of discretion
which will result in rescinding the contract or altering/modification of the
contract unilaterally. The vehicles which were exempted from payment of
toll tax were mentioned in the notification itself in terms of clause 17 of the
notification, as such, no further exemption could have been made part of
the contract. The relationship between the petitioner and the respondents in
terms of the notification is a contractual obligation but the respondents
being a State must adhere to the promise made to its citizens, which give
rise to legitimate expectation of being treated in a certain way and in
deviation from that by the State calls for interference by this Court under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India. Reliance in this regard is placed on
the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Apex Court in “State of Jharkhand v.
RP No. 87/2024
Brahmputra Metallic Ltd., Rachi and another”, 2023 (10) SCC 634,
wherein it is held as under: “....37
11.
While this doctrinal confusion has the unfortunate
consequence of making the law unclear, citizens have been
the victims. Representations by public authorities need to
be held to scrupulous standards, since citizens continue to
live their lives based on the trust they repose in the State.
In the commercial world also, certainty and consistency are
essential to planning the affairs of business. When public
authorities fail to adhere to their representations without
providing an adequate reason to the citizens for this failure,
it violates the trust reposed by citizens in the State. The
generation of a business friendly climate for investment and
trade is conditioned by the faith which can be reposed in
government to fulfill the expectations which it generates....”
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record
including the writ record.
12.
The review of the judgment is in terms of Rule 65 of J&K High
Court Rules, which provides that an application for review can only be
entertained on the grounds mentioned in Order XLVII Rule I of the Code.
13.
The scope of review under Order XLVII Rule 1 is well-settled. It
provides that the review of judgment can be made on the ground that, there
is new or important matter and evidence which after exercise of due
diligence was not within his knowledge or could not be produced by him or
discovered by him or if there is a mistake or error apparent on the face of
the record or for any other sufficient reason. Any other sufficient reason
has to be extinguished to mean for a reason which is analogous to the first
two.
14.
Averting to the facts of the case, the petitioner is aggrieved of the
judgment and seeks review on the ground that paragraphs 21 and 22 are not
in accordance with the factual matrix of the case. The submission of the
RP No. 87/2024
petitioner is that he has deposited the second and third installments as per
the agreement and had also opted for the subsequent two years, but this
aspect was not considered while issuing the final notice. As per the final
notice, the petitioner had failed to deposit the amount and, therefore, the
notice was issued calling upon him to deposit the second and third
instalments. It was only by intervention of this Court that the petitioner was
allowed to operate the toll plaza and complete the remaining two years of
his contract period.
15.
The next contention of the petitioner was that there was an
alteration in the contract as he was unable, firstly, to charge toll from the
vehicles because the Amarnath Yatra got cancelled and, secondly, because
the vehicles carrying pilgrims were exempted from payment of toll tax. The
respondents submit that, in terms of the agreement between the parties,
specifically Clause 11, they were not bound to provide any relief,
relaxation, or compensation on account of any event, adversity, or
unavoidable circumstance such as hartal, bandh, or disaster which could
lead to financial loss.
16.
This apart, the issue whether the petitioner had actually suffered
any loss cannot be considered in these proceedings. Therefore, essentially
the petitioner is alleging breach of contract on the ground that he has
suffered losses. Further, a direction regarding appointment of a committee
to assess the losses also cannot be granted in these proceedings, as it is for
the petitioner to prove the loss by leading evidence.
17.
Essentially, in the present case, the petitioner has filed the review
petition seeking re-argument of the entire matter, which is impermissible in
RP No. 87/2024
review jurisdiction. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in case titled “Lily
Thomas v. Union of India”, reported in 2000 (6) SCC 224, held that a
review lies only for correction of an error apparent on the face of the record
and cannot be treated as an appeal in disguise. In para 53 the Hon’ble
Supreme Court observed as under:“The dictionary meaning of the word "review" is "the act of looking;
offer something again with a view to correction or improvement. It
cannot be denied that the review is the creation of a statute. This
Court in Patel Narshi Thakersh and Ors. v. Pradyunman singh ji
Arjun singh ji held that the power of review is not an inherent power.
It must be conferred by law either specifically or by necessary
implication. The review is also not an appeal in disguise. If cannot
be denied that justice is a virtue which transcends all barriers and
the rules or procedures or technicalities of law cannot stand in the
way of administration of Justice. Law has to bend before Justice. If
the Court finds that the error pointed out in the review petition was
under a mistake and the earlier judgment would not have been
passed but for erroneous assumption which in fact did not exist and
its perpetration shall result in miscarriage of justice nothing would
preclude the Court from rectifying the error.”
18.
In the present case, no error apparent on the face of the record has
been demonstrated for review of the judgment dated 27.05.2024 and,
accordingly, the review petition is dismissed.
(SINDHU SHARMA )
Judge
Jammu:
06.06.2026
VISHAL KHAJURIA
Whether the judgment is speaking
:
Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable
:
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review