Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P. (C) No. 15 of 2016
Tshering Eden Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extra-Ordinary Jurisdiction)
---------------------------------------------------------------------S.B.: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, CJ.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No. 15 of 2016
Miss Tshering Eden Bhutia,
D/o Shri D. T. Bhutia,
C/o Kardo Lodge-Chooksing,
Arithang, P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
…
Petitioner.
versus
1.
State of Sikkim,
Through the Secretary,
Department of Personnel, Adm. Reforms,
Training & Public Grievances,
Government of Sikkim,
Manan Bhawan, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
2.
Through the Secretary,
Sikkim Public Service Commission,
Old West Point School,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
… Respondents.
Petition under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India
------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. A. K. Upadhyaya, Senior Advocate with Ms. Aruna
Chhetri and Ms. Hemlata Sharma, Advocates for the
Petitioner.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Senior Government Advocate with
Mr. Santosh Kr. Chettri and Ms. Pollin Rai, Assistant
Government Advocates for State-Respondent No. 1.
Mr. J.K. Kharka, Advocate for Respondent No. 2.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No. 15 of 2016
Tshering Eden Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
JUDGMENT
(03.08.2017)
Satish K. Agnihotri, CJ
In the instant petition, the petitioner seeks to assail
her
non-appointment
(Bhutia/Lepcha
on
category)
the
(for
post
of
short
“BL
Under
Secretary
category”).
The
petitioner is stated to be the applicant for selection in the Junior
Grade
of
Sikkim
State
Civil
Service,
pursuant
Advertisement dated 12.09.2012 (Annexure P-4).
to
the
According to
the petitioner, she was duly selected as her name was found in
the Select List of the Under Secretary and equivalent, notified on
09.06.2015.
Thus, she is entitled to appointment against the
said category under which she made application and was selected
therto.
Non-appointment of the petitioner, notwithstanding the
availability of post and merit, constraints her to file this petition.
2.
The facts, in brief, relevant for adjudication of the lis
as projected by the petitioner are that the petitioner pursuant to
the aforestated advertisement successfully competed the written
test and viva-voce conducted by the second respondent, Sikkim
Public Service Commission (for short “SPSC”) for the selection to
the post of Under Secretary (BL).
The petitioner, feeling
dissatisfied with the marks awarded to her in the examination at
the first instance, made a request for re-evaluation of her answer
W.P. (C) No. 15 of 2016
Tshering Eden Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
scripts on 26.08.2015 to the second respondent.
On re-
evaluation, the marks were revised and the revised merit
position of the petitioner was informed to the petitioner vide
communication dated 15.02.2016 enclosing a statement of her
rectified
marks
and
revised
merit
position,
wherein
the
petitioner’s total marks obtained in written test were increased to
408 from 392 and the final total marks were accordingly
enhanced to 478 from 462. Consequently, she was upgraded in
the merit list in Bhutia/Lepcha category, entitling her to
appointment.
3.
Mr.
A.
K.
Upadhyaya,
learned
Senior
Counsel
appearing for the petitioner, contends that the petitioner was
informed under provisions of Right to Information Act, 2005 that
out of 25 candidates for the posts of Under Secretary, 23 seats
have been filled up and the remaining 2 seats are still vacant.
One post reserved for BL category is still lying vacant. Further,
one Miss Hissay Doma Lepcha from the BL category opted out
and against the said vacant post, one Mr. Topden Ongyal Zangpo
was selected. One more seat under BL (W) category fell vacant
on account of upward movement of Miss Kunga Diki Lachungpa
and Miss Sonam Palmu Bhutia.
The petitioner was placed just
below Miss Sonam Palmu Bhutia, who belonged to BL (W)
category. In such a factual scenario, the petitioner is entitled to
W.P. (C) No. 15 of 2016
Tshering Eden Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
appointment against the seat, which fell vacant accordingly.
Learned Counsel would further contend that the petitioner,
having been duly selected, is denied the appointment which
amounts to violation of her fundamental right and also the same
is discriminatory, arbitrary and illegal.
4.
Referring to a decision rendered by this Court in Mr.
Rinzing Choppel Rai vs. State of Sikkim & Ors. [W.P. (C)
No.66 of 2015], Mr. Upadhyaya seeks parity and similar order
for appointment.
5.
Responding to the aforestated submission as well as
averments made in the Writ Petition, Mr. Karma Thinlay, learned
Senior Government Advocate appearing for the first respondent/
State, would submit that 7 candidates under BL category were
recommended for appointment to the post of Under Secretary in
order of merit. Out of 7, 2 candidates, who were higher in the
merit list, were appointed against the unreserved category. The
petitioner obtained total marks of 478 on re-verification and was
placed in the 10th position in order of merit under the BL
category. The two other women, Miss Kunga Diki Lachungpa and
Miss Sonam Palmu Bhutia, who were appointed against BL(W)
category, obtained 485 and 482 marks respectively.
In the BL
category, 2 posts meant for BL(W) were accordingly filled up.
Mr. Thinlay would further contend that Miss Hissay Doma Lepcha,
W.P. (C) No. 15 of 2016
Tshering Eden Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
who was appointed on the post of Under Secretary, declined the
offer as she was working as Veterinary Officer in Mangan. The
post, fallen vacant, was carried forward to the next recruitment
process.
6.
It
is
further
contended
that
under
horizontal
reservation, if the two seats are filled up by women candidates,
the other seat must go to a candidate on merit. In the case on
hand, the petitioner is below the other two applicants namely,
Mr. Zenden Lingzerpa and Mr. Salem Lepcha, who have obtained
479 and 478 marks respectively and as such the petitioner is not
entitled to an appointment in preference to their candidature. It
was reiterated by Mr. Thinlay that two seats reserved for women
candidates under BL category are filled up by Miss Kunga Diki
Lachungpa and Miss Sonam Palmu Bhutia. Thus, the writ petition
is misconceived and deserves to be dismissed.
7.
I have considered anxiously the submissions put forth
by the learned counsel for the parties, perused and analyzed the
pleadings and documents appended thereto.
8.
Indisputably, the marks obtained by the petitioner
were revised on revaluation and it was enhanced to 478 from
462, accordingly, she was upgraded in the merit list of BL
category for appointment on the post of Under Secretary.
The
W.P. (C) No. 15 of 2016
Tshering Eden Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
merit list for the appointment on the post of Under Secretary was
published on 09th June 2015 as under:
Roll
No.
Name
Gender
Tenzing Choden Bhutia
Sisum Wangchuk Bhutia
Tenzing Pema Bhutia
Hissay Doma Lepcha
Topden Ongyal Zangpo
Kunga Diki Lachungpa
Sonam Palmu Bhutia
Zenden Lingserpa
Salem Lepcha
Tshering Eden Bhutia
Nancy Choden Lhasungpa
Rinkila Bhutia
Yangchen Doma Bhutia
Tseten Palzor Bhutia
Female
Male
Female
Female
Male
Female
Female
Male
Male
Female
Female
Female
Female
Male
Deeki Wangmo Euthenpa
Tshering Lhamu Bhutia
Female
Female
9.
Total
Marks
obtained
(Dy.SP)
Recommend/
Selected
Recommended
Recommended
Recommended
Recommended
Recommended
Recommended
Recommended
Category/
Roster
Point
UR/16
UR/22
BL/02
BL/12
BL/17
BL(W)/07
BL(W)/21
Recommended
BL/02
The five persons were selected for appointment under
BL category are (i) Miss Tenzing Pema Bhutia, (ii) Miss Hissay
Doma Lepcha, (iii) Mr. Topden Ongyal Zangpo, (iv) Miss Kunga
Diki Lachungpa and (v) Miss Sonam Palmu Bhutia.
Out of five
seats reserved for BL category, two seats were meant for BL
(Women).
Under
horizontal
reservation,
requirement
of
appointment of two women candidates was met on appointment
of Miss Kunga Diki Lachungpa and Miss Sonam Palmu Bhutia,
who obtained 485 and 482 marks respectively.
The petitioner
was placed at Sl. No. 3, however, in all, there were two male
members, one obtained more marks than the petitioner i.e. 479
and the other one obtained equal marks, but was placed above
her in merit on the basis of other criteria.
The petitioner is
W.P. (C) No. 15 of 2016
Tshering Eden Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
claiming appointment against the post which remained vacant on
account of refusal of Miss Hissay Doma Lepcha. The contention
of Mr. Upadhyaya is that selection of Miss Kunga Diki Lachungpa
as well as Miss Sonam Palmu Bhutia was against general
category, being better placed in the merit list.
Thus, reserved
seat for women category be treated as vacant and against that
the petitioner be appointed in preference to other candidates,
who have obtained more marks.
The contention of Mr.
Upadhyaya is misconceived and is rejected on the sole ground
that the reservation for a woman in a particular category comes
within the ambit of horizontal reservation.
The concept and
philosophy of this kind of reservation is that within the post
reserved for a particular category, there should be sufficient
representation and placement of women.
Accordingly, two BL
(Women) seats meant for women candidates are already filled
up.
Thus, the petitioner is not entitled to march over other
candidates, who have better marks and merit than the petitioner.
If the post has fallen vacant, on opting out by Miss Hissay Doma
Lepcha, the same may go to the second candidate, who is a male
member and not to the petitioner on the ground that the seat
has fallen vacant on account of the fact that a woman has
declined.
W.P. (C) No. 15 of 2016
Tshering Eden Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
10.
Under the constitutional scheme, Article 15 (3) of the
Constitution of India enables the State to make any special
provision for women and children, in addition to reservation
provided to socially and educationally backward classes of
citizens as contemplated under clauses (4) and (5) of Article 15.
Article 16 provides equality of opportunity in matters of public
employment carving out exception under clauses (3), (4), (4A)
and (4B).
The Court is not concerned with other clauses of
reservation in this petition.
11.
The
issue
came
up
for
consideration
in
Indra
Sawhney vs. Union of India and others1, wherein a nine
Judges Bench of the Supreme Court, examining all aspects of the
reservation, analyzed and differentiated the reservation under
Article 16 (4) and reservation under other clauses as under: “95. We are also of the opinion that this rule of 50% applies
only to reservations in favour of backward classes made
under Article 16(4). A little clarification is in order at this
juncture: all reservations are not of the same nature. There
are two types of reservations, which may, for the sake of
convenience, be referred to as 'vertical reservations' and
'horizontal reservations'. The reservations in favour of
Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and other backward
classes (under Article 16(4) may be called vertical
reservations whereas reservations in favour of physically
handicapped (under Clause (1) of Article 16) can be referred
to as horizontal reservations. Horizontal reservations cut
across the vertical reservations - what is called inter-locking
reservations. To be more precise, suppose 3% of the
vacancies are reserved in favour of physically handicapped
persons; this would be a reservation relatable to Clause (1)
of Article 16. The persons selected against this quota will be
placed in the appropriate category; if he belongs to S.C.
category he will be placed in that quota by making
necessary adjustments; similarly, if he belongs to open
competition (O.C.) category, he will be placed in that
category by making necessary adjustments. Even after
AIR 1993 SC 477
W.P. (C) No. 15 of 2016
Tshering Eden Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
providing for these horizontal reservations, the percentage
of reservations in favour of backward class of citizens
remains - and should remain - the same. This is how these
reservations are worked out in several States and there is
no reason not to continue that procedure.
It is, however, made clear that the rule of 50% shall
be applicable only to reservations proper; they shall not be
- indeed cannot be - applicable to exemptions, concessions
or relaxations, if any, provided to 'Backward Class of
Citizens' under Article 16(4).”
12.
In Anil Kumar Gupta and others vs. State of U.P.
and others2, referring to the principle of law laid down by the
Supreme Court in Indra Sawhney (supra), the Supreme Court
reiterated the proposition of law as under:
“18.
………….. The proper and correct course is to first fill
up the O.C. quota (50%) on the basis of merit; then fill up
each of the social reservation quotas, i.e., SC, ST and BC;
the third step would be to find out how many candidates
belonging to special reservations have been selected on the
above basis. If the quota fixed for horizontal reservations is
already satisfied - in case it is an over-all horizontal
reservation - no further question arises. But if it is not so
satisfied, the requisite number of special reservation
candidates shall have to be taken and adjusted/
accommodated against their respective social reservation
categories by deleting the corresponding number of
candidates therefrom. (If, however, it is a case of
compartmentalised horizontal reservation, then the process
of verification and adjustment/accommodation as stated
above should be applied separately to each of the vertical
reservations. In such a case, the reservation of fifteen per
cent in favour of special categories, overall, may be satisfied
or may not be satisfied.) ……………”
13.
Again in Rajesh Kumar Daria vs. Rajasthan Public
Service Commission and others3, the aforestated proposition
of law was reaffirmed and observed as under: “8.
We may also refer to two related aspects before
considering the facts of this case. The first is about the
description of horizontal reservation. For example, if there
are 200 vacancies and 15% is the vertical reservation for
(1995) 5 SCC 173
(2007) 8 SCC 785
W.P. (C) No. 15 of 2016
Tshering Eden Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
SC and 30% is the horizontal reservation for women, the
proper description of the number of posts reserved for SC,
should be : "For SC : 30 posts, of which 9 posts are for
women".
We find that many a time this is wrongly
described thus : "For SC : 21 posts for men and 9 posts for
women, in all 30 posts". Obviously, there is, and there can
be, no reservation category of “male” or “men”.
9. The second relates to the difference between the
nature of vertical reservation and horizontal reservation.
Social reservations in favour of SC, ST and OBC
under Article 16(4) are “vertical reservations”. Special
reservations in favour of physically handicapped, women
etc., under Articles 16(1) or 15(3) are “horizontal
reservations”. Where a vertical reservation is made in
favour of a Backward Class under Article 16(4), the
candidates belonging to such Backward Class, may compete
for non-reserved posts and if they are appointed to the nonreserved posts on their own merit, their number will not be
counted against the quota reserved for the respective
Backward Class. Therefore, if the number of SC candidates,
who by their own merit, get selected to open competition
vacancies, equals or even exceeds the percentage of posts
reserved for SC candidates, it cannot be said the
reservation quota for SCs has been filled. The entire
reservation quota will be intact and available in addition to
those selected under open competition category. [Vide Indra Sawhney (supra), R. K. Sabharwal v. State of Punjab
[(1995) 2 SCC 745], Union of India v. Virpal Singh
Chauhan [(1995) 6 SCC 684] and Ritesh R. Sah v. Dr. Y. L.
Yamul [(1996) 3 SCC 253]. But the aforesaid principle
applicable to vertical (social) reservations will not apply to
horizontal
(special) reservations.
Where a
special
reservation for women is provided within the social
reservation for Scheduled Castes, the proper procedure is
first to fill up the quota for Scheduled Castes in order of
merit and then find out the number of candidates among
them who belong to the special reservation group of
“Scheduled Caste women”. If the number of women in such
list is equal to or more than the number of special
reservation quota, then there is no need for further
selection towards the special reservation quota. Only if
there is any shortfall, the requisite number of Scheduled
Caste women shall have to be taken by deleting the
corresponding number of candidates from the bottom of the
list relating to Scheduled Castes. To this extent, horizontal
(special)
reservation
differs
from
vertical
(social)
reservation. Thus women selected on merit within the
vertical reservation quota will be counted against the
horizontal reservation for women. Let us illustrate by an
example :
If 19 posts are reserved for SCs (of which the
quota for women is four), 19 SC candidates shall
have to be first listed in accordance with merit, from
out of the successful eligible candidates. If such list
of 19 candidates contains four SC woman
candidates, then there is no need to disturb the list
by including any further SC woman candidate. On
the other hand, if the list of 19 SC candidates
contains only two woman candidates, then the next
two SC woman candidates in accordance with merit,
W.P. (C) No. 15 of 2016
Tshering Eden Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
will have to be included in the list and corresponding
number of candidates from the bottom of such list
shall have to be deleted, so as to ensure that the
final 19 selected SC candidates contain four woman
SC candidates. (But if the list of 19 SC candidates
contains more than four woman candidates, selected
on own merit, all of them will continue in the list and
there is no question of deleting the excess woman
candidates on the ground that “SC women” have
been selected in excess of the prescribed internal
quota of four.)”
14.
It is well established proposition of law that the
horizontal reservation is to ensure minimum reservation of
women in a vertical category.
A woman candidate selected on
merit in the category will be reckoned for the purpose of
determining the fulfillment of reservation of women category in a
particular vertically reserved category.
Applying the said
principle to the facts of the case, wherein two seats reserved for
BL (Women) are filled up, other woman candidate cannot be
permitted to supersede or bypass the merit list. As in the case
on hand, there are two male candidates, who are better placed in
the merit list and as such the petitioner is not entitled to
appointment in preference to others.
15.
It is lastly contended by Mr. Upadhyaya that the other
candidates, who obtained more marks have not come officially to
claim appointment, thus, a direction be issued to appoint the
petitioner against the vacant post of the Under Secretary.
Not
approaching the Court for relief cannot deprive the eligible
candidate his/her right to appointment for the reason, other
W.P. (C) No. 15 of 2016
Tshering Eden Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
candidate having lesser marks knocked the door of justice.
In
such view, the petitioner cannot claim appointment in preference
to other meritorious candidates.
It is apt to refer herein an
observation made by the Supreme Court in R.K. Jain vs. Union
of India4, which reads as under: “74.
……………… In service jurisprudence it is settled law
that it is for the aggrieved person i.e. non-appointee to
assail the legality of the offending action. Third party has
no locus standi to canvass the legality or correctness of the
action. Only public law declaration would be made at the
behest of the petitioner, a public-spirited person.”
16.
In the case of Rinzing Chopel Rai (supra), cited by
Mr. Upadhyaya, the petitioner, being properly placed in the merit
list, was given appointment to the post of Deputy Superintendent
of Police by the State during pendency of the petition and as
such the petition was dismissed as having become infructuous.
The facts involved in the instant case
are different and
distinguishable, thus, not applicable.
16.
As a sequel, there is no merit in the case.
The writ
petition is dismissed. No order as to costs.
Chief Justice
03.08.2017
pm/jk
Approved for Reporting
Internet
(1993) 4 SCC 119
: Yes/No.
: Yes/No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review