Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010607122017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
Bench
Sr.No:-68
[3584]
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS
APPEAL Nos:448 AND 3188 OF 2017
M.A.C.M.A.No.448 of 2017
National Insurance Company Limited, Nellore
...Appellant
Vs.
Trishla W/o.late Vipul Kumar, Nellore and 4 Others
...Respondent(s)
**********
CORAM : THE CHIEF JUSTICE LISA GILL
SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
DATE
: 3rd September 2026
Present:
Advocate for Appellant:
MS.MANIMMA MEDIDA (FOR
INSURER)
Advocate for Respondents:
MR.SIVAPRASAD REDDY
VENATI (FOR CLAIMANTS)
***
COMMON JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Challa Gunaranjan)
Both insurer as well as claimants preferred present appeals
under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short, “the Act”),
dissatisfied by award, dated 09.09.2016, in M.V.O.P.No.689 of 2010,
passed by the Chairman, Principal Motor Vehicle Accidents Claims
Tribunal, Nellore (for short, “the Tribunal”), by which compensation of
₹45,59,000/- was awarded along with interest at the rate of 9% per
annum.
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.448
& 3188 of 2017
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties hereinafter are referred
to as they were arrayed in the M.V.O.P. before the Tribunal.
3.
M.A.C.M.A. No.448 of 2017 was filed by the Insurer and
M.A.C.M.A. No.3188 of 2017 by the claimants.
4.
Brief facts of the case are as follows:
(a) Deceased was aged 30 years and engaged in gold and
shares business. While he was proceeding on motorcycle, along with
his brother-in-law, when they reached Mini Bypass road at four lines
junction of Bakthavastala Nagar, Nellore, lorry bearing registration
No.AP-16-T-4944, belonging to 1st respondent, on account of rash and
negligent driving of its driver, dashed against the motorcycle from
behind. Resultantly, deceased fell down on ground and front wheels of
lorry ran over him, thus, deceased succumbed on spot.
(b) Deceased claimed to be earning ₹6,00,000/- per annum,
therefore, wife, minor daughter, and parents of deceased preferred the
claim for compensation.
(c) The incident was reported to police, and Crime No.68 of
2010 for the offence punishable under Section 304-A of IPC was
registered against driver of offending lorry. After completion of
investigation, police laid charge sheet.
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.448
& 3188 of 2017
5.
1st respondent, owner of the lorry, remained ex parte.
6.
2nd respondent, insurer of the lorry, filed written statement
denying that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of
driver of the lorry, rather, it was pleaded that the accident occurred due
to rash and negligent driving of motorcycle by deceased himself.
Further, it was also pleaded that the driver of lorry did not possess
valid and effective driving licence, therefore, the same amounted to
violation of terms and conditions of policy. Besides, the avocation, age
and income of deceased were also disputed, and accordingly, prayed
for dismissal of the claim.
7.
Based on the aforesaid pleadings, the Tribunal framed the
following issues and additional issues:
“1) Whether the death of the deceased Vipul Kumar was due to
rash and negligent driving of the driver of the lorry bearing registration
No.AP-16-TV-4944?
2) Whether the claimants are entitled for any compensation, if
so, how much amount and against which of the respondents?
3) To what relief?
Additional Issues:
1) Whether the owner and insurance company of the motorcycle
are proper and necessary parties in view of the plea of contributory
negligence of the rider of the motorcycle as pleaded by R2?
2) Whether the driver of the lorry and the deceased are not
having valid driving licenses as pleaded by R2?”
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.448
& 3188 of 2017
8.
Claimants examined PW.1 to PW.4 and marked Exs.A1 to A17.
The insurer examined RW.1 to RW.3 and marked Ex.C1 and Exs.X.1
to X,6.
9.
On appreciation of evidence on record, the Tribunal held that
accident took place due to rash and negligent driving of the lorry by its
driver, which resulted in death of deceased. Having held so, the
Tribunal answered additional Issue No.1, holding that it would be
inconsequential for the owner and insurer of motorcycle being arrayed
as necessary parties. Insofar as, additional Issue No.2, the Tribunal
held that the insurer did not adduce any evidence nor produced any
material documents to indicate that the driver of offending lorry did not
possess valid and effective driving licence. Further, the Tribunal also
held that as it has already decided that accident occurred on account
of rash and negligent driving of the driver of offending lorry, that there
was no negligence attributable to the deceased, whether the
deceased had valid driving licence or not would be of no significance,
however, at any rate, the Tribunal believed that the claimants under
Ex.A10 could establish that deceased had valid driving licence to drive
motorcycle. Coming to the aspect of income of deceased, the income
tax returns filed under Exs.A11, A13 to A15 were taken into
consideration, accordingly, the income was assessed on notional basis
at ₹3,60,000/- per annum. 1/3rd of the same was deducted towards
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.448
& 3188 of 2017
personal and living expenses. Considering the age of deceased as 30
years, 17 multiplier was applied. The Tribunal granted future prospects
at the rate of 50%, considering that deceased was self-employed, and
after deducting 30% out of the same, towards income tax, assessed
the loss of income. Further, it also awarded ₹25,000/- towards funeral
expenses, ₹1,00,000/- towards loss of consortium to 1st claimant-wife;
₹1,00,000/- towards loss of love and affection to 2nd claimant, and
₹50,000/- towards loss of estate, thus, in total awarded ₹45,59,000/-,
payable along with interest at the rate of 9% per annum.
10.
Both insurer as well as claimants challenged the award in
respective appeals.
11.
Heard Ms.Manimma Medida, learned counsel for Insurer and
Mr.Sivaprasad Reddy Venati, learned counsel for claimants.
12.
Learned counsel for insurer raised the following contentions:
(i) That the Tribunal erred in fixing entire liability on insurer
without appreciating the evidence on record, which suggested that
there was contributory negligence on the part of deceased, as the
accident has occurred on account of collision of lorry and the
motorcycle on which the deceased was proceeding. Further, the
Tribunal also erred in believing that the driver of offending lorry did
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.448
& 3188 of 2017
possess valid and effective driving licence for the purpose of attributing
liability to the insurer;
(ii) The Tribunal further erred in considering income of deceased
at ₹3,60,000/- per annum on national basis, which is excessive and
exorbitant and not supported by any evidence, further, it is also
submitted that the Tribunal awarded future prospects at the rate of
50%, which is also not in consonance with the law laid down by
Hon’ble Apex Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi1.
(iii) Further, the interest awarded at the rate of 9% p.a. is also
excessive, and that the Tribunal also awarded various components of
compensation under conventional heads, which are not in consonance
with the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in Pranay Sethi1.
13.
Conversely, learned counsel for claimants, while supporting the
award to the extent of fixing the liability on the insurer as well as
determination of income of deceased at ₹3,60,000/- per annum, further
contended that the Tribunal ought not to have applied flat rate of 30%
income tax on income assessed, rather it ought to have applied the
then income tax slab rates.
14.
We have given our anxious consideration to the submissions
advanced by both parties and perused the record.
1(2017) 16 SCC 680
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.448
& 3188 of 2017
15.
Given the facts and circumstances, following questions would
fall for our consideration.
1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in negating
contributory negligence on the part of deceased and fixing
negligence solely on driver of offending lorry for causing
the accident, thereby fastening liability on insurer for entire
compensation?
2. Whether the amount of compensation determined
by the Tribunal is just, fair and reasonable? If not, what
would be proper compensation to be awarded?
16.
POINT No.1
As per the version of claimants, on 09.07.2010 at about 04.00
p.m., while deceased and his brother-in-law were proceeding on
motorcycle,
when
they
reached
four
road
junction
at
Bhaktavasthala Nagar, Nellore, the offending lorry, driven by its driver
in a rash and negligent manner, has hit motorcycle from behind, thus,
deceased fell down on ground and front tyres of lorry have ran over
him, thus, deceased succumbed on spot due to severe injuries. In
order to prove the same, claimants have relied on evidence of PW.2,
eye witness. PW.2 was also one of the listed witnesses in the charge
sheet. The claimants exhibited Ex.A1 FIR, Ex.A2 post mortem report,
Ex.A3 inquest report, and Ex.A4 charge sheet, to establish that
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.448
& 3188 of 2017
accident occurred on account of rash and negligent driving of driver of
offending lorry,
17.
PW2 in his evidence categorically stated that he witnessed the
occurrence of incident. He further deposed that the lorry had hit the
motorcycle from behind, consequently, deceased fell down, and the
front wheels of lorry ran over him. As against aforesaid evidence, the
insurer, except for cross-examining PW.2, has not led in any other
evidence to suggest that deceased, who was driving motorcycle, was
negligent and contributed to the accident. Since it is the insurer who
had set up the plea of contributory negligence, the onus clearly rests
on it to prove the same. The best person who could have spoken
about the manner of occurrence of accident would be none other than
driver of offending lorry, admittedly, he was not examined. The
Tribunal, on appreciation of aforesaid evidence, has come to
conclusion that there was no iota of evidence to suggest any
contributory negligence on the part of deceased, rather, the evidence
clearly pointed out the negligence solely to the driver of offending lorry.
As it is now fairly settled that in the motor accident cases, the aspect of
negligence is required to be proved only on the touchstone of
preponderance of probabilities, but not beyond all reasonable doubts,
we are of the view that claimants have let in sufficient evidence,
pointing out negligence to the driver of offending lorry. The findings of
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.448
& 3188 of 2017
the Tribunal with regard to aforesaid aspect are sound and reasonable,
therefore, do not call for any interference.
18.
Insofar as the plea of insurer, that driver of offending lorry since
did not possess valid and effective driving licence, no liability could
have been fastened on it, in our considered opinion, is clearly
unsubstantiated. It is for the insurer to prove aforesaid aspect by
producing proper evidence, admittedly, it did not even examine the
driver of offending lorry, therefore, the Tribunal has rightly rejected the
said plea.
19.
POINT No.2:
To prove the income of deceased, claimants have examined
PW.3, Chartered Accountant, PW.4, Superintendent in Income Tax
Office and relied on Exs.A5 to A7, which are income tax returns for
assessment years 2008-09, 2009-10, and 2010-11. Further, they also
relied on Exs.A11, A13 to A15, which are income tax returns for
assessment years 2003-04, 2004-05, 2005-06 and 2006-07. The
income tax returns for financial years 2008-09, 2009-10 and 2010-11,
since were filed after the occurrence of accident and death, the
Tribunal did not take the same into consideration. However, income tax
returns filed under Exs.A11, A13 to A15 relating to assessment years
2003-04,
2004-05,
2005-06
and
2006-07
were
taken
into
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.448
& 3188 of 2017
consideration.
Further,
under
Ex.A17,
acknowledgement
for
assessment year 2006-07 was also produced. The gross income
declared for aforesaid years was ₹2,10,720/-, ₹2,00,836/-, ₹2,14,905/and ₹5,98,331/- respectively. The deceased was earning income
mainly on account of business carried on in gold and shares. It was
driven by the financial market scenario. Taking into consideration the
fact that deceased was assessed to income tax as early as from
assessment year 2003-04 and he has been consistently earning
income, which was predominantly on account of trading in gold and
shares, the Tribunal has considered gross income at ₹3,60,000/- per
annum. The Tribunal has assessed the same on notional basis. No
doubt, the Tribunal has rightly discarded the income tax returns filed
for
the
assessment
years
2008-09,
2009-10
and
2010-11,
nevertheless, the same indicate that deceased had regular business
income.
20.
Normally, if it is a case of salaried employee, income as
reflected in income tax return indicates the annual income from salary,
and there would be a greater amount of certainty depending on
whether such employee is holding permanent employment or
temporary
employment.
However,
if
it
is
a
case of
self-
employed individual, the income reflected in the income tax returns
would not be static, rather, it depends on various intervening
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.448
& 3188 of 2017
circumstances, such as nature of business, area where it is carried on,
potential and growth pattern of business, impact of death, and such
other factors. Normally, in cases where income tax returns for the past
three years before death are on record, the average income of three
years is to be adopted. For any reason, the immediate past three
years' income tax returns are either not readily available, or they came
to be filed after the death, while assessing income of deceased, one
should evaluate surrounding factors and circumstances and vis-a-vis
the variance in the income on a year-on-year basis, however, subject
to the same being sufficiently supported by financial statements, etc.
The determination of compensation is not an exact science and the
exercise
involves
an
assessment
based
on
estimation
and
conjectures, in the process, as many imponderable factors and
unpredictable contingencies have to be taken into consideration. In the
present case, the Tribunal has given due credence to the income for
assessment years 2004-05, 2005-06, and 2006-07, which are three
years before the occurrence of accident, however, it has also given
credence to the nature and potentiality of business carried on by
deceased and thus, arrived at the income of deceased at ₹3,60,000/per annum on national basis.
21.
Considering totality of circumstances, we are of the view that the
Tribunal has rightly assessed the income of deceased at ₹3,60,000/-
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.448
& 3188 of 2017
per annum and we do not see any reason to interdict with the same.
Having said that, the Tribunal has deducted flat 30% of the same
towards income tax, which is not justified. Rather, the Tribunal should
have applied income tax slab rates prevailing at that point of time. As
per the slab rates for financial year 2010-11, assessment year 201112, income tax up to ₹1,60,000/- is nil and over and above ₹1,60,000/and up to ₹5,00,000/- income tax rate is 10% (i.e., ₹2,00,000/- x 10%
= ₹20,000/-). Thus, ₹20,000/- has to be deducted towards income tax,
and accordingly, net income of deceased would be ₹3,40,000/- per
annum.
The
Tribunal
has
held that
3rd
claimant,
father of
deceased, was also in the business of gold and had independent
earnings and living separately. Therefore, 3rd claimant, father of
deceased, was found not to be depending on the deceased.
Accordingly, considering that there were only three dependants, onethird of income towards personal and living expenses was deducted.
We sustain the same. Therefore, 1/3rd of income is deducted towards
personal and living expenses.
22.
Further, the Tribunal has awarded future prospects at the rate of
50%. Since the deceased was self-employed, considering his age,
claimants would be entitled for future prospects at the rate of 40%.
Even the amounts awarded under various components, falling under
conventional heads, are on higher side, thus, the same are revised in
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.448
& 3188 of 2017
consonance with the law laid down by Hon’ble Apex Court in Pranay
Sethi1, and rate of interest is also revised to 7.5%.
23.
The claimants, therefore,
are
entitled to
just
and
fair
compensation as under:
Compensation
Heads
Net annual income
Future Prospects
(Age being 30
years)
Deduction (1/3)
Multiplier (17)
Loss of Income of
the deceased
Loss of Estate
Funeral expenses
Loss of
Consortium
Amount Awarded
₹3,40,000/40% of ₹3,40,000/- =
₹1,36,000/₹4,76,000/- – ₹1,58,667/- =
₹3,17,333/₹3,17,333/- x 17 =
₹53,94,661/(rounded off to
₹53,94,700/-)
In Accordance
with:
National
Insurance Co.
Ltd. v. Pranay
Sethi
(2017) 16 SCC
Para 37, 39, 41,
42 and 59.4
₹53,94,700₹18,150/National Insurance
(with 10% increase every Co. Ltd. v. Pranay
3 years from 2017)
Sethi
(2017) 16 SCC 680
₹18,150/(with 10% increase every Para 37, 39, 41, 42
and 59.4
3 years from 2017)
United India
Insurance Co. Ltd.
v. Satinder Kaur,
(2021) 11 SCC 780
Para 37.12
Rajwati alias Rajjo
₹48,400x3 = ₹1,45,200/v. United India
(with 10% increase every
Insurance Co. Ltd.
3 years from 2017)
2022 SCC OnLine
SC 1699
Para 34
Sadhana Tomar v.
Ashok Khushwaha
2025 SCC OnLine
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.448
& 3188 of 2017
SC 554
Para 17
Total
24.
₹55,76,200/-
Accordingly, both these appeals are disposed of. The impugned
award, dated 09.09.2016, shall stand modified by revising the
compensation amount to Rs.55,76,200/- as just and fair compensation,
along with interest at the rate of 7.5% p.a. thereon from the date of
claim petition till date of realisation.
Out of which, 1st claimant is
entitled to Rs.30,76,200/-, 2nd claimant is entitled to Rs.18,00,000/and 4th claimant is entitled to Rs.7,00,000/-.
The 2nd respondent
Insurer to deposit the amount as aforesaid, adjusting the amount
already deposited/paid if any, before the Tribunal within one month.
On such deposit being made, the claimants shall be entitled to
withdraw the same as apportioned above, failing which, the amount
shall be recovered as per law. No order as to costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
LISA GILL, CJ
CHALLA GUNARANJAN,J
cs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review