The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. In the result, the petition is allowed. The respondents are directed to release the remaining amount of gratuity of ₹2,35,754 by applying the revised limit. This payment shall be made along with simple interest @ 7.5% per annum from one month after the date of retirement till actual payments. Directions to be carried out within 4(four) months from today.” Placing reliance upon those two decisions, learned Single Judge had passed the following directions upon the respondents-TRTC: “[7]In view of the above discussion, respondents are directed to release the remaining amount of gratuity payable to the petitioner which shall carry simple interest at the rate of
7. 5% per annum after the completion of 1 (one) month from the date of retirement till actual payment. Payment shall be made within 3 (three) months from today.” Furthermore, the said issue was also decided by a Division Bench of this Court (comprising of S. Talapatra,J and S. G. Chattopadhyay,J in an intra-court appeal in WA No. 185 of 2020) and held that all the corporations and other establishments under the State Government shall come within the purview of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 as amended time to time by the Central Government. The relevant part of the said judgment may be reproduced here-in-below: “Admittedly, the writ petitioner is not an employee of the Central Government or State Government but of a local body. As such the said exception as curved out while defining „employee‟ cannot authorise Agartala Municipal Corporation (the appellant) to make their own rules which is in contrast to the provisions of Central Statute namely the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 in as much as the Central Government has notified that local bodies having employees more than ten would be covered by the provisions of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.” In view of this settled proposition of law, we are of the opinion that the writ-petitioner is entitled to get the benefit of gratuity at the enhanced rate of Rs. 20,00,000/-. Accordingly, we find no infirmity in the judgment passed by the lear…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA No. 207 of 2020
1. Tripura Road Transport Corporation,
(A Govt. of Tripura undertaking) to be represented
by the Chairman, Tripura Road Transport Corporation,
Krishnanagar, Agartala, West Tripura
2. The Managing Director,
Tripura Road Transport Corporation,
Krishnanagar, Agartala,
West Tripura
---- Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Lal Zakim Rokhum,
S/o. Lt. Shilnung Rokhum,
R/o. Howaibari, Teliamura,
P.O & P.S- Teliamura,
District-Khowai Tripura
---- Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
:
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, GA
Mr. P. Saha, Advocate
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY
Judgment and Order
29/07/2022
Heard Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned GA assisted by Mr. P.
Saha, learned counsel appearing for the appellants-TRTC, the
respondents in the writ petition. Also heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned
senior counsel assisted by Mr. K. Nath, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent, writ petitioner. For convenience, the parties are referred to
here-in-below according to their original status in the writ petition.
The respondents-TRTC have preferred the present appeal
challenging the legality and validity of the judgment and order dated
20.02.2020, wherein a learned Single Judge of this Court had passed an
order directing the respondent-TRTC to release the gratuity payable to the
writ-petitioner at the rate of Rs. 20,00,000/- along with simple interest at
the rate of 7.5% per annum after completion of 1 (one) month from the
date of retirement till actual payment.
Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned GA has submitted that
the
respondents-TRTC have paid gratuity to the writ-petitioner considering
the ceiling limit at Rs. 10,00,000/-. During his argument, learned GA has
relied upon Section 4-A of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.
We are at a loss to understand as to how Section 4-A of the
Payment of Gratuity Act will be applicable in case of the writ-petitioner
or as to how the respondents-TRTC are relying upon Section 4-A of the
said act. To rely upon Section 4-A of the Payment of Gratuity Act, TRTC
being an establishment of the State Government has to bring all its
employees under the coverage of insurance policy. Each and every
employees of this establishment is to be insured and liability absolutely
lies upon the Corporation to bring its employees under the umbrella of
insurance policy.
In the instant case, the respondents-corporation have not
brought their employees under the umbrella of the insurance policy. They
did not buy any policy from the Life Insurance Corporation of India as
contemplated under Section 4-A of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.
As such, according to us, Section 4-A has no application in deciding the
instant writ petition as well as the appeal before us. It is an admitted
position that none of the employees have been brought under the
Insurance coverage by the corporation. Hence, we repel the submissions
of learned GA on this point.
Next, we have to decide whether the TRTC, being an
establishment of the State Government is liable to pay gratuity
considering the upper ceiling limit as enhanced by the Central
Government vide notification dated 29.03.2018.
This issue has already been settled by this Court in a series
of decisions. Learned Single Judge while deciding a writ petition
involving similar question of law relied upon the judgment of Bhupati
Debnath Vrs. The State of Tripura and Ors [WP(C) No. 1054/2019,
decided on 13th February, 2020] and had observed thus:
“[5] Both these issues came up for consideration in
two recent judgments passed by this Court. In case of Sri
Bhupati Debnath Vrs. The State of Tripura and Others:
W.P(c) No. 1054/2019 (decided on 13th February, 2020)
under somewhat similar circumstances it was held and
observed as under:
“10. It can thus be seen that insofar as the payment
of gratuity, its computation and the ceiling up to
which such amount can be paid as referred to in
Section 4 of the said Act, the term “appropriate
Government” has no bearing. This distinction is also
apparent from the statement of objects and reasons which
provides that for the purpose of uniformity, the Central Act
was envisaged. At the same time, appropriate Government is
for the purpose of administering the Act. The ceiling limit for
payment of gratuity is provided in sub-section (3) of Section
4. Previously, such ceilings were contained in the sub-section
itself. Pursuant to amendment by virtue of Act 12 of 2018 the
power to prescribe such ceiling has been vested in the Central
Government to be exercised by issuing notification in this
regard. It is in exercise of such delegated powers of
legislation that the Central Government has issued a
notification dated 29.03.2018 which reads as under:
“S.O. 1420 (E).—In exercise of the powers
conferred by sub-section (3) of section 4 of
the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (39 of
1972), the Central Government hereby specifies that
the amount of gratuity payable to an employee under
the said Act shall not exceed twenty lakh rupees.”
11. This revised ceiling thus would apply to all establishments
irrespective of whether they are controlled or governed by the
State or the Central Government as the appropriate
Government. The stand of the respondents, therefore, that
unless and until such revised ceiling of payment of gratuity is
adopted by the State Government, the employees of the said
corporation cannot claim benefit of such revised limit cannot
be accepted. Revised ceiling limit of ₹20,00,000 (rupees
twenty lakhs) would be applicable to the petitioner.
12. The corporation cannot cite the reason of financial
constraints indefinitely for paying post retiral benefits of its
employees. The petitioner has put in more than 29 years of
service. His service is not governed by the pension scheme.
After his retirement, therefore, he would have only savings in
the form of gratuity, provident fund accumulated in his
account and leave encashment, if any, to fall back upon in
his old age. Such amount must, therefore, be paid over to him
as soon as possible.
13. Under the circumstances, petition is disposed of with
following directions:
(i) As provided earlier, the petitioner shall apply to the
respondent No.2 stating his calculation of payable gratuity.
The respondent No.2 shall examine the petitioner’s
calculation and convey to him if any gratuity remains still
payable;
(ii) While calculating such gratuity, revised limit of
₹20,00,000 (rupees twenty lakhs) shall be applicable;
(iii) If there is any shortfall in payment of gratuity, the same
shall be paid within a period of 4(four) months from today
with simple interest @ 7.5% per annum from one month
after the date of superannuation till actual payments;
(iv) The remaining amount of leave encashment shall be
released within a period of 4(four) months from today. The
entire leave encashment payment shall carry simple interest
@ 7.5% per annum from one month after the date of
retirement till actual payments;
(v) The gratuity already paid shall also carry simple interest
@ 7.5% per annum from one month after the date of
retirement till actual payments.”
Thereafter, the learned Single Judge relied upon the case of
Mamata Singha Roy Vrs. The State of Tripura and Anr [WP(C) No.
1057/2019, decided on 13th February, 2020] and held thus:
“[6] In case of Smt. Mamata Singha Roy Vrs. The State
of Tripura and another: W.P(c) No. 1057/2019 (decided on
13th February, 2020) in the context of the said memorandum
dated 15.09.2016 it was further observed as under:
“8. Under the office memorandum dated 15.09.2016 the
Government correctly clarified this position and required all
PSUs/ Autonomous Bodies/ Societies/Boards/Corporations
under different departments to make arrangements to pay the
amount of gratuity as per the said revised limit. In the last
paragraph, however, it has been stated as under:
“The payment of Gratuity Act 1972 should not
be extended without prior concurrence of the
Finance under any circumstances. This direction has
been given by the Finance Department, Government
of Tripura vide No.-F.29(9)- Fin(G)/2004 dated 16th
August 2011.”
9. This portion cannot nullify the earlier clarification of all
PSUs/Autonomous Bodies/Societies etc. under the
department of the State Government to pay gratuity as per the
revised limit under the Payment of Gratuity (Amendment)
Act, 2010 (Act No.15 of 2010). Firstly, no directive not to pay
gratuity as per the statutory provision, can be made by
executive instructions. Secondly, one possible meaning of this
clarification is that when an organisation is extending the
benefit of Payment of Gratuity Act, concurrence of the
Finance Department will be needed. In either case, this last
paragraph of the said office memorandum cannot govern the
present case as per the correct legal position emerging from
this statute.
10. Thus, when the legislature amended the said Act by
Payment of Gratuity (Amendment) Act, 2010 (Act No.15 of
2010) and revised the ceiling of gratuity from ₹3,50,000
(three lakhs fifty thousand) to ₹10,00,000 (rupees ten lakhs),
the petitioner was governed by such provision. The ceiling of
gratuity payable was thus raised to ₹10,00,000 (rupees ten
lakhs). On the date of retirement this provision was
applicable. The act of the respondent No.2 to restrict
her gratuity to ₹4,00,000 (rupees four lakhs) against the
computed
gratuity
of
₹6,35,754
was
incorrect.
11. In the result, the petition is allowed. The
respondents are directed to release the remaining amount of
gratuity of ₹2,35,754 by applying the revised limit. This
payment shall be made along with simple interest @ 7.5% per
annum from one month after the date of retirement till actual
payments. Directions to be carried out within 4(four) months
from today.”
Placing reliance upon those two decisions, learned Single
Judge had passed the following directions upon the respondents-TRTC:
“[7]In view of the above discussion, respondents are directed
to release the remaining amount of gratuity payable to the
petitioner which shall carry simple interest at the rate of
7.5% per annum after the completion of 1 (one) month from
the date of retirement till actual payment. Payment shall be
made within 3 (three) months from today.”
Furthermore, the said issue was also decided by a Division
Bench of this Court (comprising of
S. Talapatra,J and S. G.
Chattopadhyay,J in an intra-court appeal in WA No. 185 of 2020) and
held that all the corporations and other establishments under the State
Government shall come within the purview of Payment of Gratuity Act,
1972 as amended time to time by the Central Government. The relevant
part of the said judgment may be reproduced here-in-below:
“Admittedly, the writ petitioner is not an employee of the
Central Government or State Government but of a local body.
As such the said exception as curved out while defining
„employee‟ cannot authorise Agartala Municipal Corporation
(the appellant) to make their own rules which is in contrast to
the provisions of Central Statute namely the Payment of
Gratuity Act, 1972 in as much as the Central Government has
notified that local bodies having employees more than ten
would be covered by the provisions of Payment of Gratuity Act,
1972.”
In view of this settled proposition of law, we are of the
opinion that the writ-petitioner is entitled to get the benefit of gratuity at
the enhanced rate of Rs. 20,00,000/-. Accordingly, we find no infirmity
in the judgment passed by the learned Single Judge and it is hereby
affirmed and upheld.
The respondents-Corporation are directed to pay the
remaining amount of gratuity at the enhanced rate of Rs. 20,00,000/- to
the writ-petitioner within a period of 3 (three) months from today.
In terms of the above observations and directions, the instant
writ appeal stands dismissed.
JUDGE
Snigdha
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review