Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
ARB.A. NO.10 OF 2022
1. Tripura Housing & Construction Board,
represented by its Deputy Executive Officer(W-III),
Gurkhabasti, PO:- Kunjaban-799006,
District:- West Tripura, Tripura.
2. The Chief Executive Officer,
Tripura Housing & Construction Board,
Gurkhabasti, PO:-Kunjaban-799006.
3. The State of Tripura,
represented by the Secretary-cum-Commissioner,
Public Works Department(R&B),
New Secretariat Building,
PO Kunjaban,
Agartala, West Tripura.
.......Applicant-Appellant(s)
Versus
M/s Raimohan Majumder & Co.,
represented by its partner and
attorney, Sri Shyamal Kanti Majumder,
Milan Chakra, TV Tower, Road No.4/A,
PO:- A.D Nagar,
Pin:- 799003,
Agartala, Tripura West, Tripura.
....... Respondent-contractor(s)
For the applicant-appellant(s)
:
Mr. K. De, Addl. GA
For the respondent(s)
:
Mr. A. Sengupta, Advocate
Date of hearing and
delivery of Judgment & Order
:
24. 01.2024
Whether fit for reporting
:
No
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Heard Mr. K. De, learned Addl. GA appearing for the applicantappellants as well as Mr. A. Sengupta, learned counsel for the respondent.
2.
This appeal filed under Section 37(1)(c) of Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996(for short, the Act of 1996) read with Section 13(1A)
of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 is directed against the impugned
judgment and order dated 19.03.2022, passed by the learned District
Commercial Court, West Tripura, Agartala, in Civil Misc.(Arbitration) No.05
of 2017, whereby and whereunder the learned Court below rejected the
application filed by the applicant-appellants and upheld the arbitral award
passed by the learned Arbitrator in Arbitration Proceeding No.1 of 2016.
3.
The factual background in the context of which the present
appeal has been filed is briefly enumerated hereunder:
3.1.
The claimant-respondent, being a registered contractor entered
into a contract Agreement being No.THCB/T/06/DED/(W-III)/13-14 with
the applicant-appellants, the Tripura Housing & Construction Board(here-inafter referred to as the „appellants-Board‟) for construction of Auditorium
Building of St. Paul‟s H.S School, A.D. Nagar, Agartala, Tripura. The total
cost of the contract work was Rs.1,77,40,695/- and the stipulated period for
completion of the said work was 10(ten) months from the date of issuance of
the work order dated 11.12.2013 and the work was scheduled to be
commenced from the fifteenth day of the date of issuance work order.
3.2.
The appellants-Board on 20.02.2014 had furnished the relevant
structural plan of the work to the claimant-respondent and the site was also
handed over to him on finalization of layout plan. Accordingly, the claimantrespondent mobilized his plants and machineries, etc. deploying watch and
wards staff and took preparation for execution of the work. But at that stage,
the authority of the St. Paul‟s H.S School did not allow the claimantrespondent to go ahead with the work on the plea that the layout of the work
site as finalized by the appellants-Board fell inside the playground of the
school and the school authority desired to shift the work site towards back
side of the school.
3.3.
Situated thus, since there was deviation of the work site, an
option was sought for on behalf of the appellants-Board from the claimantrespondent as to whether he was ready to execute the work necessitating the
shifting of the work site of construction at the agreement rate and in response
thereto the claimant-respondent communicated his decision to execute the
work as per agreement, claiming rate for the deviated amount as well.
However, the appellants-Board did not agree to accept the deviated amount
so claimed by the claimant-respondent. Ultimately, the work could not be
commenced, rather the contract was terminated and the work order was also
cancelled.
3.4.
As a result of the difference and disputes arose between the
parties, on a petition filed on behalf of the claimant-respondent this Court
appointed an Arbitrator for adjudication of the disputes arrived at between
the parties.
3.5.
Considering the controversies transpired from the respective
statement of claims and defense and the documents filed by the parties, the
learned Arbitrator framed the following issues:
“(1)
Is
the
cancellation
of
work
order
issued
under
No.F.2(68)/THCB/DEO(W-III)/2012/82-84
dated
01.01.2015
by
letter
the
Respondent-the Dy. Executive Officer(W-III) addressed to the Claimant
justified? If not, whether it amounted to breach of the terms and conditions of
the Agreement executed by and between the Claimant and the Respondents
under No THCB/06/DEO (W-III)/13-14 and the work order issued vide No.
F.2(68)/THCB/ DEO(W- III)/2012/5702-19 dated on 11.12.2013?
(2)
Has the Claimant suffered any loss due to cancellation of the said work
order under letter No.F.2(68)/THCB/DEO(W-III)/2012/82-84 dated 01.01.2015
above liable to be compensated? If it is in the affirmative, what shall be the
quantum of compensation?
(3)
Is the Claimant entitled to interest on the amount of compensation as
claimed for? If it is in the affirmative, what shall be the rate of compensation?
(4) Is the Claimant entitled to cost of arbitration as claimed for?”
3.6.
On going through the documentary evidence furnished by the
parties with their respective statement of claim and defense and having heard
the learned counsel of the parties, the learned Arbitrator by the impugned
order dated 18.04.2017 rendered the award in the following manner:
“(1) The respondents shall pay special damages on account of loss of profit
an amount of Rs.17,74,070/- being the 10% of the value of the contract of
Rs.1,77,40,695/- to the claimant within a period of three months from the date
of announcing this award;
(2) The claimant shall also be entitled to simple interest for the period from
07.02.2015 to 08.04.2017 @7% (seven percent) per annum and the claimant
shall also be entitled to future interest @9% (nine percent) per annum with
effect from 09.04.2017 till payment by the respondents.
(3) In case the respondents fails to make payment of the amount of award
including interest within the period of three months, the claimant shall be at
liberty to realize the amount by putting the award in execution.
(4) The cost of arbitration being the fees of the Arbitrator amounting to
Rs.3,37,500/- has already been borne equally by both the parties as ordered
by the Hon'ble the Chief Justice of the High Court of Tripura. So, no further
award is made as to cost.”
3.7.
Being aggrieved by the award dated 08.04.2017, the appellants-
Board filed a petition before learned District Commercial Court, West
Tripura, Agartala under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996 for setting aside the arbitral award passed by the learned Arbitrator in
Arbitration Proceeding No.01 of 2016 which was registered as Civil
Misc(Arbitration) No.05 of 2017. The learned District Commercial Court by
an order dated 19.03.2022 upheld the arbitral award passed by the learned
Arbitrator and rejected the petition filed by the appellants-Board. Hence, the
instant application at the instance of the applicant-appellants, Board.
4.
Mr. De, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the appellants
submitted that the Dy. Executive officer(W-III) could not hand over the clear
site to the respondent-contractor to facilitate the commencement of work. As
per the modified drawing, it was estimated to an amount of Rs.3,39,91,315/and the value of the work under the agreement with the claimant-respondent
was for an amount of Rs.1,77,40,695/- and thus, the deviation amount was
Rs.1,62,50,620/- which was 92% on the higher side. It was further argued
that to observe the formalities of a proposal for inclusion of deviation of
work in the agreement in issue was placed before the Board in its 86th
meeting, but the Board rejected the proposal and decided to invite fresh
tender on the basis of modified drawing, as it was technically not feasible to
get a part of the work done by one agency and the balance part by another
agency, the appellants-Board could not consider the willingness of the
claimant-respondent for execution of the work.
4.1.
Mr. K. De, learned Addl. GA further submitted that Clause 12
and 12A of the terms of contract cannot supersede the financial power of the
Executive Engineer or Dy. Engineer who signed the cancellation order on
behalf of the Tripura Housing & Construction Board. The Board is
constituted as per law and as such the Board has the power to rescind the
agreement under compelling circumstances, which does not fall within the
domain of dispute, as a result the decision of the Board cannot be held liable
for committing breach of contract between the parties. In the instant appeal,
the appellants have inter alia made the following prayers:
“(i) Admit this application;
(ii) Issue notice upon the respondent;
(iii) Call for the LC records;
(iv) After hearing the parties, set aside the judgment and order dated
19/03/2022 passed in Civil Mise(Arbitration) 05 of 2017 by the Ld District
Commercial Court, West Tripura, Agartala, along with arbitral Award passed
by the Ld. Arbitral Tribunal on 08/04/2017 in Arbitration Proceeding No. 1 of
2016;
(v) Any other order/order(s) may pass as Your Lordship may deem fit and
proper.”
5.
On the other hand, Mr. A. Sengupta, learned counsel appearing
for the respondent-contractor submitted that the learned Arbitrator while
discussing the issue no.1 rightly found that there was no justification in
cancellation of the work order. Mr. Sengupta, learned counsel unequivocally
submitted that the said cancellation of work order amounted to a breach of
contract on the part of appellant and as such, the respondent-contractor
claimed 15% of the value of contract as „loss of expected profit’.
5.1.
Further, Mr. Sengupta, learned counsel reiterated that while
deciding issue no.(ii), the learned Arbitrator relied on the decision laid down
by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in M/s A.T. Brijpaul Singh and Bros. vs.
State of Gujarat, reported in AIR 1984 SC 1703 : (1984) 4 SCC 59 and
decided that the claimant-respondent is entitled to special damages in the
head of „loss of profit’. Learned Arbitrator had referred to paragraphs 10 and
11 of the said judgment which are encapsulated here-in-below:
“10. What would be the measure of profit would depend upon facts and
circumstances of each case. But that there shall be a reasonable expectation
of profit implied in a works contract and its loss has to be compensated by
way of damages if the other party to the contract is guilty of breach of
contract cannot be gainsaid. In this case, we have the additional reason for
rejecting the contention that for the same type of work site being in the vicinity
of each other, and for identical type of work between the same parties, a
Division Bench of the same High Court had accepted 15% of the value of the
balance of the works contract would not be an unreasonable measure of
damages for loss of profit. We, therefore, are of the opinion that the High
Court was in error in wholly rejecting the claim under the head”
11. Now if it is well-established that the respondent was guilty of breach of
contract inasmuch as the rescission of contract by the respondent is held to be
unjustified, and the plaintiff contractor had executed a part of the works
contract, the contractor would be entitled to damages by way of loss of profit.
Adopting the measure accepted by the High Court in the facts and
circumstances of the case between the same parties and for the same type of
work at 15 per cent of the value of the remaining parts of the work contract,
the damages for loss of profit can be measured.”
6.
We have considered the rival submissions of learned counsel
appearing for the parties and gone through the relevant materials placed on
record. We have also gone through the award returned by the learned
Arbitrator as well as the judgment and order passed by learned District
Commercial Court whereby the arbitral award passed by the learned
Arbitrator has been upheld.
6.1.
The scope of interference in an appeal under Section 37 of the
Act of 1996 has been delineated in several decisions rendered by the Apex
Court. We are inclined to refer to the latest decision of the Apex Court in this
regard rendered in case of S.V. Samudram v. State of Karnataka and Anr.
reported in 2024 SCC OnLine SC 19[Civil Appeal No. 8067 of 2019
decided on 04.01.2024]. We may gainfully refer here paras 62 to 73 which
read as follows:
“62. Moving further, we now consider the judgment impugned before us, i.e.,
the order of the High Court upholding such modification, under the
jurisdiction of Section 37 of the A&C Act.
63. It has been observed by this Court in MMTC Ltd. v. Vedanta Ltd.
“14. As far as interference with an order made under Section 34,
as per Section 37, is concerned, it cannot be disputed that such
interference under Section 37 cannot travel beyond the
restrictions laid down under Section 34. In other words, the court
cannot undertake an independent assessment of the merits of the
award, and must only ascertain that the exercise of power by the
court under Section 34 has not exceeded the scope of the
provision. Thus, it is evident that in case an arbitral award has
been confirmed by the court under Section 34 and by the court in
an appeal under Section 37, this Court must be extremely
cautious and slow to disturb such concurrent findings.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
64. This view has been referred to with approval by a bench of three learned
Judges in UHL Power Company Ltd v. State of Himachal Pradesh. In respect
of Section 37, this court observed:—
“16. As it is, the jurisdiction conferred on courts under Section
34 of the Arbitration Act is fairly narrow, when it comes to the
scope of an appeal under Section 37 of the Arbitration Act, the
jurisdiction of an appellate court in examining an order, setting
aside or refusing to set aside an award, is all the more
circumscribed.”
65. This Court has not lost sight of the fact that, as a consequence to our
discussion as aforesaid, holding that the judgment and order under Section
34 of the A&C Act does not stand judicial scrutiny, an independent
evaluation of the impugned judgment may not be required in view of the
holding referred to supra in MMTC Ltd. However, we proceed to examine the
same.
66. We may also notice that the circumscribed nature of the exercise of
power under Sections 34 and 37 i.e., interference with an arbitral award, is
clearly demonstrated by legislative intent. The Arbitration Act of 1940 had a
provision (Section 15) which allowed for a court to interfere in awards,
however, under the current legislation, that provision has been omitted.
67. The learned Single Judge, similar to the learned Civil Judge under
Section 34, appears to have not concerned themselves with the contours of
Section 37 of the A&C Act. The impugned judgment reads like a judgment
rendered by an appellate court, for whom re-examination of merits is open to
be taken as the course of action.
68. We find the Court to have held the award to be perverse and contrary to
public policy. The basis for such a finding being the delay on the part of the
contractor in completion of the work which “could have been avoided”.
Significantly, as we have observed earlier such a finding is not backed by any
material on record.
69. What appears to have weighed with the court is that the factoring of the
cost escalation between the years 1989-1990 and 1992 by 100% was
exaggerated. But then equally, there is no justification in granting lump sum
escalation by 25% of the contract value. Well, this cannot be a reason to
modify the award for the parties are governed by the terms and conditions
and the price escalation stood justified by the petitioner based on cogent and
reliable material as was so counted by the Arbitrator in partly accepting
and/or rejecting the claims.
70. In our considered opinion, the court while confirming the modification of
the award committed the very same mistake which the Court under Section
34 of the A&C Act, made.
71. The Court under Section 37 had only three options:—
(a) Confirming the award of the Arbitrator;
(b) Setting aside the award as modified under Section 34; and
(c) Rejecting the application(s) under Section 34 and 37.
72. The learned single Judge has examined the reasoning adopted by the
learned Arbitrator in respect of certain claims (claims 3 and 7, particularly)
and held that allowing a claim for escalation of cost, was without satisfactory
material having been placed on record and is “perverse and contrary to the
public policy”. However, it appears that such a holding on part of the Judge
is without giving reasons therefor. It has not been discussed as to what the
evidence was before the learned single Judge to arrive at such conclusion.
This is of course, entirely without reference to the scope delineated by
various judgments of this Court as also, the statutory scheme of the A & C
Act.
73. Having referred to J.G Engineers (P) Ltd. v. UOI and more particularly
para 27 thereof, it has been held that the award passed by the learned
Arbitrator is “patently illegal, unreasonable, contrary to public policy.”
There is no reason forthcoming as to how the holding of the learned
Arbitrator flies in the face of public policy.”
7.
Though the learned Arbitrator is the sole judge for construction
of the terms and conditions of the agreement, but in this case, we find that the
learned Arbitrator has not taken into account the entire Clause 12 and 12A of
the Agreement. Clause 12 of the agreement stipulates that, “the Engineer in
charge shall have the power to make any alterations in omissions from,
addition to or substitutions for the original designs and instructions that may
appear to him to be necessary or advisable during the progress of the work
but in no case shall the additions or deductions exceeded twice the deviation
limit” and Clause 12A of the agreement stipulates that—the Engineer-incharge has been given the power and liberty to cancel the order to carry out
such increased quantities of work by giving notice in writing to the agency.”
8.
The learned Judge, District Commercial Court also has failed to
test the correctness of the award within the contours of the grounds available
under Section 34(2) and 34(2-A) of the of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996 without referring to the relevant Clauses of the Agreement which
requires the determination and non-consideration of the same makes the
judgment of the learned Commercial Court unreasonable and patently illegal.
Based on the principles enunciated in S.V. Samudram(supra)
9.
and the discussions made here-in-above, we are of the view that the matter be
remitted to the learned District Commercial Court, West Tripura, Agartala, to
decide the issue relating to Clauses 12 and 12A of the condition of contract
and as regards to the expected loss of profit or adjustment in accordance with
law within a reasonable time preferably 3(three) months from the date of
receipt of the certified copy of this order since the Arbitration proceeding
was initiated way back in the year 2016.
The appeal is disposed of in the manner and to the extent as indicated
above.
(ARINDAM LODH, J)
Rohit/Puspita
SANJAY
GHOSH
SANJAY GHOSH
Date: 2024.02.13
16:58:51 +05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH, CJ)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review