Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 20
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Crl. Rev. P. No. 18 of 2022
Date of Decision: 21.04.2023
Shri. Tony T.C. Marak
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & 5 Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. P. Yobin, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Mr. A.H. Kharwanlang, GA (For R 1-4)
Mr. F.L. Iawbor, Adv. (For R 5)
Mr. H.L. Shangresio, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. E. Wanniang, Adv. (For R 6)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
Heard Mr. P. Yobin, learned counsel for the petitioner, who has
submitted that the petitioner being aggrieved by the charge sheet No.
11/2016 dated 21.06.2016 submitted by the Investigating Officer (I/O) in
Dawki P.S. Case No. 2(1)/2010 under Section 13(2) read with Section
13(1) (c) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 whereby a prima
facie case for prosecution against the petitioner herein was said to have
been found well established and the related order dated 28.10.2022
passed by the learned Special Judge, West Jaintia Hills District, Jowai in
GR Case No. 10/2010, re-registered as Special CID Case No. 1/2016 by
which order, the prayer of the petitioner/accused for discharge from the
case was not allowed and the consequential order for framing of charge
being made, the petitioner has accordingly approached this Court with
this instant application under Section 397 read with Section 482 Cr.P.C
and also under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
2.
The learned counsel has submitted that the brief facts of the
case is that the petitioner at the relevant point of time was the State’s
Chief Conservator of Forest, SF & Env. There was a Centrally Sponsored
Scheme (CSS) for establishment of a park at Syndai, Amlarem SubDivision under the Border Area Development Department Programme,
which Scheme amounting to ₹ 30,60,800/- (Rupees thirty lakhs sixty
thousand eight hundred) only was proposed by the Department of Soil
Conservation, Government of Meghalaya, the same being accordingly
approved by the State Level Screening Committee was Special Central
Assistant under the Border Area Development Department Programme.
3.
The Forest Department was however, given the responsibility
for implementation of the said project, the petitioner being the Chief
Conservator of Forest, SF & Env., he was accordingly tasked for
completion of the same. As to the utilization of funds for the said project,
the petitioner finding that there is no appropriate channel for exclusive
use of the funds meant thereof, had accordingly opened a special Current
Account with the Canara Bank, Garikhana Branch, Shillong in the name
of Chief Conservator of Forest, (SF & Env.) for transaction of money
meant for the said project. The learned counsel has submitted that it is
clarified that the said account was opened and operated in the name and
Office of the Chief Conservator of Forest and not in the petitioner’s
personal capacity.
4.
The learned counsel has submitted that the petitioner has then
entrusted the task of implementation of the project to the Divisional
Forest Officer (DFO) and was functioning only as the Drawing and
Disbursing Officer (DDO) for the project.
5.
The project was carried out and duly completed to the
satisfaction of all concerned and a Utilization-cum-Completion
Certificate for an amount of ₹ 26,32,800/- (Rupees twenty six lakhs thirty
two thousand eight hundred) only was submitted by the DFO vide
certificate dated 30.06.2010. It is also mentioned that the inspection of
the project was earlier carried out by a team headed by the Secretary to
the Government of Meghalaya, Border Area Development Department
and the inspection team was satisfied with the work done but, has
however suggested that the construction of two unit Grade-IV staff
quarter amounting to ₹ 4,28,200/- (Rupees four lakhs twenty eight
thousand two hundred) only may not be started. The inspection report
dated 13.03.2010 was also brought on record.
6.
In the meantime, on 17.01.2010, the respondents No. 5 and 6
have lodged an FIR before the Officer-in-Charge, Muktapur Police
Station alleging misappropriation of Government fund and conspiracy to
defraud the Government by the petitioner in the execution of the work for
implementation of the said construction of the park at Syndai and the FIR
was registered as Dawki P.S. Case No. 2 (1) of 2010 under Section 409
IPC and investigation was launched.
7.
In spite of the said FIR, the respondents No. 5 and 6 also
approached the Guahati High Court by filing a Public Interest Litigation
No. 26 of 2010 alleging that the Government is not taking any action
against the petitioner on the complaint made. The PIL was disposed of
vide order dated 12.12.2011 with the observation that the Investigating
Officer may submit a report to the concerned court and the court to
decide the matter in accordance with law.
8.
In course of time, the respondents No. 5 and 6 respectively have
filed a petition before the competent court at the relevant point of time
and has made a prayer that it has come to their knowledge that the
allegation made against the petitioner was totally false and misleading
and as such, has decided to withdraw the compliant/FIR. The matter was
heard by the learned court and vide order dated 13.12.2011 was satisfied
that the petition was made bonafide and since the prosecution has no
objection to the same, the charge against the accused/petitioner herein
was dropped and he was accordingly discharged from all liabilities in the
case. This, submits the learned counsel virtually is a closure of the
allegations made against the petitioner and his innocence was retained.
9.
The learned counsel has further submitted that surprisingly after
a gap of about five years from the date when the order of discharged was
passed, the Investigating Officer submitted a charge sheet No. 11 of 2016
on 21.06.2016 in the same case that is, Dawki P.S Case No. 2(1) of 2010
opining that a case under Section 13(2) read with Section 13(1) (c) of the
PC Act, 1988 was found well established against the petitioner.
10.
As submitted above, the learned Special Judge taking
cognizance of the charge sheet filed has cause registration of the Special
CID Case No. 1 of 2016 and vide the impugned order dated 28.10.2022
has directed for framing of charges against the petitioner.
11.
The learned counsel has submitted that the learned Trial Court
has failed to exercise its judicial discretion on the facts and circumstances
of the case by passing the impugned order. The same being without
jurisdiction, it is therefore liable to be set aside and quashed.
12.
The learned counsel has submitted that the issue to be
considered is whether a criminal court after passing the final order, has
the power to recall or review its own order and secondly, whether the
principle of res judicata would be applicable in criminal proceedings.
13.
In answer to this, the learned counsel has firstly led this Court
to the provision of Section 362 Cr.P.C which provides that no court when
it has signed its judgment or final order disposing of a case shall alter or
review the same except to correct a clerical or arithmetical error.
14.
It is submitted that the I/O who is expected to be aware of the
order dated 13.12.2011 passed by the competent court having chosen not
to assail the same before a higher court or as provided by the relevant
provision of law has instead submitted the charge sheet, albeit after a
delay of about five years and accordingly the action of the I/O is in error
and the learned Trial Court by accepting the said charge sheet has also
acted without any provision of law.
15.
The learned counsel on the issue of res judicata has submitted
that the charges against the petitioner having been set to nought, nothing
remains and the subsequent filing of the chargesheet on the basis of the
original charge or alleged offence complaint of in the FIR, the same
would indeed attract the application of the principle of res judicata. In
support of this contention, the learned counsel has cited the case of
Bhagat Ram v. State of Rajasthan: (1972) 2 SCC 466 at para 13 and has
specifically referred to an extract of such paragraph which reads as
follows:
“13. …It was, in our opinion, not within the competence of the
learned judge to reopen the matter and pass the above order of
conviction in the face of earlier order of the Division Bench
whereby the order of acquittal of Bhagat Ram made by the trial
Judge in respect of the said three charges had been affirmed.
The order of the Division Bench unless set aside in appeal to
this Court, was binding and conclusive in all subsequent
proceedings between the parties. The principle of res judicata
is also applicable to criminal proceedings and it is not
permissible in the subsequent stage of the same proceedings or
in some other subsequent proceedings to convict a person for
an offence in respect of which an order for his acquittal has
already been recorded. The plea of autrefois acquit as a bar to
prosecution embodied in Section 403 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure is based upon the above wholesome principle.”
16.
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, learned Sr. counsel appearing for the
respondent No. 6 has submitted that the impression or rather information
received by the respondent and his organisation is that the petitioner has
misused the fund meant for the project for his personal gain by diverting
the same to his personal bank account. Accordingly, the said FIR dated
17.01.2010 was lodged to register their complaint.
17.
On the perceived notion that the Government is not doing
anything in the matter nor was any action taken against the petitioner, the
said PIL No. 26 of 2010 was filed. The PIL being accordingly disposed
of, the I/O of the criminal case was directed to file his report. However,
in the meantime, the respondent No. 6 and his organisation has come to
know of the factual aspect of the matter inasmuch as it was confirmed
that there was no misutilization of the fund by the petitioner and that the
fund amount was deposited in a government account in the name of Chief
Conservator of Forest and not in the name of the personal account of the
petitioner.
18.
Being seized of the truth, the respondent No. 6 had accordingly
approached the Trial Court by way of a petition dated 26.09.2011 with a
prayer for withdrawal of the said FIR/complaint dated 16.01.2010 which
prayer was allowed and the proceedings against the petitioner was
dropped vide order dated 13.12.2011.
19.
Mr. Shangreiso has further submitted that the events that took
place after the proceedings against the petitioner was dropped is beyond
comprehension as a competent court having passed a judicial order, in
this case an order of discharge as could be contemplated under the
provision of Section 227 Cr.P.C, the I/O cannot by any stretch of the
imagination continue with the investigation of the case. This would be an
affront to the authority of the court and an act of insubordination.
20.
As to the issue of res judicata the learned Sr. counsel has also
agreed that the principle of res judicata would apply to the facts of the
case of the petitioner and even assuming but not admitting that the order
of discharge was passed on a misplaced or erroneous application of the
law, even then since the order was not challenged at the relevant point of
time, the principle of res judicata will apply. The case of Kalinga Mining
Corporation v. Union of India & Ors.: (2013) 5 SCC 252, para 42 is cited
by the counsel in support of his contention. The said para reads as
follows:
“42. Considering the principle of res judicata, this Court in the
Mohanlal Goenka v. Benoy Kishna Mukherjee [AIR 1953 SC
65] held as under:
“22. There is ample authority for the proposition that even
an erroneous decision on a question of law operates as „res
judicata‟ between the parties to it. The correctness or
otherwise of a judicial decision has no bearing upon the
question whether or not it operates as „res judicata‟.”
This Court also held that:
“14. …A wrong decision by a court having jurisdiction is
as much binding between the parties as a right one and may
be superseded only by appeals to higher tribunals or other
procedure like review which the law provides.”
21.
It is therefore submitted that appropriate order may be passed in
this case to assert the authority of the court in view of the facts and
circumstances as was portrayed in these proceedings.
22.
Mr. F.L. Iawbor, learned counsel for respondent No. 5 has
submitted that the submission and contention advanced by the learned Sr.
counsel for the respondent No. 6 is also adopted by the respondent No. 5
herein.
23.
Mr. N.D. Chullai, learned AAG appearing for the State
respondents has submitted that admittedly by the order dated 13.12.2011
passed by the learned Additional District Magistrate, West Jaintia Hills,
Jowai the charges against the petitioner herein have been dropped,
however the initial offence was one under Section 409 IPC. The I/O
while filing his charge sheet has come to the conclusion that on the basis
of his investigation, a case under Section 13(2) read with Section 13(1)
(c) of the PC Act 1988 has been found well established against the
petitioner/accused and accordingly, the learned Trial Court has taken
cognizance of the same and has cause initiation of the trial.
24.
It is the fair submission of the learned AAG that in the event
this Court finds that the I/O is estopped from filing the charge sheet after
the petitioner has been discharged, then the prosecution cannot make out
any case for proceeding against the petitioner.
25.
This Court has duly considered the submission and contention
raised by the learned counsels appearing for the parties herein and from
what has been brought to the fore, it appears that the only issue to be
decided is whether the impugned order dated 28.10.2022 can be sustained
in the light of the facts and circumstances of the case of the parties.
26.
The factual aspect of the matter need not be repeated as the
same has been elaborately brought out through the submission of the
parties, however what can be noticed is that there is a project for
establishment of a park at Syndai, Amlarem Sub-Division, under the CSS
for which an amount of ₹ 30,60,800/- (Rupees thirty lakhs sixty thousand
eight hundred) only which project was given under the charge of the
petitioner for completion of the same. The petitioner, as submitted by the
learned counsel has thought it prudent to put the money in a separate
bank account under his official designation. This was perhaps the cause
which has arose the suspicion in the minds of the complainants who,
without verifying the facts has assumed that the petitioner has siphoned
of the money for his personal gain. This is belied by the fact that the
subsequent inspection of the project by the competent authority has
returned a positive finding that the project was well executed.
Furthermore, the fact that the utilization certificate was issued by the
DFO indicating the actual amount spent on the project has not been
questioned by any authority. This only goes to prove that there was no
misuse of the fund for the project.
27.
The complainants have also awakened to this fact and in all
fairness have thought it fit to pray for withdrawal of the FIR and the
discharge of the accused/petitioner from all liabilities.
28.
When the application for withdrawal of the FIR was heard by
the court of the learned Additional District Magistrate, the prosecution
was also present and has not objected to the prayer made, accordingly the
order dated 13.12.2011 was passed discharging the accused/petitioner
from the liabilities of the case.
29.
As submitted, the legal position as it stood, taking into
consideration the provision of Section 227 Cr.P.C the order dated
13.12.2011 suffers from no legal infirmity. This order was never
challenged in appeal before any higher judicial forum. The same has
accordingly attained finality.
30.
It is not understood under what provision of law, the I/O has
continued with the investigation post 13.12.2011, but all the same, he has
done so and that too, after five years, the charge sheet was filed. The
action of the I/O is dehors the prevalent provisions of law and rules and
the same cannot be condoned.
31.
It is also to be understood that once the order dated 13.12.2011
has attained finality, the same court or one of equal jurisdiction cannot
alter or review the order as such an act would attract the provision of
Section 362 Cr.P.C.
32.
The learned court of the Special Judge, by acknowledging the
charge sheet dated 21.06.216 filed by I/O has acted without jurisdiction
as the said charge sheet was filed in connection with Dawki P.S. Case
No. 2(1) of 2010 which has already lost its relevance in view of the order
dated 13.12.2011.
33.
It is also seen from the materials on record that the learned
Special Judge was aware of the order dated 13.12.2011, since the same
was brought to its notice by way of a petition No. 2 of 2017 filed by the
petitioner herein. However, in utter disregard to the relevant provisions of
law, the impugned order dated 28.10.2022 was passed.
34.
It is also well settled by relevant judicial pronouncements,
brought to the notice of this Court by the parties herein as regard the
issue of res judicata, reference being had to the case of Bhagat Ram
(supra) as well as in the case of Kalinga Mining Corporation (supra) that
a matter once settled cannot be reopened in the same proceedings.
35.
In the light of the above submissions, this Court finds that the
impugned order dated 28.10.2022 whereby the charge sheet dated
21.06.2016 being taken cognizance of was passed without taking into
account judicial propriety and also without jurisdiction. The same is
therefore liable to be set aside and quashed.
36.
This petition is accordingly disposed of by setting aside and
quashing the impugned order dated 28.10.2022 along with the related
charge sheet.
37.
The petitioner is hereby discharged from all liabilities in the
case and all proceedings against him related to the said Special CID Case
No. 1 of 2016 are quashed.
38.
Order accordingly.
Judge
Meghalaya
21.04.2023
“Tiprilynti–PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review