Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.02
Supple List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No.361 of 2020
Date of Decision: 01.12.2023
____________________________________________________________
Shri. Tony Ete
Vs.
Union of India & 4 Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. P. Yobin, Adv. with
Ms. B. Ramsiej, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
i)
ii)
: Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. A. Pradhan, Adv.
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
The present writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India has been filed by the petitioner challenging the impugned orders
dated 27-03-2019 and 23-12-2019, both issued by the respondent No.4 and
also for expunging the remark made in the Integrity Character Certificate
dated 22-03-2019 issued by the respondent No.5.
1.
The case of the petitioner is that he has completed the DM -
Cardiology course in the month of November, 2018 from the North Eastern
Page 1|8
Indira Gandhi Regional Institute of Health and Medical Science
(NEIGRIHMS) and in response to an advertisement dated 14-02-2019
issued by the respondent No.2, the petitioner took part in a walk-in
interview for recruitment of Assistant Professor on ad-hoc basis in various
department of NEIGRIHMS. The interview was conducted on 28-02-2019
and thereafter the respondent No.3, who was the chairman of the selection
committee vide his letter dated 05-03-2019 recommended the name of the
petitioner along with others for appointment to the post of Assistant
Professor on ad-hoc basis in the department of Cardiology. On the basis of
the recommendation, an appointment order dated 09-03-2019 was issued to
the petitioner asking him to join the post within a period of 15 (fifteen)
days and also produce attested copies of certain documents including
Integrity/Character Certificate from the last institute worked with. The
petitioner joined his post on 12-03-2019, which was provisionally accepted
subject to the production of the documents as required by the order of
appointment. While the petitioner was working in the department for about
10 (ten) days, the respondent No.5 issued the petitioner with an adverse
Integrity Character and Conduct Certificate stating that the integrity of the
petitioner is doubtful.
As a consequence, the respondent No.4 vide
impugned order dated 27-03-2019 cancelled the appointment letter issued
to the petitioner.
2.
Faced with the situation, the petitioner sought for clarification and
raised objection against the issuance of the adverse Integrity Certificate
before all the concerned authorities of NEIGHRIHMS and as no relief was
forthcoming, he approached the respondent No.1 for redressal of his
grievance.
Thereafter, as many as three clear instructions from the
concerned ministry was issued to the respondent No.3 seeking clarification
and also for taking of corrective measures so that carrier aspects of the
Page 2|8
petitioner may not be jeopardized. As no corrective measure was taken, the
matter was ultimately taken up in the 13th meeting of the Governing
Council of the institute at New Delhi on 14-10-2019 whereupon, after
detailed discussion, it was concluded that the adverse integrity certificate
issued to the petitioner was not justified and, therefore, the petitioner
should be allowed to join the post immediately and a fresh character
integrity certificate be issued to the petitioner. Thereafter, the petitioner
was immediately asked to report for joining as Assistant Professor in the
Cardiology Department, which the petitioner did instantly on 14-10-2019
itself. A fresh character and integrity certificate was also issued to the
petitioner by the respondent No.5 on 25-11-2019 certifying satisfactory
character and conduct of the petitioner.
A formal appointment letter
appointing the petitioner as an Assistant Professor in the Department of
Cardiology on ad-hoc basis for a period of six months w.e.f. 14-10-2019
was issued on 23-12-2019 by the respondent No.4.
The petitioner
thereafter served in the same post till 18-04-2022 on the strength of various
extension orders.
3.
Mr. P. Yobin, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits
that it is because of the arbitrary and illegal action on the part of the
respondents, the petitioner could not continue in the post which he initially
joined on 12-03-2019 pursuant to the recommendation dated 05-03-2019
and appointment order dated 09-03-2019 and in the process, petitioner
ended up losing more than six valuable months of his career and he still
suffers the stigma of having lost the period of service for no fault of his
own. Further, relying on all other past character certificates issued to the
petitioner which are annexed with the writ petition, he contends that the
adverse Integrity Character and Conduct Certificate dated 22-03-2019
issued by the respondent No.5, which is the main cause of his harassment
Page 3|8
and suffering, was also issued without any reasonable cause or justification.
He submits that since the impact of the adverse Integrity Character
Certificate stood negated by the decision of the Governing Council, the
apex body of the NEIGHRIHMS, the impugned action on the part of the
respondents in cancelling the initial appointment of the petitioner requires
to be interfered by this Court and necessary direction be passed for grant of
equitable relief to the petitioner. The petitioner’s service deserves to be
restored with effect from 12-03-2019 and should be paid salary and other
monetary benefit for the period he could not continue in service. With
regard to the expunging of adverse remarks made in the Integrity Character
Certificate dated 22-03-2019, he submits that since the same stood rectified
by subsequent issuance of the certificate dated 25-11-2019, the petitioner
has no further prayer. In support of his contention, the learned counsel
places reliance on the following decisions of the Apex Court reported in
(2013) 10 SCC 324, Deepali Gundu Surwase V. Kranti Junior Adhyapak
Mahavidyalaya (paras – 38, 38.1 and 38.2), and (2014) 10 SCC 301,
Raghubir Singh V. Haryana Roadways (para – 30).
4.
On the other hand, Dr. N. Mozika, learned DSGI appearing for the
respondents submits that since the petitioner has joined the post of
Assistant Professor in the Cardiology Department on 14-10-2019 and
continued therein till the completion of his tenure pursuant to the decision
of the Governing Council and received all the benefits due upon him, he
cannot raise any grievance at this stage.
The learned counsel further
submits that as per the terms of the advertisement dated 14-02-2019, the
appointment of the petitioner was purely on ad-hoc basis for a period of six
months, extendable up to a maximum period of two years from the date of
joining and the petitioner has served for the maximum extendable period.
In fact, due to the emergence of exigency because of the outbreak of CovidPage 4|8
19, the service of the petitioner was extended beyond the prescribed period
of two years and the petitioner continued to serve in the department till 1804-2022. He submits that the period of six months with effect from 12-032019 which the petitioner claims to have lost, stood covered up by the
extension of service in view of the fact that the petitioner has served for
more than two years in the department and received all the monetary
benefits thereof. He further submits that the decision of the Governing
Council of NEIGHRIHMS dated 14-10-2019 is prospective and all the
follow-up actions taken by the department and accepted by the petitioner
would definitely mean that the grievance, which petitioner had, was fully
redressed. He contends that occurrence of the entire incident in the present
matter has no negative impact on the career of the petitioner and the
petitioner is not entitled to any further relief from this Court.
5.
The submissions advanced by the rival parties have been given
careful attention. Taking into consideration the nature of dispute involved
in the present matter, it is important to take note of the relevant terms and
conditions of the advertisement for recruitment dated 14-02-2019 which
reads as follows: “The appointment is purely temporary on ADHOC BASIS for
a period not exceeding 6 (six) months, or till such time regular
appointment against the vacant post is made, whichever is
earlier, with effect from the date of joining. If the adhoc
service is not extended further, the same will lapse
automatically. However, the adhoc appointment shall not be
extended beyond the period of two years.”
6.
It follows from the above that the maximum period of service which
could have been claimed by the petitioner on the basis of the said
advertisement was for two years. The petitioner in this case initially joined
the post of the Assistant Professor in Cardiology Department on 12-03Page 5|8
2019 and in the normal circumstances, with all possible extension of
service as per the term of the advertisement, would have continued in the
same post upto 11-03-2020 had there been no interruption of service due to
the cancellation of his initial appointment order. After the decision of the
Governing Council of NEIGHRIHMS allowing the petitioner to rejoin the
post of the Assistant Professor in the Cardiology Department immediately,
petitioner joined the post on 14-10-2019 and continued therein till 18-042022, which included the maximum period of extension of service as per
the advertisement and additional extension of two terms of three months
each due to emergence of Covid-19 pandemic. The petitioner thereby
served in the department for full period of two years as per the terms of the
advertisement dated 14-02-2019 plus extra six months of extended service
on account of emergence of Covid-19 pandemic and admittedly received all
the service benefits due thereupon. It is, therefore, clear that the loss which
the petitioner claimed to have suffered because of cancellation of his initial
appointment by the impugned order 27-09-2019, stood covered up and as
such, he cannot have any lawful grievance to be redressed by this Court at
this juncture.
Consequently, there is no question of restoration of
petitioner’s service w.e.f. 12-03-2019 and the prayer stands rejected.
7.
Insofar as, the question of adverse integrity character certificate is
concerned, it is clear that pursuant to the decision of the Governing Council
of NEIGHRIHMS directing for issuance of a fresh character integrity
certificate to the petitioner, a fresh certificate was issued by the respondent
No.5 on 25-11-2019 certifying satisfactory character and conduct of the
petitioner. For sake of convenience, the relevant part of the resolution of
the Governing Council of NEIGHRIHMS is reproduced hereinbelow: -
Page 6|8
“Agenda Item No.2
Issue of Dr. Tony Ete, Ex-post-Doctoral Student (DM
Cardiology), NEIGHRIHMS,
After detailed discussion, the Council decided that Dr. Tony
Ete, (DM Cardiology) who was selected based on the Walk-ininterview held on 28.02.2019 for the post of Assistant
Professor Cardiology (Ad hoc) should be allowed to join
immediately as the doubtful Character & Integrity certificate
issued by the Institute earlier is not justified. Therefore
institute was directed to issue a fresh Character & Integrity
certificate. It was also advised to take an assurance from Dr.
Tony Ete for maintaining harmonious relationship with all
concerned.”
8.
A perusal of the relevant part of the decision of the Governing
Council would show that the petitioner was also required to furnish
assurance for maintaining harmonious relationship with all concerned. The
petitioner complied with the said requirement and submitted an undertaking
to the department on 25-11-2019 for maintaining harmonious relationship
with all concerned in the institute. The aforesaid events definitely put an
end to the question of issue of adverse character certificate. The learned
counsel for the petitioner also fairly submitted that in view of the issuance
of a fresh character integrity certificate to the petitioner, there remains no
further grievance. It is, therefore, obvious that the petitioner has accepted
and acted on the basis of the decision of the Governing Council of
NEIGHRIHMS, and as such, he cannot raise any further grievance with
regard to the same issue in this writ petition.
09.
The learned counsel for the petitioner at the hearing submitted that
the petitioner is at present serving in Tomo Riba Institute of Health and
Medical Science (TRIHMS), Arunachal Pradesh and pursuing a successful
Page 7|8
career therein. Thus, it is apparent that the incidents basing on which the
petitioner has sought for redressal of his grievance in the present writ
petition, had no adverse impact in his career.
10.
The citations of case law relied on by the learned counsel appearing
for the petitioner has no application in the facts and circumstances of the
present case and the same do not require any elaborate discussion.
11.
For the reasons and discussions made above, the writ petition is
devoid of merit and it is hereby dismissed.
12.
There will be no order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
01.12.2023
“Biswarup PS”
Page 8|8
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review