Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Supple List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 96 of 2020
Date of Decision: 18.10.2023
Shri. Tngen Singh Basaiawmoit Vs. State of Meghalaya & 5 Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. S. A. Sheikh, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. N. D. Chullai, AAG with
Ms. Z. E. Nongkynrih, GA.
i)
ii)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
Heard Mr. S. A. Sheikh, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and also Mr. N. D. Chullai, learned AAG appearing for the
State-respondents No.1 – 4 & 6. None appeared for the respondent
No.5.
2.
The present writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India has been filed by the petitioner challenging the letters dated
28-11-2019 and 21-02-2020 by which the respondents proposed to
release provisional pension to the petitioner and withhold the payment
of gratuity.
3.
The brief fact of the case is that the petitioner, having attained
the age of superannuation, retired from service on 31-01-2014 as
Accountant from the office of the Block Development Officer, Shella,
Bholaganj C&RD Block, Sohra. However, after superannuation of the
petitioner, no service benefits like Pension, Gratuity, Leave Salary and
GPF has been released to the petitioner by the respondent. The
petitioner being aggrieved by the non-released of the retirement
benefits, filed WP(C) No.508 of 2018 before this Court and the said
writ petition was disposed of by an order dated 23-08-2019 by
directing the respondents to take up the representation dated 22-082017, which was filed by the petitioner and pending before the
respondents, for consideration and to decide the same expeditiously.
As the same was not done, the petitioner had to approach this Court by
filing a contempt petition and during the pendency of the contempt
petition the respondent authorities issued the impugned letters dated
28-09-2018 and 21-02-2020 by which the respondents decided to
release provisional pension and withhold the payment of gratuity to
the petitioner.
4.
The petitioner in his writ petition averred that after his
retirement from service on 31-01-2014, he submitted all the required
documents/papers to the concerned authority for processing of his
pension and other retirement benefits and the same were forwarded by
the respondent No.3 vide letter dated 28-042014 to the office of the
respondent No.5 for completion of the process. However, by another
letter dated 06-05-2014, the respondent No.3 requested the respondent
No.5 to stop the process of release of retirement benefits to the
petitioner on the ground that the petitioner has overstayed his service.
Consequently, the pension papers of the petitioner were returned back
by the respondent No.5 with a request to resubmit the same after
necessary correction of the date of retirement of the petitioner. The
authorities issued for withdrawal of final GPF in respect of the
petitioner was also returned by the respondent No.6 by letter dated 1005-2017 on the ground that the petitioner was placed under suspension
prior to the issuance of the authorities. As the petitioner was facing
severe financial hardship, he approached the High Court by filing
WP(C) No. 508 of 2018 for release of his retiral benefit. The writ
petition was contested by the State-respondent by filing an affidavit in
opposition wherein a stand was taken that the retirement benefits and
pension of the petitioner was kept on hold until investigation is
complete and the cases against the petitioner have been closed. It is
only at that point of time, the petitioner came to know about the
existence of two FIRs against him dated 06-06-2014 and 08-05-2014
(with supplementary FIR dated 13-05-2014) which were lodged
against him before the Sohra Police Station. The FIR dated 06-062014 culminated in filing of FR which was accepted by the Trial
Court vide order dated 31-07-2017. The case initiated on the basis of
the FIR dated 08-05-2014 also resulted in acquittal in favour of the
petitioner vide Judgment dated 10-03-2023 passed by the Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Sohra in G.R Case No. 20 of 2016 (brought
into the record by the petitioner vide an affidavit dated 05-04-2023).
The WP(C) No.508 of 2019 was disposed of with a direction to the
respondent to dispose of the representation filed by the petitioner
which resulted in passing of the impugned letters dated 20-11-2019
and 21-02-2020 by the respondents No.3 & 4 respectively.
5.
The State-respondents in their affidavit-in-opposition, inter-alia,
has taken a stand that the service benefits of the petitioner could not
be released in time because of the contradiction with regard to the date
of retirement of the petitioner and also due to the pendency of the case
against the petitioner in the Court of the First Class Magistrate, Sohra.
It is also the stand of the State respondents that in view of the
pendency of the proceedings against the petitioner, the grant of regular
pension and gratuity of the petitioner has been withheld in terms of
Rule 9 and the provisional pension was granted to the petitioner as per
Rule 64 of the Meghalaya Civil Service (Pension) Rules, 1983
(hereinafter referred to as “the Rules”).
6.
Mr. S. A. Sheikh, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
submits that the respondents could not have withheld the pension and
other retirement benefits of the petitioner as there was no departmental
proceeding or judicial proceeding pending against him on 31-01-2014,
the date of his retirement. No departmental proceeding was ever
initiated against the petitioner and he had never been placed under
suspension during the period of his service.
The confusion with
regard to the date of retirement of the petitioner also stood settled long
back in the year 2014 itself with the refund of overdrawn salary by the
petitioner to the department. He further contends that both the FIRs
were filed after his retirement from service and the respondent
authorities could not have acted on the basis of the same for
withholding his retirement benefits. He submits that the respondents
wrongly resorted to Rules 9 and 64 of the Rules to deny him the retiral
benefits as the said rules were not applicable to the case of the
petitioner. He, however, submits that during the pendency of this
case, the respondents have issued orders for release of his pension and
gratuity. Thus, the claim in the writ petition at present is confined to
the grant of interest for late release of retiral benefits to the petitioner.
He submits that the delay in release of retiral benefits to the petitioner
is not attributable to him and it is the respondents who are liable for
the same.
The learned counsel further contends that pension is
recognized as a right under Article 300A of the Constitution of India
and the same cannot be denied to the petitioner without any lawful
cause. He submits that as per the provision of Section 7 (3A) of the
Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, the respondents are liable to pay
interest for delayed release of gratuity. In support of his contentions,
the learned counsel for the petitioner places reliance of the following
decisions: i) (2013) 12 SCC 210, State of Jharkhand & Ors Vs. Jitendra
Kumar Srivastava. (para –16).
ii) (2003) 3 SCC 40, H. Gangahanume Gowda Vs. Karnataka
Agro Industries Ltd. (para – 7).
iii) (2008) 3 SCC 44, S. K. Dua Vs. State of Haryana and Ors.
(para – 14).
iv) (2013) 3SCC 472, Y.K. Singla Vs. Punjab National Bank and
ors. (para – 20).
v) (2014) 8 SCC 894, D.D. Tiwari (dead) through Legal
representative Vs. Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam limited
and Ors. (para – 4).
7.
Mr. N. D. Chullai, learned AAG appearing for the State-
respondents, submits that it is the petitioner who had misrepresented
with regard to his correct date of superannuation and overstayed in
service unauthorizedly till 31/03/2014.
He also submits that the
petitioner was involved in forgery which resulted in filing of FIRs and
initiation of criminal proceedings against him.
The Judgment of
acquittal of the petitioner was passed only on 10-03-2023 meaning
thereby that the proceeding was continuing till then.
He further
contends that the acquittal was on account of benefit of doubt given to
the petitioner which would not amount to giving clean chit to the
petitioner. The Rule 9 and Rule 64 of the Rules was invoked in view
of the pendency of the judicial proceedings against the petitioner and,
as such, the delay in release of the retirement benefit of the petitioner
cannot be termed as illegal or unjustified. He further contends that
Rule 9 (4) of the of the aforesaid rules empowers the authority to
withhold the release of service benefit to the petitioner and in such a
situation the respondents cannot be held liable. In support of his
contentions he relies on:(1999) 9 SCC 43, R. Veerabhadram Vs. Govt of A.P. (Paras 6, 7).
8.
I have heard the learned counsels for the parties and also have
gone through the materials available on record.
9.
It is an admitted fact that the petitioner retired from service on
31-01-2014.
Though initially there was an allegation that the
petitioner overstayed in service and continued till 31-03-2014, the
same stood settled by refund of salary received by him which was
accepted by the department without any punitive action against the
petitioner. The communication dated 06-05-2014, appended as
Annexure-2 to the writ petition makes disclosure of refund of salary
by the petitioner. It appears that the dispute was given a quietus.
10.
The materials on record reveal that the FIRs against the
petitioner were filed on 06-06-2014 and 08-05-2014 (with
supplementary FIR dated 13-05-2014) approximately three months
after the date of retirement of the petitioner. There is nothing on
record to suggest that the petitioner was subjected to any departmental
proceedings during his tenure of service. There is also no evidence to
remotely suggest that he was ever been placed under suspension.
Admittedly, when the petitioner attained the age of superannuation
and retired on 31-01-2014, there was no proceedings pending against
him. At this stage, to decide whether the respondent was correct in
withholding the retirement benefits of the petitioner or not, it would be
appropriate to refer to the provisions of rule 9 and rule 64 of the
Rules, which reads as follows: “Right of Governor to withhold or withdraw
pension:
9.(1) The Governor reserves to himself the right of
withholding or withdrawing a pension or part
thereof, whether permanently or for a specified
period and of ordering recovery from a pension of
the whole or part of any pecuniary loss caused to
the Government, if, in any departmental or judicial
proceedings, the pensioner is found guilty of grave
misconduct or negligence during the period of his
service, including service rendered upon reemployment after retirement.
Provided that the State Public Service Commission
shall be consulted before any final orders are
passed.
Provided further that where a part of pension is
withheld or withdrawn, the amount of such pension
shall not be reduced below the limit specified in
sub-rule (5) of rule 39.
Note – (1) The term „grave misconduct‟ is wide
enough to include „corrupt practice‟. IN case
where the charge of corruption is proved only after
pension has been sanctioned and it is not possible
to invoke the provisions of Rule 6 action to
withheld or withdraw pension may be taken under
rule 9.
(2) (a) The departmental proceedings referred to in
sub-rule (1), instituted while the Government
servant was in service whether before his
retireme3nt or during his re-employment, shall
after the final retirement of the Government
servant, be deemed to be proceedings under the
rule and shall be continued and concluded by
authority by which they are commenced in the
same manner as if the Government servant had
continued in service;
Provided that where the departmental proceedings
are instituted by an authority subordinate to the
Governor that authority shall submit a report its
findings to the Governor.
(b) The departmental proceedings, if not instituted
while the Government servant was in service,
whether before his retirement or during his
reemployment –
i) Shall not be instituted save with the sanction of
the Governor;
ii) Shall not be in respect of any servant which took
place more than four years before such institution;
and
iii) Shall be conducted by such authority and in
such place as the Governor may direct and in
accordance with the procedure applicable to
departmental proceedings in which an order of
dismissal from service could be made in relation to
the Government servant during his service.
(3) No judicial proceedings, if not instituted while
the Government servant was in service, whether
before his retirement or during his re-employment,
shall be instituted in respect of a cause of action
which arose, or in respect of an event which took
place, more than four years before such institution.
(4) In the case of a Government servant who has
retired on attaining the age of superannuation or
otherwise and against whom any departmental or
judicial proceedings are instituted or where
departmental proceedings are continued under
sub-rule (2), a provisional pension as provided in
rule 64 shall be sanctioned.
(5) where the Governor decides not to withhold or
withdraw pension but orders recovery of the
pecuniary loss from pension, the recovery shall not
ordinarily be made at a rate exceeding one-third of
the pension admissible on the date of retirement of
a Government servant.
(6) for the purpose of this rule;
(a) departmental proceedings shall be deemed to
be instituted on the date on which the statement of
charge is issued to the Government servant or
pensioner or if the Government servant has been
placed under suspension from an earlier date, on
such date; and
(b) judicial proceedings shall be deemed to be
instituted;
i) In the case of criminal proceedings, on date on
which the complaint or report of a police officer,
on which the Magistrate takes cognizance, is made,
and
ii) In the case of civil proceedings, on the date the
complaint is presented in the court.
State Government‟s decision:
(1) As soon as the proceedings of the nature
referred to in Rule 9 are instituted, the
authority which institutes such proceedings,
should without delay, intimate the fact to the
Audit Officer concerned responsible for
issuing the Pension and Gratuity order.
(2) Grant of provisional pension in the event of
proceedings;
Where departmental or judicial proceedings
instituted during the service of the Government
servant are not likely to be finalized by the date
of retirement, action to grant provisional
pension should be taken so that the retiring
Government servant may not be put to undue
hardship. No gratuity, shall, however, be paid
either by the Head of Office or by the Audit
Officer until the conclusion of the departmental
or judicial proceedings and issue of final orders
thereon.”
“64. Provisional pension where departmental
judicial proceeding may be pending – (1) (a) In
respect a Government servant referred to in
sub-rule (4) of rule 9, the Audit Officer shall
authorize the payment of provision pension not
exceeding the maximum pension which would
have been admissible on the basis of qualifying
service up to the date of retirement of the
Government servant or if it was under
suspension on the date of retirement, up to the
date immediately preceding the date on which
he was placed under suspension.
(b) No gratuity shall be paid to the Government
servant until the conclusion of the department
or judicial proceeding and issue of final orders
thereon.
(2) Payment of provisional pension made under
sub-rule (1) shall be adjusted against final
retirement benefits sanctioned to such
Government servant upon conclusion of such
proceedings but no recovery shall be made
where the pension reduced or withheld either
permanently or for a specific period.
(4) Nothing contained in this rule shall
prejudice the operation of the rule 6 when final
pension is sanctioned upon the conclusion of
the departmental or judicial proceedings.
State Government‟s decision
In the case of a Government servant who retires
from service while on deputation to
Government of India or while on foreign
service, action to sanction pension and gratuity
in accordance with the provisions of this
Chapter shall be taken by Audit Officer or the
Head of Office as the case may be, of the
Government authority which sanctioned the
deputation of the Government servant to the
State Government or to foreign service.”
11.
From the aforesaid Rules what emerges is that position with
regard to the pendency to the disciplinary proceedings or judicial
proceedings is to be seen on the date of retirement. In case there are
no proceedings pending against the employee on the date of
retirement, respondents do not have the jurisdiction to withhold the
pensionary benefits to the employee. It is an admitted fact that on the
date when the petitioner attained the age of superannuation and retired
on 31-01-2014, there was no proceeding pending against him. Once,
there was no proceeding pending against the petitioner on the date of
his retirement, respondents were under obligation to release the
pensionary benefits within a reasonable period of time.
12.
The opening words of rule 9(1) of the Rules stipulates that the
Governor reserves the right of withholding or withdrawing a pension
or any part of it, whether permanently or for a specified period. Unless
the Governor exercises such right reserved to himself, pension cannot
be withheld or withdrawn permanently or for a specified period
automatically. This would be clear from the provisions of rule 9(1) to
the effect that powers under rule 9(1) shall be exercisable not only in
case of pecuniary loss to the Government but also in all other cases.
The aforesaid provisions clearly indicates that it is a power exercisable
in a given case and may not be exercised in some cases and the action
under rule 9(1) withholding or withdrawing pension permanently or
for a specified period of time is not automatic. A further reading of
rule 9(1) will show that the right to withhold pension is different from
the right to order recovery from pension any pecuniary loss caused to
the Government which can be exercised by the Governor only if in a
departmental or judicial proceeding the petitioner is guilty of some
misconduct or negligence during the period of service, whereas the
right of withholding pension can be exercised by the Governor even
before the conclusion of the departmental proceeding. Unless,
therefore, the competent authority in a given case applies his mind to
the facts of the case passes specific order withholding or withdrawing
pension or any part of it whether permanently or for a specific period
for some good reasons, pension or any part thereof of a government
servant cannot be withheld by the authority automatically.
13.
Coming now to rule 9(4) of the Rules on which heavy
reliance was placed by Mr. N D Chullai for his contention that where
a judicial proceeding stands initiated against the government servant
immediately after his retirement and the proceeding was continuing,
the government servant is only entitled to provisional pension, the said
provision entitles a government servant to payment of provisional
pension in a case where departmental or judicial proceeding was
continued against him, but does not confer any right or power on the
Governor to withhold pension of a government servant. The provision
in rule 9(4) further does not state that the payment of regular pension
of a government servant will be automatically stopped where a
judicial proceeding is continued against a government servant. The
claim of the petitioner in this writ petition is payment of regular
pension and if the State respondents are to take any defence against
payment of such regular pension, they can only rely on rule 9(1) of the
Rules which confers only a right to the Governor to withhold pension.
The said rule does not provide for automatic stoppage of regular
pension in case a judicial proceeding is continued against a
government servant.
14.
Since no orders have been specifically passed by the competent
authority under rule 9(1) of the Rules withholding the pension of the
petitioner for a specified period, more particularly for the period when
the judicial proceeding against the petitioner was continuing, the
action of the State respondents in withholding the pension of the
petitioner as well as gratuity in terms rule 64 of the Rules is not
tenable in law.
15.
The Apex Court in the case of the State of Jharkhand (supra),
relied on by the counsel for the petitioner, lays down that the right to
receive to pension is recognized as a right in „property‟. The decision
further lays down that a person cannot be deprived of his pension
without authority of law, which is a constitutional mandate enshrined
under Article 300A of the Constitution.
17.
The other decisions relied on by the learned counsel for the
petitioner in the cases of H. Gangahanume Gowda (supra), S. K.
Dua (supra), Y. K. Singla (supra) and D. D. Tiwari (dead) through
legal representative (supra), mandate the employer to pay gratuity
within specified time and in the failure to do so, to pay interest on the
delayed time. The law laid down in the aforesaid judgments also
provides for payment of interest in case of delay in disbursement of
pension and other service benefits of a retired employee.
18.
The decision of the Apex Court in the case of R. Veerabhadram
(supra) cited by the learned AAG relates to an employee against
whom a judicial proceeding was pending on the date of his retirement.
In the present matter, it is admitted position that there were no
proceedings pending against the petitioner when he retired. The
invocation of Rule 9 of the Rules by the respondents to deny the
release of retiral benefit to the petitioner, as such, is wholly unjustified
and untenable. That apart, the FIRs against the petitioner were lodged
on 06-06-2014 and 08-05-2014 (with supplementary FIR dated 13-052014). Even if the petitioner‟s date of retirement is taken on 31-032014, the date till which petitioner overstayed in service, the FIRs
were lodged after the said date. The respondents, therefore, were
totally wrong in resorting to the provision of Rule 9 of the Rules to
deny the pensionary benefits to the petitioner.
19.
Time and again, the Apex Court has emphasized that pension is
not a bounty but the same is a right of the person concerned who has
retired from service. The pension rules itself has made specific
provision for providing pensionary benefits at the earliest opportunity.
It needs to be emphasized here that the impugned letters dated 28-112019 and 21-02-2020 cannot be termed as orders passed by the
competent authority in exercise of powers under Rule 9 (1) of the
Rules.
On the basis of the said letters, the respondents cannot
withhold even a part of the pension or gratuity of the petitioner. The
pension is hard earned benefits which accrued to the petitioner and is
in the nature of property. This right of property could not have been
taken away by the respondents without due process of law.
20.
Keeping in view the law cited above, it is clear that the action of
the respondents in withholding the pension and the gratuity amount of
the petitioner on the basis of the judicial proceeding which
commenced after the retirement was beyond their jurisdiction and was
contrary to the settled principle of law and therefore, as the amount of
pension and gratuity was retained by the respondents without any
jurisdiction, the petitioner needs to be compensated for the said illegal
action by the grant of interest.
21.
For what has been discussed in the foregoing paragraphs, the
impugned letters dated 28-11-2019 and 21-02-2020 are set aside and
quashed. The petitioner is found to be entitled to grant of interest for
delayed release of his regular pension and gratuity. Accordingly, it is
directed that the respondent shall pay simple interest @ 7.25 % per
annum on the amount of gratuity and arrear of pension from the date
on which those amounts became due till the date on which the same
are actually released to the petitioner. Since, it is submitted by the
learned counsel for the petitioner that the respondents have already
issued orders for the release of regular pension and gratuity to the
petitioner, no direction in this regard is required to be passed.
22.
Let the calculation of the amount of interest be done by the
respondents within a period of two months from the date of receipt of
the certified of this order and the actual amount, so calculated, be
released to the petitioner immediately thereafter.
23.
The writ petition stands allowed on the aforesaid terms.
24.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
18.10.2023
“Biswarup-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review