Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P. (Cril.) No. 29 of 2023
Mrs. Tinneichong Haokip, aged about 47 years, W/o
Chungpao Haokip, a permanent resident of Moreh Ward No.
7, Zion Veng, Tengnoupal Sub-Division, Chandel District,
Manipur-795131.
…... Petitioner/s
- Versus 1. Union of India, represented by Secretary, Ministry of Finance,
Dept. of Revenue, Near North Block, Room No. 26, Church
Road, RFA Brracks, New Delhi-110001.
2. The Deputy Secretary (PIT-ND & PS), Ministry of Finance,
Department of Revenue, Near North Block, Room No. 26,
Church Road, RFA Barracks, New Delhi-110001.
3. State of Manipur, represented by the Chief Secy. Government
of Manipur, Babupara, Imphal 795001.
4. Commissioner (Home), Government of Manipur Babupara,
Imphal-795001.
5. Superintendent of Central Jail, Imphal East-795001.
........Respondent/s
B E F O R E
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioner
::
Mr. Serto T Kom, Advocate
For the respondents
::
Mr. Th. Vashum, G.A. for the State
and Mr. Kh. Samarjit, DSGI for the
Union of India.
Date of Order
::
27.03.2023
Page 1
ORDER(ORAL)
A. Guneshwar Sharma, (J)
[1]
On 10.07.2022, a team of Kangpokpi District Police arrested
the detenu, namely Thangkholen Haokip @ Thanglen Haokip along with
his associates, namely Satminlun Tuboi, Lhaineineng Haokip (wife of
detenu) and Hethem Sitlhou in connection with FIR No. 14(7)2022 G SPMPS U/s 22(c)/29/60(3) ND & PS Act. From their possession WY Tablets
weighing 5.568 kgs. were recovered. Thereafter, the detenu was remanded
to judicial custody. Vide order dated 10.10.2022 passed by the Special
Judge (ND & PS), Senapati, Manipur in Cril.Misc.(B) Case No. 44 of 2022,
the bail application filed by the detenu, namely Thangkholen Haokip @
Thanglen Haokip and his wife, namely Lhaineineng Haokip was rejected.
[2]
While the detenu was in judicial custody, vide order dated
13.09.2022, the Special Secretary (Home), Government of Manipur, issued
the detention order under Section 3 (1) of the Prevention of Illicit Traffic in
Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act (PIT-ND & PS Act), 1988
for effectively preventing him from further involvement in illicit trafficking of
narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances for a period of 3 months until
further orders. It was stated that the detenu filed a bail application being
Cril.Misc.(B) Case No. 59 of 2022 in connection with FIR No. 14(7)2022 G
SPM-PS U/s 22(c)/29/60(3) ND & PS Act and the detenu, on release from
Page 2
jail on bail, would continue in illegal activities including illicit trafficking of
drugs.
[3]
Vide letter dated 16.09.2022, the Special Secretary (Home),
Government of Manipur furnished the grounds of detention to the detenu
inter-alia alleging that the detenu was a member of drug syndicate and he
filed a bail application being Cril.Misc.(B) Case No. 59 of 2022 (ref.FIR No.
14(7)2022 G SPM-PS U/s 22(c)/29/60(3) ND & PS Act) and on release on
bail, he would likely to indulge in illegal activities of drug trafficking and as
an alternative preventive measure, he was taken into prevention detention.
The detenu submitted 2 (two) representations both dated 10.10.2022 to (i)
The Deputy Secretary (PIT-ND & PS), Ministry of Finance, Department of
Revenue, Government of India, New Delhi and (ii) the Chief Secretary,
Government of Manipur through the Superintendent, Manipur Central Jail,
Sajiwa Imphal, Manipur for revoking the detention order dated 13.09.2022
on the ground that there is violation of mandatory provisions and reasons
for likelihood to be released on bail is not indicated. The detenu challenged
the 1st detention order dated 13.09.2022 before this Court by way of writ
petition being WP(Cril.) No. 40 of 2022 inter-alia on the ground that there
was no likelihood of the detenu being released on bail and delay in
disposal of the representation dated 10.10.2022.
[4]
Vide order dated 15.12.2022, the Commissioner (Home),
Government of Manipur revoked the 1st detention order dated 13.09.2022
Page 3
under Section 12 (a) of the PIT-ND & PS Act with immediate effect. Vide
order dated 16.01.2023 in WP(Cril.). No. 40 of 2022, this Court disposed of
the writ petition as infructuous as the 1st detention order dated 13.09.2022
was revoked by a subsequent order dated 15.12.2022 giving liberty to
challenge the fresh detention order.
[5]
After revocation of the 1st detention order dated 13.09.2022 on
15.12.2022, the Commissioner (Home), Government of Manipur issued the
2nd detention order dated 16.12.2022 against the detenu under Section 3(1)
of the PIT-ND & PS Act on the same grounds as mentioned in the 1 st
detention order. It was stated that the detenu filed a bail application being
Cril.Misc.(B) Case No. 59 of 2022 in connection with FIR No. 14(7)2022 G
SPM-PS U/s 22(c)/29/60(3) ND & PS Act. Vide letter dated 20.12.2022, the
Commissioner (Home), Government of Manipur furnished the 2 nd grounds
of detention against the detenu. The detenu submitted 2 (two)
representations both dated 16.01.2023 to (i) the Deputy Secretary (PIT-ND
& PS), Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, Government of India,
New Delhi and (ii) the Chief Secretary, Government of Manipur through the
Superintendent, Manipur Central Jail, Sajiwa Imphal, Manipur for revoking
the 2nd detention order inter-alia on the ground that the detenu was not
involved in the alleged recovery of 5.568 kg of WY tablets and the bail
application being Cril.Misc.(B) Case No. 44 of 2022 filed by the detenu was
rejected on 10.10.2022. The 2nd detention order was issued after
Page 4
revocation of the 1st detention order to interfere with the judicial
proceedings in connection with WP(Cril.) No. 40 of 2022 filed earlier by the
detenu. Vide order dated 23.01.2023, the Commissioner (Home),
Government of Manipur rejected the representation dated 16.01.2023 filed
by the detenu as being devoid of any merit. It was also stated that a copy
of the representation dated 16.01.2023 was forwarded to the Advisory
Board and to the Central Government on 19.01.2023.
[6]
The detention order was challenged mainly amongst on the
following grounds that:
(i)
There is no material to indicate that the detenu will be
released on bail;
(ii)
The 1st detention order dated 13.09.2022 was revoked
vide order dated 15.09.2022 to frustrate the writ petition
being WP(Cril.) No. 40 of 2022 filed by the detenu
challenging the 1st detention order;
(iii)
There is total non-application of mind as the detenu
never filed any Cril.Misc.(B) Case No. 59 of 2022 after
rejection of Cril.Misc.(B) Case No. 44 of 2022 on
10.10.2022;
(iv)
There was violation of Section 3(2) of the PIT-ND & PS
Act for failure to send to the Central Government.
Page 5
(v)
There is delay in the consideration of
the 2nd
representation dated 16.01.2023; and
(vi)
Some of the documents furnished are not legible.
Hence, it is prayed that the detention order dated
16.12.2022 be set aside.
[7]
The State Government filed counter affidavit where it is
stated that the detenu was involved in racket of drug trafficker and from him
and other associates, WY tablets weighing 5.568 kgs. were recovered. The
cause of the writ petition being WP(Cril.) No. 40 of 2022 did not survive on
revocation of the 1st detention order dated 13.09.2022 vide order dated
15.12.2022 and the writ petition was accordingly closed vide order dated
16.01.2023 giving liberty to the detenu. The revocation of the 1 st detention
order dated 13.09.2022 was done on technical ground after seeking advice
of the Ld. A.G. and obtaining approval by the then detaining authority as
corrective measure and Section 12 of the PIT-ND & PS Act permits
issuance of fresh detention order. The bail application number was clearly
indicated in the proposal letter dated 16.12.2022 submitted by the police.
The representation dated 16.01.2023 was received on 17.01.2023 and on
the same day forwarded to the DGP, Manipur for para-wise comment, to
the Advisory Board and to the Government of India vide letter dated
19.01.2023. Para-wise comment from SP, Kangpokpi vide letter dated
20.01.2023 was received on 23.01.2023 and the same was disposed of by
Page 6
considering the para-wise comment and the representation was rejected on
23.01.2023. It is stated that there is no delay on the part of the detaining
authority. It is also stated that there is no delay on the part of the State
Government and as such, the writ petition be rejected.
[8]
The Central Government did not file any reply.
[9]
Heard Mr. Serto T Kom, learned counsel for the petitioner, Mr.
Th. Vashum, learned G.A. for the State respondent and Mr. Kh. Samarjit,
learned DSGI for the Union of India.
[10]
Mr. Serto T Kom, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits
that there is total non-application of mind in both the detention orders
13.09.2022 and 16.12.2022, as the same were issued on the ground that
the detenu has filed bail application being Cril.Misc.(B) Case No. 59 of
2022 in connection with FIR No. 14(7)2022 G SPM-PS U/s 22(c)/29/60(3)
ND & PS Act. He submits that the bail application being Cril.Misc.(B) Case
No. 44 of 2022 of the detenu and his wife with reference to the same FIR
was rejected on 10.10.2022. Thereafter, the bail application being
Cril.Misc.(B) Case No. 59 of 2022 (as alleged in the detention order) was
never filed by the detenu herein. Hence, it is total non-application of mind.
He also refers to an order dated 06.02.2023 passed by this Court in
WP(Cril.) No. 10 of 2023 where similar detention order dated 16.12.2022
against detenu’s wife Mrs. Lhaineineng Haokip who was arrested in the
Page 7
same FIR along with the detenu was set aside on the ground of nonapplication of mind that the bail application number was wrongly mentioned
in the detention order and the grounds of detention.
[10.1]
Mr. Serto T Kom, learned counsel, also attacks the detention
order on the ground that there is violation of Section 3 (2) of the PIT-ND &
PS Act and there is no new grounds for issuing the 2 nd detention order
dated 16.12.2022 and the same was a verbatim reproduction of the 1st
detention order dated 13.09.2022. He submits that the 2nd detention order
is liable to be set aside on this ground also. There is 6 days of unexplained
delay by the State Government in disposal of the representation submitted
by the detenu and the Central Government is yet to pass any order on the
representation submitted by the detenu as on the date of filing of the writ
petition. During the course of hearing, learned counsel for the petitioner
informs this Court that the Central Government rejected the representation
by way of Memorandum dated 15.03.2023 and the same was furnished to
the detenu on 16.03.2023. He submits that there is no explanation for the
delay of 2 months taken by the Central Government in disposing of the
representation. Hence, it is prayed that the detention order be set aside.
[11]
Mr. Th. Vashum, learned G.A. for the State respondents,
submits that there is no delay on the part of the State Government in
dealing with the detention order of the detenu. The 1 st detention order was
withdrawn on technical ground so as to rectify the same and thereafter, the
Page 8
2nd detention order dated 16.12.2022 was issued. Hence, there is no defect
in the 2nd detention order. It took only 6 days by the State Government in
disposing of the detention order and the same has been explained in the
counter affidavit, as the time taken in receiving the para-wise comment
from the DGP Office. Hence, it is prayed that the writ petition be rejected.
[12]
Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned DSGI for the Union of India, submits
that he has no specific instruction in this matter and this Court may pass
appropriate order in the facts and circumstances of the case
[13]
Heard the learned counsel for the parties, perused the
materials available on record and the original file submitted by the State
Government.
[14]
In the present case, it is seen that the 1st detention order
dated 13.09.2022 was revoked vide revocation order dated 15.12.2022 and
the 2nd detention order dated 16.12.2022 was issued exactly on the same
ground as contained in the 1st detention order. There is no new material in
the 2nd detention order. It is also seen that in both the detention orders,
filing of bail application being Cril.Misc.(B) Case No. 59 of 2022 in
connection with FIR No. 14(7)2022 G SPM-PS U/s 22(c)/29/60(3) ND & PS
Act. was mentioned. It is the specific case of the detenu that after rejection
of Cril.Misc.(B) Case No. 44 of 2022 in connection with 14(7)2022 G SPMPS U/s 22(c)/29/60(3) ND & PS Act, the detenu did not file any fresh bail
application. On perusal of the original record submitted by the State
Page 9
Government, it is seen that there is one application being Cril.Misc. Case
No. 59 of 2022 in connection with FIR No. 14(7)2022 G SPM-PS U/s
22(c)/29/60(3) ND & PS Act wherein vide order dated 06.09.2022, the
learned Special Judge (ND & PS), Senapati, permited the Investigating
Officer (IO) to interrogate the 4 (four) accused including the detenu herein,
who were arrested in the same FIR but there is no bail application bearing
Cril.Misc.(B) Case No. 59 of 2022 in connection with FIR No. 14(7)2022 G
SPM-PS U/s 22(c)/29/60(3) ND & PS Act.
[15]
It may be noted that vide order dated 06.02.2023 in WP(Cril.)
No. 10 of 2023, this Court set aside the 2nd detention order dated
16.12.2022 with respect to the wife of the detenu herein, who was arrested
in the same FIR, due to non-application of mind as Cril.Misc.(B) Case No.
59 of 2022 was also wrongly mentioned in the detention order. The present
case is also squarely covered by the order dated 06.02.2023 as mentioned
herein above.
[16]
A 5 (five) Judge Constitution Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held in Hadibhandu Das vs. District Magistrate, Cuttack reported
as AIR (1969) SC 43 at para 7 that “In terms of Section 13(2) authorises
the making of a fresh detention order against the same person against
whom the previous order has been revoked or has expired, in any case
where fresh facts have arisen after the date of revocation or expiry, on
which the detaining authority is satisfied that such an order should be
Page 10
made. The clearest implication of Section 13 (2) is that after revocation of
expiry of the previous order, no fresh order may issue on the grounds on
which the order revoked or expired had been made.”
[17]
Relying upon this judgment, in the case of Chhagan
Bhagwan Kahar vs. N.L. Kalna reported as (1989) 2 SCC 318 at para 12,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court held as under:
“12.
It emerges from the above authoritative judicial
pronouncements that even if the order of detention
comes to an end either by revocation or by expiry of the
period of detention there must be fresh facts for
passing a subsequent order. A fortiori when a detention
order is quashed by the Court issuing a high
prerogative writ like habeas corpus or certiorari the
grounds of the said order should not be taken into
consideration either as a whole or in part even along
with the fresh grounds of detention for drawing the
requisite subjective satisfaction to pass a fresh order
because once the court strikes down an earlier order by
issuing rule it nullifies the entire order.”
[18]
The above decision was relied in the case of Anant Singh
Alias Anant Kumar Singh vs. State of Bihar & Ors. reported as (2017)
13 SCC 229. The crux of the above judgment says that when the detention
order is revoked or expired or quashed by the Competent Court, there must
be fresh facts for passing a subsequent detention order against the same
person. In the present case, the 2nd detention order dated 16.12.2022 is
Page 11
exactly a copy of the 1st detention order dated 13.09.2022, which was
revoked vide order dated 15.12.2022. There is no new ground as
mentioned in the above cited decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
Moreover, there is total non-application of mind of mentioning a wrong bail
application number in both the detention orders. As mentioned above, this
Court has already set aside similar detention order in the same FIR on the
ground of mentioning a wrong bail application number as a facet of nonapplication of mind. The 2nd detention order is also liable to be set aside on
the ground of non-application of mind as well as non-disclosure of new
facts for issuance of the 2nd detention order.
[19]
However, in the present case, the State Government took only
6 days while disposing of the detention order. The same has been
explained in the counter affidavit and the disposal of the representation on
23.01.2023 was on the same day, para-wise comment was received from
SP, Kangpokpi. Hence, there is no unexplained delay on the part of the
State Government. The Central Government has not filed anything and
there is no material on record to explain the delay of 2 months taken in
disposal of the representation dated 16.01.2023 vide memorandum dated
15.03.2023 when the same was forwarded to the Central Government on
19.01.2023.
[20]
In the case of Sarabjeet Singh Mokha vs. The District
Magistrate, Jabalpur reported as MANU/SC/1011/2021, the Hon’ble
Page 12
Supreme Court held that unexplained delay and non-disposal of the
representation submitted by the detenu strike at the very root of the
detention order as it affects the life and liberty of a person enshrined under
Article 21 of the Constitution of India. Accordingly, the detention order is
vitiated on this ground alone.
Considering all the facts and circumstances and relevant case
[21]
law in this regard, we are of the view that the detention order cannot be
sustained for (i) non-disclosure of fresh material in the 2nd detention order
dated 16.12.2022; (ii) non-application of mind while issuing the detention
order as detail of bail application is wrongly quoted;
and (iii) non-
explanation of 2 months time taken in disposal of the representation by the
Central Government. Accordingly, the detention order dated 16.12.2022 is
set aside and the detenu, namely Mr. Thangkholen Haokip @ Thanglen
Haokip, be released from detention forthwith, if not required in any other
case.
[22]
Accordingly, writ petition is allowed. No cost.
[23]
Return the original file to the State Government.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
joshua
KH.
JOSHUA
MARING
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
KH. JOSHUA
MARING
Date: 2023.05.03
10:55:34 +05'30'
Page 13
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review