Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/10
GAHC040007182025
2026:GAU-AP:310
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/206/2025
Tindu Chader
Son of Late Tayu Chader, resident of Village Gumsing Taying, PO Taksing, PS
Nacho, Upper Subansiri District, Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP and 2 Ors
represented by the Secretary, Land Management Department, Itanagar, Govt of
Arunachal Pradesh.
2:The Deputy Commissioner
Age: 0
Occupation :
Daporijo
Upper Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh.
3:The Circle Officer
Age: 0
Occupation :
Taksing
Upper Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh
Page No.# 2/10
- B e f o r eHON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
Advocates for the petitioner
: Mr. D. Kamduk
Advocate for the respondents : Ms. G. Ete,
Add. Senior
Government Advocate, respondent
Nos. 1-3
Date of which Judgment is reserved
: 23.03.2026
Date of pronouncement of Judgment
: 27.03.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the : N/A
operative part of the Judgment?
Whether the full judgment has been
: Yes
pronounced?
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. D. Kamduk, learned counsel for the petitioner and Ms. G. Ete,
learned Additional Senior Government Advocate for all the respondents.
2.
In this petition, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner
has challenged the Order No. TKG/JUD-02/2023-24, dated 23.04.2025; issued
by the Circle Officer, Taksing; whereby, the Executive Engineer, PWD, Nacho
Division, was directed to demolish the old Circle Office building and construct a
permanent RCC building for the Circle Office, in the private land of the
Page No.# 3/10
petitioner; and the petitioner has also prayed for issuing direction not to conduct
verification and demarcation of land for development of new Circle Headquarter,
in terms of the minutes of the meeting, dated 05.03.2025 and 05.05.2025;
singed by the Circle Officer, Taksing.
Background facts :3.
The background facts, leading to filing of the present petition, are briefly
stated as under “The petitioner herein has inherited a vast parcel of land at Taksing, and
during the year 2001, the respondent authorities had approached the petitioner
for lending some portion of his private land, for the purpose of establishment of
Circle Office at Taksing, on temporary basis; and on agreement with the
petitioner, a wooden type building for the Circle Office, Taksing, was
constructed. The portion of land, where the Circle Office in presently situated,
was neither acquired by the government nor donated to the government by the
petitioner and the same is apparent from the minutes of meeting, dated
05.03.2025 and 05.05.2025.
Thereafter, the Circle Officer, Taksing, vide order, dated 23.04.2025, in most
illegal and arbitrary manner, had passed an order, directing the Executive
Engineer, PWD, Nacho Division, for dismantling the old Circle Office building and
constructing a new permanent building upon the same plot of land, which
originally belongs to the petitioner. Then, being aggrieved, the petitioner had
filed one representation on 28.04.2025, raising objection for the proposed
construction work of construction of a new permanent Circle Office building; as
the land where the new building is said to be constructed, is the ancestral land
of the petitioner and the same has neither been acquired by the respondent
Page No.# 4/10
authorities nor been donated by the petitioner for such developmental works.”
4.
The respondent Nos. 2 & 3 have filed their affidavit-in-opposition, wherein,
a stand has been taken that on the particular land, where construction of Circle
Officer’s Office building is taking place; there is no such documentary evidence
of ownership from the side of the petitioner, to adduce before this Court as well
as before the Deputy Commissioner, Upper Subansiri district, Daporijo; and that
the Circle Office, Taksing, was established in the year 1959, as per the records
andthe land, where the construction of the present Circle Office is going on, is a
vacant land and it was voluntarily earmarked by the public of the Tasking Circle,
to construct the Circle Office at Taksing; and moreover, from the year 1959 till
2025, the petitioner never made any claim regarding acquisition of land. If the
land really belongs to him, then why he could have raised the objection much
earlier, not after 65 years.
4.1 It has further been stated in the affidavit-in-opposition that the respondent
authorities had conducted a meeting with the public regarding further free and
voluntary donation of land, as the administration requires more land for
establishment of Government infrastructure; as the area is very sensitive and it
is very proximate to the Mac Mohan border.
4.2 The respondent Nos. 2 & 3 have further stated that the petitioner is jealous
of awarding the work of Construction of Circle Office and his claim is tainted
with ulterior motive i.e. to hinder the development work carried out by the State
and there is no document to authenticate the claim of the petitioner; and also,
no complaint was filed by the petitioner for the last 65 years. And under such
circumstances, it is contended to dismiss this petition.
5.
The petitioner has filed his reply to the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the
Page No.# 5/10
respondent Nos. 2 & 3, denying the statements and averments made by the
respondent Nos. 2 & 3 in the affidavit-in-opposition. He has reiterated his
contention that the Circle Office was established over his plot of land, in the
year 2001 and he had lent some of the portion of his private land on temporary
basis and on agreement of the same, a wooden type building for the Circle
Office was constructed and the said plot of land is neither acquired nor donated
by him. And he also enclosed a Certificate, issued by the Head Gaon Bura,
Taksing, wherein, it is stated that the land in question belongs to him.
6.
It is to be noted here that the District Land Revenue and Settlement
Officer, Upper Subansiri District, Daporijo, has also filed an additional affidavit,
bringing on record one letter, dated 06.05.2025; and another letter written by
the Gaon Bura, Taksing Circle, being Annexure I & II; and he states that in view
of the letter, dated 06.05.2025, of Tabi Chader, who is the cousin brother of the
petitioner; the land in question, i.e., the land where the Circle Office is situated,
is not a private land solely belonging to the petitioner, as claimed by him and
that, the land was donated by their grandfather, Late Mising Chader, to the
Government. It is further stated that the petitioner, in his affidavit-in-reply has
enclosed one certificate issued by the Gaon Bura of Taksing Circle, declaring
that the land, where the Circle Office is situated, belongs to the petitioner. But,
subsequently, the Gaon Bura had withdrawn the letter, on the ground that he
was misinformed and misguided by the petitioner.
7.
Mr. Kamduk, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner
is the owner of the plot of land, where the present Circle Office is situated and
the said plot of land was given by the petitioner, in the year 2001, for
construction of Circle Office and accordingly, a wooden type building for
functioning of the Circle Office was constructed; and that, without acquiring the
Page No.# 6/10
land of the petitioner, the respondent authorities are trying to dismantle the old
building and construct a permanent building there.
7.1 It is the further submission of Mr. Kamduk that the petitioner has donated
some other portions of the land to the State respondents for construction of
stadium and for other purposes and now, he has very little plot of land left with
him and if, a permanent office is constructed over his plot of land, without
acquiring the same; it would cause serious hardship to him.
7.2
Mr. Kamduk, by referring to the land holding system in the State of
Arunachal Pradesh, submits that in Arunachal Pradesh, the land is private land
or community land, and the Government acquires the same from the private
person or from the community; and the petitioner is aggrieved by the impugned
order and also, by the minutes of the meeting, by which, the Circle Officer
wanted to demarcate the plot of land and under such circumstances, he has
contended to allow this petition.
8.
Per contra, Ms. Ete, learned Additional Senior Government Advocate has
vehemently opposed the petition. She submits that the petitioner has failed to
show any document to establish that the land, where the Circle Office is
presently situated, belongs to him; and that the petitioner has obtained one
NOC from the Gaonbura, but, the same has subsequently been cancelled.
8.1 Referring to the additional affidavit filed by the District Land Revenue and
Settlement Officer in the Office of the Deputy Commissioner, Upper Subansiri
district, Daporijo; she submits that the petitioner has been falsely claiming as
the owner of the said plot of land and one, Shri Pinju Chader, the Gaonbura of
Taksing Circle has given NOC and the same was withdrawn vide letter dated,
27.01.2026; and that the land in question, where the Circle Officer is presently
Page No.# 7/10
situated is not a private land, solely belonging to the petitioner, as claimed by
him and the said plot of land was donated by their grandfather, Late Mising
Chader; to the Government and the letter, which is annexed with additional
affidavit as ‘Annexure No. I’, dated 06.05.2025; written by one Shri Tabi Chader,
who happens to be the cousin brother of the petitioner; clearly indicates that
their grandfather, Late Mising Chader, has donated the same and that, there is
no merit in this petition and therefore, she has contended to dismiss the same.
8.2 In support of her submission, she has also referred to a decision of a Coordinate Bench of this Court, in the case of Shri Ezekiel Tayang Vs. the
State of Arunachal Pradesh, reported in 2024 Supreme (Gau) 919;
wherein, in paragraph No. 26, it is stated as under –
“26. The petitioners have failed to establish their ownership
and title over any specific area of land except bald
assertion that their lands have been occupied by the
Government by force and no acquisition proceeding has been
followed before taking over the land. As noted above, since
the area of 152.63 acres have been duly donated by the people
of area, question of acquisition would not arise. One could
have understood, if the private land of the petitioners are
taken without due process of law. In the considered view of
this Court, in the State like Arunachal Pradesh, when the
lands were donated to the Government for establishment of
Headquarters and other Government institutions and offices,
no one should be allowed to claim any right over the donated
land by way of vague claims without their being any basis,
else it will create a chaos in the State as the maximum of
the land where Headquarters, towns and other Government
establishment have been established are all on the basis of
the donation of land by the people of the area under peculiar
situation at the relevant point of time, as the State was
Page No.# 8/10
under nascent stage.”
9.
Having heard the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for both
the parties, this Court has carefully gone through the petition and the
documents placed on record and also perused the decision, referred to by Ms.
Ete, learned Senior Government Advocate, for the State respondent.
10. It appears that the land, over which, the present Circle Office of Taksing is
situated; is claimed by the petitioner and also, by the State respondents. While
the petitioner has claimed that the Circle Office was constructed in the year
2001, over the present plot of land, which was lent by him; the State
respondents have taken a stand that the said Circle Office was constructed at
Taksing, in the year 1959. However, none of the parties could adduce any
supporting documents, in support of their contentions regarding the date of
establishment of the Circle Office at Taksing.
11. Nevertheless, the Circle Office is already there; be it from the year 1959, or
from the year 2001. Though, the petitioner herein has taken a stand that he
had lent the said portion of land for establishment of Circle Office, yet, he also
could not produce any documentary evidence in support of the same. Even if it
is assumed that the Circle Office was established in the year 2001, since then,
more than 25 years have elapsed till date. But, the dispute arose between them,
when the State respondents had proposed to construct a permanent building
there. And it appears from the affidavit filed by the State respondents that the
work of construction of the Circle Office building was allotted to some other
person, instead of the petitioner, for which, the petitioner has raised the present
claim.
12. On the other hand, the additional affidavit filed by the District Land
Page No.# 9/10
Revenue & Settlement Officer, Upper Subansiri district, Daporijo, indicates that
one Tabi Chader, has written a letter to the Deputy Commissioner, stating that
the said parcel of land was donated by their forefather for establishment of the
Circle Office and that the petitioner has obtained one NOC from the Gaonbura,
but the same was subsequently withdrawn and as such, the petitioner has no
document to claim any right over the said plot of land. It also appears that the
land was not a private land, solely belonging to the petitioner and one Late
Mising Chader, had donated the same to the Government.
13. It is, however, an undeniable fact that the Taksing circle is situated near
the international border of India and China, and it has immense importance; not
only from security point of view, but also, from the development point of view;
as the development schemes of the Government are always carried out through
the officers and offices, working in the grassroot level.
14. This Court has also taken note of the observation made by a Co-ordinate
Bench by this Court, in the case of Shri Ezekiel Tayang (supra).Thus,
considering the facts and circumstances on the record and also, in view of
absence of any documentary proof that the petitioner has lent the present
parcel of land, where the Circle Office is situated; this Court is of the view that
the petitioner has failed to establish his claim over the said plot of land. Instead
from the letter of Tabi Chader, written a letter to the Deputy Commissioner, and
also from the affidavit of District Land Revenue & Settlement Officer, Upper
Subansiri district, Daporijo reveals that the said parcel of land was donated by
the forefather of the Tabi Chader and of the petitioner, namely, Late Mising
Chader, for establishment of the Circle Office. Further it appears that the NOC
obtained by the petitioner from the Gaonburah, was subsequently withdrawn. It
also appears that the land was not a private land, solely belonging to the
Page No.# 10/10
petitioner.
15. Under the given facts and circumstances, this Court is inclined to dispose
of this petition, by directing the respondent authorities to verify the claim of the
petitioner, on the basis of the representation filed by him on28.04.2025, and to
ascertain the veracity of his claim and only thereafter, to proceed with the
construction of the Circle Office in accordance with law. And if, during the
course of verification, it is found that the land in question belongs to the
petitioner, then the State respondents have to acquire the same in accordance
with law and only thereafter, the State can proceed with the construction work.
16. In terms of the above, this writ petition stands disposed of, leaving the
parties to bear their own costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review