Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S. No. 60
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CRA No. 6/2008
CrlM No.692/2019
CrlM No.1150/2019
Reserved on: 16.07.2026
Pronounced on: 30.07.2026
Uploaded on: 30.07.2026
Whether the operative part or
Full judgment is pronounced: Full
Tilak Raj S/O Balak Ram,
R/O Village Bhagot, Khalsa.
…..Appellant(s)
Through: Mr. B. R. Sharma, Adv.
Ms. Manpreet Kour, Adv.
Vs
State (now Union Territory) of J&K
through Advocate General, J&K, Jammu.
.…. Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Sumeet Bhatia, GA
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MA CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
01. Appellant herein feeling aggrieved of the judgment and order dated
12.03.2008, passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge, Reasi (‘Trial
Court’) in Sessions Case No. 20/S titled ‘State Versus Swarna Devi & Ors’,
whereby he has been convicted for the commission of offence punishable
under Section 498-A RPC and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment
for one and a half years and a fine of Rs.5,000/- and in default of payment
of fine, to undergo further rigorous imprisonment for a period of three
months.
CRA No.6/2008
02. The judgment and order impugned have been assailed on the grounds that
there was no reliable evidence on record to establish the guilt of the
appellant with the alleged crime; that the evidence of the material
prosecution witnesses was full of contradictions, exaggerations and
improvements; that none of the witnesses, on whose evidence the appellant
has been convicted, have ever supported the prosecution version of the
story; that there was not any eye witness proving the evidence against the
appellant; that the appellant was not present at the time of alleged
occurrence; that that trial court has not appreciated the evidence in its
correct perspective; that the witnesses produced were all hear-say witnesses
and had no personal knowledge; that the allegation of dowry demand by
the appellant and his family was intended only to link the appellant with the
commission of offence; that the independent witnesses Jagdish Raj PW-8,
as well as other witnesses have turned hostile and even the seizure memo
was not proved by any witness, pertaining to the site plan; that the trial
court has passed the impugned judgment on the basis of presumptions U/S
113-A of the Evidence Act only.
03. The factual matrix of the case, as per the charge sheet, FIR No.35/1998
came to be registered in the Crime Branch Jammu; that letter
No.Cr/R/10556 dated 03.09.1998 was addressed to SHO PS Crime Branch
Jammu by SSP C&R Jammu for registration of case U/Ss 306/498-A RPC
and to hand over the investigation to Kamlesh Shoor; that the complainant
Ram Dhan gave a written report to police post Pouni averring therein that
about ¾ months ago, he got his daughter Sharda Devi married at Parthal
Reasi; that his daughter has come to his house about two days ago and
CRA No.6/2008
informed him that her in-laws are demanding cooler, etc from her; that he
informed his daughter that he will give it afterwards; thereafter, she went
back to her matrimonial house; that on 13.09.1997, he came to know that
his daughter has died; that he went on spot and has full belief that his
daughter has been killed for dowry.
04.
On receipt of this report, proceedings u/s 174 CrPC were initiated,
statements of witnesses recorded and obtained the FSL report, as also post
mortem report; that during investigation, it has come out that death has
taken place due to the taunting and beating of deceased by appellant and his
family and that deceased committed suicide by consuming ‘Thiodine’
insecticide.
05. On conclusion of the investigation, charge sheet was laid against the
accused including the appellant and charges under Section 498-A/306 RPC
were framed against them. All the accused denied the charges and claimed
trial. The trial court after conducting trial vide impugned judgment and
order acquitted the sister-in-law and brother of the appellant of the charges
under Sections 306/498-A RPC. The appellant, however, was acquitted of
the charge U/S 306 RPC but was convicted for the commission of offence
punishable under Section 498-A RPC and sentenced to undergo rigorous
imprisonment for a period of one and a half years and a fine of Rs.5,000/and in default of payment of fine, to undergo further rigorous imprisonment
for a period of three months.
06. Heard learned counsel for both the sides, perused the impugned judgment
and order and considered.
CRA No.6/2008
07. Learned counsel for the appellant argued that this is a case where the
appellant and his family were falsely implicated in the case; that the
appellant has been convicted on no evidence at all; that I.O. in the case has
not been examined and due to non examination of I.O., site plan, seizure
memo and other documents have remained unproved; that there are lot of
contradictions in the statements of witnesses who have been examined. In
support of his contentions, learned counsel has placed reliance on the
decisions of the Supreme Court in ‘Munna Lal V. State of Uttar Pradesh’
reported as (2023) 18 SCC 661; and the Punjab and Haryana High Court in
the case of ‘Gagandeep Singh V. State of Punjab’ reported as 2023
NCPHHC 163994.
08.
Learned counsel for the respondents, on the other hand, vehemently argued
that the trial court has rightly convicted the appellant; that examination of
the IO was not relevant for the charge under Section 498-A RPC; that the
trial court meticulously scanned the evidence on record and returned
findings that the appellant is guilty of the offence under Section 498-A
RPC; that mere flaws in the process of investigation, according to him,
would not be sufficient for dislodging the findings so returned; that the
appeal being devoid of any merit, deserves dismissal the conviction and
sentence recorded by the trial court, be maintained and upheld.
09. While referring to the prosecution evidence, he further argued that though
there was no evidence against the mother and sister of the appellant, about
the charges framed against them, they were acquitted whereas as against
appellant, sufficient evidence could not be led so as to prove the charge
CRA No.6/2008
U/S 306 RPC (abetment to suicide) but there was sufficient evidence to
prove the charge U/S 498-A CRPC (subjecting his wife to cruelty); that the
Trial Court has rightly recorded his conviction; that there is no reason to
interfere with the impugned judgment/order and prayed dismissal of the
appeal.
10. The prosecution case, as was set up, was that on 13.09.1997, deceased, on
getting mentally disturbed, because of taunts made by appellant and his
mother for not bringing fridge, cooler, quilt covers, etc. in marriage, due to
demand of Rs.50,000/- from her father and because of pressure put by
brother of appellant for marriage with her younger sister, committed
suicide by consuming poisonous substance. Appellant and his mother were
thus charged and prosecuted before the Trial Court for the commission of
offences punishable under Sections 498-A and 306 RPC. Both of them
were however, acquitted of the charge of offence under Section 306 RPC,
nonetheless mother was acquitted of offence U/S 498-A RPC and appellant
was convicted of this charge and sentenced to imprisonment and fine.
11. Section 498-A RPC reads as under:
“498-A: Husband or relative of husband of a woman subjecting her to
cruelty:- Whoever, being the husband or the relative of the
husband of a woman, subjects such woman to cruelty shall be
punished with imprisonment for a term which may extend to
three years and shall also be liable to fine.
Explanation:- For the purpose of this section ‘cruelty’ means:(a) any wilful conduct which is of such nature as is likely to drive
the woman to commit suicide or to cause grave injury or
danger to life, limb or health whether mental or physical of the
CRA No.6/2008
woman; and
(b) harassment of the woman where such harassment is with a
view to coercing her or any person related to her to meet any
unlawful demand for any property or valuable security or is on
account of failure by her or any person related to her to meet
such demand.”
12. PW-1 Kanchan Kumari, who is sister-in-law of the deceased stated that
deceased used to tell her that her mother-in-law and husband were making
dowry demands of fridge, cooler and quilt covers and beat her also; that
appellant used to tell the deceased to get Rs.50,000/- from her parents as
his vehicle met with an accident; that on 12 th when she went on spot, she
saw blood stained clothes of the deceased. PW-2 Naresh Pal, brother of the
deceased stated that for one month after marriage, everything was alright
between deceased and appellant, thereafter appellant, his mother and
brother used to taunt deceased and to get fridge, cooler, etc; that appellant
asked deceased to get Rs.50,000/- from her parents for repairing the
vehicle; that deceased informed him that she was hit in the face. PW-3
Shallo Devi, friend of the deceased stated that prior to incident, deceased,
with her mother-in-law, met her in a matador and informed her that her
mother-in-law and other in-laws taunt her for not bringing cooler and fridge
and her husband used to abuse her and beat her up when she asked to
accompany him to Jammu for living; that the deceased told her that perhaps
they would never meet again.
13. To appreciate the rival submissions in the context of grounds of challenge,
this court would have to revert to the prosecution evidence brought on
record. Prosecution has examined as many as 14 witnesses, namely, PW-1
CRA No.6/2008
Kanchan Kumari, PW-2 Naresh Pal, PW-3 Shallo Devi, PW-4 Kamla Devi,
PW-5 Inspector Khalil-ur-Rehman, PW-6 Ram Dhan, PW-7 SI Gurdial
Sangra, PW-8 Jagdish Raj, PW-9 Krishan Lal, PW-10 Om Parkash, PW-11
Kewal Krishan, PW-12 Sita Ram, OPW-13 Vakil Singh and PW-14 Dr.
Raghubir Singh.
14. PW-4 Kamla Devi, mother of deceased stated that deceased used to cry and
say that her in-laws used to taunt her for not bringing fridge and cooler in
dowry; that accused had told deceased to get Rs.50,000/- from her parental
house; that appellant beat the deceased on one or two occasion and on
asking the reason, he told that the deceased persistently insists to take her
along with him to Jammu, whereupon the appellant got infuriated and hit
on her face with the shoe. PW-6, Ram Dhan, father of the deceased, stated
that his daughter got married with the appellant on 03.05.1997; that 15/20
days after the marriage, his daughter complained to him that her mother-inlaw and husband trouble her for not bringing fridge and cooler in marriage
though the appellant had not demanded anything from him personally; that
appellant used to beat deceased and demanded Rs.50,000/-; that Pawan
Kumar used to tell the deceased that she should get her younger sister
married with him but deceased did not agree to it; that he through Ram Lal,
father-in-law of Jagdish Lal informed the accused not to trouble his
daughter for cooler and fridge. Rest of the prosecution witnesses are of
formal nature to have witnessed the documentation in the case.
15. From the statements of prosecution witnesses, particularly, the parents of
the deceased-Ram Dhan and Kamala Devi, and her friend-Shallo Devi,
CRA No.6/2008
brother-Naresh Pal and sister-in-law Kanchan Kumari, it has been proved
that the appellant as husband had demanded certain dowry items like
refrigerator, cooler, quilts besides an amount of Rs.50,000/- for repair of
his vehicle, which had met with an accident. In this case, the evidence as
adduced by the prosecution clearly establishes that deceased Sharda Devi
was subjected to abuse, humiliation and mental torture from the very
beginning of her marriage; that allegations of demanding of dowry were
sufficiently proved against the appellant by the prosecution. The
harassment to which the deceased as wife was subjected by the appellant
has been proved by the prosecution evidence which comes within the
definition of cruelty punishable under Section 498-A RPC.
16. For the foregoing reasons and observations made hereinabove, it is found
that the Trial Court has recorded conviction of the appellant under Section
498-A RPC after recording acquittal under Section 306 RPC, along with
his mother, has been passed perfectly in consonance with law and the
judgment impugned suffers from no infirmity, much less, any illegality, so
as to warrant any interference by this court invoking appellate jurisdiction.
17.
Viewed thus, the appeal is found to be without any merit and substance
and is dismissed. The impugned order recording conviction of the appellant
under Section 498-A RPC and the order, whereby, he was sentenced is
upheld. The bail bonds executed by the appellant are cancelled with a
direction to surrender before the Trial Court within a period of 15 days
from the date of this judgment, for undergoing sentence, failing which Trial
Court shall procure his presence.
CRA No.6/2008
18. A copy of this order shall be forwarded to the Trial Court for information
and record.
19. The appeal is accordingly dismissed, along with connected applications.
(MA CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
JAMMU
30.07.2026
Raj Kumar
Whether the order is reportable: Yes/No
Raj Kumar
2026.07.30 18:15
No.6/2008
I attest to the CRA
accuracy
and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review