Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
{FA (MAT) Nos.432/2024 & 17/2025}
Digitally
signed by
SISTA
SOMAYAJULU
SISTA
SOMAYAJULU Date:
2026.01.24
13:39:28
+0530
2026:CGHC:3834-DB
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
FA(MAT) No. 432 of 2024
{Arising out of judgment and decree dated 23-9-2023 in Civil Suit
No.22A/2021 of the Judge, Family Court, Mahasamund, Camp Court/
Link Court, Saraipali}
Tikeshwar Panda, S/o Janamjay Panda, presently aged about 33 years,
Occupation Laborer, R/o Village Bade, Post Gobarsingha, Thana Sariya,
District Raigarh (C.G.)
Presently residing at Vidhya Sahu's House, Janakpur, Bus Stand
Tamnar, Tehsil Tamnar, District Raigarh (C.G.)
(Plaintiff)
--- Appellant
Versus
Smt. Sangeeta Panda, wife of Tikeshwar Panda, D/o Shravan Sathpathi,
presently aged about 30 years, Occupation Sewing, Embroidery, R/o
Mohanmuda Pandripani, Post Office Kendua, Thana & Tahsil Saraipalli,
District Mahasamund (C.G.)
(Defendant)
--- Respondent
AND
FA(MAT) No. 17 of 2025
{Arising out of judgment and decree dated 23-9-2023 in Civil Suit
No.9A/2020 of the Judge, Family Court, Mahasamund, Camp Court/
Link Court, Saraipali}
Tikeshwar Panda, S/o Janmjay Panda, presently aged about 33 years,
Occupation Laborer, R/o Village Bade, Post Gobarsingha, Thana Sariya,
District Raigarh (C.G.)
Presently residing at Kudhrikhar Post, Tehsil Tamnar, District Raigarh
(C.G.)
(Respondent)
--- Appellant
versus
{FA (MAT) Nos.432/2024 & 17/2025}
Smt. Sangeeta Panda, wife of Tikeshwar Panda, D/o Shravan Sathpathi,
presently aged about 30 years, Occupation Sewing, Embroidery, presently
residing at Mohanmunda Pandripani, Post Office Kendua, Thana & Tahsil
Saraipalli, District Mahasamund (C.G.)
(Plaintiff)
--- Respondent
For Appellant
: Mr. Hari Agrawal, Advocate.
For Respondent
: Mr. S.B. Pandey, Advocate.
Division Bench: Hon'ble Shri Sanjay K. Agrawal and
Hon'ble Shri Arvind Kumar Verma, JJ.
Judgment On Board
(22/01/2026)
Sanjay K. Agrawal, J.
1. The appellant herein/husband has preferred an application for
divorce on the ground enumerated under Section 13(1)(ia) of the
Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 seeking dissolution of marriage being the
subject matter of Civil Suit No.22A/2021, whereas the respondent
herein/wife has preferred an application for restitution of conjugal
rights being Civil Suit No.9A/2020. Both the applications have been
heard analogously by the Family Court and separate judgments have
been passed. The Family Court has dismissed the application for
divorce filed by the appellant/husband resulting into filing of FA
(MAT) No.432/2024 questioning the rejection of his application
seeking dissolution of marriage, whereas the application for
restitution of conjugal rights filed by the respondent/wife has been
granted against which the appellant/husband has preferred FA
(MAT) No.17/2025 questioning the same that the respondent/wife is
not entitled for decree of restitution of conjugal rights.
{FA (MAT) Nos.432/2024 & 17/2025}
2. Since in both the cases, husband is the appellant and wife is the
respondent, they have been clubbed together, heard together and are
being disposed of by this common judgment.
3. The aforesaid judgments & decrees have been challenged by the
appellant herein/husband on the following factual backdrop: 3.1) Marriage between appellant Tikeshwar Panda and respondent
Sangeeta was solemnized on 26-4-2012 at Village Mohanmuda
Pandripani, District Mahasamund as per Hindu rites and ceremonies
and out of their wedlock, they were blessed with two sons namely
Aadarsh Panda, aged about 12 years and Aarush Panda, aged about 8
years. Aadarsh Panda is residing with appellant Tikeshwar Panda –
husband and Master Aarush Panda is residing with respondent Smt.
Sangeeta Panda – wife. After seven years of marriage, matrimonial
discard took place between the parties.
3.2) It is the case of the appellant herein/husband in the divorce
petition that when he used to go to his work, thereupon taking
advantage of his absence, the respondent herein/wife befriended
many male friends and used to do obscene chatting and video calls
with them. Thereafter, when the appellant/husband got a hint about
the same, he tried to convince the respondent/wife to improve, but
she did not listen leading to installation of two CCTV cameras in the
bedroom and he himself saw that the respondent/wife used to make
video call with her male friends and exposes her body/private parts
to them.
{FA (MAT) Nos.432/2024 & 17/2025}
3.3) It is the further case of the appellant herein/husband in the
divorce petition that when the respondent herein/wife was exposed
by him before her parental family members, she threatened to
commit suicide and wrote a suicide note mentioning the name of the
appellant, which was informed by the appellant to Police Station
Sariya. Thereafter, on 7-12-2020, firstly, the respondent/wife filed
application for restitution of conjugal rights under Section 9 of the
Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 before the Family Court, Saraipali on the
ground that the appellant/husband has deserted her and refused to
keep her without any reasonable cause. Thereafter, on 19-7-2021, the
appellant/husband filed application for grant of decree of divorce on
the ground of cruelty contained in Section 13(1)(ia) of the Hindu
Marriage Act, 1955 before the Family Court, Link Court Saraipali,
District Mahasamund on the ground that the respondent/wife, after
marriage, treated him with cruelty by entering into extra marital
affairs and adulterous acts.
3.4) It is also the case of the appellant herein/husband in the
divorce petition that he has filed a Compact Disc showing the
objectionable behaviour of his wife/respondent herein. However, the
learned Family Court by its judgment dated 23-9-2023 dismissed the
divorce petition and refused to see the contents of the Compact Disc
on the ground that the appellant/husband has not filed the certificate
under Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 and proceeded to
grant the application for restitution of conjugal rights in favour of the
respondent/wife and against the appellant/husband against which
{FA (MAT) Nos.432/2024 & 17/2025}
the present two appeals have been preferred by the appellant
herein/husband, one against rejection of divorce petition and
another against grant of application for restitution of conjugal rights.
This is how the instant two appeals are before us.
4. Mr. Hari Agrawal, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
appellant herein/husband, would submit that the Family Court is
absolutely unjustified in rejecting the application for grant of divorce
filed on behalf of the appellant herein/husband. He would further
submit that Compact Disc is also a document and strict rule of
evidence as contained in the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 would not be
applicable to the proceeding before the Family Court by virtue of
Section 14 of the Family Courts Act, 1984. He would also submit that
the Family Court is well within its power to take into evidence or
admit any material which is essential for effective adjudication of the
lis whether or not requirements under the provisions of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872 including Section 65B are fulfilled. As such, since
the Compact Disc is also a document within the meaning of Section
14 of the Family Courts Act, 1984 and the Compact Disc was very
much necessary for just and proper disposal of the application for
divorce, it ought to have been taken into consideration and
considered by the Family Court and it could not have been rejected
on the ground of absence of certificate under Section 65B of the
Indian Evidence Act, 1872, which is also clear from Section 20 of the
Family Courts Act, 1984, which clearly gives an overriding effect to
the provisions of the Family Courts Act over other laws i.e. the
{FA (MAT) Nos.432/2024 & 17/2025}
provisions contained in the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, as far as the
present case is concerned. Therefore, both the impugned judgments
& decrees rejecting the application for divorce and granting the
application for restitution of conjugal rights deserve to be set aside
and the matter be remitted to the Family Court for adjudication
afresh after considering the Compact Disc for exhibiting and
considering the import of document (Compact Disc) in accordance
with law.
5. Mr. S.B. Pandey, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondent herein/wife, would support the impugned judgments &
decrees and oppose the appeals and submit that since along with the
Compact Disc no certificate under Section 65B of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872, was preferred which is mandatory in light of the
decision of the Supreme Court in the matter of Arjun Panditrao
Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal and others 1, the
Family Court is right in omitting to consider the Compact Disc while
passing the impugned judgments rejecting the application for divorce
and granting the application for restitution of conjugal rights and as
such, both the appeals deserve to be dismissed.
6. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and considered their
rival submissions made herein-above and also gone through the
record with utmost circumspection.
7. The short question for consideration would be, whether the provision
contained in Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, is strictly
1 (2020) 7 SCC 1
{FA (MAT) Nos.432/2024 & 17/2025}
applicable in a proceeding initiated by the Family Courts while
considering the application for divorce under Section 13(1)(ia) of the
Hindu Marriage Act, 1955?
8. In order to consider the plea raised at the Bar, it would be
appropriate to notice the provision contained in Section 14 of the
Family Courts Act, 1984, which states as under: “14. Application of Indian Evidence Act, 1872.—A Family
Court may receive as evidence any report, statement,
documents, information or matter that may, in its opinion,
assist it to deal effectually with a dispute, whether or not the
same would be otherwise relevant or admissible under the
Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (1 of 1872).”
9. A careful perusal of Section 14 of the Family Courts Act, 1984, would
show that the Family Court is entitled to receive as evidence any
report, statement, documents, information or matter which in its
opinion would assist the said Court to deal effectually with a dispute
irrespective of whether the same would otherwise be relevant or
admissible under the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. As such, the Family
Court is well within its power to take into evidence any material/
document which, as discussed, may be essential for effectively
adjudicating the dispute before it whether or not it fulfills the
requirements of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, however, while
exercising such discretion, the Family Court ought to bear in mind
that it does not violate the basic principles of legal system. The
object of Section 14 of the Family Courts Act, 1984 is to remove the
rigour of the provisions of the Evidence Act while adjudicating the
family disputes under the provisions of the Family Courts Act, 1984.
{FA (MAT) Nos.432/2024 & 17/2025}
10. In this regard, the pertinent observations made by the Bombay High
Court in the matter of Deepali Santosh Lokhande v. Santosh
Vasantrao Lokhande2 may be noticed herein in which the
Bombay High Court while noticing the provision contained in
Section 14 of the Family Courts Act, 1984, has clearly held that the
intention of the legislature in enacting this provision is to remove
complexities in the application of rules of evidence in proceedings
before the Family Court, and observed as under: “6. A plain reading of the above provision clearly indicates
that the intention of the legislature is to permit the Family
Court to receive as evidence any report, statement, documents,
information or matter which in its opinion would assist the
Family Court to deal effectually with a dispute irrespective of
whether the same would otherwise be relevant or admissible
under the Indian Evidence Act. Significantly the words
“Whether or not the same would be otherwise relevant or
admissible under the Evidence Act 1872” surely have a different
import. The object, effect and consequence of this provision is
to remove any embargo on the Family Court to first examine
the relevancy or admissibility of the documents under Indian
Evidence Act in considering such documents in adjudication of
the matrimonial dispute. The Statement of Object and Reasons
leading to the enactment of the Family Court's Act would also
become a guiding factor so as to ascertain the intention of the
legislature in framing section 14 when it uses the above words.
One of the objects of the legislation as Clause 2 (h) of the
Statement of Object and Reasons would provide is “simplify the
rules of evidence and procedure so as to enable a Family Court
to deal effectively with a dispute”. This clearly manifests the
intention of the legislature to remove complexities in the
application of rules of evidence to make the procedure more
comprehensible so as to enable a Family Court to deal
effectively with a matrimonial dispute under the Family Courts
Act, which is a special Act.
7.
When section 14 stipulates and says that the Family
Court can receive a document in evidence irrespective of the
same being relevant or admissible in evidence under the
2 2018(1) Mh.L.J. 944
{FA (MAT) Nos.432/2024 & 17/2025}
Evidence Act, it signifies two important facets namely that the
Family Court at the threshold cannot reject a document on the
ground that the document is not legally admissible in evidence
and secondly the test and rigor of relevancy and admissibility of
the document can be dispensed with by the Family Court if the
Family Court is of the opinion that any evidence would assist it
to deal effectively with the dispute. It cannot be disputed that
admissibility presupposes relevancy as admissibility is founded
on law whereas relevancy is determined by Court using judicial
skills, logic and experience. Admissibility does not signify that
a particular fact stands proved but merely that such a fact is
received by the Court for the purpose of being weighed. The
learned Judge overlooked that merely because the documents
are marked as Exhibits and the same also becoming available
for cross-examination, is neither an admission as to documents
nor can be treated as an admission of its contents.”
11. At this stage, it would also be appropriate to notice Section 20 of the
Family Courts Act, 1984, which gives an overriding effect to the
provisions of the Family Courts Act over other laws. Section 20
states as under: “20. Act to have overriding effect.—The provisions of this
Act shall have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent
therewith contained in any other law for the time being in force
or in any instrument having effect by virtue of any law other
than this Act.”
12. The Family Courts Act is a special Act and the Indian Evidence Act is
a general law. The Family Courts Act, 1984 has been enacted to
provide for the establishment of Family Courts with a view to
promote conciliation in, and secure speedy settlement of disputes
relating to marriage and family affairs and for matters connected
therewith. One of the objects of the Family Courts Act, 1984, as
contained in clause 2(h) of the Statement of Objects and Reasons is
to simplify the rules of evidence and procedure so as to enable a
Family Court to deal effectively with a matrimonial dispute.
{FA (MAT) Nos.432/2024 & 17/2025}
13. As such, Section 20 of the Family Courts Act, 1984, mandates that
the provisions of the Family Courts Act shall have overriding effect
notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith contained in any
other law for the time being in force or in any instrument having
effect by virtue of any law other than the Act.
14. In this regard also, the Bombay High Court in Deepali Santosh
Lokhande (supra) considered the scope of Section 20 of the Family
Courts Act, 1984 and held that the Family Court can receive a
document in evidence irrespective of same being relevant or
admissible in evidence under the Evidence Act and observed as
under: “9. A cumulative reading of section 14 and section 20 of the
Family Courts Act, takes within its ambit the restricted
applications of the provisions of the Evidence Act qua the
documentary evidence which includes electronic evidence,
whether or not the same is relevant or admissible, if in the
opinion of the Family Court such evidence would assist the
Family Court to deal effectively with the matrimonial dispute.
Considering the above object and the intention of the
legislature, in providing for a departure, from the normal rules
of evidence under the Evidence Act, in my opinion, there was
no embargo for the learned Judge of the Family Court to accept
and exhibit the documents as sought by the petitioner-wife.
Ultimately, it is the absolute power and authority of the Family
Court either to accept or disregard a particular evidence in
finally adjudicating the matrimonial dispute. However, to say
that a party would be precluded from placing such documents
on record and or such documents can be refused to be
exhibited unless they are proved, in my opinion, goes contrary
to the object of section 14 of the Family Courts Act.
10. In matrimonial cases, the Family Court is expected to
adopt standards as to how a prudent person would gauge the
realities of life and a situation of commotion and turmoil
between the parties and applying the principle of
preponderance of probabilities, consider whether a particular
{FA (MAT) Nos.432/2024 & 17/2025}
fact is proved. Thus, the approach of the Family Court is
required to be realistic and rational to the facts in hand rather
than technical and narrow. It cannot be overlooked that
matrimonial disputes involve human problems which are
required to be dealt with utmost human sensitivity by using all
intelligible skills to judge such issues. The Family Court has a
special feature where in a given case there may not be legal
representation of the parties. Section 13 of the Act makes such a
provision. In such a situation, the parties who are not experts
in law cannot be expected to know the technical rules of the
evidence qua the relevancy, admissibility and proof of
documents. Thus, the strict principles as referred in the
impugned order on the decisions which are not under the
Family Courts Act, would not be of any relevance in the
proceedings before the Family Court.”
The Bombay High Court further held that even if there is any
electronic record for which certificate under Section 65B of the
Evidence Act is necessary, it would also not preclude the Family
Court to exhibit such documents and receive such documents in
evidence, and observed as under: “11. Thus, in my opinion, even if there is any electronic record
for which certificate under section 65-B of the Evidence Act is
necessary, it would not preclude the learned Judge of the
Family Court to exhibit such documents and receive such
documents in evidence, on forming an opinion as to whether
the documents would assist the Court, to deal effectively with
the dispute in hand. Such exercise has not been undertaken in
passing the impugned order.”
15. Coming to the facts of the instant case, in light of the discussion
made herein-above, Compact Disc was produced by the appellant
herein/husband, which was also subjected to cross-examination by
the parties in their evidence. Undisputedly, the Compact Disc is a
document within the meaning of Section 3 of the Evidence Act and so
held by the Supreme Court in the matter of Shamsher Singh
{FA (MAT) Nos.432/2024 & 17/2025}
Verma v. State of Haryana 3, but the Family Court has
omitted/refused to consider the Compact Disc holding that the
mandatory certificate under Section 65B of the Evidence Act has not
been produced by the appellant/husband.
16. In our considered opinion, in light of the objects of the Family Courts
Act, 1984 and by virtue of Section 14 read with Section 20 of the
Family Courts Act, 1984, the document Compact Disc, which is an
electronic
document,
is
necessarily
required
for
effective
adjudication of the lis between the parties, as the allegations of the
appellant herein/husband is that it contains CCTV coverage and
obscene acts by the respondent herein/wife. Once the document is
required for effective adjudication of the lis, certificate under Section
65B of the Evidence Act would not be necessary. Therefore, merely
because certificate under Section 65B of the Evidence Act has not
been produced, the learned Family Court ought not to have refused
to consider the Compact Disc which is very much a relevant
document and very much necessary for just and proper disposal of
the application for divorce and the learned Family Court should not
have refused to consider the same.
17. As a fallout and consequence of the aforesaid discussion, the
judgments impugned rejecting the divorce application and granting
the restitution of conjugal rights, both are hereby set aside and the
matter is remitted to the concerned Family Court to firstly mark/
exhibit the Compact Disc, which is filed in divorce case, and then
3 (2016) 15 SCC 485
{FA (MAT) Nos.432/2024 & 17/2025}
allow the other side to cross-examine/object to the said document in
accordance with law and thereafter, to consider the Compact Disc
and to decide the suits afresh, in accordance with law. Since more
than four years had already elapsed from the date of institution and
it is an old one and the matter is pending since more than four years,
the Family Court is expected to consider and dispose of both the
matters expeditiously.
18. Only the available record of Civil Suit No.22A/2021 be sent back to
the Family Court forthwith along with a copy of this judgment.
19. Both the appeals are allowed to the extent indicated herein-above
leaving the parties to bear their own cost(s).
20. Decrees be drawn-up accordingly.
Sd/(Sanjay K. Agrawal)
JUDGE
Soma
Sd/(Arvind Kumar Verma)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review