Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 13 of 2021
Date of Decision: 14.09.2022
Shri Thwen Marngar & Anr. Vs. The Marwir Village Dorbar & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. T. Dkhar, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Chakrawarty, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. A. Barua, Adv. (For 1-3)
Mr. H. Kharmih, Addl. Sr. GA (For 4-6)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The petitioners are before this Court by this instant writ
application for quashing and setting aside an impugned resolution
dated 24.04.2019, passed by the respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 (Village
Dorbar and functionaries), and for directions to not restrict the
petitioners from using an existing village public road.
2.
The two petitioners herein, both senior citizens, engaged
in agriculture, are residents of a Village known as Marwir, Myriaw
Syiemship, West Khasi Hills. Sometime in the year 2019, the
respondent Village Dorbar for the proposed construction of a
motorable road on the existing village kutcha road, by availing
Government Schemes, had requested the petitioners and 5 other land
owners to give No Objection Certificates (NOCs) to part with a portion
of their individual lands for construction of the said road. It was then
alleged by the respondent No. 1, 2 and 3, that the petitioners had
refused to give an NOC, with regard to their portion of land, after which
the impugned resolution dated 24.04.2019 was passed. By the
impugned resolution, the Village Dorbar restrained the petitioners from
using the village road for transportation of their produce, and also
forbade any vehicle from transporting or carrying the produce of the
petitioners, with the condition that a fine of an amount of Rs. 5,000/would be imposed on any violator. The petitioners on the resolution
being passed against them, approached the respondents No. 1, 2 and 3,
requesting them to reconsider the same and to compromise the matter,
but it appears the same bore no fruit. Thereafter the petitioners lodged
a complaint before the Police on 23.10.2019, which was however
withdrawn, on the assurance by the respondents No. 2 and 3 that the
matter would be settled amicably. However, as the matter remained
unsettled, the petitioners then approached the State respondents, by
way of a representation, against the mis-treatment and discrimination
meted out to them by the respondent Village Dorbar. Though certain
efforts were made by the State respondents, through the Block
Development Officer, Mawthadraishan, (Respondent No. 6) and also
by the Gram Sevak, no solution could be arrived at, which had therefore
compelled the petitioners to approach before this Court.
3.
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, learned Senior counsel assisted by
Mr. T. Dkhar, learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that the
petitioners have faced undue hardships and incurred substantial
financial loss, as their agricultural produce, and essential commodities
has not been allowed to be transported via the village road due to the
resolution of the respondent Village Dorbar, forbidding usage of the
same. Learned Senior counsel submits that the petitioners in fact, by a
letter dated 02.03.2022, which is appended at Annexure-6, had refused
to sign the NOC, because the respondent Village Dorbar had asked
them to sign the NOCs, even for the lands which belonged to the other
land owners. It is submitted by the Learned Senior counsel that as far
as their portion of land is concerned, the petitioners are ready to sign
the NOC. He submits that as the actions of the respondents has resulted
in grave injustice being caused which is violative of Articles 14, 19, 21
and 300-A of the Constitution of India, the impugned resolution was
liable to be quashed and the respondents Village Dorbar be made to
compensate the petitioners for the loss and injustice caused.
4.
Mr. S. Chakrawarty, learned Senior counsel assisted by
Ms. A. Barua, learned counsel for the respondents No. 1, 2 and 3
submits that the Project for constructing a motorable road in the Village
under the available Government Schemes, was for the general benefit
of all residents of Marwir Village and its surrounding areas. Learned
Senior counsel further submits that the refusal of the petitioners to
contribute any land, whereas all the other five land owners had
willingly contributed their portions, had put the entire project in
jeopardy. It is then submitted, that the petitioners were never asked to
sign the NOC’s on behalf of all the other five land owners, but the
petitioners were to only give an NOC for the portion of their land. The
resolution dated 24.04.2019, he submits had to be adopted in view of
the non-cooperation of the writ petitioners and their failure to
participate in the Dorbar. It is then also submitted that notwithstanding
the circumstances, the respondent Village Dorbar was agreeable to take
appropriate initiatives for resolution and settlement of the dispute.
5.
Mr. H. Kharmih, learned Addl. Sr. GA on behalf of the
respondent No. 4, 5 and 6 submits that no relief has been claimed
against the State respondents. He however, refers to the affidavit filed
on behalf of the respondent No. 6, to show that the respondent No.6
had gone to meet the village authorities and the writ petitioners, to
inquire into the matter and to advise the Village Dorbar to withdraw
the impugned resolution, but the same did not materialize as the
petitioners were insisting on being compensated by the Village Dorbar.
6.
In reply to the submissions made by Mr. S. Chakrawarty,
learned Senior counsel for the respondent No. 1, 2 and 3 and Mr. H.
Kharmih, learned Addl. Sr. GA for the respondent No. 4, 5, and 6, Mr.
H.L. Shangreiso, learned Senior counsel has rebutted the same and has
placed the rejoinder affidavits filed in reply thereto, and submits that
two of the other land owners also did not give the NOC, but no action
was taken against them, and that in spite of the overtures made by the
petitioners for an amicable settlement, the respondent No. 2 and 3 never
took any steps to settle the matter, or even allow the writ petitioners to
sign the NOC for their own land. It is further submitted that the
petitioners had never demanded any compensation, but had only made
a request for withdrawal of the impugned resolution dated 24.04.2019,
by which they had been restrained from utilizing the village kutcha road
for transportation of their produce and for plying any vehicle thereon
hired or otherwise, on their behalf.
7.
Heard learned counsels for the parties.
8.
In the interest of justice and to try to work out an amicable
settlement between the parties, this Court by order dated 01.04.2022
had directed the petitioners, the respondent Village Dorbar and the
Block Development Officer (respondent No. 6) to appear personally
before this Court on 26.04.222. The parties accordingly appeared as
directed and were allowed to personally air their grievances and
difficulties. They were then instructed to sit together to try and resolve
the issue, but unfortunately though two attempts were made, no
settlement could be arrived at. As such, the matter proceeded for final
hearing.
9.
The dispute as it can be seen, stems from the issue of the
non-grant of NOC by the petitioners to the village for construction of a
motorable road over the existing kutcha road in Marwir Village. From
the facts as laid out, due to the situation and circumstances that had
prevailed, as narrated earlier in this judgment, the impugned resolution
came to be passed. A perusal of the impugned resolution shows that the
same is unconscionable, and has resulted in the violation of the
fundamental rights of the petitioners. This impugned resolution,
notwithstanding any provocation, cannot and should not, have been
passed by any authority, customary or otherwise. The translated
version of the said resolution is reproduced hereinbelow: “MARWIR VILLAGE DORBAR
MYRIAW SYIEMSHIP WEST KHASI HILLS DISTRICT
MEGHALAYA
Ref:________
The ________
Dated
Marwir,
The Marwir Village Dorbar which was held on the 24.4.2019
has arrived at the following resolutions:
Marwir Village Dorbar has thoroughly discussed with the land
owners Shri. Thwen Marngar and Smti. Drian Lyngkhoi to sign the
NOC to construct the road from Twah Mashin to Twah Ram Kynshi
which will pass through the land of Shri. Thwen Marngar and Smti.
Drian Lyngkhoi who did not sign the NOC obtained from the scheme
…. to construct this road therefore the Marwir Village along with all
the villagers has lost all the benefits especially the agricultural
products, transportation and other works therefore the Marwir
Village Dorbar with one mind has unanimously resolved to forbid
Shri. Thwen Marngar and Smti. Drian Lyngkhoi to use any vehicle
for transportation of timber, charcoal and essential commodities and
to drive through this road which is within the boundary of the Marwir
Village. The Village Dorbar has also resolved to warn that any one
who carry or transport in their vehicle any timber, charcoal and
essential commodities which belong to Shri. Twnen Marngar and
Smti. Drian Lyngkhoi, the Marwir Village will not allow them to do
so. If any vehicle violates this order of the Marwir Village Dorbar,
they have to pay a fine of Rs. 5,000/- (Rupees Five Thousand) only
and to unload the goods from the vehicle and the Dorbar will take
action later. Therefore the Marwir Village Dorbar has decided to
inform the land owners so that they will know the resolutions of the
Village Dorbar that has been taken today that you cannot carry or
transport your belongings or goods since today as long as the Marwir
Village Dorbar cannot settle until the Dorbar has meet again.
Sd/Secretary
Marwir Village
Myriaw Syiemship
West Khasi Hills
10.
Sd/Headman
Marwir Village
Myriaw Syiemship
West Khasi Hills”
First, it is noted that the respondent Dorbar sought to
obtain an NOC from the petitioners, to part with a portion of their land
for construction of the said road, which no doubt would be for the
benefit of all, but however, the manner in which the same was gone
about, without showing any respect for private property, cannot be
condoned in any manner. Article 300-A of the Constitution provides
that ‘no person shall be deprived of his property say by authority of
law’ and every citizen is guaranteed this protection, apart from every
other authority such as a Village Dorbar, being bound in this aspect.
The respondent No. 1 Village Dorbar, is headed by the respondent No.
2 Headman, who is elected and empowered in accordance with
prevalent law, in this case, the Khasi Hills Autonomous District
(Appointment and Succession of Syiem, Deputy Syiem and Electors of
Myriaw Syiemship) Act, 2007. The Village Headman is regarded as a
customary head at the village level discharging customary duties, and
as has been observed by earlier judicial pronouncements of this Court,
this customary role has been recognized and has since been accorded
importance, prominence and even legal sanction by the Government in
the implementation of Government Schemes such as MGNREGS,
agricultural and welfare Schemes etc. In the context of the present case
however, on the basis of the Government Scheme for construction of
the road, sought to be executed by the Village Dorbar, the acquisition
of land from land owners by way of donation cannot be said to have
any legal sanction, or that the petitioners were under any customary
obligation to part with the same, which would have permitted the
respondent No.1 to pass such a resolution on not receiving the NOC.
11.
As observed earlier, the resolution dated 24.04.2019, is in
violation and in contravention of the petitioners’ fundamental rights, as
it has imposed restrictions on the movement of the petitioners, as also
preventing them from transporting their produce and essential
commodities which is manifestly illegal, discriminatory and at the
same time punitive which militates against and offends Articles-14, 19
and 21 of the Constitution of India. The resolution dated 24.04.2019
therefore being patently illegal and arbitrary, is accordingly quashed
and set aside.
12.
It is also further provided and ordered that the petitioners
shall not be prevented, restrained or impeded in any manner by the
respondents 1, 2 and 3, in the use the village road for any lawful
purpose such as for transport of their agricultural produce, essential
commodities and other goods, by headload, or by vehicle as the case
may be. It is also made clear that the petitioners shall also not be
prevented in any manner from availing of any available developmental
Schemes and assistance from Govt. agencies. Any coercive action
against the petitioners, such as social boycott or any other punitive
measure that may be adopted by the respondents No. 1, 2 and 3, shall
forthwith be reported to the District Administration, who shall take
appropriate action thereon.
13.
No doubt the respondent Village Dorbar in all fairness,
had appealed for the donation of land which was in the general interest
of the village community, but what is disturbing is the manner and
method adopted by the respondents No. 1, 2 and 3, to achieve the same.
In this backdrop therefore, looking into the entire facts and
circumstances of the case and that the writ petitioners are both senior
citizens, who should not have been put to such loss and agony, affecting
their right to life and livelihood, this Court deems it fit to impose a cost
of Rs. 25,000/- (Rupees Twenty-Five Thousand) only, on the
respondent No. 1, 2 and 3 which shall be made over to the writ
petitioners within a period of 4(four) weeks from the date a certified
copy of this order is handed over to them.
14.
However, in the interest of establishing peace and harmony
in the village, it is further directed that an Executive Magistrate of the
District Administration along with the Block Development Officer,
shall facilitate a meeting in the village itself, with the village
functionaries and the writ petitioners, at the earliest, to explain and
enlighten them as to their duties and functions which should be
exercised within legal parameters, in a lawful and just manner.
15.
With the above noted direction directions, the instant writ
petition is accordingly disposed of.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
14.09.2022
“V. Lyndem-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review