Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction)
Heard on
: 11.05.2017
Pronounced on : 29.05.2017
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Single Bench: HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI,
JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl. A. No.23 of 2015
Appellant
:
Thutob Namgyal Bhutia,
Aged about 30 years,
Son of S. T. Bhutia,
Resident of Old Mangan Bazar,
North Sikkim.
versus
Respondent
:
State of Sikkim
Appeal under Section 374(2) of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. B. R. Pradhan, Senior Advocate with Ms. Tshering Palmoo
Bhutia, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. Karma Thinlay Namgyal, Additional Public Prosecutor with
Mrs. Pollin Rai, Assistant Public Prosecutor for the StateRespondent.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
Aggrieved by the Judgment dated 27-06-2016 and the
Order on Sentence dated 28-06-2016, passed by the Learned
Sessions Judge, North Sikkim, at Mangan, in Sessions Trial Case
No.01 of 2015, State of Sikkim vs. Thutob Namgyal Bhutia,
convicting the Appellant under Section 498A of the Indian Penal
Crl.A. No.23 of 2016
Thutob Namgyal Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim
Code, 1860 (for short “IPC”), and sentencing him to undergo simple
imprisonment for one year and to pay a fine of Rs.5,000/- (Rupees
five thousand) only, with a default stipulation, the instant Appeal
assails both.
2.
Prosecution was launched on an FIR, Exhibit 35, filed on
10.10.2014, by the Victim wife against her husband, the Accused
(hereinafter the “Appellant”), informing that he was a habitual drug
abuser, had attempted to kill her thrice prior to the lodging of
Exhibit 35 and on 10-10-2014, at around 1100 hours, when she was
entering her bedroom, he opened the door and without cause
assaulted her, as he often did. It was thus unsafe for her and her
minor son to live with the Appellant and in the event of any
untoward incident, the Appellant should be held responsible.
Besides, he had also stolen money from her Account in the State
Bank of India, Mangan Branch, by forging her signature.
3.
On receipt of the information, Mangan P.S. Case
No.35/2014,
dated
10-10-2014,
was
registered
against
the
Appellant under Sections 498A/420 of the IPC and endorsed for
investigation. When investigation into the matter was nearing
completion, the Victim on 07-12-2014, jumped fatally off the RangRang Bringbong Suspension Bridge, allegedly due to harassment
meted out by the Appellant.
This resulted in Mangan P.S. U.D.
(Unnatural Death) Case No.15/2014, dated 07-12-2014 being
registered, under Section 174 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 (for short “Cr.P.C.”), which revealed a prima facie case against
the Appellant under Section 306 of the IPC. Investigations of both
Crl.A. No.23 of 2016
Thutob Namgyal Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim
the cases were amalgamated by the Investigating Officer (for short
“I.O.”) and on completion of investigation, a single Charge-Sheet
was
submitted
against
the
Appellant
under
Sections
306/498A/380/468/471 of the IPC.
4.
The Learned Trial Court after hearing the parties and
considering the materials on record framed Charge against the
Appellant under Sections 498A, 306, 379, 420, 468 and 471 of the
IPC.
On the Appellant entering a plea of “not guilty”, the trial
commenced, during which the Prosecution examined thirty-three
witnesses, including the I.O. of the case.
On consideration of the
entire evidence on record, the Learned Trial Court convicted the
Appellant under Section 498A of the IPC and sentenced him, as
enumerated hereinabove, while acquitting him of the other Charges
including the Charge under Section 306 IPC.
5.
Fervidly assailing the Judgment, Learned Senior Counsel
first raised the argument before this Court that investigation of FIR
No.35/2014 dated 10-10-2014 and FIR/UD No.15/2014 dated
07-12-2014,
ought
not
to
have
been
clubbed
together
in
contravention of the mandate of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973, which thereby caused prejudice to the Appellant. That, the
Charge under Section 498A of the IPC arose out of the former FIR,
while the Charge under Section 306 of the IPC arose from the FIR of
the UD case, consequently, the evidence collected for the purpose of
Section 306 of the IPC has been used for convicting the Appellant
under Section 498A of the IPC. On this count, reliance was placed
Crl.A. No.23 of 2016
Thutob Namgyal Bhutia
on Vijender vs. State of
vs.
State of Sikkim
Delhi : (1997) 6 SCC 171 and Heeralal and
Others vs. State of Rajasthan : 2017 SCC online SC 495 .
6.
It was next contended by the learned Senior Counsel
that the Charge framed under Section 498A of the IPC, was in
violation of the provisions of Section 211 to Section 213 of the
Cr.P.C, as the learned Trial Court besides using the term “cruelty”
failed to place the requisite information of the offence before the
Appellant thereby causing him prejudice. That, cruelty, torture and
harassment cannot be interpreted as being synonymous with
„quarrel‟, as the ambit of cruelty under Section 498A includes willful
conduct of such a nature as to drive a woman to suicide, which has
remained unproved herein. On this count the evidence of PW 24 and
PW 16 were discussed at length.
7.
The third point next canvassed by learned Senior
Counsel for the Appellant was that the Court ought to have been
circumspect in accepting the evidence of PW-10, the Victim‟s 10
year old child living as he was with his maternal grandparents and
therefore, amenable to tutoring. Support was drawn from the
decisions in K. Venkateshwarlu vs. State of Andhra Pradesh : 2012 8 SCC
73 and Hamza vs. Muhammed Kutty alias Mani: (2013) 11 SCC 150.
8.
Peripheral to the above arguments was the contention of
the Appellant that the Inquest report Exhibit-9 remained unproved
by the Prosecution, the mandate of law having been overlooked.
That, the Post Mortem Report Exhibit-34, had also met the same
fate, as the Medical Officer who prepared it remained unexamined
Crl.A. No.23 of 2016
Thutob Namgyal Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim
and the document was exhibited only by the I.O. That, lacking in
evidence against the Appellant, he deserves an acquittal.
9.
Repelling the first argument, Learned Additional Public
Prosecutor contended that as the I.O. by investigation found that
the death of the Victim was due to the constant mental and physical
torture meted out by the Appellant and formed the chain of events
leading to her suicide, hence the incorporation of both the
investigations in one single Charge-Sheet. Relying on Mohan Baitha
and Others vs. State of Bihar and Another : (2001) 4 SCC 350, it was
canvassed that under Section 220 of the Cr.P.C. more than one
offence committed by the same person could be taken up at one
trial, if they can be held to be in a series of acts so as to form the
same transaction. That, this was applicable in the circumstances of
the case at hand.
10.
Countering the second contention, the learned Additional
Public Prosecutor urged that there was no violation of the provisions
of Section 211 to Section 213 of the Cr.P.C. and in any event, the
omission, if any, cannot be said to have caused any prejudice to the
Appellant. Attention on this aspect was drawn to the provisions of
Section 215 and Section 464 of the Cr.P.C. Reliance was also placed
on the decisions of the Hon‟ble Apex Court in K. Prema S. Rao and
Another vs. Yadla Srinivasa Rao and Others : (2003) 1 SCC 217, Dinesh
Seth vs. State of NCT of Delhi : (2008) 14 SCC 94 and Narwinder Singh
vs. State of Punjab : (2011) 2 SCC 47, wherein it was, inter alia, held
that it is to be gauged whether the accused had fair trial, knew what
he was being tried for and the main facts sought to be established
Crl.A. No.23 of 2016
Thutob Namgyal Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim
against him explained to him fairly, giving him a chance of defence.
If all the aforesaid elements existed, no prejudice is shown,
whatever the irregularities. It was urged that when suicide was
preceded by cruelty, as contemplated in Section 498A, within a
period of seven years of marriage, a presumption could be drawn
under Section 113A of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, that the
husband of the Victim or his relations had abetted the suicide. It
was urged that “intention” differentiates the two Sections viz; 306
and 498A IPC. That, the evidence of PW 1 to PW 4 and PW 9 to PW
11, PW 14 to PW 16 and PW 24 establish assault on the deceased
prior to lodging of Exhibit 35, thereby, leading to the conclusion that
the Appellant meted out cruelty.
11.
On the argument of the child witness‟s susceptibility, it
was urged that PW 10 had categorically given details of assault by
the Appellant on the deceased in Siliguri, corroborating the stand
taken by his grandparents and his evidence being consistent
throughout could not be doubted.
12.
Meeting
the
argument
on
Exhibit
9,
the
State-
Respondent contended that PW-13, being a witness to the Inquest,
conducted after the body was recovered on the bank of the river
Teesta has proved the contents of Exhibit 9, apart from the evidence
of PW 31. Exhibit 34, the Post Mortem Report has been proved by
PW31, the I.O., the document having been exhibited without any
objection from the Appellant which therefore may be read as
substantive evidence. That, as the Judgment of the learned Trial
Crl.A. No.23 of 2016
vs.
Thutob Namgyal Bhutia
State of Sikkim
Court is based on the evidence furnished before it, no interference
thereof is warranted.
13.
The opposing arguments advanced by learned Counsel
were heard at length and given careful consideration. I have also
carefully examined the evidence and documents on record and
perused the impugned Judgment and Order on Sentence.
14.
What arises for determination by this Court is whether
the evidence on record suffices to sustain the conviction of the
Appellant under Section 498A of the IPC?
15.
The
facts
do
not
need
reiteration,
suffice
it
to
recapitulate that as per the Prosecution, the Appellant and the
Victim were married in the month of December 2007. Alleging
frequent assaults and three attempts by the Appellant to kill her, the
Victim lodged Exhibit 35 on 10.10.2014. On 7.12.2014, almost two
months thereafter, she took her own life by jumping off a bridge
leading
to
registration
of
the
FIR
for
an
unnatural
death.
Consequently, investigation of the two cases were taken up
simultaneously and one Charge-Sheet submitted for both FIR‟s, as
already reflected hereinabove.
16.
Addressing
the
first
argument
pertaining
to
amalgamation of both FIRs and submission of one common ChargeSheet by the I.O., the first offence arose in the month of October
2014, while the second one pertained to an incident in the month of
December 2014. These appear to be completely unrelated incidents,
Crl.A. No.23 of 2016
Thutob Namgyal Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim
inasmuch as no evidence has been furnished to establish that the
Victim‟s suicide was the culmination of the alleged assaults by the
appellant or that assaults continued after the filing of Exhibit 35 and
could therefore be said to comprise of the same transaction. That,
having been said, in this context, we may refer to State of A.P. vs.
Cheemalapti Ganeswara Rao and Another : (1964) 3 SCR 297, wherein
the Hon‟ble Apex Court, inter alia, on the question of “same
transaction” observed thus :
“10. Whether a transaction can be regarded as the same
would necessarily depend upon the particular facts of each
case and it seems to us to be a difficult task to undertake a
definition of that which the Legislature has deliberately left
undefined. We have not come across a single decision of any
Court which the Legislature has embarked upon the difficult
task of defining the expression. But it is generally thought
that where there is proximity of time or place or unity of
purpose and design or continuity of action in respect of a
series of acts, it may be possible to infer that they form part
of the same transaction. It is, however, not necessary that
every one of these elements should co-exist for a transaction
to be regarded as the same.”
Further, it was held that:
“Where, however, several offences are alleged to have been
committed by several accused persons it may be more
reasonable to follow the normal rule of separate trials. But
here, again, if those offences are alleged not be wholly
unconnected but as forming part of the same transaction the
only consideration that will justify separate trials would be
the embarrassment or difficulty caused to the accused
persons in defending themselves.”
(Emphasis supplied)
17.
In State of Bombay vs. S. L. Apte : (1961) 3 SCR 107
wherein it was observed that;
“In the present case, applying the test laid down by
this Court, the two conspiracies are not the same offence:
the Jupiter conspiracy came to an end when its funds were
misappropriated. The Empire conspiracy as hatched
subsequently, though its object had an intimate connection
with the Jupiter in that the fraud of the Empire was
conceived and executed to cover up the fraud of the Jupiter.
The two conspiracies are distinct offences. It cannot even be
said that some of the ingredients of both the conspiracies
are the same. The facts constituting the Jupiter conspiracy
are not the ingredients of the offence of the Empire
conspiracy, but only afford a motive for the latter offence.
Motive is not an ingredient of an offence. The proof of
motive helps a Court in coming to a correct conclusion when
there is no direct evidence. Where there is direct offence for
Crl.A. No.23 of 2016
Thutob Namgyal Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim
implicating an accused in an offence, the absence of proof of
motive is not material. The ingredients of both the offences
are totally different and they do not form the same offence
within the meaning of Art.20(2) of the Constitution and,
therefore, that Article has no relevance to the present case.”
18.
It thus emerges that in order to bring a case under
Section 220 of the IPC, the first element that is to be established is
that there must be one series of acts, which would imply that the
acts are connected together. There must be a continuous thread of a
common purpose through the acts, as also proof of same intention,
knowledge or community of purpose. The argument of learned
Additional Public Prosecutor stating that the incident of 7.12.2014
was the result of a chain of events from 10.10.2014, cannot be
countenanced in the absence of any evidence to establish the said
allegation. Hence, it was erroneous on the part of the I.O. to have
taken up the investigation of the aforesaid FIR‟s together and
submitted a common Charge-Sheet without sufficient proof of unity
of purpose, design or continuity of action as extracted above.
19.
Dealing with the argument that the Charge framed
under Section 498A of the IPC is in violation of Sections 211 to 213
of the Cr.P.C.
Section 211 of the Cr.P.C. deals with contents of
Charge. Section 212 of the Cr.P.C. is with regard to particulars as
of time, place and person and Section 213 of the Cr.P.C. lays down
“When manner of committing offence must be stated”. The Charge
against the accused under Section 498A of the IPC reads as follows;
“Firstly: ― That you in between the tenure of year
2008 till the date of the incident i.e., 2014 you subjected
Smt. Penzy Lepcha your wife to cruelty to wit a wilful
conduct which was of such a nature as it likely to drive her
to commit suicide or to cause grave injury or danger to life,
limb or health (whether mental or physical) to her and you
thereby committed an offence punishable under Section
Crl.A. No.23 of 2016
Thutob Namgyal Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim
498A of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 which is within my
cognizance.”
20.
In the first instance, it would do well to point out that
when the Charge provides the words “to wit” the terms means
“namely” or “that is to say”. In such a situation, the Learned Trial
Court is required to explain the specific act of the Appellant,
inasmuch as after the words “to wit …..”, the Court could have
inserted the precise acts comprising cruelty. However, although the
Learned Trial Court has failed to give the details, nevertheless,
Section 215 comes to its aid, as it provides that no error in stating
either the offence or the particulars, required to be stated in the
Charge and no omission to state the offence or those particulars
shall be regarded at any stage of the case as material, unless the
accused was in fact misled by such error or omission and it has
occasioned a failure of justice. Apart from Section 215 of the
Cr.P.C., Section 464 of the Cr.P.C. also mandates that no finding
sentence or order by a Court of competent jurisdiction shall be
deemed invalid merely on the ground that no charge was framed or
on the ground of any error, omission or irregularity in the charge
including any misjoinder of charge, unless, in the opinion of the
Court of appeal, confirmation or revision, a failure of justice has in
fact been occasioned thereby. Besides, the aforesaid two Sections,
Section 216 of the Cr.P.C. clothes the Court with powers to alter or
add to any charge at any time before judgment is pronounced. It is
not disputed that the Appellant had a counsel throughout trial. Thus,
if he so desired he could have brought the shortcomings to the
notice of the learned Trial Court, which could have taken necessary
Crl.A. No.23 of 2016
Thutob Namgyal Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim
steps but no such steps were initiated. Nevertheless, despite the
alleged shortcomings, on going through the cross-examination of
the Prosecution Witness conducted by the learned Counsel for the
Appellant before the learned Trial Court, it is evident that the
Appellant was indeed aware of the Charge required to be met under
Section 498A of the IPC, as revealed by the gruelling crossexamination that witnesses were subjected to on this count,
therefore, revealing that no failure of justice has occasioned.
21.
Now
addressing
the
argument
pertaining
to
non-
reliability of the evidence of the minor witness PW 10, the records
reveal that the learned Trial Court had examined the witness as
required under Section 118 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, to test
his competence to depose. According to the witness, on the evening
of 6th (month not mentioned), his father had assaulted his mother
with a mobile handset on her forehead. His statement is falsified by
that of PW 30, who in her evidence has revealed that when the
Victim and PW 10 met her in her room, she noticed a bump on the
Victim‟s forehead. On inquiry as to its cause, the Victim replied that
she had had a verbal altercation with the Accused on the previous
evening, who in a fit of rage had thrown the mobile phone on the
window, which hit the grille, reversed back and hit her on the
forehead. Further, PW 10 alike PW 9, his grandmother, and PW 11,
his grandfather, has stated that they had all gone to a hotel in
Siliguri, where the Victim had a quarrel with the Appellant and the
Appellant assaulted her. This evidence cannot be relied on by this
Court for the fact that none of the three witnesses have specified
Crl.A. No.23 of 2016
Thutob Namgyal Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim
the body part on which the Victim had been assaulted, nor had they
seen the telltale signs of the assault. No complaint to any police
station or for that matter no documents of medical examination or
treatment were furnished as proof. Even assuming that because it
was a matter between the Appellant and the Victim, no further steps
were taken, the three witnesses ought to have been able to
enlighten the Court as to the nature of injury received by the Victim
on account of the Appellant‟s assault. Thus, this evidence appears to
have been concocted between PW 9, PW 10 and PW 11. Reverting
back to the evidence of PW 10, that on 5th (month not mentioned),
his father assaulted his mother on her hand and both her thighs
with the scabbard of a “Bamphok” (Machete). However, if we are to
look at his statement under Section 164 Cr.P.C., only for the
purposes of corroboration, he has stated that the assault was with a
“Bamphok” and not a Scabbard besides bereft of date. Also, no
mention of the Siliguri incident finds place in his 164 Cr.P.C.
Statement. Therefore, I am constrained to observe that the child,
living as he was with the grandparents, has been subjected to
tutoring and consequently, no weight can be attached to his
evidence.
22.
Coming to the question of Inquest Report, Exhibit 9, we
may examine the provision of Section 174 of the Cr.P.C. which
requires that, when the Officer in charge of a police station or some
other police officer so empowered receives information that a person
committed suicide or has died under circumstances raising a
reasonable suspicion that some other person has committed an
Crl.A. No.23 of 2016
Thutob Namgyal Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim
offence, he shall give intimation thereof immediately to the nearest
Executive Magistrate empowered to hold inquest and shall proceed
to the place where the body of such deceased is, and there, in the
presence
of
two
or
more
respectable
inhabitants
of
the
neighbourhood make an investigation and draw up a report of the
apparent cause of death, describing the wounds, fractures, etc.,
found on the body. The report is to be signed by the police officer
and other persons who concur and shall be forwarded forthwith to
the District Magistrate or Sub-Divisional Magistrate. In the case at
hand, the distance from the Police Station to the place of occurrence
is 30 kms. approximately. If such be the case, then the witnesses
are said to be Thutob Namgyal Bhutia, the Appellant himself and
one Rinzing Namgyal (PW 13), both from Mangan and evidently not
from the immediate vicinity. Therefore, the above requirement of
Law has been circumvented, apart from which P.W.13 has stated
that he was unaware of the contents of Exhibit 9.
Although the
evidence of P.W.31 indicates that she conducted the inquest in the
presence of witnesses, in the absence of compliance of the mandate
of Law, it cannot be said that the inquest was proved.
23.
An argument was raised with regard to the Post-Mortem
Report, not being proved, however, in view of the fact that the
Appellant has already been acquitted under Section 306 of the IPC,
no
further
discussions
need
ensue
on
this
point.
Apart from which the Magisterial Report, Exhibit 41, rather
haphazardly dated 05-2-2014 states that, “in observing the sequence
of event (sic) and incident and my personal presence during the inquest it
Crl.A. No.23 of 2016
Thutob Namgyal Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim
appears to be a case of suicide by jumping off the bridge and do not
appear to be any foul play in the death of the lady (sic).”
24.
Coming to the allegation that the evidence collected
under Section 306 was utilized in convicting the Appellant under
Section 498A of the IPC, we may briefly refer to these provisions.
Section 306 of the IPC refers to abetment of suicide and the
Prosecution in order to establish an offence thereof has to prove
beyond reasonable doubt that the deceased committed suicide and
the accused abetted the commission of the act. Section 498A deals
with cruelty towards a woman by her husband or his relatives. The
provisions of Section 498 A are extracted herein below for
convenience;
“498A. Husband or relative of husband of a woman
subjecting her to cruelty.—Whoever, being the
husband or the relative of the husband of a woman,
subjects such woman to cruelty shall be punished
with imprisonment for a term which may extend to
three years and shall also be liable to fine.
Explanation.—For the purpose of this section,
"cruelty" means—
(a) any wilful conduct which is of such a nature as is
likely to drive the woman to commit suicide or to
cause grave injury or danger to life, limb or health
(whether mental or physical) of the woman; or
(b) harassment of the woman where such
harassment is with a view to coercing her or any
person related to her to meet any unlawful demand
for any property or valuable security or is on account
of failure by her or any person related to her to meet
such demand.”
25.
There is no allegation of unlawful demand for property,
therefore,
we
are
concerned
with
Cruelty
as
dealt
with
in
explanation (a) of the Section viz; (i) to drive the woman to commit
suicide (ii) to cause grave injury (iii) danger to life, limb or health
both mental and physical. A close scrutiny of the evidence of the
Crl.A. No.23 of 2016
Thutob Namgyal Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim
witnesses relied on to establish Cruelty merely indicates that the
Victim and appellant were prone to frequent quarrelling. The Black‟s
Law Dictionary, 10th edition defines “Quarrel” as “An altercation or angry
dispute; an exchange of recriminations, taunts, threats, or accusations between
two persons.”
Thus, when it is a verbal duel between the parties and
not merely from the side of the Appellant, it cannot be said to be
cruelty as the Victim was undoubtedly an equal opponent. PW 16,
the Doctor, who examined the Victim on 10.10.2014, the date on
which Exhibit 35 was lodged, found a mild swelling on the left index
finger and superficial injuries on the right side of the neck and left
wrist. The injury was graded as “Simple”. PW 24, another Doctor,
examined the Victim on 28.11.2014 having been brought with
alleged history of physical assault with a serving spoon on her
forehead but this assault was by one Pema Wangyal and not
attributed to the Appellant. In the face of evidence of only one
alleged physical assault (the second assailant not having been
established), which was found to be simple and in the absence of
any evidence of continuous physical assault on the Victim by the
Appellant, the finding of the learned Trial Court under Section 498A
of the IPC defies logic. Besides, the mere fact that a married woman
commits suicide within a period of seven years of her marriage
would not automatically attract the provisions of Section 113A of the
Evidence Act, as the legislative mandate is that where a woman
commits suicide within seven years of her marriage, it must be
proved that her husband or any of his relatives had subjected her to
cruelty. Only on such attendant circumstances can the presumption
be drawn for an offence under Section 498A of the IPC to be
Crl.A. No.23 of 2016
Thutob Namgyal Bhutia
vs.
State of Sikkim
attracted. Thus, the evidence on record has failed to meet the
requirements for an offence under Section 498A of the IPC.
26.
Abetment as reflected in Section 306 of the IPC would
undoubtedly have to be understood in terms of the definition as
given in Section 107 of the IPC inasmuch as firstly the accused must
instigate any person to do that thing, secondly there must be
cooperation of one or more persons in any conspiracy for the doing
of the thing, pursuant to which an act or illegal omission takes place
and thirdly intentionally aids by any act or illegal omission the doing
of that thing. It is true that Section 306 of the IPC does not include
the above definitions but it is also clear that the suicide should have
been committed in consequence of the abetment, hence the
requirement for explaining what abetment comprises of. Thus, when
the learned Trial Court did not find the Appellant guilty of any
instigation or of commission or omission of illegal act to drive the
Victim to suicide, there is no basis for the Trial Court to reach the
finding of cruelty under Section 498A.
27.
In conclusion, on consideration of the entire gamut of
facts and circumstances, no evidence whatsoever emanates from
the witnesses to point to the fact of cruelty by the Appellant as
envisaged under Section 498A of the IPC. Accordingly, I am of the
considered opinion that the finding of the learned Trial Court
deserves to be and is accordingly set aside.
28.
Appeal allowed.
Crl.A. No.23 of 2016
Thutob Namgyal Bhutia
29.
vs.
State of Sikkim
The Appellant is acquitted of the Charge under Section
498A of the IPC and discharged from his Bail Bonds.
30.
Fine, if any, deposited by the Appellant in terms of the
impugned Order on Sentence, be reimbursed to him.
31.
Copy of this Judgment be forwarded to the Learned
Court below for information and compliance.
32.
Records of the Learned Trial Court be remitted forthwith.
Sd/-
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
29-05-2017
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds/bp
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review