Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:25363
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE VIJU ABRAHAM
WEDNESDAY, THE 19TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 28TH PHALGUNA, 1946
WP(C) NO. 11492 OF 2022
PETITIONERS:
THOMAS MATHEW
AGED 72 YEARS
S/O.N.L.THOMAS, NELLUVELIL HOUSE, NADAKKAL P.O.,
ERATTUPETTA, KOTTAYAM DISTRICT, PIN-686 122
MARIAMMA MATHEW
AGED 57 YEARS
W/O. THOMAS MATHEW, NELLUVELIL HOUSE, NADAKKAL P.O.,
ERATTUPETTA, KOTTAYAM DISTRICT, PIN-686 122
PRADEEP JOSEPH,
AGED 41 YEARS
S/O. JOSEPH P.V., VADAKKEPUTHENPURAYIL HOUSE, NADAKKAL
P.O., ERATTUPETTA, KOTTAYAM DISTRICT,PIN-686 122
BY ADVS.
ANEESH JAMES
ELIZEBATH GEORGE
RAJEE P MATHEWS
RESPONDENTS:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT,
GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695 001
THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR,
KOZHIKODE CIVIL STATION, ERANHIPALAM, KOZHIKODE-673 020
THE SPECIAL TAHSILDAR (LAND ACQUISITION),
KOYILANDY, KOZHIKODE-673 305
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
-2-
2025:KER:25363
THE KERALA STATE INDUSTRIES DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION,
TC 11/266, KESTON ROAD, KOWDIAR, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM695 003, REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR
SRI. K.P. JAYACHANDRAN, ADDL ADVOCATE GENERAL
S.RENJITH, SPECIAL GOVT.PLEADER TO AG
BY ADV P.U.SHAILAJAN
BY GP- RIYAL DEVASSY
SC – P.U. SHAILAJAM
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
ON 19.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
-3-
2025:KER:25363
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 19th day of March, 2025
Above writ petition is filed seeking to quash Ext.P16 series of
proceedings and Ext.P17 series of awards and for a consequential
direction to respondents 2 and 3 to pass a fresh award as per the
provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter referred to
as the ‘Act, 1894’) in respect of the properties of the petitioners
acquired by the 1st respondent strictly in accordance with the
findings of this Court in Exts.P6, P12 and P13 judgments.
2.
Brief facts necessary for the disposal of the writ petition
are as follows:Petitioners 1 and 2 are husband and wife and the 3 rd petitioner is the
nephew of the 1st petitioner, and the petitioners jointly own rubber
plantation known as manimala estate in Kozhikode District. An
extent of 46.5944 hectares of land out of the said rubber plantation
was acquired by the State Government under the requisition of the
4th respondent Kerala State Industrial Development Corporation for
the purpose of establishing a coconut industrial park. Out of the land
acquired 0.1740 hectare was owned by the 1 st petitioner, 34.2071
hectares by the 2nd petitioner and 12.2133 hectares by the 3 rd
petitioner. The land was acquired invoking the emergency provision
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
-4-
2025:KER:25363
under Section 17(4) of the Act, 1894 and included in the ‘Fast Track
Project’.
3.
A District level purchase committee was constituted for a
negotiated purchase and after several rounds of discussion the
amount was negotiated and finalised for Rs.10,750/- per cent along
with value of improvements in the property, on condition that the
compensation amount will be paid within a period of three months.
The
District
level
purchase
committee
agreed
to
provide
compensation at the rate of Rs.10,750/- per cent for land and
compensation for improvement, and Ext.P1 Government order was
issued and the compensation was agreed to be fixed on the basis of
Ext.P1 Government order. It was also approved by the Government
as per decision dated 07.07.2011. On the basis of the same
petitioners agreed to hand over advance possession of the land to
the respondents on payment of 80% of the compensation. Later land
was taken over on 15.02.2012 and an amount of Rs.9,90,15,986/was disbursed to the petitioners on 16.02.2012 claiming to be 80%
of the compensation amount. On receipt of the said amount
petitioners realized that the fixation of the amount was not in
accordance with Ext.P1 Government order and as agreed between
the parties, and the compensation paid was considerably less and
the petitioners informed the authorities that they are not willing to
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
-5-
2025:KER:25363
give away the land on negotiated purchase and that the land should
be acquired as per the provisions of the Act, 1894. While so,
petitioners were served with Ext.P2 series of notices intimating that
the 2nd respondent has given prior approval for passing of award with
respect to acquisition of petitioners’ properties and directing the
petitioners
to
produce
necessary
document
before
the
3 rd
respondent. Since the compensation amount mentioned in Ext.P2
series was less than one approved as per the proceedings dated
29.05.2013 of the 2nd respondent, petitioners obtained copy of
Ext.P3 award as per the provisions of the Right to Information Act,
and on finding that the awards passed were not as agreed between
the parties and that only the timber value alone was paid towards
value of improvements, filed Ext.P4 objection to Ext.P2 series of
recommendations objecting to the quantum of compensation fixed
by the Land Acquisition Officer and intimating the 3 rd respondent
that they are willing to receive the amount now awarded subject to
condition that a reference be preferred to the appropriate Court
under Section 18 of the Act, 1894 for determination of the correct
amount of compensation to be paid to the petitioners. Inspite of the
receipt of Ext.P4 series of objection no steps were taken by the 3 rd
respondent in this regard.
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
-6-
2025:KER:25363
4.
Thereupon, the matter was taken up before this Court in
WP(C) No.32066/2013 and this Court as per Ext.P5 judgment allowed
the writ petition directing respondents 1 and 3 to pass award under
Section 11(1) of the Act, 1894 and to pay the petitioners
compensation as approved in the proceedings No.B3-40436/2009
dated 29.05.2013. The respondents 1 to 3 and the 4 th respondent
challenged Ext.P5 judgment in WA Nos.1327/2016, 1326/2016 and
977/2016 respectively and the Division Bench of this Court allowed
the appeal by Ext.P6 judgment. But in Ext.P6 judgment this Court
has concluded that there was consensus ad idem between the
petitioners and the respondents for acquiring the properties of the
petitioners by paying land value at the rate of Rs.10,750/- per cent
and value of improvements in terms of Ext.P1 Government order.
Further as regards the quantum of compensation awarded in Ext.P3
series of awards this Court in Ext.P6 judgment found that value of
improvements was not calculated as provided for in Ext.P1
Government order, which was agreed between the parties. Therefore
the Division Bench directed to modify the award by calculating the
value of improvements in tune with what is provided in Ext.P1
Government order. Further taking note of the fact that there has
been considerable delay in paying compensation to the petitioners,
the Court further held that the petitioners are entitled for interest at
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
-7-
2025:KER:25363
the rate of 12% per annum on the unpaid part of the compensation
on the date of taking possession till the date of payment. An SLP was
preferred before the above Court which was ultimately dismissed as
withdrawn granting liberty to the appellants to file review application
as
per
Ext.P7
order
in
SLP
No.12459-60/17.
Thereafter
RP
No.580/2017 was filed which was dismissed and the SLP preferred by
the petitioners against the same was also dismissed as per Ext.P10.
On the basis of the same it is the contention of the petitioners that
findings in Ext.P6 judgment has become final and as per Ext.P6
judgment the 3rd respondent was bound to modify the award so far it
relates
to
compensation
for
improvement,
and
further
that
petitioners are entitled for interest at the rate of 12% per annum on
the unpaid amount of compensation from the date of taking
possession till the date of payment.
5.
Thereafter revised awards were passed as Ext.P10 series.
Petitioners contend that Ext.P10 series of awards were also not
prepared in accordance with the direction of this Court in Ext.P6
judgment. The value of improvements were not calculated in
accordance with the stipulations in Ext.P1. In the original Ext.P3
series of awards the value of timber alone was granted under the
head of value of improvement, but in Ext.P10 series of award the
value of timber already awarded was taken away and the petitioner
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
-8-
2025:KER:25363
was awarded annual produce value for the usufructs alone.
Petitioners would submit that annual produce value was not
calculated as per Ext.P1 Government order as the calculation was
made based on agriculture income tax return of the petitioners
alone. The said situation has resulted in considerable reduction in
the compensation awarded to the petitioners. Aggrieved by Ext.P10
series of awards petitioners approached this Court filing WP(C)
No.7930/2018 and the said writ petition was disposed of as per
Ext.P11 judgment directing the 2nd respondent to consider the
objection preferred by the petitioners and pass appropriate orders
thereon after hearing the petitioners. Without adverting to any of the
objections raised by the petitioners an order dated 21.03.2019 was
issued concluding that no interference is needed in Ext.P10 series of
awards.
The
said
order
was
again
challenged
in
WP(C)
No.10869/2019 and this Court was pleased to allow the said writ
petition as per Ext.P12 judgment. In Ext.P12 judgment it was found
that petitioners are entitled for both timber value as well as annual
produce value of the timber, and further directed that annual
produce value of the trees will have to be reworked after obtaining
necessary views from the competent authority. Ext.P12 judgment
was challenged by the 4th respondent filing WA No.935/2020 which
was dismissed by this Court as per Ext.P13. In Ext.P13 judgment the
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
-9-
2025:KER:25363
Division Bench also specifically affirmed the findings in Ext.P12
judgment that annual produce value is to be assessed on the basis
of actual valuation taken by a competent person and not on the
basis of the agriculture income tax return provided by the
petitioners. Though the same was challenged filing SLP (Civil)
No.1241/2021 before the Apex Court the same was dismissed as per
Ext.P14 order. Even thereafter no awards were passed as directed in
Exts.P12 and P13 judgments and only after filing of contempt of
Court case as CO(C) No.452/2021 Ext.P15 series of awards were
passed.
6.
Petitioners contended that Ext.P15 series of awards were
prepared in the most negligent and irresponsible manner with
glaring calculation errors. Thereupon a memo was filed by the
Special Government Pleader in the contempt of Court case
intimating that 2nd respondent has cancelled Ext.P15 series of
awards and that rectified award dated 06.08.2021 has been passed
by the 3rd respondent as evident from Ext.P16 series of proceedings.
Thereafter Ext.P17 series of rectified awards dated 06.08.2021 were
passed. The contention of the petitioners is that even Ext.P17 series
of awards were passed by the 3 rd respondent in contravention of the
express findings of this Court in Exts.P6, P12 and P13 judgments. It
is contended that this Court in Ext.P6 judgment has taken note of
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 10 -
2025:KER:25363
the
long
delay
on
the
part
of
the
respondents
in
paying
compensation to the petitioners and has expressly directed the
respondents to pay interest at the rate of 12% on the unpaid amount
of compensation from the date of taking possession to the actual
payment. But respondents 2 and 3 while issuing Ext.P16 series of
proceedings and Ext.P17 series of awards have restricted the
interest to 06.09.2013 stating that the petitioners have declined to
receive the amount despite service of notice under Section 12(2) of
the Act, 1894. It is contended that this restriction on payment of
interest only upto 06.09.2013 is in violation of the specific direction
issued by this Court in Ext.P6 judgment. Petitioners would contend
that no notice has been served on them as provided under Section
12(2) of the Act, 1894. Only communication issued to the petitioners
is Ext.P2 series of communication which is not one issued under
Section 12(1)(2) of the Act, 1894. Further it is contended that though
respondents 1 and 3 have averred in the counter affidavit and
additional counter affidavit filed in WP(C) No.32066/2013 regarding
the factum of deposit of compensation amount and revenue
deposits, this Court in Ext.P6 judgment, notwithstanding the deposit
of amount awarded as per Ext.P3 series of awards by the respondent
in revenue deposit directed payment of 12% interest from the date
of possession to the date of payment. Ext.P6 judgment has not been
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 11 -
2025:KER:25363
challenged till date and findings in Ext.P6 judgment with respect to
payment of interest has become final, and therefore the respondents
have no right to limit interest till the date of passing of Ext.P3 series
of awards.
7.
Petitioners denied the fact that the 3rd respondent has
made revenue deposit of the amount covered by Ext.P3 series of
awards. Further it is contended that the alleged notice under Section
12(2) of the Act to be issued in Form No.10(b) has not been
produced before this Court. Another contention raised by the
petitioners is that in Exts.P12 and P13 judgments this Court has
specifically found that the annual produce value shall not be
calculated on the basis of the agriculture income tax returns of the
petitioners, and that the respondents were bound to call for a report
from the expert body in this regard, and the Rubber Board has given
Ext.P18 report, but in Ext.P17 series of awards the annual produce
value was again calculated based on the agriculture income tax
return, completely ignoring Ext.P18 report. It is further contended
that while calculating annual produce value in Ext.P17 series of
awards value of ‘ottupal’ (scrap rubber) was not included by
respondents 2 and 3. Petitioners would contend that the price of the
scrap rubber contributes to a sizeable portion of the income earned
out from a rubber plantation, and on an average for every kilogram
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 12 -
2025:KER:25363
of rubber sheet produce by a rubber plantation 200 grams of scrap
rubber is also collected for sale. Yet another contention raised by the
petitioners is that in Ext.P12 judgment this Court after interpreting
clause 7.7 and clause 2(c) of Ext.P1 Government order has specifically
found that petitioners are entitled for annual produce value for the
last three years. Admittedly the property was taken possession on
15.02.2012 during the fag end of the financial year 2011-12. Hence it
is contended that the petitioners are entitled for compensation taking
into consideration annual produce value for the years 2011-12, 201011 and 2009-10. But in Ext.P17 series of awards the 3 rd respondent
has left out the year 2011-12 and took into consideration annual
produce value only for the years 2010-11, 2009-10 and 2008-09,
which the petitioners submit that has been done purposefully to
reduce the amount of compensation payable to the petitioners as the
price of rubber during 2011-12 was higher when compared to the
previous years. Ext.P19 is the report of the price of the rubber during
2011-12 issued by the Rubber Board, Kottayam. It is aggrieved by
these factual situation that the present writ petition has been filed.
8.
A statement has been filed by respondent No.4 KSIDC,
wherein it is contended that petitioners have already received the
amount duly entitled to them. The 4 th respondent has filed an
application for receiving the additional documents, wherein a copy of
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 13 -
2025:KER:25363
the
writ
petition
filed
by
the
petitioner
herein
as
WP(C)
No.7930/2018 is produced as Ext.R4(e) and the 4 th respondent
relying on Ext.P19 document dated 24.12.2013 produced in the said
writ petition, submits that notice under Section 12(2) of the Act,
1894 has already been issued to the petitioners on 24.12.2013 and
therefore, the contention of the petitioners that no notice under
Section 12(2) of the Act, 1894 was received by them is without any
basis. A detailed statement as well as counter affidavit has been
filed by the 4th respondent refuting the contentions in the writ
petition. It is also contended that whatever amount due has already
been duly paid as agreed upon and Ext.R4(c) report of the Rubber
Board cannot be accepted and they have filed Ext.R4(d) objection to
the same and the only reliable method for calculating the annual
produce value is considering the agriculture income tax return
submitted by the petitioners. On the basis of Ext.R3(a) notice issued
under Section 12(2) of the Act, 1894 the petitioners are not entitled
for any interest from 2013 onwards.
9.
A detailed counter affidavit has been filed by the 3 rd
respondent Tahsildar (LA), wherein it is admitted that this Court has
directed to give 12% interest per annum on the unpaid portion of the
compensation from the date of taking of possession till payment. But
it is contended that petitioners have purposefully refused to receive
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 14 -
2025:KER:25363
the compensation award amount which has been kept as revenue
deposit. The land value of Rs.10,750/- per cent was approved by the
DLPC and advance amount was paid and the possession was handed
over and the compensation for perennial crops and trees were
calculated based on annual produce value for the last three years. It
is admitted that yield from the rubber trees was finalised on the
basis of the agriculture income tax return which is admitted by the
parties before the Commercial Tax Officer, Perambra. The contention
of the petitioners that they have not been served with any notice
under Section 12(2) is denied and contended that the petitioners
were served with notice under Section 12(2) of the Act, 1894 on
24.12.2013, and the same was acknowledged by the petitioners as
is evident from Ext.R3(a), and the same was received by Thomas
Mathew as evident from Ext.R3(b) and Mariamma Mathew has
received the same as per Ext.R3(c) and the acknowledgment card of
the 3rd petitioner has not been received back from the postal
authorities. Thereupon the amount was decided to be kept in
revenue deposit as evident from Ext.R3(d). It is further submitted
that since notice was issued and thereafter the amount was
transferred to revenue deposit, petitioners are not eligible for further
interest from September/October 2013.
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 15 -
2025:KER:25363
10.
On the specific contention raised by the petitioners that
they have not received notice under Section 12(2) of the Act, 1894,
this Court has directed the 3rd respondent to file an affidavit
explaining the same. In the affidavit it is contended that Ext.P19
produced in Ext.R4(e) writ petition in WP(C) No.7930/2018 the notice
issued to the petitioners under Form 10(b) would reveal that they
have received the same on 24.12.2013. After fresh awards were
passed amounts were remitted to the petitioners’ account and also
acknowledged by the petitioners as evident by Exts.R3(e), R3(f) and
R3(g) respectively. In view of the above it is contended that the
petitioners are not entitled for interest for the period from 2012 to
2017.
11.
Petitioners have also produced Ext.P25 request submitted
by them dated 19.10.2015, wherein they have requested for release
of the amount due to them as shown in the notice dated 13.10.2013,
i.e. Ext.P2(a) which has already been deposited in the revenue
account, and contend that inspite of such request being made, the
amount has not been disbursed.
12.
I have heard the rival contentions on both sides.
13.
After hearing the contentions on both sides, the grievance
raised by the petitioners in respect of Ext.P16 series of proceedings
and Ext.P17 series of awards could be summarised as follows:-
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 16 -
2025:KER:25363
1. Ext.P17 series of awards were passed in violation of the
findings in Exts.P6, P12 and P13 judgments.
2. In Ext.P6 judgment taking note of the long delay on the part of
the respondents to pay compensation to the petitioners, the
Court has expressly directed the respondents to pay interest at
the rate of 12% on the unpaid amount of compensation from
the date of taking possession till actual payment, but while
issuing Ext.P16 series of proceedings and Ext.P17 series of
awards the 3rd respondent had restricted the interest upto
06.09.2013, the date of passing of Ext.P3 series of awards
contending that the petitioners have declined to receive the
amount despite service of notice under Section 12(2) of the
Act, 1894.
3. Petitioners were never served with any notice under Section
12(2) of the Act, 1894. The only communication which they
have received is Ext.P2 series of communication which cannot
be termed as a notice under Section 12(2) of the Act, 1894
which has to be issued in Form No.10(b) appended to the Land
Acquisition (Kerala) Rules, 1990.
4. In Exts.P12 and P13 judgments this Court has specifically found
that annual produce value should not be calculated on the
basis of agriculture income tax return of the petitioners and
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 17 -
2025:KER:25363
that the respondents are bound to call for report from the
expert body regarding the same, and though Ext.P18 report
was filed the same was not taken into consideration while
issuing Ext.P17 series of awards.
5. While calculating the annual produce value in Ext.P17 series of
awards, the value of ‘ottupal’ (scap rubber) was not included.
6. In Ext.P12 judgment this Court after interpreting clause 7.7 and
2(c) of Ext.P1 Government order has specifically found that
petitioners are entitled for annual produce value for the last
three years, and as the property was taken possession only on
15.02.2012 i.e. during the fag end of the financial year 201112, the petitioners are entitled for annual produce value for the
year 2011-12, 2010-11 and 2009-10, but the value was
calculated based on the annual produce value for the year
2011-10, 2009-10 and 2008-09, and the year 2011-12 has
been left out only for the reason that the value of the rubber
was high during the said period as evident from Ext.P19.
7. The calculations in Ext.P17(a) are also erroneous.
14.
Let me first consider whether the restriction of payment
of interest to 06.09.2013 in Ext.P17 series of awards is proper. In
Ext.P6 judgment this Court has specifically found that it is agreed
between the parties
that as regards the delay in payment of the
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 18 -
2025:KER:25363
unpaid compensation, interest will be paid at the rate of 12% per
annum from the date of taking possession till date of payment.
Paragraph 21 of Ext.P6 judgment reads as follows:“From the discussions as above, there cannot be any
doubt that there has been an agreement between the land
owners and the Acquisitioning Authority regarding voluntary
acquisition of land and passing of awards on consent. We
hold that there has been agreement between the land
owners
and
the
Acquisitioning
Authority
that
the
compensation for the land would be payable at the rate of
Rs.10,7850/- per cent and the compensation for the
improvements on the land would be paid in accordance with
G.O(Rt.) No.331/2004/RD dated 05.11.2004, and regarding
delayed payment of compensation, interest at the rate of
12% per annum would be paid on the unpaid part of the
compensation from the date of taking possession till date of
payment. We cannot agree with the reasoning given by the
learned single Judge to discard the agreement arrived at
between the parties.”
The said finding in Ext.P6 judgment has become final and has not
been challenged by any of the respondents therein. Yet another
contention raised by the respondents to deny interest till actual
disbursement of the amount is that the petitioners were issued with
Ext.P2 series of notices, Ext.R3(a) notice dated 27.12.2013 and
Ext.P19 notice dated 24.12.2013 produced along with Ext.R4(e) writ
petition filed by the petitioner herein as WP(C) No.7930/2018. The
stand of the learned Government Pleader in the counter affidavit is
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 19 -
2025:KER:25363
that Ext.R3(a) notice is a notice under Section 12(2) of the Act, 1894
which was duly received by the petitioners. Whereas the stand taken
by the 4th respondent is that petitioners were issued with Ext.P19
notice produced in WP(C) No.7930/2018, a copy of which is produced
as Ext.R4(e). Interestingly, in the affidavit filed by the 3 rd respondent
on 29.07.2023, it is claimed that Ext.P19 produced along with
Ext.R4(e) writ petition is the Form 10B notice issued to the
petitioners.
15.
Before considering the contentions raised based on
service of notice under Section 12(b) it is profitable to scan through
the relevant portions. Section 12 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894
provides when the award of the Collector could be treated as final.
Section 12(2) mandates that the Collector shall give immediate
notice of the award to such of the persons interested as are not
present personally or by the legal representatives when the award is
made. Section 12 is extracted below:“12. Award of Collector when to be final. - (1) Such
award shall be filed in the Collector’s office and shall, except
as hereinafter provided, be final and conclusive evidence, as
between the Collector and the persons interested, whether
they have respectively appeared before the Collector or not,
of the true area and value of the land, and the apportionment
of the compensation among the persons interested.
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 20 -
2025:KER:25363
(2) The Collector shall give immediate notice of his
award to such of the persons interested as are not present
personally or by their representatives when the award is
made.”
16.
Section 13 of the Land Acquisition Kerala Rules, 1990
mandates notice of award and payment, which provides that
immediately after the award is made the Land Acquisition Officer shall
issue notice of award in Form No.10(b) and the said notice shall be
served on the awardees as well as other persons interested in the land
in the manner prescribed in Section 45. Rule (2a) mandates that if an
awardee or an authorised agent have any protest on the amount of
compensation awarded they may receive the amount by recording
with the endorsement ‘received under protest’ on the counterfoil of the
cheque disbursing the amount, and Rule 13(2) mandates that in case
the awardees or their authorised agent fail to appear and accept the
award or fail to apply for a reference report under Section 18, the
amount due shall be paid to the Treasury as revenue deposit payable
to the person to whom it is respectively due. Rule 13 of the Land
Acquisition (Kerala) Rules, 1990 is extracted below:-
“13.Notice of award and payment. - (1) Immediately,
after the award is made, the Land Acquisition Officer shall
issue a notice of award in Form No.10(b). The said notice
shall be served on the awardees as well as other persons
interested in the land in the manner prescribed in Section
45.
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 21 -
2025:KER:25363
[(2a) If the awardees or their authorised agents have any
protest on the amount of compensation awarded, they may
receive the amount by recording with the endorsement
“Received under Protest” on the counterfoil of the cheque
disbursing the amount.]
(2) In case the awardees or their authorised agents fail to
appear and accept the award or fail to apply for a reference
to Court under Section 18, the amount due shall be paid
into the treasury as Revenue Deposit payable to the persons
to whom it is respectively due and vouched for in Form E. A
notice intimating the deposit of the amount into the
Treasury shall also be served on all the awardees and
interested persons in Form No.11.
(3) As soon as the payment or deposit of the award is
completed, a subsidiary statement in Form ‘B’ showing the
acceptance of award shall be sent to the Accountant
General in duplicate.
(4) Where an award has been made by a Court under
Section 25, a second award statement shall be prepared in
Form ‘C’ by the Land Acquisition Officer and a copy thereof
sent to the Accountant General in duplicate.
(5) The Accountant General will forward one copy each of
the completed A, B and C statements to the Board of
Revenue
which
will
be
filed
there
and
retained
permanently.”
So going by Rule 13 notice of award is to be given in Form No.10(b).
The appendix to the Rules, Land Acquisition (Kerala) Rules, 1990
Form No.10(b) in its appendix. Form No.10(b) as provided in Rule 13
is extracted below:“Form No.10(b)
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 22 -
2025:KER:25363
[See Rule 13]
NOTICE
The following award has been passed by the under
signed in the matter of the acquisition of the lands noted
below
and
situated
in
…………...District……………..Village……………..Taluk.
Survey
Extent Are. in
Amount
Persons to
Number and
Sq.M.
awarded Rs.
whom award
sub Division
is made
No.
You are hereby informed that you should appear either
in person or by an authorised agent before the undersigned
on…………………….. at……………………… to receive the amount
specified above, failing which the said sum of money will be
kept in Revenue Deposit and will bear no interest. If you have
any protest on the amount of compensation the words
“Received under Protest” shall be recorded on the counterfoil
of the cheque and make an application for reference to court
under section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act within the period
specified therein.]”
A perusal of the said Form reveals that it is an intimation to the
person in whose favour the award has been made to receive the
amount and in failure to receive the same, the amount will be kept in
revenue deposit and the same will not bear any interest. It is in the
said background that Ext.P2 series of notice, Ext.R3(a) and Ext.P19
notice in Ext.R4(e) is to be considered. Ext.P2 series of notices were
issued on 30.10.2013 and 22.10.2013 respectively. That is only an
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 23 -
2025:KER:25363
intimation to the petitioners that an award has been passed and
therefore petitioners should produce necessary documents in
support of their claim. To Ext.P2 series of notices after receiving
copies of Ext.P3 award, Ext.P4 series of reply was given by the
petitioners dated 31.10.2013, wherein they have intimated the
authorities that they are ready to accept the amount, if the same is
paid recording their objection and on condition that the matter will
be referred to the Court under Section 18 of the Act and that if such
an intimation is received in this regard they are ready to accept the
amount. A perusal of Ext.P2 series of notice reveal that the same is
not a notice as contemplated as per the Act and the Rules, or in the
notice form and contend specified in Form No.10(b).
17.
Now let me refer to Ext.R3(a) notice which is claimed by
the Government be the notice under Section 12(2). A perusal of
Ext.R3(a) reveals that that is a notice which is issued to the
petitioners intimating that an award has been passed in respect of
the acquired property. It is seen that the said notice has been
despatched on 27.12.2013. Ext.R3(d) is claimed to be the revenue
deposit receipt before the treasury as the petitioner has not
responded to Ext.R3(a) notice. Now let me refer to Exts.P19 referred
to in Ext.R4(e) which is claimed to be the notice under Section 10(b).
Ext.P19 notice referred to in Ext.R4(e) which is dated 24.12.2013
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 24 -
2025:KER:25363
shows that an award has been passed and as the amount was not
received on or before 13.10.2013, the amount has been deposited in
the revenue deposit and for the said amount the petitioners are not
entitled for interest. The notice what is contemplated as per Rule 13
which is in Form No.10(b) is a notice intimating the petitioners that
an award has been passed and the claimant shall receive the
amount on a particular date and on failure of receipt of the said
amount the amount will be kept in revenue deposit and the same
will not bear any interest. Ext.P2 series is only an intimation which is
admittedly not in the Form 10(2). In Ext.R3(a) it is stated that it is a
notice under Section 12(2) of the Act, 1894 which is an intimation
regarding the passing of the award, which is seen despatched on
27.12.2013. The said notice also does not contain the date on which
the petitioners have to appear for receipt of the amount, and
admittedly the said notice is also not in the form as provided as per
the Act and the Rules. The learned Government Pleader contends
that this is the notice issued to the petitioners under Section 12(2) of
the Act, 1894 which was despatched only on 27.12.2013. Ext.P19
notice in Ext.R4(e) which is relied on by the 4 th respondent to be
notice under Section 12(2) of the Act, 1894 is dated 24.12.2013,
wherein the petitioners were intimated that as they have not
received the amount, the amount has already been deposited in the
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 25 -
2025:KER:25363
revenue deposit. The date of Ext.P19 produced along with Ext.R4(e)
is 24.12.2013. If in fact the amount was deposited in the revenue
deposit and such intimation was given to the petitioners on
24.12.2013 there is no sanctity in issuing Ext.R3(a) notice which is
despatched only on 27.12.2013 to contend that it is a notice under
Section 12(2) of the Act. Therefore, I am of the view that even these
notices which are relied on by the respondents cannot be treated as
a notice under Section 12(2) of the Act, 1894 so as to deny the
petitioners their claim for interest.
18.
The Apex Court has considered the effect of issuance of
an improper notice in Commissioner of Sales Tax and Others v.
Subhash and Co. [(2003) 3 SCC 454] and held that issuance of a
notice as prescribed in the Rules constitutes a part of reasonable
opportunity of being heard. In view of the above, when no proper
notice as contemplated in Section 12(2) read with the Rules and the
Form appended to the Rules has not been issued it cannot be said
that a proper intimation regarding passing of award is issued to the
petitioner. The Apex Court in Food Corporation of India Ltd. v.
State of Punjab [(2001) 1 SCC 291] while considering the
question of validity of notice held that notice to the affected person
mandated in the Section is not an empty formality and it is meant
for a purpose, and that a vague and unreasoned notice will not
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 26 -
2025:KER:25363
provide reasonable opportunity to the party to file objection meeting
the reasons/grounds on which the action is proposed. The Punjab
and Haryana High Court in Gurcharan Singh v. Chairman, Delhi
improvement Trust [1995 AIR Punjab and Haryana 34] has
held that when the statute requires a notice to be given in a
particular form it should be in that form. The Karnataka High Court in
Mr.
S.N.
Sinha
v.
State
of
Karnataka,
by
Secretary
Department of Revenue and Others [2012 ILR Karnataka
448] has held that a notice to be valid same should be clear and
precise so as to give the party concerned adequate information of
the case he has to give.
19.
In the light of the above facts and circumstances and the
declaration of law as stated above, I am of the view that the notices
which are relied on by the respondents to be notice under Section
12(2) of the Act, 1894 cannot be accepted. In view of the above it is
to be held that no notice under Section 12(2) of the Act, 1894 was
served on the petitioners. The lack of proper notice coupled with the
direction in Ext.P6 judgment of the Division Bench, wherein specific
direction was issued to the respondent to pay interest at the rate of
12% on the unpaid amount of compensation from the date of taking
possession till actual payment, I am of the opinion that the
petitioners are entitled for 12% interest on the unpaid amount of
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 27 -
2025:KER:25363
compensation from the date of taking possession till actual payment
is made. The stand taken in Ext.P16(d) series of proceedings and
Ext.P17(a) series of awards denying the same is liable to be
interfered with.
20.
The next contention raised by the petitioners is regarding
calculation of the annual produce value based on the agriculture
income tax return of the petitioners as done in Ext.P17 series of
awards. In Ext.P12 judgment of this Court, this Court has specifically
considered the said issue and has categorically held that the
petitioners are entitled for the timber value as well as annual
produce value of the trees which has to be reworked after obtaining
necessary inputs from the competent authority. Paragraphs 11, 12
and 13 of Ext.P12 judgment reads as follows:“11. The term compensation has to be given normal
meaning. One would be entitled to timber value as well as
produce value as compensation in normal circumstances. In
the contract if nothing indicates as to the contrary, such a
compensation cannot be denied to the owner of the land. In
regard to rubber tree after the age of yield is over, one
would get timber value.
12. On interpretation of the agreement, this Court find as
per the Government order, that the petitioners are entitled
for both the timber value as well as the annual produce
value of the timber, o na conjoined reading of Clause 7.7
and Clause 2C in the Annexure II. In such circumstances,
the writ petition has to be allowed.
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 28 -
2025:KER:25363
13. The petitioners should be given the timber value as
originally calculated. The annual produce value of the trees
will have to be re-worked after obtaining necessary inputs
from the competent authority. It shall be done within a
period of two months. The compensation amount shall be
re-worked and paid within a further period of two months.
Accordingly, the impugned orders are set aside.”
Further in Ext.P13 judgment of the Division Bench which was filed
challenging Ext.P12 judgment the Division Bench has repelled the
challenge against the direction in Ext.P12 that the annual produce
value is to be assessed on the basis of actual valuation taken by the
competent person and not on the basis of the agriculture income tax
return provided by the writ petitioners. Paragraph 27 of the said
judgment reads as follows:“27. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that onece
the market value of the trees is taken in terms of clause 7.7,
then the produce value cannot be given. The learned single
Judge found that in terms of the provisions contained under
the Government order, the writ petitioners are entitled to get
the market value of the timber and annual produce value, to
which we agree absolutely. We are also of the firm opinion
that there is no illegality or other legal infirmities in the
matter of exercise of discretion by the learned single Judge.
Above all, the appellant has also questioned the direction
given by the learned single Judge that the annual produce
value is to be assessed on the basis of the actual valuation
taken by a competent person and not on the basis of the
agricultural
income
tax
return
provided
by
the
writ
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 29 -
2025:KER:25363
petitioners. We do not find any reason to interfere with the
said finding also, because it was done taking into account
the method prescribed under clause 2C of the order dated
05.11.2004 and not on the basis of the income tax return as
done by the awarding officer.”
21.
Though SLP was preferred against Ext.P13 judgment the
same was dismissed as per Ext.P14 order. After being conclusively
found by this Court in Exts.P12 and P13 and dismissal of the
challenge against Exts.P12 and P13 by the Apex Court as per
Ext.P14 order, the respondents are clearly in violation of the orders
of this Court while issuing Ext.P17 series of awards, wherein annual
product value has been calculated based on the agriculture income
tax return submitted by the petitioners. Therefore, I am of the view
that the said part of the award is also liable to be interfered with.
22.
The further contention of the petitioners that ‘ottupal’
(scrap rubber) was not included by respondents 2 and 3, while
calculating the annual produce value is to be considered next. It is a
common knowledge that ‘ottupal’ (scrap rubber) also contributes to
the sizeable portion of the income earned out of a rubber plantation.
Yet another contention of the petitioners that the annual produce
value for the year 2011-12, 2010-11 and 2009-10 was to be taken
into consideration for calculating the annual produce value is also
liable to be reconsidered by the respondents 2 and 3, especially
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 30 -
2025:KER:25363
taking into consideration the fact that the property was taken
possession only in the fag end of the financial year of 2011-12, i.e.
only on 15.02.2012. Therefore, the said aspect is liable to be
reconsidered by the 3rd respondent taking into consideration
Exts.P18 and P19 report submitted by the Rubber Board.
23.
A disturbing aspect to be noted in this case is that though
interest at the rate of 12% was awarded by the Division Bench of
this Court as per Ext.P6 judgment and the said order has become
final, the basis on which a different stand was taken overlooking the
direction of the Division Bench of this Court is not stated in Ext.P16
series of proceedings or in Ext.P17 series of awards. I have also
found that the notices under Section 12(2) claimed to have been
issued to the petitioners also cannot be accepted as a proper notice
in terms of the Act and Rules. Further it is confirmed in Exts.P12 and
P14 that the annual produce value is to be assessed on the basis of
actual valuation taken by a competent person and not on the basis
of the agriculture income tax return. Inspite of Exts.P12, P13 and P14
while issuing Ext.P17 series of awards the annual product value was
calculated based on the agriculture incomte tax return. The stand
taken in Ext.P16 series proceedings and Ext.P17 series of awards
overlooking the specific finding and direction by this Court and by
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 31 -
2025:KER:25363
the Apex Court is nothing but clear violation of the directions issued
by the Courts.
In the light of the above, I am inclined to dispose of the writ
petition as follows:1. Ext.P16(a) series of proceedings and Ext.P17(a) series of
awards are quashed.
2. There will be a direction to respondents 2 and 3 to pass fresh
awards strictly in accordance with the directions in Exts.P6, P12
and P13 judgment and the observation made in this judgment.
3. While passing the fresh award the value of ‘ottupal’ (scrap
rubber) shall also be taken into consideration for calculating
the annual produce value after obtaining necessary report in
this regard from the Rubber Board.
4. While reconsidering the annual produce value taking into
consideration the value of ‘ottupal’ (scrap rubber),
the
respondents 2 and 3 shall take into consideration Exts.P8 and
P19 reports of the Rubber Board and consider the claim of the
petitioners that the annual produce value for the year 2011-12,
2010-11 and 2009-10 has to be taken into consideration as the
property was taken possession from the petitioners only on
15.02.2012 i.e. during the fag end of the financial year 201112.
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 32 -
2025:KER:25363
5. The respondents 2 and 3 shall pay interest at the rate of 12%
per annum to the petitioners on the unpaid amount of
compensation
from
15.02.2012
i.e.
the
date
of
taking
possession of the petitioners’ property till actual payment.
6. A fresh award shall be passed in this regard within an outer
limit of four months from the date of receipt of a copy of this
judgment.
Sd/VIJU ABRAHAM
JUDGE
sbk/-
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 33 -
2025:KER:25363
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 11492/2022
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
A TRUE COPY OF GO(RT) NO.331/2004/RD DATED
05.11.2004
Exhibit P2A
A TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION DATED
30.10.2013 ISSUED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT TO
THE 1ST PETITIONER
Exhibit P2B
A TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION DATED
22.10.2013 ISSUED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT TO
THE 2ND PETITIONER
Exhibit P2C
A TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION DATED
22.10.2013 ISSUED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT
Exhibit P3A
A TRUE COPY OF THE AWARD ALLEGEDLY PASSED
IN RESPECT OF THE PROPERTY OF THE 1ST
PETITIONER IN THE YEAR 2013
Exhibit P3B
A TRUE COPY OF THE AWARD ALLEGEDLY PASSED
IN RESPECT OF THE PROPERTY OF THE 2ND
PETITIONER IN THE YEAR 2013
Exhibit P3C
A TRUE COPY OF THE AWARD ALLEGEDLY PASSED
IN RESPECT OF THE PROPERTY OF THE 3RD
PETITIONER IN THE YEAR 2013
Exhibit P4A
A TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION DATED
31.10.2013 SUBMITTED BY THE 1ST PETITIONER
BEFORE THE 3RD RESPONDENT
Exhibit P4B
A TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION DATED
31.10.2013 SUBMITTED BY THE 2ND PETITIONER
BEFORE THE 3RD RESPONDENT
Exhibit P4C
A TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION DATED
31.10.2013 SUBMITTED BY THE 3RD PETITIONER
BEFORE THE 3RD RESPONDENT
Exhibit P5
A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED
0710.2013 OF THIS HON'BLE COURT IN WPC
NO.32066 OF 2013
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 34 -
2025:KER:25363
Exhibit P6
A TRUE COPY OF THE COMMON JUDGMENT DATED
16.12.2016 IN WA NO.1327 OF 2016 AND WA
NO.977 OF 2016
Exhibit P7
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 04.05.2017
OF THIS HON'BLE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA IN
S.L.P.(C) NO.12459-60/17
Exhibit P8
A TRUE COPY OF THE COMMON ORDER DATED
05.01.2018 IN RP BO.580/2017 AND RP
NO.574/2017
Exhibit P9
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 17.05.2018
OF THE HON'BLE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA IN
SLP(C) NO.13914/2018
Exhibit P10A
A TRUE COPY OF THE REVISED AWARD DATED
21.02.2017 PASSED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT IN
RESPECT OF THE PROPERTY OF THE 1ST
PETITIONER
Exhibit P10B
A TRUE COPY OF THE REVISED AWARD DATED
21.02.2017 PASSED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT IN
RESPECT OF THE PROPERTY OF THE 2ND
PETITIONER
Exhibit P10C
A TRUE COPY OF THE REVISED AWARD DATED
21.02.2017 PASSED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT IN
RESPECT OF THE PROPERTY OF THE 3RD
PETITIONER
Exhibit P11
A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED
05.10.2018 OF THIS HON'BLE COURT IN WPC
NO.7930 OF 2019
Exhibit P12
A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED
11.03.2020 OF THIS HON'BLE COURT IN WPC
NO.10869 OF 2019
Exhibit P13
A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED
01.12.2020 OF THIS HON'BLE COURT IN WA
NO.935 OF 2020
Exhibit P14
A TUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 03.03.2021
OF THE HON'BLE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA IN
S.L.P(CIVIL) 1241 OF 2021
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 35 -
2025:KER:25363
Exhibit P15A
A TRUE COPY OF THE AWARD DATED 06.08.2021
PASSED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT IN RESPECT OF
THE PROPERTY OF THE 1ST PETITIONER
Exhibit P15B
A TRUE COPY OF THE AWARD DATED 06.08.2021
PASSED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT IN RESPECT OF
THE PROPERTY OF THE 2ND PETITIONER
Exhibit P15C
A TRUE COPY OF THE AWARD DATED 06.08.2021
PASSED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT IN RESPECT OF
THE PROPERTY OF THE 3RD PETITIONER
Exhibit P16A
A TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS
NO.DCKKD/9348/2017-B3(1) DATED 16.11.2021
OF THE 2ND RESPONDENT
Exhibit P16B
A TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS
NO.DCKKD/9348/2017-B3(2) DATED 16.11.2021
OF THE 2ND RESPONDENT
Exhibit P16C
A TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS
NO.DCKKD/9348/2017-B3(3) DATED 16.11.2021
OF THE 2ND RESPONDENT
Exhibit P17A
A TRUE COPY OF THE RECTIFIED AWARD DATED
06.08.2021 PASSED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT IN
RESPECT OF THE PROPERTY OF THE 1ST
PETITIONER
Exhibit P17B
A TRUE COPY OF THE RECTIFIED AWARD DATED
06.08.2021 PASSED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT IN
RESPECT OF THE PROPERTY OF THE 2ND
PETITIONER
Exhibit P17C
A TRUE COPY OF THE RECTIFIED AWARD DATED
06.08.2021 PASSED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT IN
RESPECT OF THE PROPERTY OF THE 2ND
PETITIONER
Exhibit P18
A TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION DATED
05.08.2021 ISSUED BY THE JOINT RUBBER
PRODUCTION COMMISSIONER RUBBER BOARD,
MINISTRY OF COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY,
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA TO THE 3RD RESPONDENT
Exhibit P19
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPORT DATED 07.01.2021
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 36 -
2025:KER:25363
FILED BY THE DIRECTOR, RUBBER RESEARCH
INSTITUTE OF INDIA, RUBBER BOARD, KOTTAYAM
BEFORE THIS HON'BLE COURT IN WPC
NO.10869/2019
Exhibit P20
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 09.02.2022
OF THIS HON'BLE COURT IN CONT.CASE (CIVIL)
NO.452 OF 2021
Exhibit P21A
CALCULATION STATEMENT SHOWING THE AMOUNTS
DUE TO THE 1ST PETITIONER
Exhibit P21B
CALCULATION STATEMENT SHOWING THE AMOUNTS
DUE TO THE 2ND PETITIONER
Exhibit P21C
CALCULATION STATEMENT SHOWING THE AMOUNTS
DUE TO THE 3RD PETITIONER
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT R3(a)
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE DATED 24.12.2013.
EXHIBIT R3(b)
TRUE COPY OF THE ACKNOWLEDGMENT CARD DATED
NIL SIGNED BY THOMAS MATHEW.
EXHIBIT R3(c)
TRUE COPY OF THE ACKNOWLEDGMENT CARD DATED
NIL SIGNED BY MARIAMMA MATHEW.
EXHIBIT R3(d)
TRUE COPY OF THE REVENUE DEPOSIT RECEIPT.
Exhibit R4(a)
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 14/7/2021 IN
CONTEMPT CASE (CIVIL) NO.452 OF 2021 IN
WPC NO.10869 OF 2019 OF THIS HON'BLE COURT
Exhibit R4(b)
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 9/2/2022
IN CON.CASE (C) NO.452/2021 OF THIS
HON'BLE COURT
Exhibit R4(c)
TRUE COPY OF THE REPORT DATED 7/1/2020
FILED BY THE DIRECTOR (RESEARCH) OF RUBBER
RESEARCH INSTITUTE OF INDIA, RUBBER BOARD,
KOTTAYAM BEFORE THIS HON'BLE COURT IN
I.A.NO.1/2019 IN WP (C) NO.10869/2019
Exhibit R4(d)
TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION DATED 25/1/2020
WP(C) No. 11492 of 2022
- 37 -
2025:KER:25363
FILED BY THE RESPONDENT NO.4 BEFORE THIS
HON'BLE COURT IN I.A.NO.1/2010 IN WPC NO.
10869/2019
Exhibit R4(e)
THE TRUE COPY OF THE W.P(C) 7930/2018
ALONG WITH EXHIBIT P19 WITHOUT THE OTHER
DOCUMENTS DT.28.2.2018
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P22
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMORANDUM OF WRIT
PETITION IN WP(C) NO. 32066 OF 2013 DATED
18-12-2013 (WITHOUT EXHIBITS)
Exhibit P23
TRUE COPY OF THE COUNTER AFFIDAVIT
(WITHOUT EXHIBITS) DATED 05-06-2014 FILED
BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT IN WP(C) NO. 32066
OF 2013
Exhibit P24
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY AFFIDAVIT (WITHOUT
EXHIBITS) DATED 29-07-2014 FILED BY THE
PETITIONERS TO THE COUNTER AFFIDAVIT FILED
BY THE RESPONDENTS 2 & 4 IN WP(C) NO.
32066 OF 2013
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit R4(f)
THE TRUE COPY OF THE CHALLAN RECEIPT WITH
NO.146 DATED 19.12.2013
EXHIBIT R3(e)
TRUE COPY OF THE ACKNOWLEDGEMENT RECEIPT
DATED 21.03.2017, EVIDENCING THE PAYMENT
OF RS.2,02,135/- TO THE 1ST PETITIONER.
EXHIBIT R3(f)
TRUE COPY OF THE ACKNOWLEDGEMENT RECEIPT
DATED 21.03.2017 EVIDENCING THE PAYMENT OF
RS. 2,59,17,847/- TO THE 2ND PETITIONER.
EXHIBIT R3(g)
TRUE COPY OF THE ACKNOWLEDGEMENT RECEIPT
DATED 21.03.2017 EVIDENCING THE PAYMENT OF
RS. 123570/- TO THE 3RD PETITIONER.
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P25
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 19-10-2015
SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONERS TO THE 2ND
RESPONDENT
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review