Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2016:SHC:21
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 26TH MARCH, 2016
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.47 of 2014
Petitioners
:
1.
Shri Thentook Bhutia,
2.
Shri Sonam Tshering Bhutia,
3.
Shri Samdup Tshering Bhutia,
4.
Shri Phigu Tshering Bhutia,
All Sons of Late Dorjee Tshering Bhutia,
R/o Simick-Lingzey,
P.O. Khamdong,
P.S. Singtam,
East Sikkim.
versus
Respondents
:
1.
Teesta Valley Power Transmission Limited,
2nd Floor, Mundra Bhawan,
Opposite Sona Motors,
Near Orbit Mall,
Sevoke Road,
Siliguri – 734 001.
2.
The Power and Energy Department,
Government of Sikkim,
through its Secretary,
Kazi Road,
Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
2016:SHC:21
WP(C) No.47 of 2014
Shri Thentook Bhutia and Others vs. Teesta Valley Power Transmission Limited and Others
3.
The District Collector,
East District,
District Administration,
Centre Sichey,
East Sikkim.
4.
Ministry of Power
through its Secretary,
Government of India,
Shram Shakti Bhawan,
New Delhi – 110 001.
Writ Petition under Article 226
of the Constitution of India
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Tamanna Chhetri and Ms.
Bindu Gurung, Advocates for the Petitioners.
Mr. Tarun Johri, Mr. Arun Kumar Sarkar, Mr. Abhijit Sarkar and
Mr. Shivadeep Roka, Advocates for Respondent No.1.
Mr. S. K. Chettri and Mrs. Pollin Rai, Assistant Government
Advocates for State-Respondents No.2 and 3.
Mrs. Sabina Chettri, Legal Counsel for Energy and Power
Department, Government of Sikkim, Respondent No.3.
Mr. Karma Thinlay Namgyal, Central Government Counsel with
Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Advocate for Respondent No.4.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The brief facts as they unfold are that the Respondent
No.1 is a Transmission Licensee under Section 14 of the Electricity
Act, 2003 (hereinafter “the Act”) conferred with powers under
2016:SHC:21
WP(C) No.47 of 2014
Shri Thentook Bhutia and Others vs. Teesta Valley Power Transmission Limited and Others
Section 164 of the Act for the purpose for placing posts and electric
lines, for transmission of electricity and is building a Dedicated
Transmission Line for laying down 400 KV D/C Teesta III Kishanganj
transmission line, passing through the States of Sikkim, West Bengal
and Bihar. The Petitioners being brothers live in Gangtok, East
Sikkim, but jointly own land measuring a total of 5.20 hectares with
a standing ‘kutcha’ house at Patuk Block, Khamdong, East Sikkim,
through which the route of the transmission lines pass. Overhead
power lines are to be strung across the land of the Petitioners where
High Tension towers have been constructed on either boundary of
their land thereby diminishing its value. Aggrieved by the act of the
Respondent No.1, the Petitioners have filed this Writ, the specific
prayers of the Petitioners being three-fold, i.e., (i) that either the
towers be removed from the existing sites to a portion of the
Petitioners’ land which will not destroy the utility of their entire
land as is the position now; or (ii) in the alternative, the Respondent
No.1 acquire their land at Rs.7,00,00,000/- (Rupees seven crores)
only, as valued; and (iii) the Respondent No.4 be directed to cancel
or withdraw the Licence issued to Respondent No.1 for undertaking
the works as per Order dated 29-04-2010.
2.
The Petitioners’ case as advanced by Learned Senior
Counsel is that in the process of the works of the Respondent No.1
for transmission of electricity the construction of the High Tension
2016:SHC:21
WP(C) No.47 of 2014
Shri Thentook Bhutia and Others vs. Teesta Valley Power Transmission Limited and Others
Electric Towers resulted in damage to a portion of the Petitioners’
land on one side for which admittedly compensation was paid by
the Respondent No.1. Now, stringing overhead power lines over the
land of the Petitioners without their consent, will have long term
detrimental health effects on the villagers and agriculture of the
area and has led to devaluation of the Petitioners’ land which had
then been assessed at Rs.7,00,00,000/- (Rupees seven crores) only.
Apart from having to discard plans for constructing an Eco-tourism
Resort the land is not being acquired by Pharmaceutical Companies,
being unfit on account of the electric transmission wires.
Admittedly, the towers so constructed are not on the land of the
Petitioners nor have the wires been strung across yet but once done
besides the aforesaid ill-effects the entire land of the Petitioners will
be rendered useless.
3.
That the Petitioner No.2 approached the Respondent
No.3 with their grievance as the Respondent No.1 had the option of
adopting an alternative route, however, Respondent No.3 failed to
issue any effective order for removal of the towers from the existing
site despite spot verification indicating problems for future
construction in the area. The matter was also taken up before the
High Court Lok Adalat but remained unsettled. It is expostulated
that the Respondent No.1 has not only violated the principles of
natural justice as no public hearing was conducted before
2016:SHC:21
WP(C) No.47 of 2014
Shri Thentook Bhutia and Others vs. Teesta Valley Power Transmission Limited and Others
construction of the towers but also violated their right to property,
apart from which they are liable under the Scheduled Castes and the
Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989, as no process
was adopted for obtaining tribal land.
4.
While resisting the case of the Petitioners, Learned
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 countered that none of the legal
rights of the Petitioners or their rights as owners of the land have
been effected as only overhead power lines are to be drawn over the
land of the Petitioners while for issuance of a mandamus there must
be an existing legal right and an infraction of such right, besides, as
is a well-settled legal principle, this Court cannot assess
compensation. The Respondent No.1 has undertaken works as per
the Order dated 29-04-2010 according approval under Section 164 of
the Act, in addition to Government approval under Section 68 of the
Act and are not subject to any consent or NOC from the Petitioners.
The apprehension that the stringing of electric lines is going to
adversely effect the health of the Petitioners is baseless and
unfounded so is the submission with regard to value of the land.
That carrying out works as per the Licence granted to the
Respondent No.1 does not require or include acquisition of any plot
of land. It is stated that where damage was caused to land owners by
installation of towers on their land compensation was awarded but
drawing of overhead power lines over the land of the Petitioners will
2016:SHC:21
WP(C) No.47 of 2014
Shri Thentook Bhutia and Others vs. Teesta Valley Power Transmission Limited and Others
not cause any damage to their property and thus does not entitle
them to any damages or compensation. That the question of realignment of the High Tension Transmission Lines does not arise as
alignment for erecting such towers is done after observing technoeconomical feasibility of the matter and appropriateness of the
route by experts in the field, keeping vertical and horizontal
clearance while stringing as required by the Act and does not render
it unsafe. It is contended that neither the application of mind for
choosing the route nor the rationality of the decision has been
challenged but the effect has been challenged as an afterthought.
That as on July, 2015, 96% of the work have been completed, the only
problem area now being the alignment corridor where the
Petitioners are the land owners where the work has been stalled.
That the Petitioners by their attitude were responsible for the
matter not being resolved before the District Magistrate, East
Sikkim.
It is clarified that before commencing work through the
village of the Petitioners, the Respondent No.1 wrote to the
concerned District Collectors and in August, 2013, to the Patuk Gram
Panchayat who issued an NOC and assured their cooperation.
5.
While relying on Annexure R2 of their documents which
was read in extenso by Leaned Counsel it was put forth that apart
from the details of route alignment and justification detailed
thereby they had also published Notifications on 17-09-2009 in 2
2016:SHC:21
WP(C) No.47 of 2014
Shri Thentook Bhutia and Others vs. Teesta Valley Power Transmission Limited and Others
(two) local Nepali vernacular newspapers in Sikkim, inter alia,
specifying that the route would run through Patuk.
Apart from
Sikkim, Notifications were also published in newspapers in West
Bengal and Bihar. It was also canvassed that bearing in mind the
principles of the provisions of Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act,
1894, a public notice in English was notified in the Gazette of India
on 24-10-2009 which reiterated the routes of the transmission lines.
No objections were received from any quarter.
That the towers
were constructed keeping in mind the public good with routes
specified before embarking on the project.
6.
That the Petitioners instead of approaching the District
Magistrate as contemplated under Section 16(4) of the Indian
Telegraph Act, 1885 (for short “Telegraph Act”), have approached
this Court, when a Writ does not lie. It is, therefore, prayed that this
Court relegate the matter to the appropriate forum under the Act
and no case being made out for interference by this Court, the Writ
Petition be dismissed.
7.
The State-Respondents No.2 and 3 in their joint
counter-affidavit have merely stated that the land of the Petitioners
is situated at Patuk Block and as such laying of transmission line
which was permitted by the Ministry of Power, Respondent No.4,
vide an Order dated 29-04-2010, is passing through the route given
2016:SHC:21
WP(C) No.47 of 2014
Shri Thentook Bhutia and Others vs. Teesta Valley Power Transmission Limited and Others
in the Gazette of India Notification for laying of 400 KV D/C Teesta
III Kishanganj transmission line.
8.
The Respondent No.4 for its part, submitted that vide
letter No.11/1/08-PG dated 28-01-2009 accorded prior approval of
the Government under Section 68 of the Act to Respondent No.1 as
per the route map submitted by the Respondent No.1. Any dispute
regarding route alignment is to be adjudicated by the State
Government or the appropriate Commission. It is reiterated that as
per the procedure for obtaining authorisation under Section 164 of
the Act, the Respondent No.1 had published the scheme in
newspapers and Gazette of India for inviting comments from the
public.
9.
The rival contentions were heard at length and due
consideration given. I have also perused all documents relied on by
the parties.
10.
It would be useful to first refer to the provisions of
Section 164 of the Act which is reproduced herein below:“164. Exercise of powers of Telegraph Authority in
certain cases.−The Appropriate Government may, by
order in writing, for the placing of electric lines or
electrical plant for the transmission of electricity or for
the purpose of telephonic or telegraphic communications
necessary for the proper coordination of works, confer
upon any public officer, licensee or any other person
engaged in the business of supplying electricity under this
Act, subject to such conditions and restrictions, if any, as
the Appropriate Government may think fit to impose and
2016:SHC:21
WP(C) No.47 of 2014
Shri Thentook Bhutia and Others vs. Teesta Valley Power Transmission Limited and Others
to the provisions of the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885, any of
the powers which the telegraph authority possesses under
that Act with respect to the placing of telegraph lines and
posts for the purposes of a telegraph established or
maintained, by the Government or to be so established or
maintained.”
11.
The Ministry of Power, New Delhi, vide its Order dated
29-04-2010, conferred upon the Respondent No.1 all powers under
Section 164 of the Act which a Telegraph Authority possesses under
the Telegraph Act with respect to the placing of telegraph lines and
posts for the purposes of a telegraph established or maintained by
the Government or to be so established or maintained, subject to 6
(six) conditions that were enumerated in the order. The same Order
also laid down that on 28-01-2009 the Government of India, Ministry
of Power, had granted to Respondent No.1, approval under Section
68 of the Act for 400 KV/DC Transmission System from 1200 MW
Teesta III HEP Kishanganj Pooling Station.
It may be stated here that Section 68 of the Act deals with
provisions relating to overhead lines and requires that an overhead
line shall, with prior approval of the Appropriate Government be
installed or kept installed above ground in accordance with the
provisions of Sub-Section (2) of the said Section. For brevity the
entire Section is not being extracted here. Having said that, it is not
disputed that powers under Section 164 of the Act and approval
under Section 68 of the Act were conferred by the Ministry of Power,
Respondent No.4 to Respondent No.1.
2016:SHC:21
WP(C) No.47 of 2014
Shri Thentook Bhutia and Others vs. Teesta Valley Power Transmission Limited and Others
12.
The Petitioners now seek revocation of the Licence
granted to the Respondent No.1 by the Respondent No.4, the
grounds being that conditions laid down in the Order dated 29-042010, specifically condition (ii) was not complied with, viz.,
“(i)
....................................................................................
(ii)
the Licensee shall have to seek the consent of
the concerned authorities i.e. local bodies,
Railways, National Highways, State Highways
etc. before erection of proposed line;
(iii)
....................................................................................
(iv)
....................................................................................
(v)
....................................................................................
(vi)
..................................................................................”
That there is nothing on record to indicate consent of the
concerned local bodies.
In rebuttal, it was reiterated by Learned
Counsel for Respondent No.1 that public notices had been issued as
also a Gazette Notification and communication made to the
concerned District Collector and Panchayat, no objections were put
forth by any person including local bodies. In this regard, attention
of this Court was invited to Annexures R2 and R9 to R15.
13.
While addressing this argument of the Petitioners
concerning consent, the Hon’ble Apex Court in T. Narasimhulu and
Others vs. State of Andhra Pradesh and Others1 discussing the case
of State of Maharashtra vs. Mayer Hans George2 held that –
1. (2010) 6 SCC 545
2. AIR 1965 SC 722
2016:SHC:21
WP(C) No.47 of 2014
Shri Thentook Bhutia and Others vs. Teesta Valley Power Transmission Limited and Others
“17. It will be clear from the law laid down by this
Court that where the law prescribes the mode of
publication of the law to become operative, the law must
be published in that mode only, but where the mode of
publication of the law is not prescribed by the law, such
law should be published in some usual or recognised mode
to bring it to the knowledge of all persons concerned. In
the present case, the contention of the appellants before
the Tribunal or the High Court was not that the
government order in GOMs Nos. 35 and 51 that the
amendment to Rule 2 of the Forest Service Rules would
have retrospective effect from 8-4-1986 was never made
known by any reasonable mode, but that it was not
published in the Official Gazette. This contention of the
appellants, as we have seen, has no merit.”
14.
Earlier in time, in Subhas Ramkumar Bind alias Vakil
and Another vs. State of Maharashtra the Hon’ble Apex Court held
at Paragraph 20, inter alia, that –
“20. ........................................... Notification
in common English acceptation means and implies a
formal announcement of a legally relevant fact and in
the event of a statute speaking of a notification being
published in the Official Gazette, the same cannot but
mean a notification published by the authority of law
in the Official Gazette. It is on formal declaration and
publication of an order and shall have to be in
accordance with the declared policies or in the event
the requirement of the statute then in that event in
accordance therewith.”
15.
In the matter at hand, it may of course be mentioned
here that the Petitioners could not point out to this Court any
provision for issuance of notice in the Acts concerned.
In my
considered opinion the scheme of the Indian Electricity Act and the
Telegraph Act do not envisage a prior notice.
The Act of the
Respondent in issuing prior notice was by way of abundant caution
3. (2003) 1 SCC 506
2016:SHC:21
WP(C) No.47 of 2014
Shri Thentook Bhutia and Others vs. Teesta Valley Power Transmission Limited and Others
in the backdrop of the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894.
Further, on going through the documents relied on by the
Respondent No.1, firstly, it is evident that they had published
notices on 17-09-2009 in 2 (two) Nepali vernacular newspapers
being “Hamro Prajashakti” and “Himali Bela” circulated in the State
of Sikkim as well as in other vernacular languages in West Bengal in
Bengali and Bihar in Hindi. There was also a public notice published
in the Hindi vernacular and in English in the Gazette of India on 2410-2009.
While going through the Order dated 29-04-2010, the
licensee is required to seek the consent of the concerned authority it
does not specify that they will seek individual consent.
16.
In fact, Section 67(2) of the Act does not say that the
consent of the owners or occupier is mandatory. In this connection,
it may be pointed out that the relevant portion of Section 10 of the
Telegraph Act reads as follows:“10. Power for telegraph authority to place and
maintain telegraph lines and posts.− ............................
(a)
..............................................................
(b)
..............................................................
(c)
except as hereinafter provided, the
telegraph authority shall not exercise those
powers in respect of any property vested in
or under the control or management of any
local authority, without the permission of
that authority; and
(d)
...............................................................”
It is not the case of the Petitioners that their property was
under the control or management of any local authority, therefore,
2016:SHC:21
WP(C) No.47 of 2014
Shri Thentook Bhutia and Others vs. Teesta Valley Power Transmission Limited and Others
question of seeking the consent of the local bodies for constructing
the towers and drawing the overhead lines over the land of the
Petitioners does not arise.
Hence, Notification as detailed above
suffices for the purpose.
17.
Apart from the above, it is not denied that spot
verification of the land of the Petitioners on plot no.989 was carried
out where land was found damaged due to a slide caused by the
construction of a tower. Compensation of Rs.1,04,060/- (Rupees one
lakh four thousand and sixty) only, was paid to the Petitioners not
only for the damage to the land but also for a variety of trees
standing on their land, i.e., Orange trees, 150 Groves of Amliso
(broom plants), “Kimboo trees”, “Panisaj”, “Okhar” and for a Hand
Packed Wall. Evidently the Petitioners had clear knowledge of the
intention of the Respondent No.1 as it is not denied that towers had
already been constructed on their two boundaries drawing an
obvious inference that the overhead lines would be strung from one
tower to the next. The Respondent No.1 does not appear to have
flouted any conditions as agitated by the Petitioners, therefore,
there appears to be no reason for the prayer for revocation of
Licence.
18.
Having dealt with that we may now consider the
provisions pertaining to compensation.
In Section 10(d) of the Telegraph Act, it is laid down that-
2016:SHC:21
WP(C) No.47 of 2014
Shri Thentook Bhutia and Others vs. Teesta Valley Power Transmission Limited and Others
“(d)
in the exercise of the powers conferred by
this section, the telegraph authority shall
do as little damage as possible, and, when it
has exercised those powers in respect of
any property other than that referred to in
clause (c), shall pay full compensation to all
persons interested for any damage
sustained by them by reason of the exercise
of those powers.”
Thus, if there is any damage to property the provisions of
Section 10(d) of the Telegraph Act postulates that compensation
shall be paid. Section 16 of the Telegraph Act comes into play if a
dispute arises with regard to the exercise of powers by the licensee
or the amount of compensation. Section 16(1) reads that –
“16. Exercise of powers conferred by section 10,
and disputes as to compensation, in case of property other
than that of a local authority.–(1) If the exercise of the
powers mentioned in section 10 in respect of property
referred to in clause (d) of that section is resisted or
obstructed, the District Magistrate may, in his discretion,
order that the telegraph authority shall be permitted to
exercise them.
...............................................................................”
This Section thereby empowers the District Magistrate to
exercise his discretionary power in terms of the provision extracted
hereinabove.
Section 16(3) and 16(4) are concerned with the quantum of
compensation or persons entitled to it and are usefully reproduced
below: “(3) If any dispute arises concerning the
sufficiency of the compensation to be paid under section
10, clause (d), it shall, on application for that purpose by
either of the disputing parties to the District Judge within
whose jurisdiction the property is situate, be determined
by him.
2016:SHC:21
WP(C) No.47 of 2014
Shri Thentook Bhutia and Others vs. Teesta Valley Power Transmission Limited and Others
(4) If any dispute arises as to the persons entitled
to receive compensation, or as to the proportions in
which the persons interested are entitled to share in it,
the telegraph authority may pay into the Court of the
District Judge such amount as he deems sufficient or,
where all the disputing parties have in writing admitted
the amount tendered to be sufficient or the amount has
been determined under sub-section (3), that amount; and
the District Judge, after giving notice to the parties and
hearing such of them as desire to be heard, shall
determine the persons entitled to receive the
compensation or, as the case may be, the proportions in
which the persons interested are entitled to share in it.”
Thus, the Section succinctly explains the powers of the
concerned authorities and the intent of the provision requires no
further elucidation.
19.
However,
while
dwelling
on
the
question
of
compensation, the thrust of the argument of the Petitioners is not
about seeking compensation for damage caused to property on their
land or for that matter diminution of the value of the land but they
seek acquisition of their entire property by the Respondent No.1.
While considering this matter assistance in the decision of Hon’ble
Apex Court in Kerala State Electricity Board vs. Livisha and Others
may be resorted to wherein it was held, inter alia;
“9. Both telegraph lines and electrical lines are
required to be drawn over the agricultural lands and/or
other properties belonging to third parties. In drawing
such lines, the entire land cannot be acquired but the
effect thereof would be diminution of value of the
property over which such line is drawn. The Telegraph
Act, 1885 provides for the manner in which the amount of
compensation is to be computed therefor. ………….
4. (2007) 6 SCC 792
2016:SHC:21
WP(C) No.47 of 2014
Shri Thentook Bhutia and Others vs. Teesta Valley Power Transmission Limited and Others
10. The situs of the land, the distance between the
high voltage electricity line laid thereover, the extent of
the line thereon as also the fact as to whether the high
voltage line passes over a small tract of land or
through the middle of the land and other similar relevant
factors in our opinion would be determinative. The value
of the land would also be a relevant factor. The owner of
the land furthermore, in a given situation may lose his
substantive right to use the property for the purpose for
which the same was meant to be used.”
The above judgment, therefore, clearly lays down that when
telegraph and electrical lines are being drawn over properties of
third parties, the entire land cannot be acquired but the
compensation can be calculated on the basis of diminution of the
value of the land.
Suffice it to say that the Act which has been
discussed above does not envisage acquisition of the land on which
the electric posts may be constructed or acquisition of land on which
the lines are taken under, over, along, or across. While considering
Annexure 6 relied on by the Petitioners, the Respondent No.3
appears to have dealt with the dispute but could not impose a
decision on Respondent No.1, the prayers of the Petitioners being for
acquisition of land and re-alignment of route and not compensation.
20.
To conclude it may be reiterated that a cumulative
reading of Section 164 of the Act and Section 10 of the Telegraph Act
recognises the powers conferred on Respondent No.1 to proceed
with the placing of overhead power lines, towers, posts for the
transmission of electricity on or over private land. It goes without
saying that under Section 16, the owner is entitled to claim
2016:SHC:21
WP(C) No.47 of 2014
Shri Thentook Bhutia and Others vs. Teesta Valley Power Transmission Limited and Others
compensation for damages which may occur in the process. In the
same breath, however, it must be stated that there is no requirement
for the Petitioners’ consent nor is there any provision for the
Respondent No.1 to acquire the Petitioners’ land for the above
purpose.
21.
Having regard to the above discussions, it is clear that
the Petitioners have put the cart before the horse and, rushed to this
Court when in fact they ought to have approached the appropriate
forum to vent their grievances, if any, with regard to compensation.
Obviously there cannot be any order to the Respondent No.1 to
acquire the land. Further, in view of the arguments put forth by the
Respondent No.1 there also cannot be any order for re-alignment of
the transmission posts as all safety parameters have been given due
consideration and advance notice given in the year 2009, whereas
construction only commenced in 2013 affording the Petitioners
adequate time to move the appropriate authority, if they had been
so aggrieved, which in the absence of any objection does not appear
so.
22.
It may be worthwhile highlighting here that although in
the Writ Petition it is admitted that the Petitioners ordinarily live in
Gangtok and their main house is at Simick Lingzey, 5 kms. away
from the place where the tower construction works were
undertaken, viz., Patuk, Labong. To the contrary, in Annexure 6, the
2016:SHC:21
WP(C) No.47 of 2014
Shri Thentook Bhutia and Others vs. Teesta Valley Power Transmission Limited and Others
application addressed to the District Collector, Respondent No.3,
dated 26-09-2013, by Sonam Tshering Bhutia, Petitioner No.2, states
that “I am in the possession of the land situated at Patuk, Kokaley, East
Sikkim being an ancestral property owned by my father Lt. Dorjee
Tshering Bhutia, where I have constructed a residential house investing
all my hard-earning money (sic). It is pertinent to state that I don’t have
any other property except my above mentioned property, where I am
residing with my entire family members.” The above statement being
contrary to the previous submissions reflected above, leads one to
suspect the bona fides of the Petitioners with regard to their
prayers.
23.
In the result, the Writ Petition stands dismissed and
disposed of, however, it would be open to the Petitioners to
approach the appropriate authority for compensation if they are so
entitled in accordance with Law.
24.
No order as to costs.
Sd/( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
26-03-2016
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review