The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. Here in the case at hand, it appears that the Learned L.A. Judge could not consider the above factors in determining the amount of compensation and furthermore, if it is found that the Learned L.A. Judge relied upon Exbt.4 which was in respect of ‘vastu’ ‘viti’ class of land but in the present case the acquired land was ‘nal’ class of land. So, there was no scope on the part of Learned L.A. Judge to rely upon said Exbt.4 at the time of determination of compensation. So, it appears that in absence of consideration of the above factors the judgment delivered by Learned L.A. Judge needs to be set aside.
14. In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is hereby allowed. The judgment and award dated 25.07.2023 delivered by Learned L.A. Judge, Court No.1, West Tripura, Agartala in connection with Misc.(L.A.)196 of 2014 is hereby set aside. The case is remanded back to the Learned L.A. Judge with a direction either to take fresh evidence of both the parties after hearing Learned counsels for the parties or to re-appreciate the evidence already on record and to deliver a fresh judgment after considering the above factors within a period of 3(three) months from the date of receipt of a copy of the judgment/order. Learned counsel of both the parties be asked to appear before the Learned L.A. Judge on 19.07.2024. Draw the decree accordingly. Send down the LCRs along with a copy of the judgment immediately. It is necessary to mention here that initially the appellant submitted a Demand Draft of Rs.71,63,949/- vide No.489377 dated
08. 03.2021 in pursuance of order dated 17.11.2020 passed in I.A.No.01 of 2020 (stay petition) arising out of L.A. App.No.53 of 2020 and thereafter, as per order of the Court, 50% of the aforesaid amount was released in favour of the referring-claimants by this Court and the remaining amount is lying with the Registry. So, the balance amount would remain with the Registry till disposal of the case by the Learned L.A. Judge as per judgment of this Court or any further order thereof. The case is thus disposed of. Pending application/s, if any, also stands disposed of. Sabyasachi. B
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
L.A.APP.No.31 of 2024
The Union of India,
represented by the 2nd in Commandant
for Commandant H.Q.,6 Bn, BSF, Fatikcherra,
Mohanpur, District-West Tripura
----Appellant-Opposite Party(s)
Versus
1. Sri Pradip Das,
son of Late Mani Bhusan Das
2. Sri Krishna Kanta Das,
Son of Late Mani Bhusan Das
3. Sri Keshab Kumar Das,
son of Late Mani Bhusan Das
4. Smt. Uma Das,
daughter of Late Mani Bhusan Das
wife of Sri Badal Roy Sarkar
5. Smt. Purnima Das,
daughter of Late Mani Bhusan Das
wife of Sri Sushanta Roy
all are represented by Sri Pradip Kumar Das,
son of Late Mani Bhusan Das of Jagatpur,
P.O. Abhoynagar, P.S. East Agartala, District-West Tripura
(The Referring Claimants No.1 is their constituted Attorney)
----Respondent-Claimant(s)
6. L.A. Collector,
West Tripura, Agartala
----Respondent (s)
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. B. Majumder, DSGI.
Mr. S.S. Debnath, Adv.
Mr. D.S. Kunwar, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
05.07.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
Whether fit for reporting
:
:
09.07.2024
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This is an appeal under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition
Act challenging the judgment and award dated 25.07.2023 passed in
connection with Case No.Misc.(L.A.)196 of 2014 delivered by Learned
Land Acquisition Judge, Court No.1, West Tripura, Agartala.
2.
Heard Mr. B. Majumder, Learned DSGI appearing for the
appellant and Mr. S.S. Debnath, Learned counsel appearing for the
claimant-respondent Nos.1 to 5 and also Mr. D.S. Kunwar, Learned
counsel appearing for the respondent No.6, L.A. Collector.
3.
In course of hearing of argument, Learned counsel for the
appellant submitted that the Learned L.A. Judge without application of
proper mind has determined/assessed the market value of the acquired
land @ Rs.25,00,000/- per kani for which the judgment/award needs to
be set aside. Learned counsel for the appellant in course of hearing
referred para Nos.19, 22, 23, 24 & 26 of the judgment and submitted
that the referring-claimants in support of their claim could not adduce
any satisfactory documents i.e. the sale deeds for proper determination
of the compensation and the Learned L.A. Judge without any basis and
without any reasoning and finding has determined the market value @
Rs.25,00,000/-
per
kani.
Referring
para-22
of
the
judgment
he
submitted that the sale instance (Exbt.4) appears to be executed in the
year 2001, but the notification for acquisition of land was published in
the year 2011 i.e. 9 years after the date of execution of the sale deed in
question. So, there was no scope to place any reliance upon that
document.
4.
Referring para Nos.23 & 24, Learned counsel for the
appellant submitted that on perusal of paper book and also on perusal of
the said document i.e. Exbt.2 the same was nothing but a general power
of attorney wherein Learned Court below in the judgment/award
mentioned that it was a sale deed. Thus, it is clear that without
application of proper mind he has delivered the judgment.
5.
Finally, in para No.26 according to the Learned counsel for
the appellant the Learned L.A. Judge without any reasoning and finding
has assessed the market value of the acquired land @ Rs.25,00,000/per kani. So, Learned counsel for the appellant urged for setting aside
the award delivered by the Learned L.A. Judge.
6.
Learned counsel for the appellant further submitted that the
land of Exbt.4 is ‘vastu’ class of land and the acquired land was ‘nal’
class of land which are totally different and no site plan or map is proved
by the respondent-claimants before the Learned Court below to
substantiate that the same was nearby the original land for which this
cannot be compared as a sale instance in determination of the market
price of the acquired land.
7.
On the other hand, Learned counsel for the referring-
claimants drawn the attention of the Court that initially on the claim of
the referring-claimants i.e. the respondent herein Learned L.A. Judge
passed an award determining the market value of the acquired land @
Rs.35,00,000/- per kani and challenging that award, the present
appellant preferred an appeal before the High Court which was
numbered as L.A.53 of 2020 and this High Court after hearing a batch of
matters in L.A. appeals by a common judgment remanded back the
matter to the Learned L.A. Judge by the judgment and award dated
22.02.2023 with a direction to rehear the matter and to pass a reasoned
judgment in accordance with law within a period of 6(six) months after
appreciating the evidence on record and accordingly, the Learned L.A.
Judge passed a fresh judgment on 25.07.2023 against which the present
appeal is preferred by the appellant.
8.
I have heard arguments of both the sides and gone through
the records of the Learned Court below. It appears that on a reference
under Section 18 of L.A. Act Misc.(L.A.)Case No.196 of 2014 was
registered before the L.A. Judge, West Tripura, Agartala, Court No.1
whereas both the parties have submitted their claim statement and their
counter statement and after taking evidence on record Learned L.A.
Judge
passed
an
award/judgment.
Initially,
award
was
passed
determining the market price @ Rs.35,00,000/-per kani which was
challenged in appeal and this High Court as already stated was pleased
to set aside the judgment and remanded back the matter to the Learned
L.A. Judge with a direction to pass a fresh judgment after appreciating
the evidence on record and accordingly, the judgment was passed.
9.
In the case at hand, land measuring 0.94 acres classified as
‘nal’ under mouja-Ramnagar, Sheet No.2/p, recorded in khatian No.3121
comprising in C/S plot Nos.4384, 4301, 4218, 4213/p and 4304
belonging to the referring-claimants were acquired by the government
for the purpose of establishment of BOP ACP of 6 Bn. BSF under Sadar
Sub-Division,
West
REV/ACQ/VI/11
Tripura
dated
District
vide
notification
No.F.09(02)-
21.02.2011.
The
referring-claimants
were
represented by their constituted attorney No.1 by submitting a General
Power of Attorney. The L.A. Collector in determining the compensation
assessed the market value of the acquired land @ Rs.37,50,000/- per
acre and also assessed additional compensation @ 30% solatium and
interest @ 12% per annum w.e.f. 24.02.2011 to 22.07.2011 for a period
of 149 days and assessed the total amount of compensation amounting
to Rs.47,55,177/-. As the claimants were dissatisfied with the award of
the L.A. Collector so they submitted an application before the Learned
L.A. Collector for referring the matter before the L.A. Judge for
determination of compensation as per prevailing market price of the
acquired land. The matter was accordingly come up before the Learned
L.A. Judge and the case was registered and both the parties submitted
their claim statement and counter-statement. Before the Learned L.A.
Judge one of the referring-claimants namely Sri Pradip Kumar Das was
examined as P.W.1 and he relied upon some documents General Power
of Attorney dated 06.03.2019 (8 sheets) which was marked as Exbt.2 to
Exbt.2(vii), the copy of sale deed bearing No.1-1597 dated 25.02.2015
(9 sheets) marked as Exbt.3 to Exbt.3(viii), the copy of sale deed no.19625 dated 12.11.2001 (4 sheets) marked as Exbt.4 to Exbt.4(iii). From
the side of the L.A. Collector one Debananda Debbarma, Senior
Government Surveyor was examined and from the requiring Department
one witness namely Sri K. Nath, Head Constable (Ministerial), Office of
the Commandant 120 Bn. BSF, Fatikcherra, Tripura was examined as
OPW-2. No documentary evidence was adduced by the opposite parties
to substantiate their pleadings. Finally, on the basis of evidence on
record, Learned L.A. Judge determined the market value of the acquire
land
@
Rs.25,00,000/-
per
kani
by
the
judgment/award
dated
25.07.2023.
10.
I have gone through the para Nos.19, 20, 23 & 24 of the
judgment it appears that the Learned Tribunal below did not rely upon
Exbt.3 i.e. the sale deed of the year 2015 as it was four years later from
the date of notification of acquisition. So, Learned Tribunal below did not
consider the same. Rather, Learned Tribunal below relied upon Exbt.4
i.e. sale deed of the year 2001 which was executed almost nine years
prior to the date of notification of acquisition. In para Nos.23 & 24
Learned Tribunal below relied upon Exbt.2 but factually on perusal of
records it appears that the same was a General Power of Attorney, not a
sale deed. It is not clear how the Learned Tribunal below referred Exbt.2
in paras-23 & 24 of the judgment, there was no explanation in this
regard. Exbt.2 was a General Power of Attorney which was executed by
Sri Krishna Kanta Das, Sri Keshab Kumar Das, Smti. Uma Das and Smti.
Purnima Das in favour of one Sri Pradip Kumar Das. Thus, it appears
that the Learned Tribunal below either misconstrued the said exhibited
document or did not apply the mind at the time of delivery of the
judgment properly in referring the document as Exbt.2.
11.
In course of hearing of argument, Learned Counsel for the
appellant relied upon two citations. In Shaji Kuriakose and Another
versus Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. and Others reported in (2001) 7
SCC 650 the Hon’ble Apex Court in para No.3 observed as under :
“3. It is no doubt true that courts adopt comparable sales
Method of valuation of land while fixing the market value of
the acquired land. While fixing the market value of the
acquired land, Comparable Sales Method of valuation is
preferred than other methods of valuation of land such as
Capitalisation of Net Income Method or Expert Opinion
Method. Comparable Sales Method of valuation is preferred
because it furnishes the evidence for determination of the
market value of the acquired land at which a willing purchaser
would pay for the acquired land if it has been sold in open
market at the time of issue of notification under Section 4 of
the Act. However, Comparable Sales Method of valuation of
land for fixing the market value of the acquired land is not
always conclusive. There are certain factors which are
required to be fulfilled and on fulfilment of those factors the
compensation can be awarded, according to the value the land
reflected in the sales. The factors laid down" inter alia are :
(1) the sale must be a genuine transaction, that (2) the sale
deed must have been executed at the time proximate to the
date of issue of notification under Section 4 of the Act, that
(3) the land covered by the sales must be in the vicinity of the
acquired land, that (4) the land covered by the sale must be
similar to the acquired land and that (5) the size of plot of the
land covered by the sales be comparable to the land acquired.
If all these factors are satisfied, then there is no reason why
the sale value of the land covered by the sales be not given for
the acquired land. However, if there is a dissimilarity in regard
to locality shape, site or nature of land between land covered
by sales and land acquired, it is open to Court to
proportionately reduce the compensation for acquired land
than what is reflected in the sales depending upon the
disadvantages attached with the acquired land. In the present
case, what we find is that the first two factors are satisfied.
The sale transaction covered by the sale Ex. A-4 is genuine,
inasmuch as sale was executed in proximity to the date of
notification under Section 4 of the Act. However, there is a
difference in the similarity in the land acquired and the land
covered by Ex. A-4. The land covered by Ex. A-4 is situated at
Kottayam and Ernakulam, PWD Road, whereas the acquired
land is situated at a distance of 3 furlong from the main road.
There is no access to the acquired land and there exists only
an internal mud road which belonged to one of the
claimantsss, whose land has also been acquired. Further, the
land covered by Ex. A-4 is a dry land and whereas the
acquired land is a wet land. After acquisition, the acquired
land has to be re-claimed and a lot of amount would be spent
for filling the land. Moreover, the land covered by Ex. A-4
relates to a small piece of land which do not reflect the true
market value of the acquired land. It is often seen that a sale
for a smaller plot of land fetches more consideration than
larger or bigger piece of land. For all these reasons, the High
Court was fully justified in lowering the rate of compensation
that what was the market value of the land covered by Ex. A4. We therefore, do not find any infirmity in the judgment of
the High Court. ”
In Karnataka Urban Water Supply and Drainage Board
and Others versus K.S. Gangadharappa and Another reported in
(2009) 11 SCC 164 the Hon’ble Apex Court in paras-9 & 10 observed
as under :
“9. It is right as contended by learned counsel for the
respondents that deductions can be made for development.
But the deductions have to be made from some definite figure.
In the instant case the High Court has not indicated any basis
but has come to an abrupt conclusion that the claim of the
owners for enhancement has to be accepted but not for
Rs.9,00,000/- per acre as claimed but at Rs.4,00,000/- per
acre. Market value has a definite concept and it cannot be
evaluated without any foundation or basis.
10. In the circumstances we set aside the impugned judgment
of the High Court to decide the matter afresh and indicate a
basis for fixation of market value at a definite figure. The
appeals are allowed to the aforesaid extent.”
Referring the same, Learned counsel for the appellant drawn
the attention of the Court that the Hon’ble Apex Court has given certain
parameters in determining the amount of compensation in respect of the
acquired land which the Learned Tribunal below consider in this case at
the time of delivery of judgment for which the interference of the Court
is required by setting aside the judgment of the Learned Tribunal below.
12.
I have perused the record of the Learned Tribunal below very
carefully. It appears that at the time of determination of compensation in
respect of the present case Learned Tribunal below relied upon Exbt.4
i.e. the sale deed of the year 2001 which was almost about nine years
earlier prior to the date of notification in the year 2011. Furthermore, in
the said deed the quantum of land has been shown as the ‘vastu’ viti
class of land whereas in the present case, the acquired land of the
referring-claimants was nal/paddy land which is apparent from the
judgment of the Learned Tribunal below. So, in view of the principle of
law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the aforenoted cases it
appears that the Learned Tribunal below without application of proper
mind and without considering all the above factors determined the
amount of compensation in respect of the acquired land without
assigning any justified grounds/reasons @ Rs.25,00,000/- per kani for
which in my considered view the judgment/award of the Learned
Tribunal below suffers from perversity. So, it appears that the matter
again needs to be remanded back to the Learned Tribunal below again
either to take fresh evidence of both the sides or to re-appreciate the
evidence on record properly and to deliver the judgment afresh. At the
time of determination of the judgment, Learned Court below should
consider the following factors :
(1) the sale must be a genuine transaction.
(2) the sale deed must have been executed at the
time proximate to the date of issue of notification
under Section 4 of the Act.
(3) the land covered by the sales must be in the
vicinity of the acquired land.
(4) the land covered by the sale must be similar to
the acquired land.
(5) the size of plot of the land covered by the sales
be comparable to the land acquired.
13.
Here in the case at hand, it appears that the Learned L.A.
Judge could not consider the above factors in determining the amount of
compensation and furthermore, if it is found that the Learned L.A. Judge
relied upon Exbt.4 which was in respect of ‘vastu’ ‘viti’ class of land but
in the present case the acquired land was ‘nal’ class of land. So, there
was no scope on the part of Learned L.A. Judge to rely upon said Exbt.4
at the time of determination of compensation. So, it appears that in
absence of consideration of the above factors the judgment delivered by
Learned L.A. Judge needs to be set aside.
14.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is hereby
allowed. The judgment and award dated 25.07.2023 delivered by
Learned L.A. Judge, Court No.1, West Tripura, Agartala in connection
with Misc.(L.A.)196 of 2014 is hereby set aside. The case is remanded
back to the Learned L.A. Judge with a direction either to take fresh
evidence of both the parties after hearing Learned counsels for the
parties or to re-appreciate the evidence already on record and to deliver
a fresh judgment after considering the above factors within a period of
3(three)
months
from
the
date
of
receipt
of
a
copy
of
the
judgment/order.
Learned counsel of both the parties be asked to appear
before the Learned L.A. Judge on 19.07.2024.
Draw the decree accordingly.
Send down the LCRs along with a copy of the judgment
immediately.
It is necessary to mention here that initially the appellant
submitted a Demand Draft of Rs.71,63,949/- vide No.489377 dated
08.03.2021 in pursuance of order dated 17.11.2020 passed in I.A.No.01
of 2020 (stay petition) arising out of L.A. App.No.53 of 2020 and
thereafter, as per order of the Court, 50% of the aforesaid amount was
released in favour of the referring-claimants by this Court and the
remaining amount is lying with the Registry. So, the balance amount
would remain with the Registry till disposal of the case by the Learned
L.A. Judge as per judgment of this Court or any further order thereof.
The case is thus disposed of.
Pending application/s, if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2024.07.11 13:02:34 +05'30'
Sabyasachi. B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review