Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
LA App. No.29 of 2024
1. The Union of India,
Represented by the 2nd-in-Command,
For Commandant H.Q., 6 Bn, BSF,
Fatikcherra, Mohanpur,
District-West Tripura.
……..Appellant(s)
–Versus–
1. Sri Dipankar Das,
S/o Sudhir Chandra Das.
2. Sri Bhaskar Das,
S/o Sudhir Chandra Das,
Both are resident at Ramnagar, Agartala,
District-West Tripura.
3. L.A. Collector,
West Tripura, Agartala.
…….. Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
:
Mr. B. Majumder, Dy. S.G.I.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D.K. Biswas, Senior Advocate.
Mr. P. Gautam, Advocate.
Mr. S.S. Debnath, Advocate.
Mr. D.S. Kunwar, Advocate.
Date of hearing
:
18th July, 2024.
Date of delivery of
Judgment & order
:
29th November, 2024.
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
This appeal arises out of an award passed by learned L.A.
Judge (Court No.1), West Tripura District, Agartala on 25.7.2023 in case
No. Misc.(LA) 258 of 2016 whereby learned L.A. Judge awarded
compensation to the present respondent Nos.1 and 2 (hereinafter
referred to as the ‘claimants’) @ Rs.25,00,000/- per kani for the
acquired land with other statutory benefits.
[2]
The land area of 0.18 acre of RS plot No.4387 of Khatian
No.2084 of Mouja Ramnagar, Sheet No.2/P was acquired by the
Government
vide
notification
No.F.09(02)-REV/ACQ/VI/11
dated
21.2.2011 under Section 4 of Land Acquisition Act for the purpose of
establishment of BOP ACP of 6th Battalion BSF under Sadar Sub-division.
[3]
L.A. Collector awarded compensation @ Rs.15,00,000/- per
kani for the acquired land, against which being aggrieved, the claimants
prayed for reference under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act. In the
Court of learned L.A. Judge, the aforesaid case bearing No. Misc.(LA)
258 of 2016 was, accordingly, cropped up. The claimants lodged their
claim before learned L.A. Judge for compensation @ Rs.1,00,00,000/per kani on the ground that the acquired land fell within Municipal area
of Agartala adjacent to Kalikapur Market, Border Golchakkar Market and
Ramnagar as well as Durga Chowmuhani Market. It was stated that the
land was well connected by the main road and the by-lanes. According
to them, several Government establishments, nationalized Banks, Post
Office etc were within stone throw distance from the acquired land.
Ramnagar Higher Secondary School, Bani Bidhya Pith Women Higher
Secondary School and several other junior and senior basic schools were
also situated encircling the acquired land within walking distance and
even AGMC and GBP Hospital of Agartala was also situated within 2
kilometers from the acquired land.
[4]
During trial before learned L.A. Judge, from the side of
claimants, claimant Dipankar Das examined himself as a witness and he
placed two documents, i.e. two certified copies of sale deeds, into
evidence. From the side of L.A. Collector, one Narendra Chandra Deb,
was examined as OPW-1 and he also submitted certified copy of one
sale exemplar in the evidence. Details of all the sale exemplars will be
discussed in later part of the judgment. The appellant, requiring
department though submitted their counter objection in the said
proceedings but did not adduce any evidence to support the same.
[5]
Learned L.A. Judge, thereafter, awarded compensation @
Rs.25,00,000/- per kani vide award dated 18.5.2022. Challenging said
award, the requiring department preferred L.A. App. No.42 of 2022
which was disposed of by a coordinate bench of this Court along with
other three appeals by remanding the matter to the learned L.A. Judge
for a fresh consideration with a direction that learned L.A. Judge after
hearing both the sides afresh, shall pass a reasoned order by
appreciating the evidence and fixing the compensation in accordance
with the law.
[6]
In compliance with the said direction, learned L.A. Judge has
again passed the impugned award on 25.7.2023 maintaining the same
award as passed earlier i.e. compensation @ Rs.25,00,000/- per kani.
Learned L.A. Judge in his reasoning observed that Exbt.1, the Sale Deed
No.1-1597 dated 25.2.2015 as was proved from the side of claimants,
was executed 4(four) years after the acquisition in question. Therefore,
that was kept out of consideration. Regarding Exbt.2, another Sale Deed
bearing No.1-9625 dated 12.11.2001 wherein land of „Bastu‟ class
measuring 2 karas 2 krantas 14.5 dhurs was sold at Rs.90,000/- i.e. @
Rs.24,71,000/- per kani, learned L.A. Judge observed that it was a
transaction taken place about 9(nine) years prior to the date of
acquisition. Meanwhile, the land price in that area escalated. According
to learned L.A. Judge, though the acquired land was comparatively of
inferior quality than the land of Exbt.2 but after lapse of 9(nine) years,
price of the said land also must have been increased, and therefore, the
award
given
by
L.A.
Collector
@
Rs.15,00,000/-
per
kani
was
inadequate. Learned L.A. Judge also took into consideration the
evidence of the L.A. Collector‟s witness and observed that the acquired
land was well connected with the valuable establishments situated
within Agartala city area within a distance of 500 meters to 1 km.
Mr. B. Majumder, learned Dy. S.G.I., for the appellant
[7]
argues that Exbt.2 was a totally different class of land i.e. of „Bastu‟
class, whereas, the witness of L.A. Collector proved a sale deed under
Exbt.A
which
was
sold
at
Rs.9,91,736/-
per
kani
i.e.
around
Rs.10,00,000/- per kani, just few days prior to the date of notification
at Chandinamura Mouja regarding „Nal‟ class of land, similar to the class
of acquired land, but learned L.A. Judge failed to appreciate the fact
that even L.A. Collector awarded higher compensation than the rate of
the transaction as taken place in Exbt.A. Mr. Majumder, learned Dy.
S.G.I. also submits that the reasoning for determining the award as
given by the L.A. Collector in the assessment note was very sound and
acceptable.
[8]
Mr. P. Gautam, learned counsel representing the L.A.
Collector also supported the version of Mr. Majumder, learned Dy.
S.G.I. also relies on a decision of the Apex Court in the case of Shaji
Kuriakose and Another vs. Indian Oil Corpn. Ltd. and Others,
(2001) 7 SCC 650. The relevant paragraph No.3 as relied upon by
learned Dy. S.G.I. is excerpted hereinbelow :
“3. It is no doubt true that courts adopt comparable
sales method of valuation of land while fixing the
market value of the acquired land. While fixing the
market value of the acquired land, comparable sales
method of valuation is preferred than other methods of
valuation of land such as capitalisation of net income
method or expert opinion method. Comparable sales
method of valuation is preferred because it furnishes
the evidence for determination of the market value of
the acquired land at which a willing purchaser would
pay for the acquired land if it has been sold in the open
market at the time of issue of notification under
Section 4 of the Act. However, comparable sales
method of valuation of land for fixing the market value
of the acquired land is not always conclusive. There are
certain factors which are required to be fulfilled and on
fulfilment of those factors the compensation can be
awarded, according to the value of the land reflected in
the sales. The factors laid down inter alia are : (1) the
sale must be a genuine transaction, (2) that the sale
deed must have been executed at the time proximate
to the date of issue of notification under Section 4 of
the Act, (3) that the land covered by the sale must be
in the vicinity of the acquired land, (4) that the land
covered by the sales must be similar to the acquired
land, and (5) that the size of plot of the land covered
by the sales be comparable to the land acquired. If all
these factors are satisfied, then there is no reason why
the sale value of the land covered by the sales be not
given for the acquired land. However, if there is a
dissimilarity in regard to locality, shape, site or nature
of land between land covered by sales and land
acquired, it is open to the court to proportionately
reduce the compensation for acquired land than what is
reflected
in
the
sales
depending
upon
the
disadvantages attached with the acquired land.”
[9]
Learned Dy. S.G.I. also relies on another decision of a co-
equal Bench of this Court dated 9.7.2024 passed in L.A. App. No.31 of
2024 between The Union of India vs. Sri Pradip Das & Ors. The
said case also arose out of the same acquisition and by a common
judgment dated 22·2.2023 in said L.A. App. No.42 of 2022 and other
analogous matter, said case was earlier remanded to the learned L.A.
Judge for the re-determination of compensation wherein similar rate of
Rs.25,00,000/- per kani was again maintained by learned L.A. Judge.
Thereafter, in the said appeal bearing L.A. App. No.31 of 2024, learned
bench of this Court again remanded the matter with a direction either to
take fresh evidence of both the parties or to re-appreciate the evidence
already on record and to pass a fresh award after considering the
relevant factors. This Court in that case also relied on the decision of the
Apex Court rendered in Shaji Kuriakose (supra) and observed thus :
“12. I have perused the record of the Learned Tribunal below
very carefully. It appears that at the time of determination of
compensation in respect of the present case Learned Tribunal
below relied upon Exbt.4 i.e. the sale deed of the year 2001
which was almost about nine years earlier prior to the date of
notification in the year 2011. Furthermore, in the said deed
the quantum of land has been shown as the ‘vastu’ viti class
of land whereas in the present case, the acquired land of the
referring-claimants was nal/paddy land which is apparent
from the judgment of the Learned Tribunal below. So, in view
of the principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in
the aforenoted cases it appears that the Learned Tribunal
below without application of proper mind and without
considering all the above factors determined the amount of
compensation in respect of the acquired land without
assigning any justified grounds/reasons @ Rs.25,00,000/- per
kani for which in my considered view the judgment/award of
the Learned Tribunal below suffers from perversity. So, it
appears that the matter again needs to be remanded back to
the Learned Tribunal below again either to take fresh
evidence of both the sides or to re-appreciate the evidence on
record properly and to deliver the judgment afresh. At the
time of determination of the judgment, Learned Court below
should consider the following factors :
(1) the sale must be a genuine transaction.
(2) the sale deed must have been executed at the time
proximate to the date of issue of notification under
Section 4 of the Act.
(3) the land covered by the sales must be in the vicinity
of the acquired land.
(4) the land covered by the sale must be similar to the
acquired land.
(5) the size of plot of the land covered by the sales be
comparable to the land acquired.
13. Here in the case at hand, it appears that the Learned L.A.
Judge could not consider the above factors in determining the
amount of compensation and furthermore, if it is found that
the Learned L.A. Judge relied upon Exbt.4 which was in
respect of ‘vastu’ ‘viti’ class of land but in the present case
the acquired land was ‘nal’ class of land. So, there was no
scope on the part of Learned L.A. Judge to rely upon said
Exbt.4 at the time of determination of compensation. So, it
appears that in absence of consideration of the above factors
the judgment delivered by Learned L.A. Judge needs to be set
aside.”
[10]
Mr. D.K. Biswas, learned senior counsel, on the other hand,
representing the claimants, and referring to paragraph No.12 of the
impugned award has submitted that earlier the matter was remanded by
this Court to learned L.A. Judge just to pass a reasoned order and now,
a complete reasoned order has been passed by learned L.A. Judge
requiring no further interference. Mr. Biswas, learned senior counsel also
submits that in a city or town area, none cares for the class of land and
due to scarcity of land, the intending purchaser without giving much
importance to the classification of the land, purchases the land and
converts it generally either for residential purpose or for commercial
purpose and more so, the acquired land is situated within Ramnagar
Mouja which itself is a very posh area of Agartala city used for both
commercial as well as residential purposes. According to Mr. Biswas, the
original acquisition was made for construction of BOP which required no
further development of land against huge expenditure and the border
road is situated within the city area itself.
[11]
Finally, learned senior counsel relying on a decision of the
Apex Court in the case of H.P. Housing Board vs. Bharat S. Negi and
Others, (2004) 2 SCC 184, submits that in the said case award was
passed by learned L.A. Judge taking into consideration five sale
instances proved by the claimants-respondents and two sale instances
proved by appellants, and the sale instances pertained to land which
was a „kiar awal’ (irrigated land) class of land but the acquired land was
„bakhal awal’ (non-irrigated land) class. The Reference Court in said
case did not make any difference in classification of land as the land was
acquired for housing purposes and they were all suitable for construction
activity. The Reference Court also refused to give any deduction for the
largeness of the land. In appeal, the High Court refused to take into
consideration two sale instances cited by the appellants on the ground
that the appellants have themselves offered a price of Rs.80,000/- per
bigha and took into consideration only the five sale instances cited by
the claimants and thereafter, making the average price of those five sale
instances, which arrived at Rs.1,80,000/- per bigha, deducted 40% due
to the largeness of the land and fixed compensation @ Rs.1,08,000/per bigha. In that backdrop, the Apex Court held as follows :
“5. We have heard the parties. In our view, the High
Court was absolutely wrong in excluding the two sale
instances cited by the appellants. The High Court
omitted to notice that the offer of Rs. 80,000 per bigha
had not been accepted by the claimants. In any event
the offer was for Rs. 80,000 per bigha as a consolidated
amount. The appellants would not then have to pay the
solatium and interest amounts. We are told, and it is
not disputed that the figure of Rs. 80,000 per bigha
would, if solatium and interest is deducted, have gone
down to less than Rs. 40,000 per bigha. In our view the
approach of the Reference Court was correct. As all
sale instances were proved, they were all to be taken
into consideration. If all the sale instances are taken
into consideration the average would work out to Rs.
1,11,660 per bigha. But as all the sale instances are of
small pieces of lands and the acquisition is of the large
piece of land, a deduction of 33 1/3% must be made
towards development cost. Thus the compensation
would work out to Rs. 74,444 per bigha.”
[12]
Before entering into the factual facet of the present case,
the basic principles and parameters for deciding the compensation in
land acquisition cases as enunciated by the Apex Court and also by this
Court are required to be revisited. In the case of
Chimanlal
Hargovinddas vs. Special Land Acquisition Officer, Poona and
another, AIR 1988 SC 1652, the following parameters were laid down
by the Apex Court for determination of just and proper compensation :
“4.
(1)………..
…………………..
(10) The most comparable instances out of the
genuine
instances
have
to
be
identified
on
the
following considerations :
(i) proximity from time angle
(ii) proximity from situation angle.
(11) Having identified the instances which provide the
index of market value the price reflected therein may
be taken as the norm and the market value of the land
under acquisition may be deduced by making suitable
adjustments for the plus and minus factors vis-à-vis
land
under
acquisition
by
placing
the
two
in
juxtaposition.
(12) A balance-sheet of plus and minus factors may
be drawn for this purpose and the relevant factors may
be evaluated in terms of price variation as a prudent
purchaser would do.
(13) The market value of the land under acquisition
has thereafter to be deduced by loading the price
reflected in the instance taken as norm for plus factors
and unloading it for minus factors.
(14) The exercise indicated in clauses (11) to (13)
has to be undertaken in a common sense manner as a
prudent man of the world of business would do. We
may illustrate some such illustrative (not exhaustive)
factors : for table see below)
(15) The evaluation of these factors of course depends
on the facts of each case. There cannot be any hard and
fast or rigid rule. Common sense is the best and most
reliable guide. For instance, take the factor regarding
the size. A building plot of land say 500 to 1000 sq. yds
cannot be compared with a large tract or block of land
of say 10000 eq. yds. or more. Firstly while a smaller
plot is within the reach of many, a large block of land
will have to be developed by preparing a lay out,
carving out roads, leaving open space, plotting out
smaller plots, waiting for purchasers (meanwhile the
invested money will be blocked up) and the hazards of
an entrepreneur. The factor can be discounted by
making a deduction by way of an allowance at an
appropriate rate ranging approx. between 20% to 50%
to account for land required to be set apart for carving
out lands and plotting out small plots. The discounting
will to some extent also depend on whether it is a rural
area or urban area, whether building activity is picking
up, and whether waiting period during which the
capital of the entrepreneur would be locked up, will be
longer or shorter and the attendant hazards.
(16) Every case must be dealt with on its own fact
pattern bearing in mind all these factors as a prudent
purchaser of land in which position the Judge must
place himself.
(17) These are general guidelines to be applied with
understanding informed with common sense.
Sl.No.
Plus factors
Minus factors
1.
Smallness of size.
largeness of area.
2.
Proximity to a road.
situation in the interior
at a distance from the
road.
[13]
3.
frontage on a road.
4.
nearness
area.
5.
regular shape.
6.
level vis-a-vis land under
acquisition.
7.
special value for an
owner of an adjoining
property to whom it may
have some very special
advantage.
to
developed
narrow strip of land
with
very
small
frontage compared to
depth.
lower level requiring
the depressed portion
to be filled up.
remoteness from
developed locality.
some special
disadvantageous factor
which would deter a
purchaser.
In Land Acquisition Officer vs. B. Vijender Reddy and
Others, (2001) 10 SCC 669, the Apex Court held the followings :
“13. …….. It is true, in the
fixation of
rate
of
compensation under the Land Acquisition Act, there is
always some element of guesswork. But that has to be
based on some foundation. It must spring from the
totality of evidence, the pattern of rate, the pattern of
escalation
and
escalation
of
price
in
the
years
preceding and succeeding Section 4 notification etc. In
other
words,
the
guesswork
could
reasonably
be
inferable from it. It is always possible to assess the
rate within
this realm.…….”
[14]
In Kasturi and Others vs. State of Haryana, (2003) 1
SCC 354, it was held by the Apex Court that in respect of agricultural
land or undeveloped land which has potential value for housing or
commercial purposes, normally 1/3rd amount of compensation has to be
deducted out of the amount of compensation payable on the acquired
land subject to certain variations depending on its nature, location,
extent of expenditure involved for development and the area required
for roads and other civic amenities to develop the land so as to make
the plots for residential or commercial purposes. It was also observed by
the Apex Court that a land may be plain or uneven, the soil of the land
may be soft or hard bearing on the foundation for the purpose of
making construction; may be the land is situated in the midst of a
developed area all around but that land may have a hillock or may be
low-lying or may be having deep ditches. So the amount of expenses
that may be incurred in developing the area also varies. There may be
various factual factors which may have to be taken into consideration
while
applying
the
cut
in
payment
of
compensation
towards
developmental charges.
[15]
In Viluben Jhalejar Contractor (D) by LRs., vs. State of
Gujarat, in AIR 2005 SC 2214, the principle laid down in Chimanlal
Hargovinddas (supra) was also reiterated. Further, at para No.25 of
the judgment, the Apex Court observed thus :
“25. In Bhagwathula Samanna (supra), it has been
held:
“11. The principle of deduction in the land value
covered by the comparable sale is thus adopted in
order to arrive at the market value of the acquired
land. In applying the principle it is necessary to
consider all relevant facts. It is not the extent of the
area covered under the acquisition which is the only
relevant factor. Even in the vast area there may be land
which is fully developed having all amenities and
situated in an advantageous position. If smaller area
within the large tract is already developed and suitable
for building purposes and have in its vicinity roads,
drainage, electricity, communications etc. then the
principle of deduction simply for the reason that it is
part of the large tract acquired, may not be justified.”
[16]
In the case of Rishi Pal Singh and Others vs. Meerut
Development Authority and Another, (2006) 3 SCC 205, the Apex
Court observed that there is no bar in law to consider the exemplars of
small plots. In an appropriate case, specially when other relevant or
material evidence is not available, such exemplars can be considered
after making adequate discount.
[17]
In Subh Ram and Others vs. State of Haryana and
Another, (2010) 1 SCC 444, the Apex Court held that if the valuation
of a large extent of agricultural or undeveloped land is to be based on
the sale price of a small developed plot in a private layout, then the
standard deductions should be one-third (for roads, etc.) plus one-third
(for expenditure of development), in all two-thirds (or 67%), as
“development cost” from the value of small plot and the percentage of
such deduction may vary between 20% to 75% depending on several
circumstances. It was also observed that the purpose of acquisition will
not be relevant for taking into account the percentage of deduction.
[18]
In Andhra Pradesh Housing Board vs. K. Manohar
Reddy and Others, (2010) 12 SCC 707, and Mehrawal Khewaji
Trust (Regd.) Faridkot & Ors. vs. State of Punjab & Ors, 2012
AIR SCW 2822, it was held that when large tract of land is acquired
and sale instances produced for small plots as exemplar, the best course
for the court to arrive at a reasonable and fair valuation is to deduct a
reasonable percentage from the valuation shown in the exemplar land
and on the basis thereof to arrive at a just and fair valuation. In
Mehrawal Khewaji Trust (supra), it was further held that when there
are several exemplars with reference to similar lands, it is the general
rule that the highest of the exemplars, if it is satisfied, that it is a bona
fide transaction has to be considered and accepted.
[19]
Recently, in Horrmal (Deceased) through his Lrs and
others vs. State of Haryana and Others, 2024 SCC Online SC
2990, again said principle has been reiterated by the Apex Court that
sale exemplars of smaller plots can be taken into consideration provided
they are subject to adequate developmental charges. It has also been
further observed that post-notification sales can only be considered
when better evidence is not available on record and when the party
relying on it can convincingly demonstrate that there has been no
upward trend in market prices due to the acquisition.
[20]
In the case of Shaji Kuriakose (supra), as relied upon by
learned Dy. S.G.I., the Apex Court while citing some factors for taking
into consideration for determination of compensation noted, inter alia,
that the land covered by the sales must be similar to the acquired land.
[21]
The word ‘similar land’ was interpreted by this Court in
Smti Nanda Rani Debnath & Ors. vs. In-charge, HR-ER, O.N.G.C.
Limited & Anr., in L.A. App. No.21 of 2016 decided on 23.8.2018 in
the following terms :
“16. The phrase that has been used in Mehrawal
Khewaji Trust (supra) “the similar lands”, has to be
critically dwelled upon for having an accurate insight to
the legal proposition. What makes two pieces of land
similar to each other? According to this Court, its
location, the index of development, the class of the
land and the other advantages attached to the land.
These
four
parameters
if
considered
cumulatively
allows a prudent person to come to a conclusion that
whether two pieces of land, though differently located
is liable to be treated as similar.”
[22]
Further, this Court while determining compensation under
the provisions of Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land
Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, in the case of
The
Deputy
Chief
Engineer
(Construction-1),
N.F.
Railway,
Badharghat, Agartala vs. Smt. Sandhya Rani Deb & Ors., in L.A.
App. No.28 of 2023 decided along with CO(FA) No.10 of 2023 on
25.1.2024 observed as follows :
“14. The provision of Section 26 further cast a duty on
the Collector to consider the sale price of similar type of
land. The words „similar type‟ cannot be equated with
the words „same type‟. As per Oxford Advanced Learner‟s
Dictionary, 8th Edition, the word „same‟ denotes „exactly
the one or ones referred to or mentioned‟ whereas, the
word „similar‟ means „like but not exactly the same‟.
[23]
On
careful
consideration
of
aforementioned
successive
pronouncements of the Apex Court and above said two decisions of this
Court, the law is no longer res integra that, to arrive at a just and
proper decision, some groundwork is required to be done by the Court
based
on
certain
foundational
facts.
While
determining
the
compensation, the factors which were required to be taken care of are
that the sale of the exemplars must be genuine transaction and that the
sale deed must have been executed at the time proximate to the date of
issue of notification under Section 4 of the Act. The land covered by the
sale should be in the vicinity of the acquired land and should be similar
to the acquired land. Further, the size of plot of the land covered by the
sales should be comparable to the land acquired. If these factors are
satisfied, then the sale value of the land of such exemplars can safely be
given to the land losers for the acquisition of their lands. But, where
there are dissimilarities in regard to the locality, shape, site or nature of
the land between the land involved in sale exemplars and the acquired
land, it is always open to the Court to proportionately reduce the
compensation for the acquired land than what is reflected in the sale
exemplars. While making such reduction of the value, the permissible
range is between 20% to 75% and even sale exemplars concerning
small tract of land can also form basis to determine large area of land
acquired.
[24]
There is no fixed principle that, to claim compensation for a
particular class of land, the sale exemplars involving „same class‟ of land
shall have to be produced by the claimant and on failure to produce the
same in the Court, his claim has to be negated by affirming the award of
the L.A. Collector. It is the solemn duty of the Tribunal to arrive at just
and proper compensation for the land losers. In a particular area if a
„Bastu‟ class of land is acquired, there may not be sale exemplars
available in the vicinity showing transaction of „Bastu‟ class of land and
for that reason the land losers cannot be given a go-by. If the claimant
is able to produce other satisfactory evidences to enable the Tribunal to
determine fair compensation, it is always open to the learned L.A. Judge
to determine the compensation basing on such exemplars subject to
necessary cuts or increase of value whichever applicable, in the light of
the parameters laid down by the Apex Court from time to time.
[25]
It is also well settled that a reference under Section 18 of
the Act is not an appeal against the award and the Court cannot take
into account the material relied upon by the Land Acquisition Collector in
his award, unless said materials are proved before the learned L.A.
Judge. The Court is required to treat the reference as original
proceeding and to determine the market value of the acquired land
afresh basing on the materials placed before it [Ref.- Chimanlal
Hargovinddas (supra)].
[26]
The contention of the appellant that Exbt.2 pertains to a
different class of land i.e. „Bastu‟ class of land, and therefore, same is
unreliable and no compensation can be determined based on such
exemplar, is not acceptable. So far the observations of this Court in The
Union of India vs. Sri Pradip Das (supra), that in Exbt.4 of that case
involved „Bastu‟ (vitti) class of land whereas the acquired land was
„Nal/Paddy‟ class of land, and therefore, there was no scope on the part
of learned L.A. Judge to rely on said Exbt.4, are concerned, same were
completely some incidental observation of the Court on factual aspects
of that case while appreciating the evidences and did not enunciate any
law on the issue.
Moreover, as it appears, decisions of this Court in
above said Smti Nanda Rani Debnath (supra) and The Deputy Chief
Engineer (Construction-1), N.F. Railway, Badharghat, Agartala vs. Smt.
Sandhya Rani Deb (supra) were not placed before said Bench while
deciding that case.
[27]
Now coming to the case in hand, the claimants have proved
one Sale Deed No.1-1597, dated 25.2.2015, which was executed 4(four)
years after the date of notification. Therefore, it would not be safer and
prudent to rely on it. The claimants also proved another Sale Deed
bearing No.1-9625, dated 12.11.2001, wherein a very small tract of
land of 2 karas 2 krantas 14.5 dhurs (628 square feet) of „Bastu‟ class of
land of Mouja-Agartala Town, sheet No.3 was sold at Rs.90,000/-, i.e.,
@ Rs.24,76,440/- per kani. This deed was executed 9(nine) years prior
to the date of the notification. Learned L.A. Judge relied on said deed.
[28]
From the side of L.A. Collector, the witness, Sri Narendra
Chandra Deb, proved one Sale Deed bearing No.1-1287, dated
4.2.2011, of Mouja-Chandinamura (erstwhile Ramnagar), wherein a
„Nal‟ class of land from RS plot Nos.3719, 3690 and 3322/9326 was sold
@ Rs.10,00,000/- per kani. From the assessment note of the L.A.
Collector, it appears that the L.A. Collector did not rely on said sale deed
reflecting that said land was situated at a distance of 3900 ft. away from
the acquired land. When the L.A. Collector did not rely on said deed, it
will not be much helpful for the appellant to gain support of the same.
In the said assessment note, the L.A. Collector further observed that the
area of acquisition was not very large, and the utilization of all the
classes of lands were similar, and therefore, L.A. Collector decided not
to apply belting method. The L.A. Collector actually relied on another
sale deed (not proved into evidence), wherein „Nal‟ class of land was
sold @ Rs.13,33,333/- per kani about 5(five) months prior to the
acquisition, but despite
the
same, he
did not fix the
rate of
compensation at the said rate, as even, according to the L.A. Collector,
there was trend of escalation of price of land everywhere. Finally, the
rate of Rs.15,00,000/- per kani was fixed by him, taking note of
valuation assessed by the SDM, Sadar. However, as the said deed
bearing the rate of Rs.13,33,333/- was not proved in the evidence.
[29]
In such a situation, there is no other alternative document
except to rely on Exbt.2, as indicated above, subject to consideration of
all the advantages and disadvantages attached therewith vis-a-vis the
acquired land. The witness of the L.A. Collector has admitted in his
evidence that the acquired land was situated within 500 meters from
Durga Chowmuhani Market and Ramnagar Higher Secondary School and
Bani Bidhya Pith H.S. School were also situated within 500 meters to 1
km from the acquired land. Thus, it appears that the acquired land,
though adjacent to the Indo-Bangla border, was situated within Agartala
Township and all urbanized facilities were available within that area.
[30]
This Court is of the view that even though the acquired land
is of „Nal‟ class, it can be made usable as „Bastu‟ class of land by certain
earth-filling and thereby making it comparable to Exbt.2. Therefore,
some amount is required to be deducted on the count of development
cost from the consideration price of Exbt.2. No map has been submitted
by the claimants to show the distance of acquired land from the land of
Exbt.2, and therefore, normal inference will be that it is situated at a
considerable distance from the acquired land. Moreover, the land of
Exbt.2 is comparatively smaller than the acquired land. Therefore, some
deductions are required to be made further on above said two counts to
make the value of the acquired land comparable to the sale price of
Exbt.2. According to this Court, it will be just and proper to deduct 45%
(15% for development cost, 15% for distance and 15% for smaller plot
size of Exbt.2) from the consideration price of Exbt.2. After such
deduction, the same will fetch the approximate value of the acquired
land as it was in the year 2001. Therefore, the value of acquired land in
2001 is assessed at Rs.24,76,000 – 45% = Rs.13,61,800/-. Due to the
rapid escalation of prices in that locality, as indicated by the L.A.
Collector, at least 10% may be increased for every two years from the
above said value on account of such escalation. Therefore, further 45%
is required to be added with the same for such escalation for next nine
years, which comes to Rs.19,74,610/- rounded off to Rs.20,00,000/-.
The
value
of
the
acquired
land
is
accordingly
determined
at
Rs.20,00,000/- per kani.
[31]
In the result, the appeal is partly allowed. The claimants will
get compensation @ Rs.20,00,000/- along with 30% solatium, 12%
additional compensation, and all statutory interests and costs as granted
by learned L.A. Judge in the impugned award.
The appeal is accordingly disposed of.
Send down the LCRs along with a copy of the judgment
immediately.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
SUJAY
GHOSH
Dinashree
SUJAY GHOSH
Date: 2024.11.29
17:26:12 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review