Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC010261432017
2026:GAU-AS:7512
IN THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
MFA/53/2017
The Union of India,
Represented By The General Manager,
N.F. Railway, Maligaon, Guwahati-11,
Assam.
…..Appellant
-Versus-
For Appellant
For Respondent
Date of Hearing
Date of Judgment
1.
M/S Shree Mahalaxmi Mills and Anr.,
M.G. Road, Fancy Bazar, Guwahati-1.
2.
The General Manager,
South East Central Railway,
Bilaspur, Pin Code-495001.
:
……Respondent
Mr. G. Goswami,Advocate
:
Mr. Divyansh Rathi, Advocate
:
17.02.2026
:
29.05.2026
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MRIDUL KUMAR KALITA
MFA/53/2017
Page 1
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
[1]
Heard Mr. G. Goswami, the learned Standing Counsel, N.F. Railways,
appearing for the appellant. Also heard Mr. Divyansh Rathi, the
learned counsel for the respondents.
[2]
This appeal under Section 23 of the Railway Claims Tribunal Act,
1987 has been filed against the common Judgment and Order dated
24.11.2016 passed by the Railway Claims Tribunal, Guwahati Bench
in Original Application No. 479/2007, whereby the Railway Claims
Tribunal has directed the present appellant to refund the under
charges and demurrage charges imposed on the respondent No. 1
by the appellant, along with an interest @ 9% per annum from the
date of filing of the original application till the date of realization.
[3]
The facts relevant for consideration of this appeal, in brief, are that
the respondent No. 1 had booked a consignment from Tilda(TLD) to
the destination i.e., New Guwahati (NGC). The consignment booked
by the respondent No. 1 said to contain 3,760 quintals of rice. The
said consignment was booked @ Rs.109.46 per quintal.
[4]
It is also stated that the distance between the originating station i.e.
Tilda(TLD) to the destination i.e. New Guwahati(NGC) is 1570 kms
and the freight calculated on the aforesaid consignment was to the
tune of Rs.4,11,570/-. However, the present appellant owing to
excess weight of the aforesaid consignment imposed the penal
undercharges to the tune of Rs. 31,733 as well as demurrage
charges at the destination station to the tune of Rs.20,475/- and
MFA/53/2017
Page 2
thereby, the respondent No. 1 was made to pay an excess charge of
Rs.57,962/-.
[5]
The present respondent filed an original application before the
Railway Claims Tribunal, Guwahati Bench claiming refund of the
excess freight charges paid by him. The said original application was
registered as Original Application No. 479/2007. The said original
application was taken up by the Railway Claims Tribunal, along with
45 other original applications where similar questions of law was
involved. Ultimately, by the impugned judgment dated 24.11.2016,
the Railway Claims Tribunal directed the present appellants to
refund the excess charges imposed on the respondent No. 1, along
with the simple interest @ 9% per annum.
[6]
Mr. G. Goswami, the learned Standing Counsel for the appellant has
submitted that the respondent authority had lawfully imposed the
punitive charges for overloading the wagon by the respondent No.
1. He submits that though, a full bench of this Court in the case of
the “Megha Technical & Engineers (Pvt.) Ltd. Vs. The Union of India &
Ors.”, W.A. No. 333/2010 had held that under Section 73 of the
Railways Act, 1989, punitive charges cannot be imposed without
affording an opportunity of being heard to the person on whom the
charges were sought to be imposed, however, recently the Apex
Court in the Judgment of “Union of India Vs. Megha Technical &
Engineers (Pvt.) Ltd.” (SLP (c) No. 8024/2018) has set aside the
aforesaid judgment of the full bench of this court and has held that
when excess weightage has been detected at the time of offloading,
it would be practically difficult for the railways to issue a show-cause
MFA/53/2017
Page 3
notice to consignor or the consignee and to hold a mini trial to
determine the question of excess weight and levy of compensatory
charges. He, therefore, submits that the railways were well within
their right to impose the punitive charge for overloading of the
wagons by the respondent No. 1.
[7]
He submits that the impugned judgment of the Railway Claims
Tribunal is also bad in as much as it failed to take into consideration
that burden of proving that the weight declared by the consignor, at
the time of issuance of railway receipt to him is the correct weight
of the consignment and that no penal freight should be imposed, is
on the applicant, who moves the original application before the
Railway Claims Tribunal in view of the provisions of Section 110 of
the Railways Act, 1989. He submits that the Railway Claims Tribunal
has erred by holding that it was the burden of the appellant to
prove that there was overloading of the consignment as Section 110
of the Railways Act, 1989 cast such burden on the person claiming
compensation.
[8]
The learned Standing Counsel for the appellant further submits that
though railway receipts are prima facie evidence of the weight and
number of packages stated in the said receipt, however, in a case
where the consignment in a wagon load and the weight or number
of packages is not checked by a railway servant authorized in this
behalf and a statement to that effect is recorded in such railway
receipt the burden of proving the weight, or as the case may be the
numbers of packages stated therein shall lie on the consigner.
MFA/53/2017
Page 4
[9]
He submits that in the instant case in the railway receipt produced
by the respondent No. 1 before the Railway Claims Tribunal clearly
shows that the said receipts were issued without any supervision by
any of the railway officials and hence, it was incumbent on the
respondent No. 1 to prove the weight of the consignment in the
proceedings before the Railway Tribunal.
[10] He submits that as the respondent as original applicant before the
Railway Claims Tribunal had failed to relieve the burden cast on him
under the proviso to Section 65 (2) as well as Section 110 of the
Railways Act, 1989 the Tribunal was wrong in allowing the original
application by shifting the burden to the union of India.
[11] In support of his submission, the learned Standing Counsel for the
appellant has cited following rulings:i. “Union of India Vs. Megha Technical & Engineers (Pvt.) Ltd.”
(supra);
ii. “Union of India Vs. M/s Indian Oil Corporation Limited”
[judgment dated 06.01.2026 in MFA No. 76/2014.]
[12] The learned Standing Counsel for the appellant has also produced
during the course of hearing a copy of theweighment chart,
wherein, he claims the excess weight in case of the consignment
booked by respondent No. 1 has been mentioned, however, he fairly
submits that said weighment chartwas not produced by the
MFA/53/2017
Page 5
Railwaysbefore the Railway Claims Tribunal as reflected in the
impugned judgment.
[13] He further submits that though a discovery application was filed by
the respondent No.1 before the Railway Claims Tribunal, however,
the railway are not required to preserve the documents, relating to
booking of consignment beyond six months. In support of his
submissions, he has cited a ruling of this court in the case of “The
Union of India Vs. M/S Shree Gopal Enterprises” in MFA Case No.
269/2010.
[14] He submits that the appellant has legally imposed the punitive
charges on therespondent No. 1, when the consignment book by
him was found to be excess, when same was weighedbefore the
destination station by the railways, hence, he submits that the
Railway Claims Tribunal had erred in allowing the original application
filed by the respondent No. 1. He, therefore, submits that this
appeal may be allowed and the impugned judgment of the Railway
Claims Tribunal may be set aside.
[15] On the other hand, Mr. D. Rathi, the learned counsel for the
respondent No. 1, has submitted that the Tribunal has rightly
allowed the original application filed by the respondent No. 1, as
appellant had failed to adduce any evidence before the Railway
Claims Tribunal to prove that the assignment booked by the
respondent No. 1 was in excess of the weight mentioned in the
railway receipt.
MFA/53/2017
Page 6
[16] He submits that, even assuming, but not admitting that if the
consignment was found to be overweight, when weighed by the
Railways, it was incumbent upon the appellant authority under the
proviso Section 73 of the Railway’s Act, 1989 that it should have
unloaded the excess amount and recovered cost of such unloading
and any charge for detention of wagon in that regard, however,
nothing of that sort was done in this case which belies the claim of
railway authority regarding overloading of the consignment by the
respondent No. 1.
[17] The learned counsel for the respondent No. 1 submits that though
in some of the original applications, which were taken up along with
the original application filed by the present respondent, the railways
had filed some documents in support of its contention, however, as
regards the present respondent No 1 is concerned, they did not file
even a single document in support of their contention. He submits
that the Railway Claims Tribunal was right in holding that the
railways (present appellant) had failed to prove that there was an
overloading of consignment as no evidence was adduced by the
railways before the Railway Claims Tribunal.
[18] The learned counsel for the respondent No. 1 has also submitted
that before the Railway Claims Tribunal, in the proceeding of original
application No. 479/2007, the present respondent No. 1 had also
filed an application for discovery of documents under Section
18(3)(b) of the Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987. However, the
railways failed to produce even a single document. He also submits
MFA/53/2017
Page 7
that since the appellant has failed to abide by the order of the
Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987 regarding discovery application
filed by the present respondent No. 1 before the Railway Claims
Tribunal Act, 1987 and adverse inference may be drawn against the
railways that they do not possess any such document.
[19] He also submits that though the judgment of the full bench of this
court in the case of “Megha Technical & Engineers (Pvt.) Ltd. Vs. The
Union of India &Ors.” (supra) has been set aside by the Apex Court
in the case cited by the learned Standing Counsel of Railways.
However, he submits that the facts of the said case are
distinguishable from the facts of the instant case in as much as in
the said case the Apex Court observed that when the excess weight
has been detected at the time of offloading, it would be practically
difficult for the railways to issue show-cause notice. Whereas, in the
instant case, no offloading was done and it was the claim of the
railways that excess weight was found when the wagons were
weight in between the originating station and the destination station
and nothing was informed to the respondent No. 1 regarding the
basis of imposing punitive charges under Section 73 of the Railways
Act, 1989. He, therefore, submits that the Railway Claims Tribunal
has rightly directed the railways to refund the punitive charge as
well as demurrage imposed on the appellant and same needs no
interference by this court.
[20] I have considered the submissions made by the learned counsel for
both sides and have gone through the materials available on record,
including the original records received before the Railway Claims
MFA/53/2017
Page 8
Tribunal Act, 1987. I have also gone through the rulings cited by the
learned counsel for both sides.
[21] After going through the judgment of the Supreme Court of India
delivered in the case of “Union of India Vs. Megha Technical &
Engineers (Pvt.) Ltd.” (supra), it appears that though by the said
judgment the judgment delivered by the full bench of this court in
Writ Appeal No. 333 / 2010 was set aside, however, it was not held
in the said judgment that no opportunity of hearing ought to be
given before imposing penalty on account of excess weight being
detected in a consignment. It has only recognized the practical
difficulties in doing so at the time of offloading when such excess
weight has been detected, rather the Apex Court in the aforesaid
judgment has emphasized the need for developing and introducing
effective scientific methods to prove allegations of the excess weight
by the Indian Railways.
[22] It is further pertinent to note that in the said case after finding that
the judgment passed by the full bench of this court which was
impugned before the Apex Court in the aforesaid case was complied
with by the railways and a show cause notice was issued to the
respondent, the Apex Court found the impugned judgment to be
obsolete and redundant and, therefore, it was set aside. However, it
observed that the railways must have introduced some effective
scientific method to meet with such challenges. The challenge
before the court was whether the consigner or the consignee is
entitled to an opportunity of hearing before imposition of penalty on
account of excess weight being detected in a consignment. This
MFA/53/2017
Page 9
court is of considered opinion that such opportunity has not been
ruled out in the case of “Union of India Vs. Megha Technical &
Engineers (Pvt.) Ltd.” (supra), by the Apex Court rather the Apex
Court has emphasized on more effective scientific method to meet
the said challenge.
[23] In the instant case, it appears that under charges of Rs.31,733/(Rupees Thirty One Thousand Seven Hundred and Thirty Three
only)as well as demurrage charges of Rs.20,475/- (Rupees Twenty
Thousand Four Hundred and Seventy Five only) were imposed on
the respondent No.1, in addition to the freight charges of Rs.
4,11,570/-(Rupees Four Lakhs Eleven Thousand Five Hundred and
Seventy).
[24] On perusal of the records of this case, it appears that the
respondent No. 1, in addition to the copies of railway receipts,
which indicates that the consignment booked by the respondent No.
1said to contain 3,760 quintals of rice, has also submitted sale
invoice issued by Agrawal Foods and Goyal Udyog, as well as money
receipts against the same, which also indicates the same quantity of
rice. As such the burden cast on the claimant by statute was
relieved by the respondent No. 1. Whereas, the present appellant
produced no documents before the Railway Claims Tribunal not
even the weighment chartwhich could have shown the excess
weight of the consignment by the respondent No. 1. The appellant
has failed to rebut the evidence adduced by the respondent No.1 in
form of railway receipt, sale invoices and money receipts to show
MFA/53/2017
Page 10
that the weight of the consignment as mentioned in the railway
receipt where the correct weight.
[25] In the case of“Jagjit Cotton Textile Mills Vs. Chief Commercial
Superintendent N.R. and Ors.” reported in “(1998) 5 SCC 126” the
Supreme Court of India has upheld the validity of Section 73 of the
Railways Act, 1989 and held that the said provision is not violative
of the Article 14 of the Constitution of India. It recognized the
railway's right to impose punitive charges in case of excess weight is
found in a consignment, However, in the said case also, it has not
ruled out the right of the consignor or consignee to know as to how
much excess weight was found by the railway and on what basis
such excess weight is alleged. The right of giving an opportunity of
hearing was not ruled out by the Apex Court, while deciding the
validity of the provisions contained in Section 73 of the Railways
Act, 1989.
[26] In the instant case, though the learned Standing Counsel for
Railways had produced a photocopy of weighment chartat the
hearing of this appeal, however, no such document was available in
the record before the Tribunal when the impugned judgment was
passed. Neither there is any indication that at any point of time such
weighment chartwas furnished to the respondent No. 1, therefore,
there is no materials on record to indicate on what basis the
railways imposed punitive charges, and, how much excess weight
was found by the railways. As such, this court is of considered
opinion that the Railway Claims Tribunal has not erred in directing
the appellant to refund the under charges and demurrage charges
MFA/53/2017
Page 11
paid by the respondent No.1 for which no basis exists in the records
before this court or before the Railway Claims Tribunal.
[27] In view of the discussions made and reason cited in the foregoing
paragraphs, this court is of considered opinion that this appeal lacks
merit.
[28] This appeal is, accordingly, dismissed.
[29] Send back the records of the original application to the Railway
Claims Tribunal, along with a copy of this judgment.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
Munmu
n Boruah
MFA/53/2017
Digitally signed
by Munmun
Boruah
Date: 2026.05.30
11:12:57 +05'30'
Page 12
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review