Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/8
GAHC010286742025
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/448/2026
THE UNION OF INDIA
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY, GOVERNMENT OFFICE INDIA,
MINISTRY OF COMMUNICATIONS, DEPARTMENT OF POSTS,DAK
BHUWAN NEW DELHI 1
2: THE SECRETARY
GOVT OF INDIA
MINISTRY OF COMMUNICATIONS DEPARTMENT OF
TELECOMMUNICATION
SAMCHAR BHAWAN NEW DELHI 1
3: THE GENERAL MANAGER
POSTSL ACCOUNT WING
NEW DELHI 54
4: THE CHIEF POSTMASTER GENERAL ASSAM
MEGHDOOT BHUWAN
GUWAHATI ASSAM PIN 7 81001
5: THE DIRECTOR
POSTAL ACCOUNT WING
DEPARTMENT OF POSTS
DAK BHUWAN NEW DELHI 1
6: THE CONTROLLER OF COMMUNICATION ACCOUNT
ASSAM TELECOM CIRCLE
GUWAHAT
VERSUS
IMRANA BEGUM
POSTAL ASSISTANT, DO FAKHARUL ISLAM MOTIRAM BORA PATH, WARD
NO 13 , PO NAGAON , DIST NAGAON ASSAM
Page No.# 2/8
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. B CHAKRAVARTY,
Advocate for the Respondent : MR D N SARMA, FOR CAVEATOR
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MICHAEL ZOTHANKHUMA
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KAUSHIK GOSWAMI
ORDER
02.02.2026
(M. Zothankhuma, J)
1.
Heard Mr. B. Chakravarty, learned counsel for the writ petitioners and Mr.
D.N. Sarma, learned counsel for the respondent/caveator.
2.
The petitioners have put to challenge the impugned order dated
26.06.2025 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Guwahati in Original
Application No.040/00169/2019, by which the writ petitioners have been
directed to consider the case of the respondent for appointment as Assistant
Accounts Officer against available vacancy and to promote her w.e.f the date of
joining of the junior in the promoted post, within a period of three months from
the date of receipt of the order.
3.
The learned counsel for the writ petitioners submits that the respondent
could not be promoted to the post of Assistant Accounts Officer, inasmuch as,
the Recruitment Rules required the candidate to have 9 (nine) years of
qualifying service in Level-4, i.e. the feeder post of Postal Assistant which was
being held by the respondent. The respondent had been allowed to participate
Page No.# 3/8
in the examination/selection process for the post of Assistant Accounts Officer,
despite not having the nine years qualifying service. However, even though the
respondent had passed the examination, the respondent could not be promoted
due to the respondent not having the qualifying service.
4.
The counsel for the respondent, on the other hand submits that in terms
of the Note to Column-11 of the Schedule provided in “The Indian Posts &
Telecommunications Accounts & Finance Service (IP&TAFS) Group “B” (Accounts
Officers & Assistant Accounts Officers) Recruitment Rules, 2018” (hereinafter
referred to as the “Rules”), a senior can be considered for promotion when his
juniors, who have the qualifying or eligibility service are considered for
promotion. The only requirement is that the seniors should have completed
more than half of such qualifying or eligibility service, or 2 years, whichever is
less. Further, they should have successfully completed their probation period for
promotion to the next higher Grade along with their juniors who had already
completed such qualifying or eligibility service.
5.
The learned counsel for the respondent submits that though at first glance
it appears that a junior cannot have a longer length of qualifying or eligibility
service than his seniors, Rule 38 of the Posts and Telegraphs Manual, Volume IV,
Chapter-I, hereinafter referred to as the “Manual” shows that a junior can have
a longer length of qualifying or eligibility service than his seniors in certain
situations. He submits that Assam is made up of 11 Circles/Divisions. When a
person is transferred from one Division to another on own request, though the
transferred person would become junior to those persons already serving in the
transferred Circle/Division. He submits that one Sri Prabitra Saharia had initially
Page No.# 4/8
joined as a Postal Assistant in Guwahati Division on 27.11.2006. The
respondent, on the other hand had joined the Darrang Circle/Division as Postal
Assistant on 29.12.2009. However, when Sri Prabitra Saharia was transferred to
Darrang Circle/Division on own request, in terms of Rule 38 of the “Manual”, his
seniority as Postal Assistant had to be counted from the date he joined the new
Division, wherein he became junior to the present respondent. As Sri Prabitra
Saharia had the eligibility criteria/qualifying service of 9 years for participating in
the examination/selection process for the post of Assistant Accounts Officer, in
terms of the Notification dated 19.04.2018 for recruitment to the post of
Assistant Accounts Officer by way of Limited Departmental Competitive
Examination (LDCE), the respondent also became qualified to participate in the
selection process in terms of the Note to Column 11 of the Schedule to the
Rules. He accordingly submits that though Shri Pabitra Saharia had failed the
examination, the respondent had passed the said examination and as such,
there was no infirmity in the direction of the learned Tribunal to promote the
respondent to a vacant post of Assistant Accounts Officer.
6.
Rule 38 of the Transfers and Posting-General Rules states as follows :
“38.
Transfer at one’s own request.
(1) Transfers of officials when desired for their own convenience should
not be discouraged if they can be made without injury to the rights of
others. However, as a general rule, an official should not be transferred
from one unit to another, either within the same Circle, or to another
Circle unless he is permanent. As it is not possible to accommodate an
official borne on one gradation list into another gradation list without
injury to the other members in that gradation list such transfers should
not ordinarily be allowed except by way of mutual exchange. Transfers by
way of mutual exchange, if in them-selves inherently unobjectionable,
Page No.# 5/8
should be allowed, but in order to safeguard the rights of men borne in
the gradation lists of both the offices, the official brought in should take
the place, in the new gradation list; that would have been assigned to him
had he been originally recruited in that unit or the place vacated by the
official with whom he exchanges appointment, whichever is the lower.
Note-Transfer of officials, who are not permanent in the grade, may, in
deserving cases, be permitted with the personal approval of the Head of
Circle/Administrative Office
(2) When an official is transferred at his own request but without
arranging for mutual exchange, he will rank junior in the gradation list of
the new unit to all officials of that unit on the date on which the transfer
order issued, including also all persons who have been approved for
appointment to that grade as on that date,
(3) If the old and the new unit form parts of a wider unit for the purpose
of promotion to a higher cadre, the transferee (whether by mutual
exchange or otherwise) will retain his original seniority in the gradation list
of the wider unit.
7.
The Note to Column 11 of the Schedule to the Rules states as follows :’
“Note: Where juniors who have completed their qualifying or eligibility
service are being considered for promotion, their seniors would also be
considered provided they are not short of the requisite qualifying or
eligibility service by more than half of such qualifying or eligibility service,
or two years, whichever is less, and have successfully completed their
probation period for promotion to the next higher grade along with their
juniors who have already completed such qualifying or
eligibility service.”
8.
The guidelines to check/scrutinize and prepare a tentative/provisional List
regarding the candidates who can take part in the LDCE, for filling up the vacant
posts of Assistant Accounts Officer, 2018, in terms of the Notification dated
Page No.# 6/8
19.04.2018 has been set out in the Communication No.301(05)/2018/PA
Admn.III/1363 to 1420 dated 18.07.2018 issued by the Government of India,
Ministry of Communication, Department of Posts, Postal Accounts Wing, Dak
Bhavan, New Delhi, which states at paragraph-12 as follows :
“12. It is assumed that maximum no. of candidates are eligible as per
their own service records. Hence, for ineligible candidates because of not
fulfilling length of service criteria, they may be contacted on telephone
available in Annexure 'C' prepared by respective SNOs and may be asked
to clarify/justify their eligibility for AAO LDCE 2018 under relevant clause
of Recruitment Rules in time bound manner. This contacting on telephone
may be used only as a last resort. Based on the clarifications, Screening
Committee may seek additional records from respective DDOs and
check/scrutnize it accordingly. It is reiterated that no documents should be
sought/called/taken from the candidates.
For this purpose, all seniors for whom Note below point 2 Col. 11 of
RRs is/might be applicable may be considered eligible whether their
eligible juniors (as per the same gradation list) by virtue of length of
service as prescribed and graduate in event of candidate being other than
JA/SAa) applied for examination or not or
b) if applied got rejected for incomplete form or
c) didn't appear after being issued roll no. or
d) didn't appear in all 6 papers.”
9.
The Gradation List of Postal Assistants as on 04.09.2018 made by the
Superintendant of Post Offices, Darrang Division, Tezpur on 04.09.2018 shows
the respondent’s (who is at Sl. No.91) date of entry as Postal Assistant on
29.12.2009. Shri Pabitra Saharia, who was allowed to take part in the LDCE for
Page No.# 7/8
the post of Assistant Accounts Officer along with the respondent, is at Sl.
No.151 and his date of entry as Personnel Accounts officer has been shown to
be 27.11.2006.
10.
The above clearly shows that despite Shri Pabitra Saharia having joined
the post of Postal Assistant 3 years prior to the entry of the respondent as
Postal Assistant, Shri Pabitra Saharia was made junior to the respondent on
account of Rule 38 of the Manual.
11.
The above Gradation List and the facts enumerated therein show that in
the Darrang Division, Shri Pabitra Saharia is junior to the respondent, though
he had joined the post of Postal Assistant earlier. However, in view of Rule 38 of
the Manual and the Note to Column 11 of the Schedule to the Rules, the
respondent has the eligibility criteria of service for participating in the LDCE, as
she has more than half of the required 9 years of qualifying/eligibility service. As
such, when the respondent has the qualifying/eligibility service period for taking
part in the selection process, the respondent would have to be promoted as per
law, as she had passed the said examination.
12.
In view the reasons stated above, we do not find any ground to interfere
with the impugned order passed by the learned Tribunal.
13.
The writ petition is accordingly dismissed.
JUDGE
JUDGE
Page No.# 8/8
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review