Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA 56 OF 2022
Kanhaiya Udairaj Yadav, IRLA No.11215738,
Assistant Commandant (Electrical), D.I.G. Headquarters, B.S.F.,
R.K. Puram, New Delhi-110056.
….Appellant.
Vrs.
1. Abinash Nanda, Assistant Commandant (Electrical),
Care of Inspector General, Border Security Force, Frontier Headquarters,
Tripura, P.O. Salbagan, P.S. Capital Complex, Salbagan,
Agartala, Tripura-799012.
2. Union of India, through its Secretary,
Ministry of Home Affairs, North Block,
Central Secretariat, New Delhi-110001.
3. The Director General, Border Security Force,
C.G.O. Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003.
4. The Inspector General, Border Security Force,
Frontier Headquarters, Tripura, Salbagan, Agartala,
Tripura-799001.
5. Sri Pradeep Suthar, IRLA No.11217305,
Assistant Commandant (Electrical), SHQ BSF
Ferozpur, Ferozpur Cantonment, Moga Road,
Punjab-152001.
...Respondents.
WA 26 OF 2022
1. Union of India, represented by the Secretary,
Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India,
North Block, Central Secretariat, New Delhi-110001.
2. The Director General, BSF,
C.G.O. Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003.
3. Inspector General, Border Security Force,
Frontier Headquarters, Salbagan, Agartala,
Tripura.
….Appellants.
Vrs.
1. Abinash Nanda, son of Sri Ambika Charan Nanda,
Assistant Commandant (Electrical),
C/O Inspector General, Border Security Force, Frontier Headquarters,
P.O. Salbagan, P.S. NCC, Agartala, Tripura-799012.
2. Sri Yadav Kanhaiya Udairaj,
Assistant Commandant (Electrical), D.I.G. Headquarters, B.S.F.,
R.K. Puram, New Delhi-110056.
3. Sri Pradeep Suthar, IRLA No.11217305,
Assistant Commandant (Electrical), SHQ BSF
Ferozpur, Ferozpur Cantonment, Moga Road,
Punjab-152001.
...Respondents.
IN WA NO. 56/2022
For the appellant(s)
For the respondent(s)
IN WA NO.26/2022
For the appellant(s)
For the respondent(s)
Argument heard and
judgment delivered on
Whether fit for
reporting
: Mr. J. Rajesh, Advocate.
Mr. K. K. Pal, Advocate.
: Mrs. S. Deb(Gupta), Advocate.
Mr. Biswanath Majumder, CGC.
: Mr. Biswanath Majumder, CGC
: Mr. J. Rajesh, Advocate.
Mr. K. K. Pal, Advocate.
Mrs. S. Deb (Gupta), Advocate.
: 24.01.2023
: Yes
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
[ T.Amarnath Goud, ACJ]
Both the writ appeals are directed against the judgment and
order dated 26.04.2021, passed by the learned Single Judge of this court in
WP(C) No.13 of 2020 whereby the learned Single Judge had allowed the
writ petition. Since the facts and issues are identical, these two appeals are
taken up together for hearing and disposal by this common judgment.
2.
The writ appeal no.56 of 2022 was filed by the respondent
no.4 in the writ petition and the writ appeal no.26 of 2022 was filed by the
respondent no.1, the Union of India in the writ petition.
3.
The petitioner in the writ petition has sought for the following
reliefs:
“It is, therefore, prayed that Your Lordship would graciously be
pleased to issue rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why the
respondents should not transmit all records relating to the case of the
Petitioner:
i)
ii)
iii)
As to a writ in the nature of mandamus directing the Respondents
and each of them to prepare the seniority list as per the Border
Security Force Rules.
As to a writ in the nature of certiorari quashing the final InterSe-Seniority of direct recruits and promotees (AC/Elect.,
Ac/Works & AC/WW) as per rota-quota system dated 31.12.2019
and the process of DPC for promotion of AC(Elect.) to DC
(Elect.) for the transitional vacancy year 2018.
As to a writ in the nature of mandamus directing the Respondents
and each of them to modify the seniority list as per guideline of
iv)
v)
4.
the judgment passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court and as well as
the office memorandum and as per the tentative
seniority/gradation list prior to the tentative seniority list dated
21.01.2019.
It is therefore prayed that your Lordship would graciously
pleased to consider the above and pleased to pass an interim
order staying effect of the final Inter-Se-Seniority list of direct
recruits and promotes(AE (Elec.), AC/Works & AC/WW) as per
rota-quota staying the process for promotion as per final InterSe-Seniority list of direct recruits and promotees (AE(Elec.),
AC/Works & AC/WW) as per rota-quota system dated 31.12.2019
till disposal of the writ petition.
AND
As to why such other order/orders should not be passed so as to
give full relief to the petitioner and upon cause shown to make
the Rule absolute.”
After hearing both sides, the learned Single Judge allowed the
writ petition with the following observations and directions:
“19. The solitary question that is material for our purpose
is that whether an Assistant Commandant who was not borne in the
cadre during the vacancy year or in the recruitment year can be
made senior to a person who had been substantively appointed in
the same vacancy year (2011-2012). This answer has been
unequivocally returned in K. Meghachandra Singh & Others
versus Ningam Siro & Others (supra) in the manner that “under
Service Jurisprudence, seniority cannot be claimed from a date
when the incumbent is yet to be borne in the cadre. In our
considered opinion, the law on the issue is correctly declared in
J.C. Patnaik (supra) and consequently we disapprove the norms on
assessment of inter-se seniority, suggested in N. R. Parmar
(supra).”
20. There cannot be any amount of dispute that when the
petitioner was promoted to the post of Assistant Commandant
(Electrical) by virtue of the order dated 30.12.2011, the
respondents No.4 and 5 were not born in the cadre. As such,
following the principles as laid down in K. Meghachandra Singh
& Others versus Ningam Siro & Others (supra), the inter-se
seniority as declared by the office memorandum dated 31.12.2019
is liable to be interfered with and accordingly it is interfered. The
said office memorandum dated 31.12.2019 stands set aside. The
seniority of the petitioner shall be restored and the name of the
petitioner shall be placed above the respondents No.4 and 5 and
the person who got promotion after the petitioner. Before the final
inter-se seniority list for the post of Assistant Commandant
(Electrical) is recast, no promotion be made to the next grade on
the basis of the said inter-se seniority list/gradation list of AC
(Electrical). The final seniority list in terms of the above direction
shall be recast within a period of 3(three) months from today.
This writ petition stands allowed to the extent as indicated
above.
There shall be no order as to costs.”
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the impugned
judgment and order, the respondent nos. 1 and 4 of the writ petition have
preferred the present writ appeals before this court.
5.
The case of the appellant in writ appeal no.56 of 2022
[Respondent no.4 in WP(C) No.13 of 2020] is that he being a direct
recruitee under the Electrical Wing of Border Security Force would be
governed by the Central Government’s Act and Rules and the promotees
(in-service candidates) including the writ petitioner (respondent no.1 in
Writ Appeal No.56 of 2022) are also seeking promotion and claiming
seniority above the direct recruitees. In this regard the appellant, has relied
upon the office memorandum dated 31.12.2019 and contended that in the
absence of any specific rules governing the central government employees
in which the appellant’s case clearly falls and is supposed to be considered
under the office memorandum which are the guidelines for considering the
case of the appellant. In this background the learned single judge erred in
considering the case of the writ petitioner in the light of K. Meghachandra
Singh & Ors Vrs. Ningam Siro & Ors, (2020) 5 SCC 689 and allowed the
writ petition. In so far as the said judgment which was referred by the
learned Single Judge is concerned, the matter pertains to the Manipur State
Police Services and the said rules do not govern the case of the appellant
herein. Further, this judgment had been referred to a larger bench of
Supreme Court and further contended that the said judgment is per
incuriam and accordingly, the appellant prayed to set aside the order of the
learned Single Judge and allow the writ appeal.
6.
The Union of India, who was the respondent no.1 in the writ
petition preferred the writ appeal no. 26/2022 and Mr. Biswanath
Majumder, learned CGC appearing for the Union of India has adopted the
argument of Mr. J. Rajesh, learned counsel of writ appeal no.56/2022 and
also prayed to allow the writ appeal filed by the Union of India. Mrs. S.
Deb Gupta, learned counsel appearing for the respondent no. 1 herein,
contended that the respondent no.1 is entitled for claiming his seniority
over and above the respondent-appellant of WA No.56/2022 and further
submitted that the judgment passed by the learned Single Judge is correct
and the writ appeals needs to be dismissed.
7.
This court after fair consideration of the arguments and the
documents and the judgments placed before this court, the issue for
consideration with regard to the inter se seniority between direct recruits
and promotees both stand on the separate footing and cannot be equated. It
is settled principle of law that when there are no governing rules on any
aspect, any administrative instructions issued would have standard recourse
of law.
8.
Mr. J. Rajesh, learned counsel appearing for the appellant in
WA No.56/2022 has submitted a written argument. The excerpts of the
written submission and written argument read as follows:“…. The seniority list of ‘Group A’ Officers in the
Electrical Engineering Cadre was finalized by Respondent
No.2 on 31.12.2019, based on the principles of inter-se
seniority, i.e ‘rota-quota’ as provided for by the DoPT OM
dated 04.03.2014. The Seniority list was prepared on the
recommendation of the Board of Officers (BOO) to apply the
rules provided in the DoPT OM dated 04.03.2014. The O.M.
dated 04.03.2014 is binding on the Central Armed Police
Forces, such as the Border Security Force, which falls under
the Ministry of Home Affairs.[Reference: Impugned Judgment
at Pg.374-392, O.M. dated 31.12.2019 at Pg.242-249, O.M.
dated 04.03.2014 at Pg.220-222, and Seniority List dated
31.12.2019 at Pg.250-260]
The Seniority List dated 31.12.2019 was implemented
by Respondent No. 2 to 4, complying with the directions
issued by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in W.P.(C) No.
1285 of 2019 titled Santosh Kumar v. Union of India and
Others, vide Order dated 07.03.2019 [Reference: Order dated
07.03.2019 at Pg.223-224.]
Permanently, based on the Seniority List dated
31.12.2019, the petitioner in WP(C) No.1285 of 2019,
i.e.Santosh Kumar, was promoted to Deputy Commandant
(Electrical). [Reference: Santosh Kumar at Srl. No.2 at
Pg.252].
It is respectfully submitted that the impugned
judgment has incorrectly set aside the O.M. dated 31.12.2019
and interfered with the final Seniority List dated 31.12.2019.
Vide the impugned judgment, the Ld. Single Judge inter alia
directed the Respondent No.2 to 4 as follows:i. Recast the seniority list and place Respondent No.1
above the Petitioner, and {Reference: Impugned Judgment at
Pg.391.}
ii. Until the seniority list is recast, no promotions can
be made to the rank of Deputy Commandant based on the
final Seniority List dated 31.12.2019. {Reference: Impugned
Judgment at Pg.392}.
………
…….. ………
WRITTEN ARGUMENT ON BEHALF OF THE
APPELLANT
A. The Office Memorandum dated 04.03.2014
controls the field for determining inter-se seniority between
Direct Recruits and Promotees and squarely falls within the
exception carved out in Paragraph 40 of the Judgment in K.
Meghachandra Singh and Ors. v. Ningam Siro and Ors.
(2020) 5 SCC 689.
It is submitted that the O.M. dated 04.03.2014 lays
down the fundamental principle of inter-se-seniority of Direct
Recruits and promotes in Central Civil Services. The said
O.M. operates in the present case regarding the dispute of
inter-se seniority and constitutes binding executive
instructions promulgated under Article 73 of the Constitution
of India,1950.
The O.M. dated 04.03.2014 states that the relative
seniority of direct recruits and promotes shall be determined
according to the rotation of vacancies reserved for direct
recruitment and promotion, respectively, in the Recruitment
Rules. The O.M. lays down that the date from which the
seniority would be calculated would be; (a) In the case direct
recruits; the initiation of the recruitment process in vacancy
year, which would also be the date of sending of requisition
for filling up of vacancies to the recruiting agency; and (b) In
the case of promotees, the date on which a proposal, complete
in all respect, is sent to Chairman-DPC for convening of DPC
to fill up the vacancies through promotion.
It is pertinent to mention that keeping in view the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in K. Meghachandra
(supra) dated 19.11.2019, Respondent No.2, Ministry of Home
Affairs has published the O.M. dated 13.08.2021 whereby the
application of the O.M. dated 04.03.2014 has been saved in
the following circumstances as set out in paragraph 7 of the
O.M. dated 13.08.2021, to ensure that there is equal and nonarbitrary treatment:
i. Where the inter se seniority of direct recruits and
promotees has already been decided in terms of the O.M.
dated 04.03.2014,
ii. Where the inter-se seniority could not be finalized
by 18.11.2019, i.e. the date of the Judgment in K.
Meghachandra (supra),
iii. In all cases of inter-se seniority where the
administrative Department/Cadre Authority has initiated the
recruitment process before 19.11.2019.
Therefore, it is submitted that the Ld. Single Judge
could not have applied the Judgment of K.
Mechachandra(supra) without considering that the O.M.
dated 04.03.2014 are binding executive instruction and rules
that control the field to determine inter-se seniority between
direct receuits and promotees.
However, the Judgment of K. Meghachandra (supra)
refers to the O.M. dated 04.03.2014, although it does not set
aside the same. Neither has Respondent No.1 challenged the
O.M. dated 04.03.2014, nor has Respondent No.1 denied that
the O.M. applies to stakeholders before this Hon’ble Court.
The impugned Judgment does not decide the question as to
whether the O.M. dated 04.03.2014 controls the principles for
inter-se seniority between direct recruits and promotees.
The Impugned Judgment bypassed the O.M. dated
04.03.2014 and incorrectly applied the Judgment of K.
Meghachandra (supra). It is pertinent to state that the
Judgment itself in Paraghaph 40 carves out the exception for
the application of the Judgment, even though it provides that
it only applies prospectively and not retrospectively.
It is respectfully submitted that the Petitioner and the
stakeholders before this Hon’ble Court squarely fall within
the exceptions caved out by the Judgment for the following
reasons:
i. Firstly, the Judgment was rendered in the specific
context of Manipur Police Services, a service of the State
Government, unlike Respondent No.1 to 3, which is a service
of the Central Government. For this reason, the Judgment in
paragraphs 36 and 37; resists the reliance on O.M. dated
04.03.2014 and excapes its folds based on the reasoning that
the same does not apply to the Manipur Police Services.
ii. Secondly, in paragraph 37, the Judgment concedes
that the O.M. dated 01.01.2018, promulgated by the State
Government, which adopts the O.M. dated 04.03.2014 passed
by the Central Government, will remain applicable and in
force prospectively from 01.01.2018. Therefore, it is clear that
the Hon’ble Supreme Court did not intend to disturb the
applicability of the O.M. 04.03.2014.
iii. Thirdly, the Judgment at paragraph 40 provides
two exceptions for its applicability and applicability of the
rota-quota principle. The relevant excerpt to the Judgment is
as follows:“40. The Judgment in N. R. Parmar (Supra) relating to the
Central Government employees cannot in our opinion,
automatically apply to the Manipur State Police Officers,
governed by the MPS Rules, 1965. We also feel that N.R.
Parmar (Supra) had incorrectly distinguished the longstanding seniority determination principles propounded in,
inter-alia, J.C. Patnaik (Supra), Suraj Prakash Gupta & Ors.
vs. State of J&K & Ors. 5 and Pawan Pratap Singh & Ors.
Vs. Reevan Singh & Ors.(Supra). These three judgments and
several others with like enunciation on the law for
determination of seniority makes it abundantly clear that
under Service Jurisprudence, seniority cannot be claimed
from a date when the incumbent is yet to be borne in the
cadre. In our considered opinion, the law on the issue is
correctly declared in J.C. Patnaik (Supra) and consequently
we disapprove the norms on assessment of inter-se seniority,
suggested in N. R. Parmar (Supra). Accordingly, the decision
in N.R. Parmar is overruled. However, it is made clear that
this decision will not affect the inter-se seniority already
based on N.R. Parmar and the same is protected. This
decision will apply prospectively except where seniority is to
be fixed under the relevant Rules from the date of
vacancy/the date of advertisement.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
iv. Therefore, it is clear that in the present case, as
the inter-se seniority has is based on the relevant rule, i.e., the
O.M. dated 04.03.2014, the same will remain protected, i.e.
that the seniority will be determined from the date of
vacancy/date of advertisement as stated in the O.M. dated
04.03.3014, and not from the date of appointment.
In Union of India v. Somasundaram Viswanath,
(1989) 1 SCC 175, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India held
as follows:“6. It is well-settled that the norms regarding
recruitment and promotion of officers belonging to the Civil
Services can be laid down either by a law made by the
appropriate Legislature or by rules made under the proviso
to Article 309 of the Constitution of India or by means of
executive instructions issued under Article 73 of the
Constitution of India in the case of Civil Services under the
Union of India and under Article 162 of the Constitution of
India in the case of Civil Services under the State
Governments. If there is a conflict between the executive
instructions and the rules made under the proviso to Article
309 of the Constitution of India, the rules made under proviso
to Article 309 of the Constitution of India prevail, and if there
is conflict between the rules made under the proviso to Article
309 of the Constitution of India and the law made by the
appropriate Legislature the law made by the appropriate
Legislature prevails. The question for consideration is
whether in the instant case there is any conflict between the
Rules and the Office Memorandum dated 30.12.1976, referred
to above. We have already noticed that there are different
rules framed under the proviso to Article 309 of the
Constitution of India for making recruitments to services in
the different departments and provisions have been made in
them for the constitution of Departmental Promotion
Committees for purposes of making recommendations with
regard to promotions of officers from a lower cadre to a
higher cadre. But these rules are to some extent skeletal in
character. No provision has been made in any of them with
regard to the procedure to be followed by the Departmental
Promotion Committees and their various functions and also
to the quorum of the Departmental Promotion Committees.
….The Office Memorandum dated 30.12.1976, therefore, is in
the nature of a complete code with regard to the topics dealt
with by it, unless there is anything in the Rules made under
the proviso to article 309 of the Constitution of India, which is
repugnant to the instructions contained in the Office
Memorandum, the Office Memorandum which is apparently
issued under article 73 of the Constitution of India is entitle
to be treated as valid and binding on all concerned. In the
instant case the Rules do not contain any of these details
except indicating who are all the persons who constitute the
Departmental Promotion Committee. We do not, therefore,
find any repugnance between the Rules and the Office
Memorandum…..”
(Emphasis Supplied)
It is respectfully submitted that Respondent No.2,
while deciding the representation of Respondent No.1 vide the
O.M. dated 31.12.2019, has categorically held that there is no
rule under the BSF (Engineering Officers) Recruitment Rules,
2000 and the BSF (Engineering Officers) Recruitment Rules,
2012 regarding the fixation of inter-se seniority. Therefore, no
provision conflicts with the O.M. dated 04.03.2014, a complete
code governing the norms for fixation of inter-se seniority. As a
result, the O.M. dated 04.03.2014 is binding on the Electrical
Engineering Cadre of the BSF.
For the reason stated above, Respondent No.2 issued
the O.M. dated 13.08.2021, which effectively resolved the
controversy regarding the applicability of the O.M. dated
04.03.2014 vis-a-vis the Judgment of K. Meghachandra (supra).
Pertinently, what has been laid down in the O.M. dated
13.08.2021 at Paragraph 7 is only an exposition of Paragraph
40 of the Judgment of K. Meghachandra (supra).
The Petitioner has been placed at Serial No.5 in the
seniority list dated 31.12.2019. The decision to retain this
formulation
of
seniority
was
taken
despite
the
objections/representations of Promotee officers such as
Respondent No.1. Further, based on this formulation, officers
from Serial No.1 to Serial No.3 of the Seniority List dated
31.12.2019 have already been promoted to the next rank of
Deputy Commandant (Electrical). Therefore, the Impugned
Judgment effectively creates two norms after the implementation
of the Seniority List dated 31.12.2019.
The decision of Respondent No.1 to Respondent No.3
vide O.M. dated 31.12.2019 is consistent with the object sought
to be achieved by the Judgment in K. Meghachandra (supra) as
the Judgment itself is based on the reasoning that the
judgments/common law governing the inter-se seniority must
necessarily yield to the relevant rules that provide for the
manner seniority such as the O.M. dated 04.03.2014. Hence, the
reliance on K. Meghachandra (supra) in the Impugned Judgment
is wholly incorrect in the context of the stakeholders before this
Hon’ble Court.
It is respectfully submitted that the Impugned
Judgment has the effect of unsettling the seniority list dated
31.12.2019 and will have far reaching consequences which will
directly and indirectly affect many officers who are not before
this Hon’ble Court. It is settled that once the seniority list has
been finalized, the same must not be unsettled. This principle has
gained acceptance by various precedents and is applicable more
so, in cases where promotions have already been given effect,
based on the seniority list.
For the reasons stated above, it is respectfully
submitted that the Impugned Judgment must be set aside, and the
decision taken by Respondent No.2 to Respondent No.4 while
issuing the O.M. dated 31.12.2019 and the final seniority list
dated 31.12.2019 must be upheld.
B. The Judgment of Rohitash Kumar and Ors. V. Om
Prakash Sharma, (2013) 11 SCC 451 is only applicable to the
General Duty Cadre and not the special cadres i.e., Electrical
Engineering cadre of the BSF.
That the Petitioner’s reliance on the Judgment of
Rohitash Kumar v. Omprakash, (2013) 11 SCC 451 is wholly
misplaced as this judgement is not applicable only to General
Duty (‘G.D.’) Officers and not to Officers in the Electrical
Engineering Cadre. The Officers of the Electrical Engineering
Cadre are governed by the cadre specific rules, i.e., BSF
(Engineering Officers) Recruitment Rules, 2000 and the BSF
(Engineering Officers) Recruitment Rules, 2012.
That Respondent No.2 and Respondent No.3 have
themselves made this correction earlier on 01.08.2017 while
clarifying that Rohitash Kumar (Supra) is not applicable to the
Officers who are the stakeholders before this Hon’ble Court.
Further, it is respectfully submitted that unlike the G.D. officers,
where the basic training of Promotees and Direct Entry Officers
is conducted together, the Electrical Engineering Officers do not
undergo the training with the Promotees.
The G.D. officers recruited through both the Direct
Entry mode and through promotions are appointed on the same
date, i.e. after the completion of their training which takes place
together, and for which they are given marks which affects their
overall seniority. However, the selection for the officers of the
Electrical Engineering Cadre is based on the marks obtained in
the written test.
Therefore, the Impugned Judgment incorrectly
applied the principle of law in Rohitash Kumar (supra) despite
the fact that the selection of the Electrical Engineering officers.
In case the Direct Entry Officer are ranked based on the date of
joining, it would completely frustrate the objective of “Selection
by Merit”.
It is submitted that the Impugned Judgment erred
while holding that the Judgment of Rohitash Kumar (supra) and
the rules applicable to the G.D. officer could apply to Electrical
Engineering Officers of the BSF. Therefore, as a consequence,
there can be no doubt regarding the applicability of the O.M.
dated 04.03.2014 to the Appellant.
In view of the submissions made above, it is humbly
prayed before this Hon’ble Court to set aside the Impugned
Order.”
9.
Mr. Biswanath Majumder, learned CGC for the Union of
India, the appellant in WA No. 26/2022 and the respondent nos. 1, 2 and 3
in WA No.56/2022 contended that as per the directions of the Delhi High
Court and the Kerala High Court, the tentative seniority list that was
published on 21.01.2019 was sent for consideration of Ministry of Home
Affairs and accordingly, the said tentative seniority list after being
approved by the Ministry of Home Affairs, the final inter se seniority list
dated 31.12.2019 was published. It is further contended by Mr. Majumder,
learned CGC that the Border Security Force (Seniority, Promotion and
Superannuation of Officers) Rules, 1978 has been superseded by the
Border Security Force (General Duty Officers) Recruitment Rules,2001
published vide GSR-351 dated 28.06.2001. Again, Mr. Majumder, learned
CGC reiterated that the rotation of quota has been applied only on available
direct recruits and promotees who were appointed against the same
vacancy year as per DoP & T OM dated 04.03.2014 and even the decision
in K. Meghachandra (supra) overruling the judgment dated 27.11.2012 in
Union of India & Ors. Vrs. N. R. Parmar, (2012) 13 SCC 340, the matter
has been referred to the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India on
05.03.2020. Mr. Majumder, learned CGC has strongly pressed on the DoP
& T OM dated 04.03.2014 urging that by that OM, the inter se seniority of
the direct recruitees and promotees who were appointed and promoted in
the vacancy year 2011-12, has been determined.
10.
In the light of above submissions of Mr. Majumder, learned
CGC, we may go through the OM dated 04.03.2014, issued by the DoP &
T vide Memorandum No.20011/1/2012/Estt.(D), in pursuance of the
judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of N.R Parmar
(supra) in consultation with the Department of Legal Affairs, Govt. of
India. The relevant part of the said memorandum is reproduced here-inbelow:
“b) The rotation of quota based on the available direct
recruits and promotees appointed against the vacancies of
a Recruitment Year, as provided in DOPT O.M. dated
7.2.1986/3.07.1986, would continue to operate for
determination of inter se seniority between direct recruits
and promotees;
“c) The available direct recruits and promotees, for
assignment of inter se seniority, would refer to the direct
recruits and promotees, who are appointed against the
vacancies of a Recruitment Year;
d) Recruitment Year would be the year of initiating the
recruitment process against a vacancy year;
e) Initiation of recruitment process against a vacancy year
would be the date of sending of requisition for filling up of
vacancies to the recruiting agency in the case of direct
recruits; in the case of promotees the date on which a
proposal, complete in all respects, is sent to
UPSC/Chairman-DPC for convening of DPC to fill up the
vacancies through promotion would be the relevant date.
f) The initiation of recruitment process for any of the
modes viz. direct recruitment or promotion would be
deemed to be the initiation of recruitment process for the
other mode as well;
g) Carry forward of vacancies against direct recruitment
or promotion quota would be determined from the
appointments made against the first attempt for filling up
of the vacancies for a Recruitment Year;
h) The above principles for determination of inter se
seniority of direct recruits and promotees would be
effective from 27.11.2012 the date of Supreme Court
Judgment in Civil Appeal No.7514-7515/2005 in the case
of N.R. Parmar Vs. UOI & Ors.
i) The cases of seniority already settled with reference to
the applicable interpretation of the term availability, as
contained in DoPT O.M. dated 7.2.86/3.7.86 may not be
reopened.”
11.
So, it is apparent from the OM dated 04.03.2014 that the inter
se seniority list of direct recruits and promotees in the Electrical
Engineering Cadre was finalized by the Director General, BSF (respondent
no.2 in the writ petition) on 31.12.2019 based on the principles of ‘rotaquota’ system and even the said seniority list was prepared as per
recommendation of Board of Officers applying the rules provided in the
DoP & T OM dated 04.03.2014. Further, it is gathered from the record that
based on this formulation, officers from Serial No.1 to Serial No.3 of the
Seniority List dated 31.12.2019 have already been promoted to the next
rank of Deputy Commandant (Electrical). So, the impugned judgment has
the impact of unsettling the seniority list dated 31.12.2019 and will have
mass consequences of direct and indirect affect to many of the officers who
are not before this court. So, the O.M. dated 04.03.2014 is binding on the
Central Armed Police Forces, such as the Border Security Force, which
falls under the Ministry of Home Affairs.
12.
In view of the above, this court finds that the judgment and
order dated 26.04.2021, passed by the learned Single Judge in WP(C)
No.13 of 2020, needs to be interfered and accordingly, the same is set aside
and quashed. The writ appeals are allowed. The inter se seniority list
published vide office memorandum dated 31.12.2019, by the Director
General of Police, the respondent no.2 in the impugned writ petition, shall
hold good.
13.
Both the writ appeals are, accordingly, disposed of. Pending
application, if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
sanjay
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review