Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/21
GAHC010204872025
2026:GAU-AS:3362
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WA/15/2026
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 9 ORS.
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS, NEW
DELHI, PIN-110001.
2: THE DIRECTOR GENERAL
CENTRAL RESERVE POLICE FORCE
BLOCK NO. 1
CGO COMPLEX
LODHI ROAD
NEW DELHI
PIN 110003
3: THE DY. INSPECTOR GENERAL (CR AND VIG)
OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE GENERAL
CENTRAL RESERVE POLICE FORCE
BLOCK NO. 1
CGO COMPLEX
LODHI ROAD
NEW DELHI
PIN 110003
4: THE INSPECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE
NORTH EASTERN SECTOR CENTRAL RESERVE POLICE FORCE
SHILLONG
MEGHALAYA PIN 793001
5: THE INSPECTOR GENERAL
OPERATION SECTOR
CENTRAL RESERVE POLICE FORCE
POLICE COMPLEX
ROWRIAH
JORHAT
Page No.# 2/21
ASSAM
PIN 785004
6: BHARAT KUMAR VAISHNAV (IRLAA 4858)
COMMANDANT 142
BATTALION
CENTRAL RESERVE POLICE FORCE
C/O OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE GENERAL
CENTRAL RESERVE POLICE FORCE
BLOCK NO. 1
CGO COMPLEX
LODHI ROAD
NEW DELHI PIN 110003
7: L. KIPGEN
(IRLA 70450)
DEPUTY COMMANDANT GROUUP CENTRE KHATKHATI
CENTRAL RESERVE POLICE FORCE
C/O OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE GENERAL
CENTRAL RESERVE POLICE FORCE
BLOCK NO. 1
CGO COMPLEX
LODHI ROAD
NEW DELHI 110003
8: SUNIL KR. SHAHI
SECOND IN COMMAND (IRLA 5884) 26 BATTALION
CENTRAL RESERVE POLICE FORCE
C/O OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE GENERAL
CENTRAL RESERVE POLICE FORCE
BLOCK NO. 1
CGO COMPLEX
LODHI ROAD
NEW DELHI 110003
9: RADHE SHYAM SINGH
COMMANDANT (IRL 4692)
COMMANDANT 94
BATTALION
CENTRAL RESERVE POLICE FORCE
C/O OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE GENERAL
CENTRAL RESERVE POLICE FORCE
BLOCK NO. 1
CGO COMPLEX
LODHI ROAD
NEW DELHI
Page No.# 3/21
PIN 110003
10: MAHESH VISHWAKARMA
SECOND IN COMMAND (IRLA 6538) 112 BATTALION
CENTRAL RESERVE POLICE FORCE
C/O OFFICE OF THE DG
CRPF
BLOCK NO. 1
CGO COMPLEX
LODHI ROAD
NEW DELHI 11000
VERSUS
SANTOSH KUMAR
ASSISTANT COMMANDANT (PS) (IRLA NO. 11192) (UNDER SUSPENSION),
PRESENTLY POSTED AT OFFICE OF THE INSPECTOR GENERAL
OPERATION, JORHAT, ASSAM, HEADQUARTERS DURING SUSPENSION AT
GROUP CENTRE KHATKHATI, CENTRAL RESERVE POLCE FORCE,
KHATKHATI, KARBI ANGLONG, ASSAM, PIN-782480.
Advocate for the Petitioner
: HAREESH GUPTA,
Advocate for the Respondent : MR. D GOGOI, MS T WAPANGLA,MR. R DEKA
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MICHAEL ZOTHANKHUMA
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KAUSHIK GOSWAMI
ORDER
06.03.2026
(M. Zothankhuma, J)
1.
Heard Mr. H. Gupta, learned counsel for the appellants, i.e., Union of India
and Mr. D. Gogoi, learned counsel for the respondent (writ petitioner).
2.
The impugned common judgment and order dated 06.03.2025 passed in
WP(C) Nos. 350/2023, 360/2023 is under challenge by way of this appeal.
Page No.# 4/21
3.
The learned Single Judge, vide the impugned judgment and order dated
06.03.2025, has directed the appellants not to conclude the three inquiry
proceedings initiated against the respondent, until and unless the alleged
mental illness of the respondent is examined by the Composite Hospital, CRPF,
Guwahati, comprising of a qualified psychiatrist and such other qualified medical
professionals as deemed necessary. The learned Single Judge held that after the
Medical Board of the Composite Hospital, CRPF, Guwahati, undertakes a proper
medical examination of the respondent and makes its decision, in terms of
Section 20 of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 (hereinafter
referred to as the Act), the petitioner should be allowed to file his
reply/representation to the 3 Inquiry Reports in relation to the three Inquiry
Proceedings, before the Disciplinary Authority.
4.
The learned counsel for the appellants submits that the three Inquiry
proceedings had been initiated against the respondent, who is an Assistant
Commandant in the CRPF, due to various charges of misconduct, which the
respondent wilfully did not participate in. The respondent was also given the
opportunity to engage a defence assistant. However, as the respondent did not
participate, ex-parte Inquiry Proceedings were held against him. The three
Inquiry Reports were also furnished to the respondent, to enable him to file
representations against the same. Instead of filing representation/s against the
Inquiry Reports, the respondent instead made a challenge to the three Inquiry
Proceedings and Inquiry Reports, vide WP(C) Nos. 350/2023, 360/2023 and
456/2023, on the ground that as he was having some physical and mental
impairment, i.e., he was a “person with disability” in terms of Section 2(s) of the
Act, the Inquiry Proceedings should not be concluded till he was fully cured. Due
Page No.# 5/21
to the learned Single Judge passing an interim order directing that no penalty
should be imposed on the respondent, unless and until a Medical Examination of
the respondent was conducted, vide the impugned judgment and order dated
06.03.2025, the respondent is still working in the CRPF as on date.
5.
The learned counsel for the appellants submits that in view of an
Exemption Notification dated 18.08.2021 having been issued by the Ministry of
Social Justice and Empowerment, in exercise of powers conferred by the proviso
to Section 20 of the Act for combatant personnel of CAPFs, the respondent is
not entitled to get any relief under Section 20 of the Act. He also submits that
the principles laid down in the case of Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal and
Another vs. Union of India and Others reported in (2023) 2 SCC 209
cannot be applied to the present case, as the writ petition had been filed in the
year 2023, i.e. after issuance of the Exemption Notification dated 18.08.2021.
The learned Counsel for the appellants submits that in terms of the judgment of
the Supreme Court in Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal (supra), the preliminary
question to be decided was as to whether disciplinary proceedings could be
instituted against the conduct of an employee, who allegedly had a mental
disability and whether the alleged misconduct was found to be connected to the
mental disability of the employee.
6.
The learned counsel for the appellants submits that in the present case,
the allegation of misconduct/charges framed against the respondent, was in
relation to a period prior to the respondent having made any claim before the
authorities that he was suffering from any mental disability, in terms of Section
2(s) of the Act and, as such, the issue of whether the respondent suffered from
Page No.# 6/21
any mental impairment at the relevant point of time was not an issue. He
submits that the impugned judgment and order of the learned Single Judge not
having addressed the main subject matter in issue, i.e. as the respondent did
not have any mental disability/impairment at the relevant point of time, the
issue of mental disability/impairment from a period after the alleged
misconduct, was irrelevant.
7.
The learned counsel for the respondent (writ petitioner) submits that the
respondent had been suffering from mental disability and this fact had been
informed to the authorities by the respondent’s wife on 26.07.2021. He also
submits that in terms of the opinion of the Medical Board of Central Institute of
Psychiatry, Kanke, Ranchi, made on 21.10.2022, in respect of a medical
examination conducted on the respondent on 18.10.2022, the respondent
suffered from severe depressive episode with psychotic symptoms, but currently
he was asymptomatic. He submits that the respondent’s case is covered by
Section 20 of the Act and the respondent cannot be discriminated against in any
Inquiry Proceeding, in terms of the said provisions. He accordingly submits that
the impugned judgment and order does not suffer from any infirmity and the
same should not be interfered with.
8.
We have heard the learned counsels for the parties.
9.
As can be seen from the impugned judgment and order passed by the
learned Single Judge in respect of the three writ petitions filed by the
respondent, the respondent has challenged the three Inquiry Proceedings,
wherein the Inquiry Officer in the 3 Inquiry Reports has found the respondent to
Page No.# 7/21
be guilty of all the charges framed against him in the three memorandum of
charges dated 18.09.2020, 19.01.2021 and 16.10.2020.
10.
In WP(C) 350/2023, which pertains to the memorandum of charge dated
18.09.2020, the respondent was charged with fraudulently and illegally getting
HRA @ 6% of his Basic Pay sanctioned w.e.f. 06.10.2017 to 30.09.2019, while
availing the benefit of a Government quarter in Ranchi, by submitting false
documents and false undertaking certificates.
11.
In WP(C) 360/2023 pertaining to the memorandum of charge dated
19.01.2021, four articles of charge had been framed against the respondent.
Article -1 was with regard to purchase of a flat on 04.06.2019. The revised
source of income for the flat in the respondent’s application, was that he had
withdrawn Rs. 2 lakhs from his salary savings, Rs.3.5 Lakhs from his GPF
Account, Rs.4.0 Lakhs from the PPF Maturity and Rs.35,50,000/- from Aditya
Birla Housing Finance Limited as housing loan. However, the GPF and PPF
amounts had not been actually withdrawn by the respondent during the said
period. Article-2 was that the respondent had not furnished required information
regarding the purchase of a Royal Enfield Motor Cycle and a Maruti Alto K-10 to
the authorities. Article-3 was with regard to the respondent not disclosing the
source of income of Rs.2 Lakh in his application dated 14.09.2015 for purchase
of a Maruti S Cross Car. Article-4 was with regard to the respondent not
furnishing the required information regarding the purchase of Mahindra XUV-500
car in February, 2016, amounting to Rs.13,08,280/-.
12.
In WP(C) 456/2023, the memorandum of charge dated 16.10.2020
Page No.# 8/21
contained eight articles of charge against the respondent, who was posted as
AC(PS) to IG, Jharkhand Sector Quarters, CRPF, Ranchi. The articles of charge in
the memorandum of charge dated 16.10.2020 was basically with regard to the
respondent
destroying
the
original
secret
cipher
messages
regarding
remittances of a sum of Rs. 12.5 Lakh and falsifying and fabricating secret
cipher messages showing deposits of Rs.10 Lakhs only, thereby embezzling Rs.
2.5 Lakhs on various occasions for his personal gain.
13. In the memorandum of charge dated 16.10.2020, the respondent had also
unauthorizedly linked his personal mobile No. 9430120739 with the official bank
account No. 31303458311 in favour of the IGP (Ops), CRPF, Ranchi in SBI
Branch of Hatia, to receive SMS alerts in place of the authorised account holder
of the above account, i.e., DIGP, Jharkhand Sector, CRPF, Ranchi without his
permission and had continued having the link even after moving to the office of
the IG, CRPF, Jorhat, Assam. The other article of charge against the respondent
in the memorandum of charge dated 16.10.2020 was that he had entered into
huge financial transactions in his salaried bank account bearing No.
10158066014 of SBI Branch, R. K. Puram, New Delhi, with his subordinates and
the force personnel having official dealings. Further, he had withdrawn
Rs.25,18,000/- from the official bank account no. 31303458311 in favour of
IGP(Ops), CRPF, Jharkhand, SBI Branch of Hatia, Ranchi, by way of eight
different transactions. He deposited a part of it but not all of it, as per the SSF
cash book. Further, the respondent did not hand over three official rubber
stamps issued to him for official use to his counterpart, while handing over the
charge of his office on 16.07.2019. Instead, he had handed over three different
rubber stamps, which were unauthorizedly fabricated/prepared by him for wilful
Page No.# 9/21
misuse and personal gain.
14. Though the respondent had been given the opportunity to be represented
by a defence assistant, he chose not to do so in all the three Inquiry Reports
and he also did not participate in the inquiry proceedings. After completion of
the ex-parte inquiry proceedings, the Inquiry Officer made 3 Inquiry Reports in
respect of all the three inquiry proceedings. The three Inquiry Reports were
forwarded to the respondent for his representation/s, vide forwarding letters
dated 19.10.2022, 13.07.2022 and 15.09.2022. Instead of making any
representations/replies to the three Inquiry Reports, the respondent challenged
the three Inquiry Reports by way of the three writ petitions mentioned above.
He prayed to set aside and quash the ex-parte Inquiry Proceedings and the
Inquiry Reports.
15.
It is also to be noted that FIR 157/2019 dated 19/09/2019 under section
467/468/471/419/420/409 IPC had been registered against the respondent and
he was arrested by the Jharkhand State Police on 20/09/2019 in connection
with embezzlement of Government money. The above was the start of all the
Inquiry Proceedings initiated against the respondent.
16.
The learned Single Judge disposed of the three writ petitions by way of
the impugned common judgment and order dated 06.03.2025, by applying the
law laid down by the Supreme Court in Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal (supra).
The learned Single Judge held that the respondent had undergone medical
treatment for his mental illness and in view of the mandate of Section 20 of the
Act, the Disciplinary Authority would have to examine the matter from the stand
Page No.# 10/21
point of the law laid down by the Apex Court in Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal
(supra), read with the provisions of the Act, specifically 20 of the Act. The
respondent should also be examined by a Medical Board of the Composite
Hospital, CRPF, Guwahati and after the opinion of the Medical Board is given,
the respondent may file his reply/representation before the Disciplinary
Authority. Till the same was done, no penalty was to be imposed upon the
respondent in relation to the three Inquiry Proceedings, which were stayed by
way of interim orders.
17.
Section 20 of the Act provides for non-discrimination in employment and
states that no Government establishment shall discriminate against any person
with disability in any matter relating to employment and that no Government
establishment shall dispense with or reduce in rank, an employee who acquires
a disability during his or her service. Section 20 of the Act is reproduced herein
below as follows:
“20. Non-discrimination in employment
(1) No Government establishment shall discriminate against any person with
disability in any matter relating to employment:
Provided that the appropriate Government may, having regard to the type
of work carried on in any establishment, by notification and subject to such
conditions, if any, exempt any establishment from the provisions of this section.
(2) Every Government establishment shall provide reasonable
accommodation and appropriate barrier free and conducive environment to
employees
with
disability.
(3) No promotion shall be denied to a person merely on the ground of
disability.
(4) No Government establishment shall dispense with or reduce in rank,
an employee who acquires a disability during his or her service:
Provided that, if an employee after acquiring disability is not suitable for
the post he was holding, shall be shifted to some other post with the same pay
Page No.# 11/21
scale
and
service
benefits:
Provided further that if it is not possible to adjust the employee against
any post, he may be kept on a supernumerary post until a suitable post is
available or he attains the age of superannuation, whichever is earlier.
(5) The appropriate Government may frame policies for posting and
transfer of employees with disabilities.”
18.
As can be seen from Section 20 of the Act, the respondent cannot be
discriminated against with regard to any disability acquired by him during his
service. The Exemption Notification dated 18.08.2021 issued by the Ministry of
Social Justice and Empowerment, exempts all category of posts of combatant
personnel of the CAPFs, including CRPF, from the ambit of Section 20 of the Act.
Section 34 of the Act provides that the Government shall appoint in every
Government establishment not less than 4% of the total number of vacancies in
the cadre strength of each group of posts meant to be filled up with persons
with benchmark disabilities, 1% each shall be reserved for persons under Clause
(a), (b), (c), (d) & (e) persons with benchmark disabilities. The contents of the
Exemption Notification dated 18.08.2021 is reproduced here-in-below, as follows
:
“S.0. 3367(E). In exercise of the powers conferred by the proviso to sub-
section (1) of section 20 and the second proviso to sub-section (1) of
section 34 of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act. 2016 (49 of
2016), the Central Government, in consultation with the Chief
Commissioner for Persons with Disabilities, having regard to the nature
and type of work, hereby exempts all categories of combatant personnel
of Central Armed Police Forces, namely, Border Security Force, Central
Reserve Police Force, Central Industrial Security Force, Indo-Tibetan
Border Police, Sashastra Seema Bal and Assam Rifles from the provisions
of the said sections.”
Page No.# 12/21
19.
In the case of Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal (supra), the issue to be
decided was with regard to the appellant therein going into the chamber of
DIGP,
who
was
sitting
with
Commandant
(staff)
and
with
Assistant
Commandant. The appellant then threatened them that he was obsessed with
either to kill or and be killed and that he could shoot. It was in view of the fact
situation therein that the action of the appellant, in making such a threat, was
considered in terms of Section 20 of the Act. The issue as to whether the
appellant therein suffered from a medical illness at the time of the alleged
misconduct (threat), was to be decided.
20. It was in the above context that the Supreme Court in Ravinder Kumar
Dhariwal (supra) had held that the validity of the disciplinary proceedings
would have to be determined against the provisions of the Act and that a person
with disability was entitled to protection under the Act, as long as the mental
disability was one of the factors for the misconduct.
21. The misconduct, i.e. the threat made by the Assistant Commandant in
Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal (supra) was on 18/04/2010. The Officer had a
history of obsessive compulsive disorder and depression from 2009 and
undergoing treatment. He had been diagnosed with 40% to 70% of permanent
disability by a Government Hospital. Three Inquiry Proceedings were initiated,
the last being on 17/02/2015. Enquiry Reports on the first two Inquiry
proceedings were completed prior to the initiation of the 3 rd Inquiry Report.
These were challenged in the High Court and the Hon’ble Supreme Court, prior
to the issuance of the Exemption Notification dated 18/08/2021. The Supreme
Court held in para 58 that the right to non-discrimination in matters of
Page No.# 13/21
employment provided under Section 20, accrued to the appellant therein on the
filing of the Special Leave Petition, since the 2021 Exemption Notification had
not been notified at the relevant time. Para 58 of the above judgement is
reproduced herein below as follows :“58.
Before proceeding to the merits of the case on the validity of the
disciplinary proceedings vis-a-vis the provisions of the RPwD Act, the
applicability of the 2021 notification to the facts of the present case will have to
be determined. As explained above, on the repeal of the PwD Act by the RPwD
Act, the 2002 Notification also lost its force of law. Between 27/12/2016, when
the RPwD Act had come into force and 18/08/2021, when the 2021 notification
was issued, there was no exemption notification in force. The Special Leave
Petition was instituted on 5/10/2020. In Ambalal Sarabhai Enterprises Ltd. Vs.
Amrit Lal & Co. [(2001) 8 SCC 397], it was held that when a lis commences, all
rights and obligations of the parties get crystallised on that date. Therefore, the
rights of the parties would freeze as on the date of filing the Special Leave
Petition. In the Special Leave Petition filed before this Court, it was submitted
that the initiation of disciplinary proceedings is discriminatory and violative of
the provisions of the RPwD Act. Therefore, the right to non-discrimination in
matters of employment provided under Section 20, accrued to the appellant on
the filing of the Special Leave Petition since the 2021 notification had not been
notified at the relevant time. Thus, the 2021 notification would have no
application to the facts of this case.”
22.
In the case of Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal (supra), the Hon’ble
Supreme Court directed that the appellant therein could not be removed from
his service in view of Section 20 of the Act, as the Exemption Notification dated
18.08.2021 had not been in existence at the time of filing the SLP in the
Supreme Court.
23.
In the case of Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal (supra), the very act of
misconduct, i.e. the threat given by the appellant therein, would require one to
Page No.# 14/21
determine whether the appellant was mentally stable at the time of his giving
his threat to kill his superior officers. As it is settled law that a judgment is only
a decision for what it decides and not what follows from it, the ratio in
Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal (supra) cannot be applied in this case, as the
fact situation in this case is different. The precedential value of a decision would
lessen when there is difference in facts. As the facts in this case and in
Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal (supra) are completely different, we are of the
view that the learned Single Judge was in error in applying the decision of the
Supreme Court and Section 20(4) of the Act to the facts of this case.
24.
The fact situation in the present case is however altogether different. At
the time of the alleged misconduct as provided in three memorandum of
charges, there is not a whisper made by the respondent that he was suffering
from any mental illness, during the relevant period of the misconduct/s. The
claim of mental illness had only surfaced after the Inquiry Proceedings had been
initiated by the appellants.
25. In the present case, the challenge to the 3 Inquiry Proceedings had been
initiated before the learned Single Judge only in the year 2023 and as such the
exemption provided in the Exemption Notification would apply to this case.
26.
Despite the judgment of the Supreme Court in Ravinder Kumar
Dhariwal (supra) not being applicable to the facts of this case and as Section
20 of the Act was not applicable to the respondent’s case in view of the
Exemption Notification dated 18.08.2021, the learned Single Judge has applied
the law laid down by the Supreme Court in Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal
Page No.# 15/21
(supra) in the impugned judgment and order dated 16.03.2025 disposing of
the three writ petitions.
27.
Para Nos. 16, 17 and 18 of the impugned judgment and order dated
06.03.2025 is reproduced herein below as follows:“16. Coming to the fact of the present writ petitions also, in view of the law laid
down by the Apex Court in Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal (supra) and in view of the
fact that the petitioner having underwent medical treatment for his mental
illness and also in view of the mandate of Section 20 of the Rights of Persons
with Disabilities Act, 2016, this Court is of the view that the Disciplinary
Authority will now have to examine the matter from the stand point of the law
laid down by the Apex Court in Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal (supra) read with the
provisions of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 and the Rules
made thereunder and thereafter, pass appropriate orders. While passing such
an order the Disciplinary Authority is required to take special care to ensure that
the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016, more particularly, under
Section 20 of the said Act are not violated. Before passing such order, the
medical condition of the writ petitioner may be examined by referring to the
petitioner to the Composite Hospital CRPF, Guwahati. In such an event the
Composite Hospital, CRPF Guwahati will constitute a Medial Board, comprising
of qualified psychiatrist and such other qualified medical professionals as
deemed necessary. This medical professionals as a part of the Medical Board
will examine the petitioner as per the procedure prescribed and thereafter,
render an opinion as regards his status of the mental illness claimed to have
been suffered by the petitioner and the extent of his disability, if so, established.
The Disciplinary Authority will thereafter pass a speaking order in terms of the
directions above within a period of 60 (sixty) days from the date of receipt of
the opinion of the Medical Board of the Composite Hospital, CRPF, Guwahati, as
has been directed to be constitute. The Authorities in the Composite Hospital
CRPF will constitute the Medical Board as directed within a period of 30 (thirty
days) from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order and will ensure
proper intimation being given to the petitioner and also his guardians/caregivers
including his spouse if available. The petitioner and his guardians/caregivers will
ensure that the petitioner remain present for proper medical examination before
the Medical Board of the Composite Hospital, CRPF, Guwahati as have been
directed in this order within the time frame specified. The petitioner may also
file his reply/representation, if any, before the Disciplinary Authority in his
support.
Page No.# 16/21
17. With the above observations, the writ petitions stand closed and disposed
of.
18. The directions above will be applicable in respect of all the three writ
petitions being W.P.(C) No. 350/2023; W.P.(C) No. 360/2023 and W.P(C) No.
456/2023 and the enquiry proceedings conducted or initiated vide
Memorandum dated 18.09.2020, 19.01.2021 and 16.10.2020 respectively.
Till the order as directed above is passed by the Disciplinary Authority,
the Interim order passed will continue to operate.”
28.
The issue herein is not with regard to reducing a person in rank on
account of the alleged disability of the respondent, but with regard to whether
there was misconduct committed by the respondent while in service. Further,
the documents on record, specifically the inquiry report dated 19.10.2022
pertaining to WP(C) 350/2023, has clearly recorded the fact that the wife of the
respondent, Smt. Kiran Kumari, had sent an e-mail dated 26.07.2021 to the
authorities in Government NIC mail ID (co142bn@crpf.gov.in) of 142 Bn.,
intimating that the respondent was under treatment at RINPAS Hospital, Ranchi,
w.e.f. 24.06.2021 due to mental illness, for which he was granted 2 months
medical rest and again 1 month medical rest w.e.f. 07.07.2021. Though there is
no document to prove the same, the respondent allegedly suffered from mental
illness w.e.f. 24.06.2021, which was allegedly made known to the authorities
only on 26.07.2021. However, the various acts of misconduct committed by the
appellant in all the three memorandum of charges/Inquiry Proceedings, show
that the misconducts had occurred much prior to the year 2020, when there is
no whisper of the respondent having any mental illness.
29.
As such, the issue in the present case is not with regard to whether the
Page No.# 17/21
respondent was to be reduced in rank due to any mental illness that had been
acquired during his service after the year 2020. The instances of misconduct in
this case occurred prior to 2020. Further, the opinion of the Medical Board,
CRPF, Kanke, Ranchi dated 21.10.2022 shows that the DIGP (Medical)
Composite Hospital had written a letter dated 20.09.2021 for conducting a
medical examination of the respondent before the Medical Board. However, the
respondent had appeared before the Medical Board only on 08.10.2022. He was
interviewed in detail by the Medical Board and his case record file and
psychological assessment reports were reviewed. The opinion of the Medical
Board was that the respondent was a case of severe depressive episode with
psychotic symptoms, but that he was currently asymptomatic and as such, the
Medical Board was of the opinion that the respondent was fit to resume his
duties and that he needed regular follow up treatment. Severe depressive
episode involves persistent intense sadness, hopelessness or loss of interest,
which could severely impacting daily functioning. It is a mood disorder which
can lead to a variety of emotional and physical problems. However, he was
found to be asymptomatic at that time.
30.
The opinion of the Medical Board dated 21.10.2022 is reproduced herein
below as follows:Subject: Regarding opinion of Medical Board for fitness or otherwise of Sri
Santosh Kumar CRF No-285685/A & UHID-20210013685.
Sir, With reference to your letter no- nil dated 20/09/2021 Index patient Sri
Santosh Kumar presented himself before the Medical Board on 18/10/2022. He
was interviewed in detail and his case record file and psychological assessment
reports were reviewed. He is a case of severe depressive episode with psychotic
symptoms, but currently he is asymptomatic. So, the Medical Board is of the
Page No.# 18/21
opinion that at present he is fit to resume his duties. He needs regular follow-up
treatment.
31. Section 2(s) of the Act states as follows :
“2(s) person with disability" means a person with long term physical,
mental, intellectual or sensory impairment which, in interaction with
barriers, hinders his full and effective participation in society equally with
others”
As can be seen from the previous paragraph, at the time of his medical
examination by the Medical Board on 18.10.2022, the respondent was found to
be asymptomatic, which basically means that he showed no symptoms of
having any severe depressive episode. In any event it is not the case of the
respondent that he did not take HRA while occupying a Government quarter or
that he had not committed the various acts of misconduct, as per the Charges
framed in the Memorandum of Charges. The stand taken by the respondent is
basically to the effect that the appellants have fabricated cases against him and
that he was a person with mental disability.
32.
In the case of Lalit Popli vs Canara Bank & Others, reported in
(2003) 3 SCC 583, the Supreme Court has held that while exercising
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, the High Court does not act as
an appellate authority. Its jurisdiction is circumscribed by limits of judicial
review, to correct errors of law or procedural errors leading to manifest injustice
or violation of principles of natural justice.
33.
In the case of B.C. Chaturvedi vs Union Of India And Ors , reported
Page No.# 19/21
in (1995) 6 SCC 749, the Supreme Court has held that the High Court cannot reappreciate evidence and the Disciplinary Authority is the sole Judge of facts in
departmental proceedings. As stated earlier, the question of misconduct was
with regard to a period where there was no whisper that the appellant was
suffering from any mental illness and as such, the only issue to be decided is
whether the respondent was guilty of the charges framed against him at the
relevant point of time. Though it can be argued that the respondent cannot be
expected to defend himself properly, unless he is free from mental impairment,
the report of the Medical Board dated 21.10.2022 does not prove that the
appellant is suffering from any mental illness as of now. Further, it is surprising
that the respondent is still working, though he claims to be mentally ill,
especially when the Exemption Notification dated 18/08/2021 is applicable to
the respondent’s case. He appears to be mentally fit to work, but mentally ill to
participate in the Inquiry Proceedings.
There can be justification for not
concluding the Inquiry Proceedings, as the respondent does not appear to be
suffering any mental disability due to the reasons stated in the foregoing
paragraphs.
34. As stated in the foregoing paragraphs, the decision of the Supreme Court
in Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal (supra) is not applicable to the facts of this
case, inasmuch as, Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal was undergoing medical treatment
for his mental disorder since the year 2009 and his misconduct was connected
to his mental disorder, which occurred in the year 2010. Further, the wife of the
appellant in Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal (supra) was also a party to the case.
She represented her husband as the appellant therein was having a mental
disorder. In the present case, the wife of respondent herein is not a party. In
Page No.# 20/21
fact, the respondent herein had signed all the affidavits in WP(C) Nos.350/2023,
360/2023 and 456/2023, stating that he was competent to swear the affidavits.
All the affidavits have been made in the three writ petitions in the year 2022.
Further, after the respondent had been examined by a Medical Board and the
opinion of the Medical Board dated 21.10.2022 had opined that the respondent
was asymptomatic, the respondent was taken back into service and is presently
holding the post of Assistant Commandant in the office of the Inspector General
(Operations). This holding of a sensitive post by the respondent, coupled with
the fact that there is nothing stated by the appellants or the respondent that the
respondent is unable to do his work properly, gives rise to an inference that the
respondent is not having any mental illness or disability. In view of the
Exemption Notification dated 18.08.2021, Section 20 of the Act is not applicable
to the case of the respondent. Further, as the allegations of misconduct pertain
to a period, prior to the respondent making a claim for any mental
illness/disability, there is no justification for not concluding the Inquiry
Proceedings. The same would have to be concluded, as there is nothing to show
that the respondent is having mental disability.
35.
In view of the fact that the 3 Inquiry Reports in relation to the three
memorandum of charges dated 18.09.2020, 19.01.2021 and 16.10.2020 have
been furnished to the respondent, the respondent shall submit representations
to the 3 Inquiry Reports on merit, if not done earlier, inasmuch as, the charges
of misconduct occurred during the time when he was not suffering from any
mental illness. The said representation/s should be submitted by the respondent
within a period of four weeks from today. In the event the respondent does not
submit his representations to the three Inquiry Reports within the prescribed
Page No.# 21/21
time period, the appellant shall have the liberty to conclude the three Inquiry
Reports, even in the absence of the respondent’s representations.
36.
Consequently, the impugned judgment and order dated 06.03.2025
passed in WP(C) Nos. 350/2023, 360/2023 and 456/2023 are hereby set aside.
37.
The above being said, the respondent should be examined by a Medical
Board, to determine if he is suffering from any mental illness. If he is found to
be suffering from any mental illness or impairment, the concerned persons
should be made aware of it for taking appropriate measures. If the respondent
is found to be suffering from any mental illness, then the respondent may be
sent on invalid pension or disability pension or take any other decision as per
the relevant Service Rules, as the appellants deem fit and proper, in view of
Section 20 of the Act not being applicable to case of the respondent.
38. The appeal is accordingly allowed.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review