Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA 156 OF 2021
1. The Union of India
Represented by the Secretary to the Ministry of Home Affairs,
Having its office at South Block, New Delhi-110001.
2. The Secretary,
Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India,
Having its office at South Block, New Delhi-110001.
3. The Director General,
Central Reserve Police Force, CGO Complex,
Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003.
4. The DIG(CR & Vigilance),
Central Reserve Police Force, CGO Complex,
Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003.
….Appellants.
Vrs.
Sri Vinay Kumar Rai , son of Shri Brahmeshwar Nath Rai,
Holding the post of DIG, CRPF, presently residing at Usha Bazaar,
Airport Road, P.O. Usha Bazaar, P.S. Airport, Sub-Division-Agartala,
District-West Tripura.
AND 34 others.
...Respondents.
For the appellant(s)
: Mr. Bidyut Majumder, DySGI
For the respondent(s)
: Mr. Saptarshi Majumder, Advocate.
Date of hearing & date
of delivery of
: 04.05.2023
judgment and order
Whether fit for
reporting
: Yes
HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE T.AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
[ T.Amarnath Goud, J]
This writ appeal is directed by the appellants i.e. the original
respondents of the writ petition against the judgment and order dated
28.01.2021, passed by the learned Single Judge of this court in WP(C)
No.1280 of 2017 whereby the learned Single Judge had allowed the writ
petition.
2.
The petitioner, the respondent no.1 herein, in the writ petition
had sought for the following reliefs:
“In the premises whereof, it is most humbly and respectfully
submitted that Your Lordships would be graciously pleased to:
i)
ii)
Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them, to
show cause as to why a Writ of Certiorari and/or in the nature
thereof, shall not be issued, for calling for the records, lying with
the respondents, for rendering substantive and conscionable
justice to the petitioner, and for quashing/setting aside the
impugned Order dated 13.08.2015 (Annexure-14 supra), and the
various Orders of promotion (Annexure-18 supra);
Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them, to
show cause as to why a Writ of Mandamus and/.or in the nature
thereof, shall not be issued, for mandating/directing them, to
revoke/rescind the impugned Order dated 13.08.2015 (Annexure14 supra), the impougned Order dated 17.03.2016 (Annexure-16
supra), and the various Orders of promotion (Annexure-18
supra), and restore the seniority of the petitioner, over the private
respondents, as on the rank of the Commandant in the Central
Reserve Police Force, and consider the case of thepetitioner, for
promotion, to the rank of DIG in the CRPF, with effect from
05.06.2-12, and thereupon, accord promotion, to the rank of DIG
in the CRPF, to the petitioner, with effect from the said date, with
all consequential benefits including seniority.”
3.
After hearing both sides, the learned Single Judge allowed the
writ petition with the following observations and directions:
“15. Under the circumstances, impugned orders dated
13.08.2015 and 17.03.2016 are set aside. Resultantly, the official
respondents shall open the sealed covers of the DPCs which
considered the petitioner’s case from time to time and act on the
recommendations in view of quashing of the penalty imposed on
thepetitioner. If for some reason the petitioner’s case was not
considered and kept in sealed cover, the department would draw a
review DPC for considering the case of the petitioner when for the
first time his junior was considered and promoted. As and when the
petitioner gets such promotion, the same would be retrospective
from due date with consequential seniority benefits and pay
fixation but not actual arrears of salary from the retrospective date
of promotion till actual promotion which I am told has already
been granted to the petitioner subsequently. Entire exercise shall
be completed within a period of six months from today.
With these observations, petition is disposed of.”
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the impugned
judgment and order, the respondents-Union of India have preferred the
present writ appeal before this court.
4.
The case of the appellants is that the respondent Sri Vinay
Kumar Rai, Commandant, 41 Bn. CRPF was functioning as a Presiding
Officer of a Recruitment Board of the Eastern Sector for recruitment of
Constable (Technical)/Tradesmen at Group Centre, CRPF, Durgapur which
had been conducted during the period from 26.12.2006 to 06.01.2007.
While acting as such, the respondent-petitioner had committed serious
misconduct in fair and impartial selection of the candidates for which the
deserving candidates were deprived of the selection as physical
examinations and trade test were tampered to favour some other candidates
unlawfully. He had lack of integrity and devotion to his duty. For such
alleged misconduct, a departmental proceeding was initiated against the
respondent-petitioner and after completion of departmental proceeding, the
disciplinary authority, i.e. the DIG(CR & Vigilance) of Central Reserve
Police Force, Ministry of Home Affairs vide order dated 13.08.2015
imposed a penalty/punishment upon the respondent-petitioner to the extent
of reduction to lower stage in the time scale of pay by one stage for a
period of one year without cumulative effect. The respondent-petitioner had
preferred appeal against the said impugned order before the appellate
authority, but, the appellate authority had dismissed the appeal affirming
the order of disciplinary authority.
5.
We have gone through the impugned order dated 13.08.2015,
passed by the disciplinary authority and the relevant portion of the said
order is reproduced here-under:“….
14.NOW, THEREFORE, in the light of above and having
regard to all aspects of the case as well as considering the advice of
the UPSC, the President considers that the ends of justice would be
met, if the penalty of “reduction to lower stage in the time scale of
pay by one stage for a period of one year without cumulative effect
and not adversely affecting his pension” i.e. from Rs.51,500/- to
49,750/- w.e.f. 1/9/2015 in the pay band of Rs.37,400-67,000/- with
Grade Pay of Rs.8700/-, is imposed upon V.K.Rai, Commandant
(IRLA-3370) of 41 Bn (now posted in GC, CRPF, Muzaffarpur and
orders accordingly.”
6.
We have heard Mr. Bidyut Majumder, learned DySGI
appearing for the appellants-Union of India and Mr. Saptarshi Majumder,
learned counsel appearing for the respondent-petitioner.
7.
Mr. Majumder, learned DySGI has refuted the contention of
the respondent-petitioner that was urged before the learned single Judge by
filing the writ petition that the time consumed from initiation and
completion of departmental inquiry of the matter relating to the charged
officer, suffered from gross delay. It is contended by Mr. Majumder,
learned DySGI that large number of alteration and cuttings established that
the charged officer acted in a negligent manner in conducting the
recruitment test. The junior officers were promoted since the petitioner was
facing departmental proceeding, his case was kept in sealed cover by the
DPC for the vacancy year 2012-13, 2013-14 and 2015-16 and vide order
dated 13.08.2015 the aforesaid penalty/punishment was imposed upon him.
As such, sealed cover was not acted upon as per DPC rules upto
13.08.2016. Therefore, promotion of officers junior to the respondent-
petitioner was within order. So, the delay has not caused any prejudice to
the petitioner.
8.
Mr. S. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent-petitioner submitted that the punishment imposed upon the
petitioner has badly affected promotion of the respondent-petitioner. He
has been superseded by his junior officers. He further submitted that the
charge levelled against the respondent-petitioner was baseless and
fabricated out of ill motive. Hence, he prayed for dismissal of the appeal.
9.
On careful reading of the judgment and order of learned single
Judge, it appears to us that learned single Judge has vividly discussed the
issue of delay in initiation and completion of the inquiry and was of the
opinion that the delay in the present case is not so grave in nature since the
petitioner has neither pleaded nor proved any prejudice in his defence
during the departmental inquiry for such delay. We are of the view that
learned single Judge has rightly observed that during departmental
proceeding a considerable time is required to complete the same as there
are some formalities to be followed such as, records are to be produced and
witnesses are be to be examined.
10.
We have seen that the respondent-petitioner by filing a reply
to the inquiry report has denied every aspect and every finding at length. It
is clear that the respondent-petitioner was the Presiding Officer of the
Recruitment Board. Certainly there were other members also, but, we find
no convincing evidence of any of the members of the Board came out from
their depositions that the charged officer had manipulated the result sheets
of the candidates during the recruitment process for which the deserving
candidates had been deprived of. The members of the selection committee
unequivocally denied that the charged officer was guilty of any
manipulation of the records of the selection committee and that all such
corrections in the records were made in their presence. Further, it is
apparent that the disciplinary authority did not even suggest to cancel the
recruitment process if there were any gross illegalities in selecting the
candidates. Had there been any types malpractice on the part of the chargeofficer in respect of such a serious issue, particularly, in a recruitment
process, the disciplinary authority would not have awarded a minor
punishment as we have seen in the impugned order dated 13.08.2015.
Having gone through the depositions of the members of the selection
committee and the reply of the charged officer filed at the time of
disciplinary proceeding, this court does not find any cogent and convincing
evidence that the charged officer most negligently committed any
misconduct in the alleged recruitment process and that he deliberately and
wilfully changed and altered any result sheets of the deserving candidates.
11.
In view of the above perspective, we do not find any
infirmities to interfere with the judgment and order dated 28.01.2021,
passed by the learned Single Judge in WP(C) No.1280/2017 and
accordingly, the same is affirmed.
The appeal stands dismissed.
In regard to the time granted for compliance of the order
passed by the learned Single Judge which has been indicated in the said
order, learned DySGI appearing for the appellants seeks further 3 (three
months) time to complete the exercise. Considering the request, further
three months time is allowed from today. It is made clear that no further
time would be granted.
12.
The writ appeal is, accordingly, disposed of. Pending
application, if any, shall also stand disposed of.
JUDGE
sanjay
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review