Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/8
GAHC010258332025
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WA/29/2026
1.THE UNION OF INDIA,
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS, NORTH BLOCK , NEW DELHI-110001.
2: THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF JAMMU FRONTIER, BSF,
PALOURA CAMPUS, JAMMU (J&K), PIN-181124.
3: THE COMMANDANT, 98 BN, BSF
BSF THQ PALOURA BSF CAMP, JAMMU (J&K), PIN-181124.
4: THE CHIEF LAW OFFICER, LAW BRANCH, FHQ BSF,
NEW DELHI-110001.
……Appellants
-VERSUS No. 119880627 CONSTABLE GD DEBEN SINHA,
C COY, 98 BN BSF, SON OF DINENDRA NARAYAN SINHA, RO: ALGAPUR,
P.O.: RAJNAGAR, DISTRICT: CACHAR, P.S.: SILCHAR, AASAM, PIN-788026.
……Respondent
– BEFORE –
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. ASHUTOSH KUMAR
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN DEV CHOUDHURY
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. K.K. Parasar, Central Government Counsel.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. M.J. Quadir, Advocate.
Page No.# 2/8
Date of hearing
: 09.06.2026.
Date of Judgment
: 09.06.2026.
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
(Ashutosh Kumar, CJ)
We have heard Mr. K.K. Parasar, learned Central Government
Counsel for the appellants and Mr. M.J. Quadir, learned counsel for the
sole respondent.
2.
This writ appeal has been preferred against the judgment
dated 22.07.2025 passed by a learned Single Judge of this Court in WP(C)
No.5947/2021, whereby the respondent has been directed to be
reinstated in service and has been held to be entitled to pay and
allowances on such reinstatement.
3.
By order dated 24.07.2020 passed by the Commandant, 98
Battalion of Border Security Force, the respondent was dismissed from
service in connection with a decision by the Summary Security Force
Court (SSFC). The appeal against the afore-noted order was also
dismissed vide order dated 19.07.2021.
4.
The respondent, while posted at Jammu Frontier, Border
Security Force at Paloura, Jammu, was found to be sleeping at his Post.
When the respondent was asked to wake up by his colleague, he picked
up his INSAS Rifles, cocked it and also fired. The shot hit no one. He was
immediately disarmed and later subjected to a disciplinary proceeding,
Page No.# 3/8
5.
A Record of Evidence (RoE) was ordered on 12.06.2019. Later,
a Summary Security Force Court trial was approved and the same was
conducted on 24.07.2020 by the Commandant of 98 Battalion, BSF under
Sections 20(a) [assaulting superior]; 16(c) [sleeping at the post]; 20(b)
[using threatening language]; and 22(e) [disgraceful conduct] of the
Border Security Force Act, 1968 (hereinafter to be referred as the “Act of
1968”). The respondent pleaded guilty to charge Nos.1, 2 and 4 but not
guilty for charge No.3, namely, threatening. He was assisted by a “friend
of the accused” of his choice. However, he was sentenced to dismissal
from service, which was conveyed to him on 24.07.2020.
As noted above, the statutory appeal preferred by the
respondent before the Inspector General, Frontier Headquarter, BSF,
Jammu was rejected as meritless.
6.
A writ petition thereafter was filed by the respondent vide
WP(C) No.4265/2021 challenging the dismissal but the same was
dismissed as withdrawn on 16.09.2021. He again filed a writ petition vide
WP(C) No.5947/2021 alleging procedural flaws, especially, that the
Commandant
acted
as
an
Interpreter
without
providing
any
objection/opportunity to the respondent and that no Prosecutor was
appointed. He denied the allegation that he had cocked the rifle for
harming any person; rather, it was out of fear and for self-defence.
7.
The appellants defended the proceedings before the learned
Single Judge as compliant with the Border Security Force Rules, 1969
(hereinafter to be referred as the “Rules of 1969”). It was urged before the
learned Single Judge that Rule 134(2) of the Rules of 1969 allowed the
Page No.# 4/8
Court to act as an Interpreter and that no Prosecutor is actually required
in Summary Security Force Court. The appellants also relied on the
voluntary guilt plea of the respondent.
8.
However, by the impugned judgment, the dismissal order of
the respondent was quashed by holding the proceedings to have been
vitiated because of the dual role adopted by the Commandant as the
Presiding Officer as also of an Interpreter, reflected bias and for improper
recording of the plea of guilt.
It was also observed by the learned Single Judge that the
provisions contained in Section 134(2) of the Rules of 1969, was not
followed in its entirety.
9.
While quashing the punishment of dismissal of the respondent,
the learned Single Judge also held that the three out of the four charges
levelled against the respondent was held to be proved against him on
the guilt plea recorded by him in the proceedings in question.
10.
The guilt plea made by the respondent had to be considered
in terms of the provisions of the Rules of 142 and 143 of the Rules of 1969.
Rule 134 thereof is being extracted herein below for ready reference:
“134. Evidence when to be translated- (1) When any evidence is given in
a language which the Court of the accused does not understand, that
evidence shall be translated to the Court or accused as the case may be in a
language which it or he does understand.
(2) The Court shall for this purpose either appoint an interpreter, or shall
itself take the oath or affirmation prescribed for the interpreter at a
Summary Security Force Court.
(3) When documents are produced for the purpose of formal proof, it shall be
Page No.# 5/8
in the discretion of the Court to cause as much to be interpreted as appears
necessary.”
11.
A bare perusal of Rule 134 of the Rules of 1969 would reflect
that whenever it is necessary, the evidence would either be translated to
the Court or the accused in a language in which the Court or the
accused understands.
12.
For the aforesaid purpose, Rule 134(2) gives the latitude to the
Court that for such purposes, the Court would either appoint an
Interpreter, or would itself be the Interpreter and take the oath or
affirmation prescribed for the Interpreter at a Summary Security Force
Court.
13.
The Presiding Officer, in this instance, himself became an
Interpreter though there is nothing in the record to indicate that he had
prescribed the oath of affirmation prescribed for interpreting at a
Summary Security Force Court.
Nonetheless, no such challenge was made regarding the
Presiding Officer himself becoming the Interpreter by the respondent
during the proceedings or even in the appeal.
14.
Apart from that, as has rightly been argued by the
appellants/Union of India & Ors., the respondent hails from the Manipuri
community and understood Hindi language very well. That apart, no
objection raised by him at any stage either during the proceedings or in
the appeal would disentitle him to raise this issue at this stage.
Page No.# 6/8
15.
A perusal of records further reveals that the guilt plea made by
the respondent was voluntary.
16.
Rule 142 of the Rules of 1969 provides that the plea of guilt shall
be recorded with respect to each of the charges. If an accused pleads
guilty, that plea shall be recorded as the finding of the Court; but before
it is recorded, the Court shall ascertain that the accused understands the
nature of the charges to which he has pleaded guilty and shall inform
him of the general effect of that plea, and in particular the meaning of
the charge to which he had pleaded guilty, and of the difference in
procedure which will be made by the plea of guilt and shall advise him
to withdraw that plea if it appears from the record or abstract of
evidence (if any) or otherwise that the accused ought not to plead
guilty.
After the recording of the plea of guilt, the signature of the
accused and “the friend of the accused” shall be obtained.
17.
Rule 143 provides that on the recording of the plea of guilt with
respect to some of the charges and if there are other charges in the
same charge-sheet to which the accused had not pleaded guilty, the
trial shall first proceed with respect to those charges, and, after giving
finding on those other charges, shall proceed with the charges on which
a plea of guilt has been entered. However, if there are alternative
charges, the Court could either proceed with respect to such charges as
if the accused had not pleaded guilty to any charge, or may, instead of
trying him, record a finding of guilt upon any one of the alternative
charges to which he had pleaded guilty and finding of not guilty upon all
Page No.# 7/8
the other alternative charges which precede such charge.
There are other procedural safeguards provided in Rules 142
and 143 of the Rules of 1969.
18.
It appears that all those safeguards have been followed in the
instant case. The records further reveal that during the trial, 13(thirteen)
Prosecution Witnesses were examined and 13(thirteen) documents were
also exhibited. The respondent neither adduced any evidence nor
offered any document in defence.
19.
The plea of guilt also was voluntary and the records reveal that
the respondent was made to understand the effect of his plea of guilt.
20.
The learned Single Judge interfered with the order passed by
the Summary Security Force Court and of the Appellate Authority
primarily on the ground of the Presiding Officer of the Summary Security
Force Court having adopted the dual responsibility of being the Court
and the Interpreter, both. This is permissible. That apart, as already noted
above, no objection regarding the same was raised by the respondent
at any stage of the proceedings.
21.
Thus, we find that the interference with the finding of the
Summary Security Force Court and the Appellate Authority was not
required/justified especially in such a case where there is a positive
breach of the duty protocol in a disciplined service.
22.
For the afore-noted reasons, we set aside the impugned
judgment passed by the learned Single Judge and restore the findings
Page No.# 8/8
and the punishment of the Summary Security Force Court as well as the
order passed by the Appellate Authority affirming the same.
23.
With the above observation, the appeal stands allowed.
JUDGE
Bijoy
Sarma
Comparing Assistant
Digitally signed
by Bijoy Sarma
Date: 2026.06.09
19:15:38 +05'30'
CHIEF JUSTICE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review