Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010605912025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3396]
FRIDAY, THE THIRTEENTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE DR. JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 11675/2025
Between:
1. THE STATION HOUSE OFFICER, THROUGH THE INSPECTOR OF
POLICE,NANDIGAMA PS, NTR DISTRICT,REPRESENTED BY
PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,HIGH COURT OF AP, AT AMARAVATI.
...PETITIONER / STATE
AND
1. KANNEGANTI SAJJANA RAO, S/O. RATNAM, AGED 51 YEARS, R/O.
NEAR FISH MARKET, CHANDAMAMPET, NANDIGAMA TOWN AND
MANDAL, NTR DISTRICT.
2. BEJAWADA KARTHIK, S/O. VASANTHA RAO, AGED 29 YEARS,R/O.
D.NO. 1-83, OLD HARIJANAWADA, NANDIGAMA TOWN AND
MANDAL, NTR DISTRICT.
3. PARIMI KISHORE, S/O. YAKOBU L, AGED 40 YEARS,R/O. D.NO.219, NEW HARIJANAWADA, NANDIGAMA TOWN AND MANDAL, NTR
DISTRICT
4. MARTA SRINIVASA RAO, S/O. VENKATESWARA RAO, AGED 40
YEARSR/O.
NEAR
WINE
SHOP,
PARITALA
VILLAGE,
KANCHIKACHERLA MANDAL, NTR DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENTS/ACCUSED:
Counsel for the Petitioner/State:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
Counsel for the Respondents/Accused:
1. VELADI SAI SRI HARSHA
2. P NAGENDRA REDDY
The Court made the following:
ORDER:
The instant petition under Section 483(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (for short „BNSS‟) has been filed by the State seeking
cancellation of the bail granted to the Respondents / Accused Nos.1 to 4 vide
Order dated 23.11.2024 in C.F.No.5594 of 2024 on the file of the Court of
Additional Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Nandigama in connection with
Crime No. 575 of 2022 of Nandigama Police Station, NTR District for the
offences under Sections 120-B, 147, 307, 332, 324 and 353 read with 149 of
Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short „IPC‟).
2.
The case of the prosecution, in brief, is that Accused Nos. 1 to 4, being
close associates and residents of Nandigama and surrounding areas,
allegedly conspired with other Accused to eliminate Sri Nara Chandrababu
Naidu, who was then the Leader of the Opposition. On 04.11.2022, during a
roadshow at Nandigama, while he was addressing the public from the
“Prachara Radham,” one of the Accused allegedly hurled a stone, which
struck his chin and caused injury. It is further alleged that the Accused
targeted vital parts of his body with sharp-edged stones with an intention to kill
him, but the attempt was thwarted by the intervention of security personnel.
3.
Heard Sri M.Lakshmi Narayana, learned Public Prosecutor for the
Petitioner / State and Sri P.Nagendra Reddy, learned counsel for the
Respondents / Accused Nos.1 to 4.
4.
Learned Public Prosecutor would submit that the investigation, based
on the statements of LWs 1 to 25, clearly establishes that the incident
involved a pre-planned attack. It is further submitted that the witnesses have
consistently stated that there was a sudden power cut, immediately followed
by stone pelting. LWs 15 to 17, the linemen accompanying the roadshow of
Sri Nara Chandrababu Naidu, confirmed that the street lights were
deliberately switched off and stones were thrown, causing injury to LW1.
Learned Public Prosecutor further submitted that independent
eyewitnesses, including LW-18 and LW-22, identified the Accused as
participants in the attack, with specific roles attributed to them in pelting
stones and cutting power supply. LW-23‟s statement regarding recording the
incident in his mobile phone and being threatened, and the confessional
statement of LW-25 before LW-24, clearly reveal a criminal conspiracy to
target and kill Sri Nara Chandrababu Naidu by planning to attack in
darkness.
It is further submitted that the material on record prima facie attracts
alleged offences against Respondents / Accused Nos.1 to 4. Despite the
gravity of the offence and strong evidence indicating a conspiracy and direct
involvement of the Accused Nos.1 to 4, they were released on bail. Learned
Public Prosecutor would further submit that Accused Nos.1 to 4 also have
criminal antecedents. In view of the seriousness of the allegations levelled
against Respondents / Accused Nos.1 to 4, learned Public Prosecutor
prayed for cancellation of the bail granted to Accused Nos.1 to 4.
5.
Learned counsel for Respondents / Accused Nos.1 to 4 would submit
that the allegations made by the prosecution are baseless, exaggerated,
and do not disclose the essential ingredients of the offences alleged. It is
contended that the entire case rests on interested and inconsistent witness
statements,
without
any
credible
and
corroborative
material.
The
prosecution has failed to seize the stone allegedly used in the incident,
which strikes at the root of the case and renders the version of the
prosecution doubtful.
It is further submitted that there is an unexplained delay of nearly one
year in seeking cancellation of bail, which itself shows that there are no
supervening circumstances warranting such cancellation. Learned counsel
would further submit that, no material was placed before the learned
Magistrate to show the criminal antecedents of Accused Nos.1 to 4, at the
time of granting bail. The Respondents have complied with all bail
conditions and have not misused their liberty in any manner.
Learned counsel would also submit that, as rightly observed by the
learned Magistrate in the remand report and upon consideration of the
material on record, the ingredients of the alleged offences are not made out
against the Respondents. The confessional and witness statements are
insufficient to prima facie establish any conspiracy, much less an intention to
commit murder. Hence, prayed for dismissal of the petition. In support of
their contentions, learned counsel has placed reliance on the judgments of
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India in Surinder Singh vs. State (Union
Territory of Chandigarh)1, Girija Shankar vs. State of U.P2, State of
Madhya Pradesh vs. Kanha @ Omprakash3 and Pasupuleti Siva
Ramakrishna Rao vs. State of A.P and others4.
(2021) 20 SCC 24
(2004) 3 SCC 793
(2019) 3 SCC 605
(2014) 5 SCC 369
6.
The scope of consideration in a petition for cancellation of bail is
distinct from that of grant of bail. While it is true that cancellation ordinarily
requires supervening circumstances, it is equally well settled that bail can be
cancelled where the Accused, who is granted bail, failed to comply with the
conditions imposed or the order granting bail suffers from serious infirmities,
and is passed without proper appreciation of material, or where relevant
factors have been ignored.
7.
It is a settled law vide a catena of decisions from the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court and this Court that the following illustrative list of principles are to be
taken into consideration while considering an application for bail:
a. the nature of accusation and the severity of the punishment in the
case of conviction and the nature of the materials relied upon by the
prosecution;
b. reasonable apprehension of tampering with the witnesses or
apprehension of threat to the complainant or the witnesses;
c. reasonable possibility of securing the presence of the accused at the
time of trial or the likelihood of his abscondence;
d. character, behaviour and standing of the accused and the
circumstances which are peculiar to the accused;
e. larger interest of the public or the State and similar other
considerations.
8.
In the present case, the material collected during investigation,
particularly the statements of LWs 15 to 17, prima facie indicates that there
was a deliberate power outage immediately preceding the incident. The
statements of LWs 18 and 22, who are independent eyewitnesses, clearly
attribute specific roles to Accused Nos.1 to 4 in executing the attack. The
statement of LW-23 regarding recording the incident over mobile phone and
being threatened, coupled with the confessional statement of LW-25, further
strengthens the prosecution case regarding a premeditated conspiracy.
9.
The effect of these statements, at this stage, cannot be brushed aside
as mere uncorroborated or interested testimony. They disclose a
coordinated and planned attack, allegedly intended to cause fatal harm. The
gravity of the offence, the nature of allegations, and the prima facie material
indicating conspiracy and active participation of the Accused Nos.1 to 4
were required to be given due weight at the time of granting bail.
10.
Further, the record indicates that relevant aspects, including the
seriousness of the allegations and the material pointing towards conspiracy,
were not adequately considered while granting bail. In cases involving grave
offences and organized acts of violence, a liberal approach in granting bail
is not warranted. Further, to prove the contention of presence of criminal
antecedents against Accused Nos.1 to 4, the Prosecution placed the
particulars of the cases in which Accused Nos.1 to 4 had already involved.
11.
Though the learned counsel for the Respondents has raised the issue
of delay in filing the present petition, such delay, by itself, cannot be a
ground to sustain an order of bail which appears to have been granted
without proper appreciation of material. The contention regarding nonseizure of stones is a matter for trial and does not, at this stage, dilute the
prima facie evidence available in the form of consistent witness statements.
12.
A bare perusal of the order passed by the learned trial Judge, while
granting bail to the Petitioners, would reveal that the same is legally
unsustainable as it undertakes a detailed evaluation of the evidence and
virtually conducts a mini-trial, which is impermissible at the stage of bail
where only a prima facie view is required. By conclusively holding that
offences under Sections 147, 149, 307, 332 and 353 IPC are not attracted,
the court has prejudged the case.
13.
With regard to the offence under Section 149 IPC, the learned trial
Judge gave a finding that, to attract the offence punishable under Section
149 IPC, there must be minimum of 5 persons and that, in this case, there
are only 4 persons, hence, the said offence does not attract against the
Respondents / Accused.
14.
The finding of the learned trial Judge that Section 149 IPC is not
attracted on the ground that only four Accused persons are before the Court
is erroneous and contrary to settled principles of law. The case of the
prosecution is that Accused Nos.1 to 4, along with other accused persons,
conspired to eliminate Sri Nara Chandrababu Naidu during the roadshow
conducted at Nandigama on 04.11.2022 and, in furtherance of their
common object, one of the Accused hurled a stone aiming at vital parts of
his body. The prosecution specifically alleges participation of other Accused
persons apart from the four respondents herein. For invoking Section 149
IPC, what is relevant is the existence of an unlawful assembly consisting of
five or more persons at the time of commission of the offence, and not
merely the number of Accused who ultimately faced trial. Therefore, merely
because only four Accused are before the Court, it cannot be concluded that
Sections 147 and 149 IPC are not attracted. The learned trial Judge failed to
appreciate this settled legal position and thus the finding rendered on this
aspect is legally unsustainable.
15.
Further, the trial Judge has excluded Section 332 IPC holding that it is
not the case of the prosecution that the Accused prevented or deterred
L.W.1 from performing his duty. It is only the case that when the Accused
pelted stones, they hit L.W.1.
16.
The above finding of the learned trial Judge excluding the offence
under Section 332 IPC is also erroneous. Section 332 IPC is attracted when
hurt is voluntarily caused to a public servant while such public servant is
acting in the discharge of his official duties. In the present case, L.W.1 was
admittedly performing official duties during the roadshow and sustained
injuries when the Accused allegedly pelted stones at the gathering. At this
stage, it cannot be said that there was no act intended to deter or obstruct
the public servant from discharging his duties. The very act of pelting stones
during a public event attended by security personnel and public servants
prima facie amounts to use of criminal force causing hurt in the course of
discharge of official duty. Therefore, the reasoning of the learned trial Judge
with regard to the offence under Section 332 IPC, is legally unsustainable.
17.
The learned trial Judge further held that, in this case no criminal force
or assault has been made against L.W.1 by the Accused. The Accused only
pelted stones against the former Chief Minister, but it hit L.W.1 accidentally.
That does not mean that they obstructed or abstained L.W.1 from executing
his duties. Thus, the ingredients of Section and 353 IPC also do not attract
against the Respondents / Accused.
18.
The said finding of the learned trial Judge is erroneous. L.W.1 was
admittedly discharging official duties during the roadshow when the Accused
allegedly pelted stones at the gathering. Even if the stones were aimed at
the former Chief Minister, the act of pelting stones in the course of a public
event involving security personnel and public servants prima facie amounts
to use of criminal force. The fact that L.W.1 sustained injuries during the
incident cannot be brushed aside as a mere accident at this stage. Whether
the act was intended to deter or obstruct the public servant in discharge of
duties is a matter for trial. Therefore, the learned trial Judge was not justified
in excluding the offence under Section 353 IPC at the threshold.
19.
Furthermore, the learned trial Judge also held that pelting a stone
against a person will not attract the offence of attempt to murder which is
punishable under Section 307 IPC. It was further held that the prosecution
also had not shown the fact that the Accused had targeted a part of the
body of the former Chief Minister at that time and that the stone is not a
weapon which causes death and further if it is thrown from a distance, it will
not at all cause the death. While holding so, the learned trial Judge opined
that there are no ingredients of the offence under Section 307 IPC against
the Respondents / Accused.
20.
The said finding of the learned trial Judge is legally unsustainable and
contrary to the settled principles governing the offence of attempt to murder.
For constituting an offence under Section 307 IPC, the nature of the weapon
used alone is not decisive; the intention or knowledge accompanying the act
and the surrounding circumstances are the determinative factors. The
reasoning of the learned trial Judge that a stone is not a deadly weapon and
that throwing it from a distance would not cause death is wholly erroneous. A
stone, depending upon its size, force and the manner in which it is hurled, is
certainly capable of causing fatal injuries, particularly when directed against a
person in a public gathering. The absence of evidence showing that the
Accused specifically aimed at a particular part of the body is not by itself
sufficient to exclude the offence under Section 307 IPC. In offences of this
nature, the Court is required to consider the totality of circumstances including
the nature of the act, the force employed, the target of the attack, the potential
consequences of such act, and the intention apparent from the conduct of the
Accused. When a stone is deliberately hurled at a public function where a
former Chief Minister was present amidst a gathering, the act cannot be
minimized merely because the weapon used was a stone. The offence under
Section 307 IPC does not require that death should actually occur, nor is it
necessary that the injury inflicted should be sufficient in the ordinary course of
nature to cause death. What is required is the intention or knowledge coupled
with an overt act towards the commission of murder. The materials on record
prima facie disclose the commission of an act, warranting invocation of
Section 307 IPC against the Respondents / Accused.
21.
The court also erred in relying on absence of documents like wound
certificate and photographs, which are matters for investigation, and in
mechanically applying Section 41-A Cr.P.C., by holding that there are only
ingredients of Section 324 and 120-B(2) IPC and the same are punishable
with imprisonment below seven years. In such circumstances, this Court is
of the view that the order reflects misapplication of law, premature
appreciation of evidence, and failure to consider the seriousness of the
allegations.
22.
The order granting bail by the learned trial Judge suffers from non-
application of mind and is unsustainable in law. It is a settled proposition
that while considering an application for bail, the Court is required to take
into account, inter alia, the nature and gravity of the accusation, the severity
of punishment in the event of conviction, the material collected during
investigation, the possibility of the Accused tampering with prosecution
witnesses, likelihood of abscondence, the character and antecedents of the
Accused, and the larger interest of the society and the State.
23.
In the present case, the learned trial Judge, while granting bail at the
stage of remand itself, failed to advert to any of the aforesaid relevant
considerations. The impugned order does not disclose any satisfaction
regarding the absence of apprehension of witness intimidation or tampering
with evidence, nor does it reflect consideration of the seriousness of the
allegations and the supporting material placed by the prosecution. The order
is completely silent on the likelihood of the Accused evading the process of
law or the impact of release on the fair conduct of investigation and trial.
24.
Grant of bail in a serious criminal matter cannot be exercised in a
mechanical manner or as a matter of course. Judicial discretion must be
exercised cautiously, judiciously, and upon due application of mind to the
settled parameters governing the grant of bail. Though it is not the case of
the prosecution that Accused Nos.1 to 4 have not complied with the
conditions imposed against them while granting bail, this Court is of the
opinion that the order granting bail to Accused Nos.1 to 4 suffers from nonconsideration of material aspects and that there exists prima facie evidence
indicating their involvement in a serious and pre-planned offence. Therefore,
this Court finds it a fit case to exercise its power to cancel the bail.
25.
Accordingly, the Criminal Petition is allowed setting aside the Order
dated 23.11.2024 in C.F.No.5594 of 2024 on the file of the Court of
Additional Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Nandigama in connection with
Crime No. 575 of 2022 of Nandigama Police Station, NTR District and the
bail granted to Accused Nos.1 to 4 is hereby cancelled. The Respondents /
Accused Nos.1 to 4 are directed to surrender before the concerned
Jurisdictional Court within one (01) week from the date of receipt of copy of
this order. After surrender, the Respondents/Accused Nos.1 to 4 are at
liberty to file fresh applications for bail. On such application, the Court
concerned has to take decision on its own merits.
As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
________________________________________
Dr.JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
Date:13.03.2026
ARB
THE HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
CRIMINAL PETITION No.11675 of 2025
DATE:13.03.2026
ARB
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review